Darling tells of 'fundamental disagreements' with Brown


Former Chancellor Alistair Darling talks to Andrew Marr

Related Stories

Alistair Darling has spoken of the "fundamental disagreement" he had with Gordon Brown over key economic policies during the last Labour government.

The ex-chancellor told the BBC he was the victim of "debilitating" attacks by No 10 and accused of "exaggerating" the severity of the 2008 financial crisis.

Mr Darling, whose memoirs are published next week, also claimed Mr Brown had "ignored" the problem of the deficit.

But another colleague said Mr Brown had shown "great leadership" at the time.

Mr Darling served as Mr Brown's chancellor between 2007 and 2010, a period during which tensions between the two men increased markedly.

In his memoirs - serialised by the Sunday Times before their publication on Wednesday - Mr Darling claims Mr Brown believed the banking crisis could be over within six months while the then chancellor was of the opinion it risked an "absolute meltdown".

'Unpleasant attacks'

Speaking to the BBC's Andrew Marr programme, Mr Darling said there was a lack of "complete unity" between him and the prime minister, comparing their relationship to that between Margaret Thatcher and Nigel Lawson during the 1980s.


Yet again a leading Labour figure has decided to bank a few pennies from a publisher in return for unburdening himself about his experience of working for Gordon Brown.

Yet again it falls some distance short of a tidal wave of compliments and bonhomie.

But beyond Mr Darling's rather direct assessments of Gordon Brown's character, we also get a first hand account of their disagreements over their approach to the recession.

Mr Darling wanted to be candid about cuts.

He was deeply pessimistic about the economic outlook. Mr Brown was, apparently, neither.

Alistair Darling is blunt in his criticism too of the Bank of England, and its governor, Sir Mervyn King: it, he, didn't know enough about what was going on in the banks, he claims.

The coalition government does face its own questions about banking reforms.

But it is another day for Ed Miliband and Labour where they - and we - are reminded of the poisonous atmosphere at the top of their party when they were in government.

"Relations between myself and Gordon became progressively more difficult," he said.

"We had a fundamental disagreement in 2008 as to how bad this was going to be. And then during 2009 we had this whole argument about what you do about the deficit."

After Mr Darling told a newspaper the financial crisis could be the worst for 60 years, he said he was subject to "deeply unpleasant" briefings against him - assumed to have come from No 10 aides.

"I really don't mind, and relish, attacking Tories and Tories attacking me," he said. "What is so debilitating is when your own lot are doing it to you. It left a mark on me you really can't erase."

"What I do mind is when you have got people briefing all over the place that you have made a fool of yourself, your days are numbered, your have got the judgement wrong, that kind of stuff.

'Chaotic air'

Labour could have presented its economic arguments more clearly during the 2010 election campaign, he said, but were stymied by the fact it was "blindingly obvious" that he and Mr Brown disagreed over how to deal with the deficit and how far to cut spending.

"My frustration is that we could have got through this, we could have charted a political way through this... We could have come through this but we didn't."

He said he stood by his plan at the time to cut borrowing in half over four years and suggested that Mr Brown was in denial about the need to rein in spending.

Start Quote

He dealt with some of the most difficult issues that this country has ever faced and faced them with great insight and leadership”

End Quote Andy Burnham on Gordon Brown Shadow education secretary

"At the end point you had to say you had to get your borrowing down and ignoring the problem, frankly, is as bad as the present government's policy."

In his memoirs, Mr Darling says the last 18 months of Mr Brown's government had a "permanent air of chaos and crisis" about them.

He said he always feared Mr Brown regarded him as a "stopgap" chancellor and describes how he resisted efforts to replace him with Ed Balls, a close ally of Mr Brown, in June 2009.

"Part of me wanted to go. I was tired of the atmosphere of feuding and the perpetual sniping. Our friendship had been strained beyond breaking point," he wrote.

"And yet another part of me did not want to be forced out at this stage."

Miliband meeting

Mr Darling also revealed that shortly afterwards he held a meeting with David Miliband, the former foreign secretary, to "discuss whether there was any way of getting rid of Gordon".

Mr Darling said they concluded such a move was not possible at the time.

"That afternoon we came to a pretty unsatisfactory conclusion: that Gordon wouldn't leave; that there was no alternative leader in prospect; and that there was an inevitability that we must just soldier on."

He acknowledged that he and other former ministers concerned about Mr Brown's behaviour should have challenged him at the time.

"Perhaps we should have done something," he told Andrew Marr.

"Why did I not do it? I am afraid for me - despite everything - I had a residual loyalty which I found it very difficult to overcome. We go back a long, long way."

'Lot of respect'

The former prime minister has not yet responded to Mr Darling's claims, but on Tuesday refused to comment on other claims attributed to the book that he had a "brutal and volcanic" mood.

But shadow education secretary Andrew Burnham - a member of Mr Brown's cabinet - said he thought "raking over these coals" was not helpful to Labour and "demoralising" for party members trying to focus on current challenges.

"I have got a lot of respect for Gordon Brown," he told Sky News.

"He dealt with some of the most difficult issues that this country has ever faced and faced them with great insight and leadership.

"Because of the action we took, we helped set a course for the rest of the world."


More on This Story

Related Stories


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 479.

    What gets me is that every now and then we get these amazing revelations, and we all shake our heads in despair. So can you imagine what goes on that we DON'T know about ?? The mind boggles.

  • rate this

    Comment number 465.

    @ 451 Tiffany

    So you would rather have a Government that never changed its mind or admitted it made a mistake, such as Darling et al? We all know how that works out.

    Anyone expecting a Government to get everything right first time is naive - life never works like that. It's having the grace to admit when you're wrong that makes the difference.

  • rate this

    Comment number 378.

    None of them were right. Politicians all are a group of egomaniacs in it strictly for the power trip and self aggrandisement. How else can someone get up on their hind legs and say "I know whats good for you all". If that statement isn't a definition of a massive ego I don't know what is.

    Its time we reined these people in and got some policies that puts some balance into society.

  • rate this

    Comment number 214.

    gordon brown was right, the guy described is exactly the kind of no nonsense leader you want. darling damaged this county imeasurably by letting the cat out of the bag before we had the chance to claw quite a bit of it back. brown should have sacked him the. there would be continual crises when the leader was gettting stabbed in the back by so called labour politicians, brown has been dignified.

  • rate this

    Comment number 158.

    Much of the New Labour administration was a shambles, the early years saw genuine growth but their failure to set something aside for the future came to bite them, and more importantly, bite us. Blair hung on for too long, and Brown seemed to care most about his "right" to succeed him. Up to about 2003/4 they could have turned things around, but after that it was too late to reverse the decline.


Comments 5 of 13


More Politics stories



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.