LHC: Surprise and elation as signal crosses finish line

Belgian physicist Francois Englert, left, and British physicist Peter Higgs Belgium's Francois Englert (L) and the UK's Peter Higgs are now prime candidates for a Nobel

Related Stories

After a 45-year-long quest, the hunters have cornered their quarry.

The Large Hadron Collider (LHC), the most powerful "atom smasher" ever built, has nailed the most coveted prize in physics. Right?

Well, not quite.

Scientists at Cern (European Organization for Nuclear Research) are confident that they have discovered a new sub-atomic particle, and a boson (those which carry forces) at that. But the question of whether it is the Higgs boson or not, never mind the simplest version vs an exotic form of the particle, remains unconfirmed.

But many think that will be more of a formality.

"We are very careful in not stating that it is the Higgs boson. It could be the Higgs boson, but I am pretty convinced it is a Higgs boson," Rolf Heuer, director-general of Cern, which operates the LHC, told BBC News.

"Our famous Standard Model contains only one Higgs. That would be the Higgs boson. But there are extensions to the Standard Model, which we need because [this theory] is not everything.

"There could be many more Higgs bosons."

Indeed, according to one idea, there could be five Higgs bosons with similar masses but different electric charges. But there are many other possible schemes to describe the "new physics" that must lie beyond the best theory of how the Universe works.

The Higgs boson

Higgs candidate event
  • The Higgs is a sub-atomic particle that is predicted to exist, but has not yet been definitively pinned down
  • It was proposed as a mechanism to explain mass by six physicists, including Peter Higgs, in 1964
  • It imparts mass to other fundamental particles via the associated Higgs field
  • It is the last missing member of the Standard Model, which explains how particles interact

The Standard Model can only explain the 4% of the Universe that we can see, not the other 96% of the Universe that remains veiled - made up of those mysterious quantities known as dark matter and dark energy.

Particle physics is a game of statistics, relying on analysing multiple events gathered over time. Researchers work to tease out faint signals amid a sea of noise.

What might seem like a signal at first can later fade into nothingness after more numbers are gathered and crunched, so it is no surprise that physicists are usually careful to avoid the risk of jumping the gun.

But few could be in doubt about the significance of the result from the LHC.

Rolf Heuer admits to surprise about how quickly the hadron collider discovered the new Higgs-like particle, and says that the work that begins now to characterise it could make surprisingly rapid progress.

"I would not have predicted the discovery of a Higgs boson already by the middle of this year. So I think [the scientists] could work miracles," he told me here at Cern's headquarters in Geneva.

Mere weeks ago, the rumour mill suggested the certainty level for the signal had not reached the benchmark of five sigma (about a one in 3.5 million chance of a fluke) required to claim a discovery, and that the champagne would - once again - have to remain corked.

"We didn't know quite how significant this phenomenon was going to be. So it has been an extraordinarly exciting couple of weeks - very intense," says Dr Pippa Wells, from Cern, who works on the Atlas collaboration.

Physicists queued for an overflow room to hear the Higgs results Physicists braved long queues to hear the results announced on Wednesday morning at Cern

But scientists continued to crunch the data up until two days before the presentations.

By Tuesday night, the excitement had reached fever pitch; many tweets about the announcement were carrying the hashtag #higgsteria - and it wasn't an exaggeration.

Cern bolted the doors to the auditorium hosting the talks from the Atlas and CMS teams, lest any sizeable group of scientists camped out overnight in the lecture theatre.

"They probably know what we're like," one particle physicist joked to me.

Indeed, physicists simply camped outside the auditorium instead. Scientists turning up at 0630 in the morning were forced to join a vast queue for seats.

But let's not forget this was a momentous day in the history of science.

The Higgs is the cornerstone of the Standard Model and, as Dr Tara Shears from the University of Liverpool says, the field of particle physics has seen nothing like this present phase of exploration "in 40 years".

Rolf Heuer Rolf Heuer says the result excludes some versions of supersymmetry theory

Compared with previous particle accelerators, Dr Shears explained, "the LHC does have that power, that [large] amount of data generated, that precision".

"Everything is coming together to achieve this moment."

Once the results were announced, showing discovery-level signals from both Atlas and CMS (the two experiments designed to search for the Higgs at the LHC) in the same part of the search region, the audience erupted with applause and cheers. Some took to their feet and pumped their fists.

There was nothing fake about this, no mutual back-slapping exercise. This was the culmination of a search that has been continuing as long as many people in the room had been physicists - a milestone some thought they might never see.

Peter Higgs, after whom the particle is named, wiped a tear from his eye, later adding: "It's really an incredible thing that it's happened in my lifetime."

Statistics of a 'discovery'

Swiss franc coin
  • Particle physics has an accepted definition for a "discovery": a five-sigma level of certainty
  • The number of standard deviations, or sigmas, is a measure of how unlikely it is that an experimental result is simply down to chance, in the absence of a real effect
  • Similarly, tossing a coin and getting a number of heads in a row may just be chance, rather than a sign of a "loaded" coin
  • The "three sigma" level represents about the same likelihood of tossing nine heads in a row
  • Five sigma, on the other hand, would correspond to tossing more than 21 in a row
  • Unlikely results are more probable when several experiments are carried out at once - equivalent to several people flipping coins at the same time
  • With independent confirmation by other experiments, five-sigma findings become accepted discoveries

It was an irritation to many journalists that he had been asked to abstain from giving his spontaneous reaction to the assembled press corps ahead of a pooled interview and a press conference at Edinburgh University on Friday.

The 83-year-old sat alongside three of the five living theorists who proposed the Higgs mechanism: Fran├žois Englert, Gerald Guralnik and Carl Hagen. The other discoverers have felt overlooked by peers in the intervening years, something a Nobel Prize could go some way to redressing (depending on how it is awarded).

Some say a Nobel is far more likely to go to one or several of these theorists than the experimental team who detected the boson, as this endeavour is too much of a team effort to single out a small group of people.

For the experimental team, there will be plenty of glory to come as they get on with the task of confirming that the particle is a Higgs boson, and then determining whether it conforms to the version predicted by the Standard Model, or resembles something more exotic.

The discovery has already had an important scientific side effect. Supersymmetry is one of the proposed schemes for extending physics beyond the Standard Model and predicts that each Standard Model particle is accompanied by a heavier partner known as a "sparticle".

It has numerous variations, but some versions of the theory have tight parameters. The discovery outlined on Wednesday has dealt the final blow to some of them.

"It's exciting that the mass of this boson would exclude certain constrained models of supersymmetry, and that is a real result," said Rolf Heuer.

More on This Story

Related Stories

More Science & Environment stories



  • A very clever little girlBrain gain

    Why are people getting better at intelligence tests?

  • BeefaloBeefalo hunt

    The hybrid animal causing havoc in the Grand Canyon

  • A British Rail signBringing back BR

    Would it be realistic to renationalise the railways?

  • Banksy image of girl letting go of heart-shaped balloonFrom the heart

    Fergal Keane on the relationship between love and politics

  • Don Roberto Placa Quiet Don

    The world's worst interview - with one of the loneliest men on Earth

Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.