Google outlines plan to keep smartphone market lead

Google’s Hugo Barra tells Rory Cellan-Jones that its operating system is ready for a new generation of tablets

After years of warnings from science fiction writers, it seems androids may finally be taking over the world.

For now, their influence is limited to mobile phones, in the guise of Google's hugely popular operating system.

At Mobile World Congress in Barcelona, hundreds of Android-powered devices were on show.

Google's chief executive Eric Schmidt declared his company's platform to be the market leader.

"It is the fastest growing mobile ecosystem," he told delegates.

Mr Schmidt said that 300,000 Android-based phones are being activated each day, and more than 170 Android compatible devices are on the market.

Centre of attention

He claimed that IT graduates, fresh out of university were attracted to working on the platform.

"Young programmers think mobile first. That is where the action is," he said.

Around the halls of the world's largest mobile phone show, Android seemed omni-present.


"Android's rapid rise to become top seller in the smartphone market is nothing but staggering. Who can stand in its way?

Blackberry is losing ground, Windows Phone 7 isn't gaining traction, Apple's iPhone could soon be niche.

Now handset makers use the (free) Android software to push into the mid-market, making smartphones cheap.

However Android's success is not rock solid. Its rapid development has left many users with old versions of the operating system.

That undermines the all-important "app market", because key applications don't work on all versions.

This fragmentation is made worse by attempts by handset makers to tune up early versions of Android with their own user interface, for example HTC Sense.

Google is fighting back. After hiring a new user interface team, Google promises that new versions of Android - Honeycomb for tablets, and the forthcoming Icecream for smartphones - will be fine just as they are.

Hand set makers won't like this plain vanilla approach, though. It makes it difficult for them to stand out. So Android's very success might be the seed of its undoing."

HTC's stand was full of Android devices, while LG's headline grabbing 3D smartphone and tablet also feature Google's operating system.

Android's own colourful stand was a mini version of Google's famous Mountain View headquarters, with its huge Android slide and smoothie bar.

But despite the fun image, Android has not been without its critics.

Fragmented market

One of the biggest problems faced by Android is fragmentation, according to Ben Trewhella from application developer Mubaloo.

"The growth in Android has come from a large number of mobile manufacturers finding it easy to adapt to various screen sizes, hardware features and unique user interfaces.

"Developers are having to test across many devices and sometimes create device specific versions," he said.

During a question and answer session that followed Mr Schmidt's keynote, he was asked about the issue of fragmentation.

"You develop an app on one device and it won't run on another," the questioner said.

"We hear some of this," Mr Schmidt replied.

"Under our terms and agreements there is an anti-fragmentation clause. No operator will want to be in an eco-system without access to all apps but we do this by conformity to the apps [policy] rather than forcing anyone on a platform," he said.

As more devices move onto Google's latest iteration of Android - Gingerbread - fragmentation will be less of an issue, he said.

"Everyone on a common platform should address your concerns."

Sweet dreams

Mr Schmidt also gave a glimpse of Android's future.

"We've had Gingerbread, which begins with a G, then Honeycomb [the first version designed with tablets in mind], which begins with an H so the next one will begin with an I and be named after a dessert," he said.

But while Google is busy working through the mobile alphabet, software maker Microsoft is hoping to attract some attention away from the little green robot.

Before the first queues had even formed in Barcelona, the software giant stole a march on its rivals with the announcement that it had signed a deal with Nokia to make the software giant's Windows Phone 7 its primary operating system for smartphones.

Mr Schmidt said Google had "tried" to woo Nokia.

"We would have loved if it they had chosen Android. The offer remains open," he said.

Joint forces
eric schmidt Google's smartphone and tablet systems will be compatible say chief executive Eric Schmidt

Android's director of mobile experience Matias Duarte was magnanimous in defeat.

"Microsoft has done a nice job with Windows 7. It is a beautiful design, but at Android our ambitions are about as big as they get. We want to create the best mobile platform," he said.

During his keynote speech, Microsoft's chief executive Steve Ballmer was in more modest mood.

"We are off to a strong start but we know we have a lot of work to do," he said.

The Microsoft/Nokia partnership has a long way to go to catch Apple and Android, according to Ian Fogg, an analyst with Forrester Research

"It certainly strengthens the Windows Phone 7 brand in the market but the fundamental issue will be what will Microsoft allow Nokia to do that will differentiate the first Windows Nokia phone?" he said.

Android is hardly a veteran itself, having only came onto the market in 2008.

At the time, operators were crying out for a viable alternative to the dominance of Apple.

"There are multiple reasons why it is popular but simply put, it brought an iPhone like experience to other devices," said Tony Cripps, an analyst with research firm Ovum.

Elephant in the room

According to figures from Canalys, in 2010 Android went from being a bit player in the smartphone market to outselling Nokia's Symbian operating system.

Start Quote

What will Microsoft allow Nokia to do that will differentiate the first Windows Nokia phone?”

End Quote Ian Fogg Forrester Research

In the last quarter of 2010, 32.9 million Android-based phones shipped worldwide, compared with 31 million running on Symbian. Apple had 16.2 million and RIM 14.6 million.

"There are always shifting sands when it comes to operating systems. Three years ago, Symbian was the number one," said Mr Cripps.

The death knell for Symbian may have been sounded, but it could be too early to declare the mobile operating systems battle a three horse race, as Nokia's Stephen Elop did last week.

Blackberry is still very much in the race, said RIM co-executive director Jim Balsillie.

"We feel very good about our business. I wouldn't write us off."

He said that the firm had experienced 70% growth in the last year and is appealing to a new demographic of teenagers, who love Blackberry Messenger.

But the elephant in the room at Mobile World Congress was Apple. It had no stand at the event and no keynote speakers, yet the iPhone was still in the hands of many of the delegates.

More on This Story

Mobile week 2011

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Technology stories



Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.