Women and tech: Why don't girls want to be geeks?

Girl geeks, copyright Thinkstock The image of the geek still lingers

Last month Yahoo appointed a self-styled "super geek" as its chief executive. Nothing unusual there - except this one was a woman and a pregnant one to boot.

While female tech bosses like Marissa Mayer aren't quite as rare as hen's teeth, her appointment generated far more headlines than a man's would have.

So why when technology is becoming increasingly desirable, is there little desire to work in IT, especially for girls?

In the UK, 84% of IT professionals are men.

Many companies want more women involved - in a survey conducted by IT recruitment company CW Jobs, 64% said more females in the workplace would be beneficial.

"There is this conception that IT is men with long hair sitting in air-tight rooms programming all day," said the company's website director Richard Nott.

Java club

A personal view from Lydia Pincott, 16

My experience with technology started from when I was about seven, and the video player chewed up my favourite video. Since then, I have found technology increasingly frustrating.

The frustration, however, has not put me off, and I have found myself buying new technology every year, desperate to have the top of the range iPad and iPhone - and not even being put off by both of them breaking within a month of getting them.

The need for new gadgets is just too overwhelming for me and I find the ability to find a McDonald's anywhere in the world or to slice flying fruit too exciting to contain.

My experience with maths, however, is less passionate. I have dawdled along in maths lessons for the past 10 years, and intentionally spent as little time as possible doing maths.

My experience is that you either love it or you hate it, and with skill in maths mostly being limited to the gifted few, I despised every minute of it.

But as much as I enjoy using the technology that I seem to have become dependent on, a career in technology or maths would just not appeal to me.

The need for such precision and perfection doesn't excite me; the idea of having to conform to a seemingly pointless formula does not seem like an interesting career.

For me, it is not about image or being geeky, I just find it dull.

This image problem starts at school, according to one teacher.

"Girls don't see IT as creative. It is that image of the geek or nerd in a room typing lines of code," said Peter Mapstone, head of IT at King Edward VI school in Hampshire.

Gender differences become apparent during IT lessons, even though there is no difference in ability, according to Carol Dawkins, an IT teacher at Toynbee School in Chandlers Ford.

"Boys are more, 'Game on' - they don't mind if they make mistakes. They are more confident around the technology, whereas girls are a little bit shy, on the back foot before they start," she said.

The point is perfectly illustrated by Toynbee's after-school Java club - only boys have signed up.

"For the boys, hacking Linux is their comfort zone - whereas for girls, technology is all about email and Facebook," said Mrs Dawkins.

School girls looking at a computer screen Girls tend not to choose technology or maths-based careers

When IBM's master inventor Mandy Chessell was at school, she said she had "missed the memo which said that girls don't do maths and science".

But she had a rude awakening when she joined her classmates in her first O-level lesson and realised she was the only girl.

Now working at IBM's Hursley laboratory, Ms Chessell has long since got used to working in male-dominated environments.

It hasn't held her back - she is now one of IBM's few senior female engineers and recently won the Cisco Women In Technology award.

And she is clear about the need for women at senior levels in technology firms.

"You can become a leader and you can lead in feminine ways," she said.

For her, this means a greater emphasis on collaboration.

"For junior technology roles, often the emphasis is on logical skills, which may put girls off, but most systems these days are put together as part of team effort," she said.

IBM has a series of projects aimed at encouraging girls to take more science, technology, engineering and maths (Stem) subjects.

The BBC took part in its Think IT workshop in July, where 100 girls aged 12 and 13 came to IBM's lab to find out more about how a technology product comes to market.

The girls were divided into teams, each named after a famous female technologist or scientist, and asked to come up with a new piece of sport technology, from apps through to running shoes.

IBM has reaped some rewards from the scheme - several girls that have been through the programme have gone on to become apprentices at the firm.

Indeed the girls on the course seemed fired up by what they were doing, but none wanted to take it to exam level.

Carol Dawkins with some of her Year 8 pupils IBM runs events to encourage girls to consider a career in technology

Interestingly, few felt that ICT was a difficult subject, some actively enjoy it, but none of those the BBC spoke to wanted to pursue it as a career.

"I enjoy it, but I don't want to do it as a job," said Carys, aged 13.

But it isn't down to lack of confidence in the subject. "We are better than the boys," said one girl bluntly.

Ruth Amos, now 23, won a young engineer of the year award when she was 16.

For her, it was a gradual realisation that engineering didn't have to be about dirty overalls.

"I realised that I could do it and wear a dress and nice shoes and still be me," she said.

She believes Stem subjects need a higher profile in the media.

"It really upsets me when I see girls watching shows like The Only Way is Essex and aspiring to be like that. Why not give that air time to inspiring them about Stem? Look at what The Apprentice and Dragon's Den have done for entrepreneurs." she said.

Recently she has taken part in Soapbox Science, a project where women in technology, engineering and science literally take to soap boxes on London's south bank to evangelise their chosen careers.

But she thinks the discussion about why girls don't want to be geeks will continue for a while.

"We have been talking about it for ever and, while things are changing, it is very gradual," she said.

Yahoo's new boss Marissa Mayer has promised to address the issue of too few women in the tech industry, but she may face a tough job.

Last month Microsoft had to apologise when a chunk of code emerged labelled "big boobs".

There is clearly some way to go.

More Technology stories



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.