Open Sesame: science surviving against all the odds

 
SESAME staff A model of collaboration

Related Stories

News that Middle Eastern adversaries are jointly building an advanced research centre has generated a mix of incredulity and optimism.

My story about the Sesame project appeared on Monday.

The incredulity comes from the fact that the endeavour is supported by Arabs, Turks, Iranians and Israelis.

Not only are these people meeting, calmly and productively, but also their governments are contributing large amounts of money for the construction of the synchrotron light source in Jordan which they will all share.

Against all the odds, the project is going ahead and the first research is scheduled for 2015.

The optimism is because the scientists from these different nationalities are getting along and somehow managing to leave conflict and politics at the lab door.

A typical reaction has been one of relief that at a time of rising tension in the region it is still possible for people to reach across barriers and enjoy a dialogue.

One comment posted on my blog about Sesame said simply: "This helps me recover some faith in humanity. Learn from this guys, this is how our world should be!"

But for many scientists this initiative is not surprising. They have long been proud of the ability of science to serve as a common language and Sesame shows that this idea is not a cliché but a reality.

I saw for myself how people from countries that do not recognize each other diplomatically, or even threaten to destroy or go to war with each other, can sit in the same seminar or chat amiably in the coffee breaks.

This is why the project attracted early support from the UN cultural and scientific agency UNESCO.

Science Golden Age

Interestingly though, this is nothing new to the Middle East. A key feature of the Golden Age of Islamic Science, when research flourished from the 9th to 15 centuries, was that it too ignored boundaries of religion and race.

The science was hosted by the Muslim leaders of the time but Christian and Jewish researchers were encouraged to be part of this era of inquiry and exploration.

More recently, in the Cold War, scientists reached out across the Iron Curtain in an effort to talk and lessen tensions.

Start Quote

A few of those involved in Sesame feel I focused too heavily on the participation of Iran and Israel - that the presence of Turkey and Cyprus was equally interesting and that singling out particular countries would draw unwelcome attention to people who might face criticism back home”

End Quote

The motivation back then was to reduce the risk of nuclear war. In 1955 Bertrand Russell and Albert Einstein issued a now-famous statement appealing for calm:

"Here then is the problem which we present to you. Stark and dreadful and inescapable: Shall we put an end to the human race; or shall mankind renounce war?"

That led to a meeting in 1957 in the Canadian village of Pugwash which brought together British, American and Soviet scientists to discuss ridding the world of nuclear weapons.

Some critics at the time said the Pugwash conferences were overly idealistic and one could argue over whether they had any influence over the events that led to the end of the Cold War.

But the movement and one of its founders, Professor Joseph Rotblat, were eventually awarded the Nobel Peace Prize in 1995.

And as we reported, the model for Sesame is CERN, the European research centre set up in Geneva to unite scientists from countries that had been fighting each other in the Second World war.

Long way to go

To spread the 'CERN effect', the lab is now providing some of Sesame's key components - the magnets for the main 'storage ring' - with the EU picking up the $5m bill.

Sesame is having to endure far more troubled waters than CERN did; it's experiencing tensions more similar to those faced by the Pugwash pioneers so, if it succeeds, it too may be in the running for Nobel honour.

But it has a long way to go yet.

Between visiting the Sesame site, and publishing our stories about the project, the conflict between Israel and Hamas in Gaza erupted. Rockets and air strikes claimed the lives of six Israelis and more than 100 Palestinians.

SESAME The facility is full of hi-tech equipment

I kept checking but this violence did not derail Sesame, as one might have expected. The motivation for those taking part - to have access to a sophisticated synchrotron - must outweigh any diplomatic unease.

One leading Jordanian scientist, who is not involved in the project, did tell me that she could not imagine meeting any Israeli scientists unless they denounced their government's actions.

If the researchers were getting together in a spirit of common humanity, she said, that humanity would require a basic statement condemning the air strikes.

But if that sentiment is felt by any of those taking part in Sesame, there has been no sign of it so far. Officially at least no scientist or government has suggested pulling out.

Key test

The key test will be next summer when the Sesame Council is due to meet again. This is where government representatives turn up and debate the strategic issues like funding.

At the meeting earlier this month, all the key countries were there except for the delegate from Bahrain was absent - which may or may not indicate that country's degree of support, even before the Gaza conflict.

A greater threat lies in the risk of war between Iran and Israel. The president of the Sesame Council, Prof Sir Chris Llewellyn Smith, told me that a major conflict would "stop us in our tracks".

In that extreme scenario, it would presumably be politically impossible for Iranians and Israelis to meet, and travel would probably be too dangerous.

A few of those involved in Sesame feel I focused too heavily on the participation of Iran and Israel - that the presence of Turkey and Cyprus was equally interesting and that singling out particular countries would draw unwelcome attention to people who might face criticism back home.

I understand the concern and in our filming we were very mindful of the need to tread carefully. It's one thing for certain nationalities to be filmed together in the formal setting of a conference, quite another to be seen being friendly.

Yet this is what Sesame is all about: creating a unique forum for exchange and it needs publicity to help secure more funding and political support.

The minefield surrounding the project is what makes it fascinating and newsworthy:

  • how Iran can continue participating despite the difficulties of coping with international sanctions;
  • how Israel can take part when Iran is accused of supplying Hamas with missiles;
  • whether the United States can ever support Sesame with Iran as a participant;
  • whether the richest Arab states, notably Saudi Arabia, which are investing massively research, will ever be able to overlook Israel's participation;
  • whether Jordan, facing a surge in unrest in the past fortnight, will remain stable enough to host the facility.

Covering this story often made me wonder if I was being naïve about Sesame's chances.

But on the day of broadcast, I received a Tweet saying "this is how the world is meant to be". Maybe, occasionally, a little optimism is justified.

 
David Shukman Article written by David Shukman David Shukman Science editor

Five steps to landing on a comet

How do you land on a comet? That's problem facing the people running Esa's Rosetta mission after the successful rendezvous with Comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko.

Read full article

More on This Story

Related Stories

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 19.

    No surprises here: scientists, indeed scholars in general, have always been willing to ignore the petty bickerings of nation-states in the quest for knowledge. It is glorious and worthy of celebration - I wonder if the Sesame facility will get the Nobel Peace Prize before anyone working there gets the Physics one!

  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 18.

    "The optimism is because the scientists from these different nationalities are getting along and somehow managing to leave conflict and politics at the lab door".

    In other word leave RELIGION at the lab door. Borders, conflicts and politics have been shaped by religion for centuries, whereas history showed that greatest advanacements were made in open societies.

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 17.

    Hopefully this can lead to more positive vibes between opposition resulting in a bit of peace and harmony inshallah

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 16.

    It just goes to show that all people need is some excuse, any excuse, to talk to one another about something in common. As soon as that happens you see John Smith is not so very different from you.

  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 15.

    Curiosity and desire of young people finally gain over blinkered self serving power hungry fools.
    How refreshing.
    A small spark and some hope for this troubled region.

  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 14.

    Lets hope the science is better than that elsewhere on the BBC:

    "Gap-year students are more likely to have smoked cannabis by the age of 16 than those who go straight to university, a study suggests"

  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 13.

    12.vessel

    "...man is capable of warring without religion..."

    ===

    Absolutely right.

    Give us any excuse, in fact.

    But religion seems better at providing them than almost anything else.

  • rate this
    -3

    Comment number 12.

    it is important to remember that the greater wars and deaths in human history have come from non religious wars - the chinese, mongol, world wars - and the greatest single act of human death and devastation came from a fruit of secular science misusing intelligence and ingenuity, the nuclear bomb

    so man is capable of warring without religion - religion is about holiness, goodness, peace, justice

  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 11.

    Einstein was Buddhist!? I've never seen that claimed anywhere before, so forgive my scepticism.
    As far as I'm aware he was a pantheist; he thought the idea of a personal god was childish wishful thinking, but still believed in something greater than man.

  • rate this
    -1

    Comment number 10.

    8. Robert Lucien

    "Einstein was Buddhist"

    Indeed. The Nazi's, however, classified him as a Jew and treated him accordingly.
    Regarding Jewish talent, for centuries Jewish mothers have judged potential husbands by their perfomance at the Bah Mitzvah, selecting for verbal skills and intelligence. Think of it as evolution in action!

  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 9.

    8.Robert Lucien

    "...I believe what you meant is that he was Jewish by cultural and racial background..."

    ===

    Correct.

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 8.

    #6 Entropic man
    #5 Eddy from Waring

    Einstein was Buddhist by religion. I believe what you meant is that he was Jewish by cultural and racial background. :) Its always amazing how many of the worlds most talented people have Jewish backgrounds ..

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 7.

    4.Little_Old_Me ".The arab/muslim world has a long & proud science tradition, long may it continue..."

    Hmm. A long long time ago ... Jews = 0.2%, and Arabs = 20% of the worlds current population. Yet the Arabs have just 4 Nobel prizes - just one for science (Chemistry: 1999 - Ahmed Zewa) ... The Jews have won 129 (including 96 for science & medicine). Something of an imbalance I would suggest.

  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 6.

    Einstein had to leave his home country after it persecuted him because of his religion!
    This is what Sesame is trying to leave behind.

  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 5.

    4.Little_Old_Me

    "...The arab/muslim world has a long & proud science tradition, long may it continue..."

    ===

    Indeed. Seconded. But didn't a Jew called Einstein do something once too?

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 4.

    The arab/muslim world has a long & proud science tradition, long may it continue.

    After all, who kept science alive & active whilst we Europeans were in the dark ages?

  • rate this
    +3

    Comment number 3.

    Science 1 : Religion 0

  • rate this
    +2

    Comment number 2.

    From the 8th to13th centuries medieval Islamic civilization encouraged learning and science, both in Arabic translations from the Greeks and the work of scholars within ther own culture. For 500 years they were the most scientifically sophisticated people on the planet.
    After a long gap, it is very welcome to see the Middle East returning to its scientific tradition.

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 1.

    Such a shame that there are always the few that want to spoil things. Wouldn't it be great if there were no religious or political divides. Who knows what we could achieve as a 'collective'

 

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.