Do white people have a future in South Africa?

Woman and child at Krugersdorp squatter camp, June 2010

Apartheid South Africa looked after white people and nobody else. Now some of its white communities face a level of deprivation, or of violence, which threatens their future in the country.

Everyone here, regardless of colour, tells you that white people are still riding high.

They run the economy. They have a disproportionate amount of influence in politics and the media. They still have the best houses and most of the best jobs.

All of this is true but it is not the only picture.

Look below the surface and you will find poverty and a sense of growing vulnerability.

The question I have come to South Africa to answer is whether white people genuinely have a future here.

The answer, as with so many similar existential questions, is "Yes - but…"

BBC World Affairs Editor John Simpson examines the challenges facing white South Africans

Start Quote

You are twice as likely to be murdered if you are a white farmer than if you are a police officer”

End Quote

It seems to me that only certain parts of the white community really have a genuine future here: the better-off, more adaptable parts.

Working-class white people, most of them Afrikaans-speakers, are going through an intense crisis. But you will not read about it in the newspapers or see it reported on television because their plight seems to be something arising out of South Africa's bad old past - a past which everyone, black and white, would like to forget.

According to one leading political activist, Mandla Nyaqela, this is the after-effect of the huge degree of selfishness and brutality which was shown towards the black population under apartheid.

"It is having its effect on whites today, even though they still own a share of South Africa's wealth which is entirely disproportionate," he said.

Find out more

John Simpson

BBC News: The Editors features the BBC's on-air specialists asking questions which reveal deeper truths about their areas of expertise

That may all be true. But the people who are suffering now are the weakest and most vulnerable members of the white community.

Ernst Roets, a leading Afrikaans campaigner from the AfriForum organisation, took me to a squatter camp outside the country's capital, Pretoria. A white squatter camp.

It has been set up on the property of a sympathetic white farmer and is called, optimistically, Sonskyn Hoekie - Sunshine Corner.

There are broken-down cars and bits of discarded furniture everywhere. Beyond the wooden shacks lie ditches and pools of dirty, stagnant water where mosquitoes breed. Two basic toilets serve the whole camp.

According to Roets there are 80 white squatter camps - many of them bigger than this - in the Pretoria area alone. Across South Africa as a whole he believes there could be as many as 400,000 poor whites in conditions like these.

Sonskyn Hoekie has no water and no electricity. The inhabitants live on two hand-out meals of maize porridge a day, which is provided by local volunteers. There is no social security for them, no lifeline - any more than there was for non-whites when apartheid ruled.

Share of income in South Africa 1993 and 2008

Graph showing share of income in South Africa between 1993 and 2008

"I don't want to live in a place like this," said Frans de Jaeger, a former bricklayer, who with his beard and wrinkled face looks like one of the old Voortrekkers.

"But I can't get out."

His wife died suddenly of cancer a few years ago and it sent him into a downward spiral of binge drinking and destitution.

Semi-skilled white people have little chance of getting a job when so many black South Africans are unemployed.

There is another group of white Afrikaners, far higher up the social scale, who are deeply threatened - in this case, literally. Virtually every week the press here report the murders of white farmers, though you will not hear much about it in the media outside South Africa.

In South Africa you are twice as likely to be murdered if you are a white farmer than if you are a police officer - and the police here have a particularly dangerous life. The killings of farmers are often particularly brutal.

A graveyard near Geluik A graveyard near Geluik, where two murdered farmers were recently buried

Ernst Roets's organisation has published the names of more than 2,000 people who have died over the last two decades. The government has so far been unwilling to make solving and preventing these murders a priority.

Who is poor in South Africa?

  • Average annual black income in 2011: $2,300
  • Mixed-race (coloured): $4,300
  • Asian: $7.700
  • White: $17,500

Source: South African Institute of Race Relations

I went to a little town called Geluik - happiness. A few weeks ago gunmen burst into the farm shop there and opened fire, killing one farmer outright and injuring one of his sons and a shopworker.

They stole next to nothing. It seemed to be a deliberate, targeted killing. Soon afterwards the son died of his injuries.

Belinda van Nord, the daughter and sister of the men who died, told me how dangerous the lives of white people in the countryside have become. The police, she said, had seemed to show little interest in this case.

In the little graveyard where her father and brother are buried there are two other graves of farmers murdered recently. The wonderful landscape which surrounds it has become a killing ground.

There used to be 60,000 white farmers in South Africa. In 20 years that number has halved.

In the old days, the apartheid system looked after whites and did very little for anyone else. Nowadays white people here are on their own.

Those who fit in and succeed will certainly have a future. As for the rest, there are no guarantees whatsoever.

BBC News: The Editors features the BBC's on-air specialists asking questions which reveal deeper truths about their areas of expertise. It is available on the BBC iPlayer and is also on BBC World News.

  • Update 29 May: John Simpson addresses some of the issues raised by this report in this article.

More on This Story

In today's Magazine


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 371.

    90% of people reading this wouldn't have even known about the white squatter camps because its not reported by the media. Why keep it quiet?

  • rate this

    Comment number 225.

    In Zimbabwe we have a Shona saying "Demo rinokanganwa asi muti watemwa haukanganwe" (The axe that cuts the tree can easily forget, but the tree thats been cut will not forget). Simply put it means, its easy to forget your own faults, but those you've wronged won't find it so easy to forget.

    What's happening should be a lesson to humanity on the need to respect and treat each other as equals.

  • rate this

    Comment number 74.

    The child in that picture is not guilty of anything. Put aside your pre-conceived ideas about all white saffers being ignorant racists who 'deserve' this. They come in all types just like the rest of us. The world media chooses not to report whats really happening to white and black alike because it suits them not to do so. The level of violence is intolerable. More reporting please.

  • rate this

    Comment number 60.

    The worm has definitely turned! Afrikaans speaking white people are in the minority, even amongst the white people, they speak a dying language. They must look towards their own for succour, Although their plight, especially the children, , is pitiful, there remain, millions more black south africans in similar, or worse, plights.

  • rate this

    Comment number 59.

    Poverty and deprivation exists in South Africa. I am surprised that people think that because of Apartheid, white people have brought this situation on themselves. We should feel sympathy regardless of colour


Comments 5 of 9



Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.