Young Foundation report: Why Britain should mind its Ps and Qs

 
Youth walks past grafitti

"There is just incredible incivility in this country… people are rude to each other… public discourse is so bad mannered… we have come to assume and resign ourselves to the fact that civility is on a permanent and inevitable downward slide."

So said David Cameron in 2007, echoing a widespread public view that Britain's behaviour was indicative of a country careering headlong for hell in a handcart.

Indeed a BBC poll a few months later suggested 83% of people thought the UK was suffering moral decline.

But now along comes the Young Foundation, a social science think-tank, with a report that says such views are not only bunkum but dangerously counter-productive bunkum.

Britain might see itself as rudeness central but when you ask about personal experience, sizeable majorities say they get treated with consideration and respect. Concerns about anti-social behaviour appear to be falling and when asked what is good about living in Britain, among the top answers are tolerance and politeness.

"Generalisations about declining standards of civility are inaccurate and problematic", say the researchers.

"While there are flashpoints of incivility, these tend to be contained to certain places or certain times. But in general Britain remains a well-mannered and courteous country. We still compare favourably to other developed nations."

Golden era?

I can almost hear a nation harrumphing at this idea. Where on earth did these "researchers" do their "research"?

The answer is partly in one of the poorest and most diverse neighbourhoods in London's East End; Queen's market in Newham to be precise.

Woman shouting and gesticulating

"We observed how shoppers of a range of ethnicities queued patiently and stepped out of the way of prams and elderly shoppers", they noted.

They also travelled to relatively prosperous communities - Salisbury and Trowbridge - and recorded how "high levels of superficial civility... often hid deeper, covert incivilities" such as domestic violence, racism and prejudice against younger residents.

People were quick "to jump to conclusions about 'spoilt', 'rowdy', 'rude' and 'intimidating' young people", they noted, while local youth complained about being "on the receiving end of uncivil behaviours". Some spoke of behaving rudely to adults to "give them a taste of their own medicine".

And that tit for tat attitude is what worries the Young Foundation team. Ultimately, they warn, such prejudices "can deter civil behaviour, as people are likely to live up to the negative generalisations".

There are long-term trends which threaten to undermine good manners, the report says: busy lives in dense and transitory communities make civility harder and new technologies such as mobile phones and the internet have developed too fast for codes of acceptable behaviour to develop.

But the answer is not simply punitive sanction, the report concludes.

"If we want to tackle anti-social behaviour and build stronger communities in the long term, a better balance is needed between tough talk from the top and local interventions based on understanding."

The British, it seems to me, almost revel in a narrative of national decline. I have no doubt that many people will refuse to believe the central findings of today's report on the basis that school-kids are often noisy on the bus or "someone was rude to me last Wednesday".

There is an easy assumption that things were so much better in the past. As today's report reminds readers, "in his 1983 classic, Hooligan, Geoffrey Pearson illuminates our tendency to constantly recall a golden era - typically 20 years earlier - where young people's behaviour was better, crime lower and where civility flourished."

The trouble with such views, usually based on anecdote rather than evidence, is that with manners and behaviour they can become a self-fulfilling prophecy.

If people assume that the world is a rude, individualistic and selfish place, they are more likely to act that way themselves.

(20 October: We have amended the list of towns that were visited as part of the research following advice from the Young Foundation.)

 
Mark Easton, Home editor Article written by Mark Easton Mark Easton Home editor

More on This Story

Comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    +57

    Comment number 1.

    The implication from the excerpts you quote Mark, is that the researchers observed in the daytime. I have no doubt that, in that environment, their conclusions are broadly true. But what would they find if they stood in Cardiff centre (say) on a Saturday night?

    Yes, 99% of people (teenagers included) are polite and considerate. But the 1% have an impact out of all proportion to their numbers.

  • rate this
    +103

    Comment number 2.

    On the whole, I find people polite and courteous. I find with teenagers and young people, if you engage them as an equal, you find the response to be as an equal.
    The place I find most impoliteness is on the road or anything to do with vehicles.
    We seem think just because we are isolated in our cars we are immune from normal social behaviour.

  • Comment number 3.

    This comment was removed because the moderators found it broke the house rules. Explain.

  • rate this
    -25

    Comment number 4.

    Judging by the personnel displayed on the Young Foundation's website, most of them will be so far removed from reality they wouldn't notice what was going on anyway. I hope this shower isn't a public funded body too. Courtesy is sadly lacking, not only in the young, but right across the spectrum including in BBC programming. The basics, please ,thank you , and excuse me have left the language.

  • rate this
    +77

    Comment number 5.

    The reasearch is almost certainly correct; however, the moaning classes won't believe it. Why? Because of a deep ignorance about the past, and about how their own brains process memory. You only have to read, say, Dickens or even Faulkner to understand that some people have always been loud and rude, but most people haven't, and that's as true today as ever.

 

Comments 5 of 349

 

This entry is now closed for comments

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.