Greenland's ice 'melts in spurts'

Rainbow at ice edge The stabilisation scenario may present a rainbow of hope for Greenland's ice

Related Stories

Ice loss from Greenland's vast sheet may happen mainly in short bursts, research by Danish scientists suggests.

They used aerial photos dating back to the 1980s to plot shrinking of glaciers around the island's northwest coast.

In the journal Science, they show that most of the ice loss happened in two periods - 1985-1993 and 2005-10 - with relative stability in between.

They say it will be hard to project sea level changes from Greenland ice melt until these patterns are deciphered.

A complete melt of the ice sheet would raise sea levels globally by about 7m, but it could take centuries for this to occur.

Last month, Nasa released evidence showing that ice melting had been observed across virtually the whole extent of the Greenland ice sheet, unprecedented in the satellite era.

Days earlier, an iceberg twice the size of Manhattan broke away from the Petermann glacier in northwest Greenland.

Dramatic though those events were, neither means much on its own for the long-term picture.

The last global climate assessment by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) in 2007 said that "dynamic" melting - where ice loss suddenly accelerates, for example because sea temperatures rise - was too poorly understood to be accurately modelled.

The new Danish paper is one of a number that have emerged since in an attempt to improve understanding.

Thin data

Start Quote

It is too early to proclaim the 'ice sheet's future doom'”

End Quote Kurt Kjaer University of Copenhagen

In recent years, satellites have found fast rates of retreat in a number of Greenlandic glaciers, as well as an overall loss of mass as measured by the Grace mission, which detects minuscule changes in the Earth's gravitational field.

But other studies suggested the rapid retreat was not consistent.

With the two most important satellite missions - Grace and ICESat - dating back less than a decade, there is obviously a danger that scientists will decipher accurately what is happening now and assume this is a constant pattern.

The Danish team realised they could effectively extend the measurement record back in time, by using images obtained during aerial survey missions to compile a model of how the coastal region of the ice sheet behaved over time.

"We've used a combination of old aerial photographs from the 1980s to construct a digital elevation map, and recent satellite data," said Shfaqat Abbas Khan of the Technical University of Denmark, one of the project team.

"In this way we've been able to gain an overview of the thinning of the ice sheet over the last 30 years in northwestern Greenland."

The overall trend is a "pronounced" thinning - by 100-150m in most of the glacier outlets, by much less in between them.

Ice island in Greenland fjord The giant slab that broke off the Petermann glacier is continuing its journey

In parallel, the glacier snouts have retreated by up to 12km.

Within that there is a lot of variation, with many examples where one glacier has thinned much more than its neighbour.

About three-quarters of the ice mass lost across the northwest region during the second period of rapid decline - 2005-10 - occurred in the coastal zone.

The researchers were able to show that there was a relatively stable spell in between the two periods of rapid loss, and suggest that this part of Greenland may be entering another stable interlude.

Until the long-term pattern is resolved, they suggest, it will not be possible to forecast sea level rise from Greenland's water store with any accuracy.

"These variations in the amount of thinning that we are able to document since the 1980s make it difficult to predict how much the world's oceans will rise over a longer period of time - a century for instance - as a result of Greenland glacial melt-water runoff," said study leader Prof Kurt Kjaer of the University of Copenhagen.

"However, it is certain that many of the present calculations and computer models of ice sheet conditions that built upon a short range of years since 2000 must be reassessed.

"It is too early to proclaim the 'ice sheet's future doom' and subsequent contribution to serious water problems for the world."

However, they conclude, it is likely that the Greenland ice is "becoming more sensitive" to rises in air temperature.

One avenue the Danish team wants to explore is extending the analysis further back in time using aerial photos, possibly as far back as the 1930s.

Follow Richard on Twitter

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Science & Environment stories

RSS

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.