British space penetrator passes icy test


The penetrator shatters the ice block into a shower of small crystals

UK engineers have tested a projectile technology that they believe could be used to explore the Solar System.

The steel penetrator was fired at a 10-tonne cube of ice to simulate the surface of Jupiter's moon Europa.

It hit the block at a speed of 340m/s and decelerated rapidly, but its structure remained intact, as did its interior components.

Researchers say the penetrator would be a robust and inexpensive way to land instruments on other worlds.

These might be seismometers to study the interior of Mars, or a miniature organic chemistry laboratory to check for microbial activity on icy Jovian satellites.

Scientists envisage several penetrators being deployed at once, carrying perhaps a network of sensors to widely separated locations in the sub-surface.

Being able to get just a few metres down is key, because if life exists anywhere else in the Solar System, it is likely to be buried away from harsh space radiation.

Europa - Icy moon of Jupiter

Europa diagram (Credit: SPL)
  • Discovered along with three other Jovian moons by Italian astronomer Galileo Galilei in 1610
  • Orbits 670,900km from Jupiter with same hemisphere always facing the gas giant
  • Nasa's Galileo probe returned detailed pictures of cracked surface in 1990s
  • Has small metal core (light blue, centre) surrounded by silicate rock (orange)
  • Global ocean of liquid water (blue) is covered by a thick layer of ice (beige)
  • Considered a promising place to look for microbial life beyond Earth

Thursday's test was certainly spectacular.

The full-size, 20kg projectile slammed into the ice block at just under the speed of sound, producing a huge plume of snow.

Space 'ploughshare'

The probe experienced a peak deceleration of 24,000g. To put that in context, an ejecting fighter pilot might experience 12-14g.

Its paintwork was scuffed a little after coming to rest against the roof of the concrete holding box, but the projectile was otherwise unaffected by the violent encounter.

"It was really successful because the entry velocity was higher than expected and all the systems we've looked at so far have survived," Marie-Claire Perkinson, the programme's industrial leader from Astrium UK, told BBC News.

The latest demonstration was conducted at Pendine in West Wales. This is where defence company QinetiQ operates a long rocket track on which objects can be accelerated to high speed before impacting a target. Normally, this would be a new type of missile that needed to be tested before entering military service.

"It's a classic case of swords to ploughshares," said QinetiQ fellow Phil Church.

Alan Smith, MSSL: "Ice fields are where you'd like to go"

"This is a civilian project where we are applying a lot of our technical capabilities in simulation, experiments and materials, but which we wouldn't be able to do without the Ministry of Defence research over the past 30 to 40 years underpinning it all."

The space penetrator has itself been in development for almost 10 years, and was originally proposed for a British lunar mission called Moonlite.

That venture was eventually shelved, but the idea of a "hard lander" was so compelling, the European Space Agency decided to pick up the concept.

Marie-Claire Perkinson: "We need to survive the cold"

It now wants to take the technology through to full maturity.

"Penetrators offer a number of advantages over 'soft landers', which have to slow down to reach the surface safely," explained Esa project manager Sanjay Vijendran.

"They would enable you to get deep into the sub-surface essentially for free, up to three metres without having to drill. And being light means you can deploy a few at once from a single spacecraft orbiter."

Thursday's demonstrator carried accelerometers and data loggers to help engineers better understand the forces of impact.

The penetrator could be ideal for investigating Jupiter's moons

In addition, it incorporated a special spring mechanism to isolate the interior payload compartments from the outer skin of the projectile.

If the penetrator is sent into ice such as exists on Europa or in a shadowed crater on the Moon, it will have to survive not only the collision but also extremely low temperatures, down to minus 200C. Batteries and electronics will quickly stop working in these conditions.

Space penetrator system

  • Deployed from carrier satellite at 200km altitude; retro-rocket slows initial fall to surface
  • Designed for hard landing; will break through ice and regolith (soil) and penetrate to 2-3m depth
  • Internal components designed to survive massive deceleration, about 25,000g
  • Electronics covered in resin coating to prevent breakage; any voids filled with glass beads
  • Instruments might include sample retrieval drill, microscope and mass spectrometer
  • Vacuum gap insulates internal compartments from extreme cold; around -200C on icy moons
  • Battery needs to last a few weeks; UHF data relay back through carrier satellite

But the team has designed a suspension system from a Torlon polymer. This material will collapse under a high deceleration but then push back to maintain a 2mm insulation gap around the sensitive payload casing.

The post-impact inspection revealed the springs had done precisely what was expected of them.

The test penetrator also carried a mini-drill that on a real mission could push out into the surrounding ice to grab samples for onboard analysis.

On this occasion, the drill was not operated but the developers, Rapid Space Technologies, should get a lot of feedback on how their equipment coped with the huge loads from the impact.

Ultimate test

Future work will now concentrate on battery and communications capabilities. A penetrator will likely live for only a few weeks once in place, and it will need sufficient power to run its experiments and then radio the results to the spacecraft that deployed it for onward relay to Earth.

Engineers believe they should have a flight-ready system before the end of the decade.

As yet, no mission opportunity for a penetrator has been identified.

Esa has a spacecraft called Juice going to Europa in the next decade, but there is no space onboard for this technology.

Phil Church: "The penetrator leans on MoD heritage"

Nonetheless, the British team is hopeful an attractive opportunity will arise soon.

"We will need to demonstrate it all, end-to-end," Alan Smith, the director of the Mullard Space Science Laboratory, University College London, told BBC News.

"This will involve firing one of these demonstrators into an ice target, get it to sample the ice and transmit the data from the target without human intervention.

"That's the ultimate demonstration - a real penetrator doing its job. We're about three years away from that position."

Ice target The 10-tonne block of ice was reduced to a pile of snow after the impact
Jonathan Amos Article written by Jonathan Amos Jonathan Amos Science correspondent

Lisa Pathfinder: 'Exquisite' gravity probe leaves UK

UK industry completes construction of the modules that make up the Lisa Pathfinder satellite - a remarkable probe that will test the key technologies needed to detect gravitational waves in space.

Read full article

More on This Story

Related Stories


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 162.

    @161.Robert Lucien,
    A thermal borer wouldn't need crawler tracks, .. again something that could just jam. Since your boring vertically through the ice you can just have your borer negatively buoyant so it sinks as it melts the ice. Once it hits the ocean it can shed weights to become neutrally buoyant and use propulsion at this stage. Later shed weights to become positively buoyant and bore up.

  • rate this

    Comment number 161.

    Just did a few calculations for a thermal borer - these might work.. 1 to 5 megawatts of power and a weight of about 1 to 2 tons. Maximise efficiency by minimising the size of the hot area to a plate on the front. long thin shape - use crawler tracks on three sides for movement and pump liquid water from front to back where it will re-freeze. Communication by thin cables laid behind the machine.

  • rate this

    Comment number 160.


    "You were just telling us what was badly engineered"

    Under the hypothesized context proposed of a 'designer' yes it is! however the result renders the idea of a 'designer' obsolete.


    Whether "engineered" by evolution or a deity, the items that you identified as deficiencies cannot suddenly cease to be deficiencies. Otherwise your argument falls by its inconsistency.

  • rate this

    Comment number 159.

    5 Minutes ago
    "That single weight bearing column is possessed by a tiny fraction of organisms"

    Yes but its still a single weight bearing column that many creatures have!


    The vast majority doesn't have it by a massive factor.

  • rate this

    Comment number 158.

    "That single weight bearing column is possessed by a tiny fraction of organisms"

    Yes but its still a single weight bearing column that many creatures have!
    "You were just telling us what was badly engineered"

    Under the hypothesized context proposed of a 'designer' yes it is! however the result renders the idea of a 'designer' obsolete.


Comments 5 of 162



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.