Bangkok breakthroughs gives Cites a bigger stick

Cites meeting

Amidst the great celebrations of a historic moment in the history of the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species (Cites), when regulations on the trading of several shark species were upheld, one man stood looking a little forlorn.

For Shingo Ota, the spokesman for Japan's negotiating team in the conference hall, the debate and the result made it an unhappy day.

"It was not so pleasant to listen to all the clapping and sometimes screaming on the floor," he told me.

The upgrading of oceanic whitetip, porbeagle and hammerheads to Cites Appendix 2 - mandating trade licenses and quotas - would not stop fishermen from catching these species, he said.

"Hammerheads are caught by small-scale fishermen - they don't care about Cites, the fins may not be exported now because of Cites listing but hammerheads will continue to die."

Sea change

Many people saw the decision, upheld by the tiniest of margins, as a major step forward for the 40-year-old convention.

Mark Jones from Humane Society International said that another decision on a complicated issue called Introduction from the Sea was seismic in its implications for the convention.

Start Quote

Cites is a trade tool - is that the best way to save species?”

End Quote Shingo Ota Japanese delegation

"I think it sets the framework by which Cites can become a global player in commercial fisheries management - and that's exactly what it ought to be," he said.

"A lot of species that are in commercial trade are being very adversely affected by that trade and not being effectively managed by the regional or national fishing bodies.

"We hope that in the future it will set the scene for many more commercial fish species to be listed under Cites."

China and Japan are certainly convinced that Cites aims to become the new sheriff of the high seas -and they don't like it at all.

"We are worried about the tendency from our standpoint," said Shingo Ota. "Cites is a trade tool - is that the best way to save species?"

Snake charmers

As well as the seas, this Cites meeting took aim at timber and listed several species of rare hardwoods, including ebony and rosewoods much in demand by the middle classes in China.

And big international companies came to this meeting because they see its growing importance.

Ebony tree cross-section Delegates managed to get to the heart of the issue on hardwoods such as ebony

Delegates from Gucci and other fashion houses were here in Bangkok to talk to the producers and suppliers of snake skins.

As several observers remarked, for Cites to move into regulating the international trade in fishing and forestry products affects many more people than in the past.

Perhaps the most important people affected are finance ministers in governments around the world.

We're now seeing Cites having an impact on areas that raise revenue and feed people. And what makes the treaty significant is that it has real teeth.

By some accident of birth, the founding fathers of Cites agreed that if a member broke the rules, they could be sanctioned across the entire range of species that Cites covers.

That's 35,000 increasingly lucrative species of flora and fauna.

Imagine how you'd respond if you were a finance minister in a country that was suddenly facing a to ban your international trading in timber or fish because you hadn't taken care of a species of frog?

As the world gets more populated over the next 30 years, as the pressure on the natural world continues to grow, we could be witnessing the emergence of a major new player on the world stage to balance trade with conservation.

Cites - It is a name many more people will have to get familiar with in the coming years.

Follow Matt on Twitter.

Matt McGrath Article written by Matt McGrath Matt McGrath Environment correspondent

Will Kerry strike gold at Lima climate talks?

As US Secretary of State John Kerry joins UN climate talks in Lima, we look at some of the hurdles on the path to an historic global deal.

Read full article


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 6.

    Sounds all very sensible if your logic is based on western values. Unfortunately, the people slicing up our planet's endangered wildlife are neither logical nor brought up with western values.
    If they were then logic would suggest the trade in rhino horn would have been wiped out by the invention of viagra - it has not, and neither will any of these enhanced Cites powers have any effect.

  • rate this

    Comment number 5.

    China is using its new wealth to create an ecological catastrophe. Many species of marine life, in addition to elephants, rhinos, tigers, and bears are vanishing because of the Chinese market for endangered wildlife products.

    One thing we can all do to help save our planet's biological diversity is to stop buying products made in China. Why send them more money to be used to kill wildlife?

  • rate this

    Comment number 4.

    Unfortunately China, Japan,Korea and other Far East countries will give lip service while ignoring the actual smuggling that feeds their 'collectors' manias.

  • rate this

    Comment number 3.

    Hi... please take a look at the grammatical mistake in the headline... it's sad for journalists who look up to BBC as a temple.

  • rate this

    Comment number 2.

    This sounds good in principle but where there's profit there's corruption. When it comes to the crunch will anyone stand up to China given its huge economic muscle and do the members have the will to enforce sanctions?

    However it's welcome news news on the day that plans are announced for stripmining the seabed and exploiting an ecosystem that we didn't even know existed 10 years ago.


Comments 5 of 6



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.