Housing benefit cap won't make 20,000 homeless - Shapps
- 4 July 2011
- From the section UK
A planned cap on housing benefit will not lead to a rise in homelessness, Housing Minister Grant Shapps has said.
He hit back after a leaked document showed the communities department warned Number 10 in January that 20,000 more people could end up on the street.
Labour say that contradicts claims by ministers that the potential impact of the policy could not be quantified.
But Downing Street says it "completely disagrees" with any suggestion that ministers misled Parliament.
Plans for a maximum limit on the amount of benefits one family can claim a year from 2013 - of about £26,000 - were announced at the Conservative conference last October.
It is estimated the £500-a-week cap, which would apply to the combined income from benefits such as jobseekers allowance, housing benefit and council tax benefit, could result in about 50,000 families being about £93 a week worse off.
The leaked document was written Communities Secretary Eric Pickles' then private secretary Nico Heslop and sent to Prime Minister David Cameron's private secretary Matthew Style.
It said Mr Pickles' department supported the principle of the cap, but feared it could cause some "very serious practical issues" because thousands of families would be unable to pay their rent.
It said 20,000 could be uprooted - in addition to another 20,000 forced to leave their homes by other benefit changes.
Asked whether that warning was accurate, Mr Shapps told the BBC: "I see no reason for this to lead to homelessness...
"This won't lead to more people on the streets."
Mr Shapps denied that the leak had caused tension between his department and Number 10.
He also said the document in question was six months old and a key concern it raised had now been addressed.
The letter warned that the cap might have a damaging effect on plans to create 150,000 new affordable homes, with the resulting shortfall then leading to more homelessness.
But Mr Shapps said the number of bids from the private sector to deliver those homes had "surpassed my wildest expectations" and meant that the government was "very likely" to meets its objective by 2015.
A Downing Street spokeswoman said the changes to housing benefits were about "fairness".
She declined to go into details about the correspondence between Mr Pickles' office and that of the prime minister, but she insisted it was completely untrue to suggest that ministers had misled Parliament over the issue.
A spokesman for Mr Pickles said he and his department were "fully supportive of all the government's policies on benefits".
But Labour have accused ministers of failing to "disclose crucial material information" to MPs about the impact on homelessness when they were asked to debate the cap policy.
Shadow work and pensions secretary Liam Byrne raised a point of order in the House of Commons on Monday afternoon to ask "who knew what and when".
He said it was "inconceivable" ministers did not know about it much earlier given that a number of their advisers and other officials did.
Commons Speaker John Bercow said it was "an extremely important issue" and told the House he would look into the matter.
He also said ministers would have heard the point of order and would have to decide whether or not they needed to say something to the Commons, "sooner rather than later".
Earlier, Labour leader Ed Miliband said: "I think it's a matter of real concern that six months ago, the government was warned that its policy on housing benefit wouldn't save money and would lead to greater homelessness.
"That means it's an ineffective policy and and it's an unfair policy, and I think they have to be providing some answers about why they didn't act on these clear conclusions from the Department of Communities and Local Government."
Labour have said they would support the idea, in principle, of a cap on total benefit payouts while giving no details of what level it should be set at.