Are public attitudes to climate change as fickle as the weather?

Australia storm Much of the debate on long-term climate change can be obscured by notions drawn from short-term weather

Public attitudes in the developed world to the reality and the causes of climate change have tended to ebb and flow over the past few years.

A survey carried out for the Pew Research Centre in the US in 2012 concluded that the belief that the Earth's temperature is rising was down 10% from 2006 at 67% of responders.

Pew found 42% agreed with the statement that climate change is mostly caused by human activity, down five points in the last six years.

Start Quote

You regularly see even the best science communicators tie themselves up in knots about the relationship between weather and climate because it is just really subtle”

End Quote Dr Adam Corner Cardiff University

In the UK, public opinion has fluctuated as well. A YouGov survey from last summer indicated that 43% believed that the world is becoming warmer as a result of human activity. That's down from previous surveys. The percentage of those who said they were not sure about the answer increased to one in five respondents.

Researchers have tried to work out what's been affecting the figures - they looked at events such as the so-called ClimateGate affair in 2009 and found that it had a significant impact on public faith - a BBC poll in 2010 showed that scepticism was on the rise as a result.

But apart from this anomaly, pollsters have struggled to explain the variation in the figures.

Knee-jerk reaction

Now a new piece of research on opinion in the US published in the journal Climatic Change suggests that the public's response to the great scientific issue of the day is often determined by the state of the weather. The study, carried out by the University of British Columbia, looked at public and media attitudes to climate science over the past 20 years.

They found that scepticism rose during cold snaps, but belief in global warming increased during hot spells.

Prof Simon Donner who carried out the analysis told me that it wasn't quite as simple as that.

"It is not just a knee-jerk reaction - 'Oh it's cold outside, global warming must be fake', it is the accumulated experience over a few months that makes you start to question things, and it is that accumulated experience that makes things start appearing in the papers," he said.

Chile power station Perceptions of climate change in developing countries are connected to concerns about economic development

He argues that in the US, climate issues have become highly politicised and it is hard to separate these political leanings from people's views on the science of climate.

Scientists in the field have also made matters worse, according to Prof Donner.

"We go on offense during a heat wave and then we lie low the rest of the time and don't talk about it. During a cold spell, the only time you hear from climate scientists in the newspapers is when we are refuting things - we need to be consistent and talk about this regardless of the weather," he said.

In the UK, a YouGov poll in January suggests that people here are almost evenly split on the link between weather events and climate change.

Dr Adam Corner from Cardiff University, who is also a consultant with the Climate Outreach and Information Network, says that scientists taking about individual meteorological events is dangerous.

"You regularly see even the best science communicators tie themselves up in knots about the relationship between weather and climate because it is just really subtle.

"It does cut both ways, it allows people to say, 'Oh it's been cold locally, that must mean temperatures are not rising'," he said.

While it might appear on some level a little odd to have your views on climate change shaped by weather patterns, Dr Corner says that there is some reason in this view.

"In some senses, it is exactly what you should be basing it on over time, because we're not meteorologists and apart from the things we get told, the things going on around us are going to provide more of a steer," he added.

Follow Matt on Twitter.

Matt McGrath Article written by Matt McGrath Matt McGrath Environment correspondent

Will Kerry strike gold at Lima climate talks?

As US Secretary of State John Kerry joins UN climate talks in Lima, we look at some of the hurdles on the path to an historic global deal.

Read full article


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 2.

    It makes me sad when we argue about if mankind is changing the climate What you need to realise is that the weather, and the climate is determined by a power far higher than men.

    I'm not sure if we can influence either by the way we behave, but if we can it will be because GOD decides to respond to what we do. I think if we live by HIS law, HE wll look after us.

  • rate this

    Comment number 13.

    We know that the climate change narrative is a scam, that the science has been wrongly presented and that it is closely tied to taxation and jollies for the renewables industry. Climate change is the religion of the extreme environmentalists who preach of burning hell, melting ice caps, floods, and plagues of frogs or whatever. The public are wising up. TMR 4, the laws of physics again- oh dear

  • rate this

    Comment number 24.

    Can't believe we are still having such debates.
    The global warming (hastily renamed to climate change for this very reason) is discredited. It was an excuse for some quite dodgy scientists who selectively presented some data to get some research money and for people like Gordon Brown to fleece normal people for some more taxes.

  • rate this

    Comment number 83.

    "Much of the debate on long-term climate change can be obscured by notions drawn from short-term weather"

    Much of the nonsense on climate change can be complicated by real life observations drawn from people who have already lived in this weather for 70+ years

    The weather changes folks

    Anyone who honestly believes we can influence the weather is suffering from King Canute syndrome

  • rate this

    Comment number 6.

    CO2 levels have been steadily falling thru'out geological history and the earth will swallow up the minuscule amount we are releasing without so much as a burp then levels will continue to fall. Once they fall below about 80 ppm plants will start to die off followed by animals. We are more than half way thru this planets ability to sustain complex life and nothing man does will change that.


Comments 5 of 156



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.