10 things readers want in a history of the world

history composite #2

Andrew Marr's History of the World is attempting to tell the story of civilisation in eight hour-long episodes. Last week he spoke of the difficulty of choosing what to include, and what to leave out.

Charlemagne didn't make the cut. Mughal emperor Aurangzeb did. And there had to be a host of other difficult omissions.

We asked for your suggestions for often overlooked moments in world history. Here are 10.

1. Industrial ammonia


"The work of Fritz Haber and Carl Bosch in 1909 is particularly important. They paved the way for a worldwide expansion in mechanised agriculture." Ade Jones, Lydney, Glos

In 1909 Fritz Haber and Carl Bosch created a way of producing huge amounts of fertiliser by artificially synthesising ammonia from nitrogen and hydrogen.

Fritz Haber

Fritz Haber

The fertiliser increased crop yields which allowed more food to be produced for a growing population. The process was described as conjuring "bread from air".

Without the Haber-Bosch process, about 40% of people - nearly three billion - would not be alive today because we could not produce the amount of food we need, says environmental expert Professor Vaclav Smil from the University of Manitoba.

"We have to eat and drink, everything else is optional. In that sense it's the most important scientific discovery. Organic agriculture would not provide enough food to feed the world."

But Haber's contribution to agriculture is often overshadowed by his work developing chemical weapons. During World War I, he developed the use of gas for warfare and his work was later used by the Nazis to poison Jews in the gas chambers.

Find out more

Of Jewish descent but "pardoned" because of his patriotic efforts in World War I, Haber was expelled from Germany after he refused to fire Jewish workers. He died of a heart attack one year later in 1934.

"We should remember his peaceful efforts before the Great War and recognise his contributions to science, useful for the whole of humanity to stave off possible famine," says Haber's godson, the historian Fritz Stern.

"He was a prime example of the complexities and contradictions of a scientist in wartime."

2. Andreas Hofer, rebel Austrian leader

"The story of Andreas Hofer deserves to be much more widely told." Dr Andrew Bellenkes, Pinswang, Austria

Napoleon and Austria

Arc de Triophe
  • Two of Napoleon's most famous victories fought against the Austrians - at Ulm and Austerlitz
  • Arc de Triomphe in Paris built to commemorate Austerlitz victory
  • Treaty of Vienna (1814) carved up Europe after Napoleon's defeat, and was a diplomatic triumph for the Austrian statesman Metternich

In 1809 Andreas Hofer led a rural rebel army to fight against Napoleon's troops to try and claim back Tyrol, a region of Austria that had been given to the German state of Bavaria.

An innkeeper in the countryside, his army was made up mostly of peasant workers and farmers. They only had improvised weapons and primitive military tactics.

For a short period in 1809 he ruled the land, announced new laws and made his own coins. But his success was short lived, and less than a year later, in exile, he was betrayed and executed.

Today he is celebrated as a hero. He has museums, books, streets and hotels named after him, but not many outside of Austria know who he is.

"If you look to Europe during the Napoleonic era, Tyrol was not of economic importance, it was just keeping the traffic routes between the North and South open," says historian and director of the Tiroler Landesmuseen, Wolfgang Meighoerner.

3. Alhazen and his work on optics

"The great Arabic scientific work of the 10th Century, and in particular the life of men such as Ibn al-Haytham (Alhazen)." James, Bristol

Father of scientific method

  • Al-Haytham proved that we see because light enters our eyes
  • Many of his scientific discoveries were made while under a 10-year house arrest

Ibn al-Haytham was born in about 965 in what is now Iraq, and is regarded by some by some as the real father of the scientific method, predating Francis Bacon and Rene Descartes in the 17th Century.

Al-Haytham was the first to disprove the theory that we see objects by rays of light emitted from our eyes, realising instead that we see because light enters our eyes.

No other scientist before him had used maths to prove this process, says Prof Jim Al-Khalili from the University of Surrey.

"When the great scientific revolution took place in Europe, science had advanced so much that people forgot it was built on previous knowledge."

Al-Haytham was part of the golden age of Arabic science, and while Europe was stuck in the Dark Ages, he filled the gap, says Al-Khalili.

4. Danube script

The Neolithic civilisation of central Europe (6000-3,500BC) and the enigmatic Danube script, which possibly influenced the first true writing." Jeremy Glover, Leighton Buzzard

The Danube script is a controversial subject among archaeologists, some of whom claim it is the earliest known form of writing in the world.

The early signs are found on Neolithic artefacts such as pottery and spindle whorls, concentrated in the Balkans and associated with the Vinca culture.

Some think tablets from Tartaria, in Romania, are exceptional as they "really look like 'writing'", notes James Mallory, professor of prehistoric archaeology at Queen's University in Belfast.

But he says no-one can tell for sure whether they are random symbols, a system of select magical symbols, or possibly some form of early writing.

There has also been a debate about whether they actually date to the Vinca period or were later insertions into the mound, he says.

5. Double-entry book-keeping

"Double-entry book-keeping, which revolutionised commerce first in Europe and then the world over." Philippa Sutton, Newcastle

Luca Pacioli, father of accounting

  • Born around 1447 in Tuscany, this Franciscan friar was friend of Leonardo da Vinci
  • His masterwork Summa de Arithmetica, Geometria, Proportioni et Proportionalita set out principles of double-entry accounting
  • His motto: "No person should go to bed until the debits equal the credits"

Double-entry book-keeping, which is widely believed to have been introduced to Europe in the early 16th Century by the monk Luca Pacioli, is a financial accounting system. It recognises that all transactions have two aspects, a credit and a debit, and in a properly constituted set of books, the two sets of figures always balance.

Prof Christopher Napier from the Royal Holloway, University of London, says the system provided a standard structure for businesses and individuals to record transactions, and it helped entrepreneurs and investors to measure their capital, and the profits of their business.

Some people argue that double-entry prompted a shift in culture, Napier says, from a time when the goal was simply to earn a good living, to a culture where the goal was to maximise one's capital. But there are some historians of accounting who argue it's possible to overstate the influence of double-entry, Napier says.

6. Seven Years' War

"The Seven Years War was truly the first WORLD war and is overlooked in history." Cleggy, Northfleet, Kent

The Seven Years' War (1756-1763) involved all the great powers of Europe and saw France, Austria, Russia and Sweden on one side, and Britain, Prussia and Hanover on the other.

The Death of Wolfe

The Death of Wolfe
  • Benjamin West's 1770 painting is probably most famous image of Seven Years' War
  • James Wolfe died from his injuries while leading British troops in Battle of Quebec

Michael Ball, curator of Britain's National Army Museum, says the Seven Years' war could arguably be seen as the first world war, "not in the sense of the 20th Century wars, which saw entire nations mobilised for war, but in terms of geography".

"The battles affected North America, India, the Caribbean, the Philippines and large parts of central Europe," he says.

Prof Mark Knights, of the University of Warwick, says the Seven Years' War could also be seen as the first world war due to its "shockingly high" casualties.

"Estimates vary but it is likely that more than a million people died," he says.

The result of the fighting, which saw Britain acquire Canada from the French and control all of North America east of the Mississippi, was also "very significant", according to Ball, and ultimately led to the American war of Independence.

It also saw Britain become, arguably, the first world power, he says.

7. The Kingdom of Axum

"Civilisations are neglected. What about Axum?" Berhanu Tessema, Addis Ababa

The Kingdom of Axum (or Aksum) rose to prominence as a trading nation in the 1st Century, and at its height became the greatest market of north-eastern Africa.

Its most renowned surviving monuments are a group of memorial obelisks, or stelae.

There are many reasons for including Axum in any world history, says James Burns, author of A History of Sub-Saharan Africa.

The kingdom represents a significant and highly innovative urban civilisation.

"Its economy was based on the cultivation of crops grown exclusively in the Ethiopian highlands, supplemented with cereals and technologies imported from Asia. It was one of Rome's great trading partners, and they rose and fell in close parallel," he says.

The kingdom was one of the earliest regions of Christian conversion in Africa. "The image of an isolated Christian kingdom captured the imagination of Christians in Europe throughout the Middle Ages", he says.

8. The law code of Hammurabi

Hammurabi's code

"The law code of Hammurabi ought to be in too - the first time a ruler laid down a coherent set of laws which all his people must live by." Ben Gate, Pontypridd

A basalt stele (slab) protrudes into Paris' Louvre like a thumb. On it is the earliest truly extensive documented set of laws of the ancient world, written in Akkadian.

It is commonly referred to as the Law Code of Hammurabi, but some experts argue it's not really a law code at all. It does however provide an incomparable insight into life and justice during King Hammurabi's reign (1792-1750BC) as first ruler of the Babylonian Empire.

The stele sets out the famous principle of "an eye for an eye". But also included are familiar concepts of evidence-based justice and giving testimony under oath - even provisions for the maintenance of divorced wives.

There were precursors to Hammurabi's laws, explains Dr Frances Reynolds, Assyriology expert at Oxford University, but the stele and 130,000 clay tablet documents from the period establish the king as a "fantastic administrator".

It perhaps explains why he adorns the wall of the American Supreme Court, suggests Reynolds.

9. Rise of the Khmer empire and creation of Angkor Wat

Angkor Wat

"The Khmer Empire reaching its peak in the 12th Century and its influence on south-east Asia." Paul McShane, Edinburgh

Thousands of backpackers and awed holidaymakers have stood and gazed at the massive temple complex of Angkor Wat deep inside the Cambodian jungle.

The Angkor temples are legacies of the Khmer Empire, which dominated south-east Asia from the 9th Century.

"One of the first and certainly the most important classical civilisation of southeast Asia, it set the standards by which kingdoms and societies that came after measured themselves", says Dr Charney, an expert from SOAS.

Angkor became the "largest pre-industrial urban complex in the world", says Cambridge PhD student Mary Beth Day, featuring the "most sophisticated hydraulic engineering and water management system". The Khmer could collect and store water across 1,000 square km, channelling it directly to rice paddies.

Yet the empire's demise remains a "contentious issue", says Day, with many details shrouded in mystery.

10. The life of Simon Bolivar

Mural of Simon Bolivar

"Simon Bolivar's liberation of five countries from the Spanish yoke." Luis Rodriguez, Leigh-on-Sea

Inspired by European enlightenment philosophy, Caracas-born Simon Bolivar helped liberate his people from the Spanish Empire, gaining independence for the modern-day nations of Bolivia, Colombia, Ecuador, Panama, Peru and Venezuela.

Simon Bolivar

  • Born 1783 in Caracas, New Granada (now Venezuela), died 1830
  • Soldier and statesman who led revolutions against Spanish rule in Latin America
  • Bolivia named after him

His political rule was less successful. Unable to fend off factional enemies and increasingly dictatorial, Bolivar died awaiting exile in 1830, "disillusioned that he was unable to maintain the ideals of freedom, liberty and equality", says Dr Matthew Brown, a Latin America expert at Bristol University.

Bolivar's impact was nevertheless vast.

The "most significant figure" to emerge from Latin America, he was even "more important than [US President George] Washington", says Anthony McFarlane, emeritus professor at Warwick University.

He played a critical role in the decline of the Spanish Empire, which in turn marked a huge shift in global imperial relations. Bolivar's leadership also served as a "model" for later anti-colonialist movements, adds McFarlane.

Reporting by Tom Heyden, Vanessa Barford and Melissa Hogenboom


More on This Story

In today's Magazine


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 107.


    See your point and I'm not religious myself. However, pretty much all flavours of personal morality and cultural norms have sprung from religious roots. Lunatic extremists aside for a moment, I seriously doubt whether mankind could have reached its present level of development without the civilising role of the major religions.

    ..as religion recedes, so do personal ethics. Sad but true

  • rate this

    Comment number 106.

    This is running before we can walk. Given the general abysmal standard of historical knowledge in this country, I kind of think the basics are more important than arguing over (politcally-correct) omissions.

  • rate this

    Comment number 105.

    Yes, these are 10 important historical moments important for a Western reader, not necessarily every single 'reader'.

  • rate this

    Comment number 104.

    None of these appear to be of earth shattering significance based on criteria of media friendly, profound and long lasting influence, and political correctness

  • rate this

    Comment number 103.

    92 topcat. yes history repeats itself and it should not. Politicians never seem to learn from the errors of the past and try the same daft policies that caused major headaches. As well as life experience they should have studied History before getting into parliament.
    A summary of History is like a coffee table book all pictures and no substance.

  • rate this

    Comment number 102.

    .James Froggatt
    4 Minutes ago
    My contenders are
    The first Arable Farmer
    The !812 US incursion to Canada

    11th November this year marks the 200th anniversary of the Battle of Cryslers Farm at which troops on the latter side defeated very many more troops of the former.

  • Comment number 101.

    All this user's posts have been removed.Why?

  • rate this

    Comment number 100.

    Slavery! Made such a huge contrubution to the wealth of the UK but is barely mentioned, ever. There are great lessons to be learned from slavery and rather than making the children of slavery angry, it would give them a sense of identy as survivors and not victims as it has done for me.

  • rate this

    Comment number 99.

    I did not find it that enlightening. I have listened to J.M.Roberts History of the world. And that is much better. How many things in world's history do you think can be fit into 8 hours. It also goes into depth concerning everything pre-history, Pre Paleolithic, and Paleolithic. It is a great program for children who don't learn much in the way of history now. But there are much better options

  • rate this

    Comment number 98.

    how about the throwing out of the French from Haiti? The only documented succesful slave revolt.

  • rate this

    Comment number 97.

    Many of the comments are about inventions and they are all important and cumulative. They all depend on the previous ones.
    However I would argue that the world has changed more in the last 50 years than in the previous 1,000 purely down to the invention of the greatest enabler of all time, the integrated circuit or microchip.
    This very debate could not happen without it.

  • rate this

    Comment number 96.

    There are others normally minimised or forgotten - the partition of India, Jinna's role in it, and the millions who died in the consequent bloodbath, Dutch atrocities in the East Indies and their links to the Boers and South Africa, the migration of Christianity through Europe in the 4th Century, and - above all - the Indus civilisation.

  • rate this

    Comment number 95.

    This programme is a dumbed down version of Brysons 'A Short History of Nearly Everything'. Which is in itself a massively dumbed down version of history for a populist audience.

    'History Lite', I'm afraid. I prefer my history from turgid academic tomes anyway. Quite agree with the 'left out' selections, btw. Some good ones in there - Haber-Bosch and the codification of Hammurabi in particular.

  • rate this

    Comment number 94.

    If there's one thing that the BBC should include for it to be considered as transparent and objective as it claims to be, it is the atrocities of what our British Empire did to the rest of the world.

  • rate this

    Comment number 93.

    @ HELEN_of_TROY

    I think the lack of women in history is more down to societies norms regarding men and women at the time rather than a deliberate attempt to exclude women from history.

  • rate this

    Comment number 92.

    81 # yes history repeats it self on the wheel of life,looking foward to lessons to learn,greeks oldest computer in world ,2000 years old, big human settlements in amazon pre conquistadors,big topic see the sky at night history in the making before our very eyes,The lesson is i suppose keep on trying u never know,what will come up with,all the codes to decypher and interpretet fascinating indeed

  • rate this

    Comment number 91.

    I've a soft spot for 'technology moments' as the missing but vital ingredient - like the argument of Lynn White Jr that the invention of the stirrup was vital for our whole social and political system, or the argument of Joseph Needham that the invention of gunpowder in China changed our world forever.

  • rate this

    Comment number 90.

    As noted, someone will always feel like something has been left out.


    I don't mind when they talk about religion, because religion shaped civilisation, even if, like myself, you believe it to be wholly irrelevant now, it formed civilisation as we know it, for better and for worse. No point in pretending it didn't affect anything.

  • rate this

    Comment number 89.

    Haven't watched it yet but I bet the first ten minutes of the programme, and every subsequent one, is taken up by telling us what is going to be in the rest of the series, complete with cute little clips and sound-bites, and the last five minutes is used to tell us what we will be told "next time" with a selection of the same cute little clips and sound-bites which we saw at the beginning.

  • rate this

    Comment number 88.

    My contenders are
    The first Arable Farmer
    The !812 US incursion to Canada
    French Philosophy particularly Denis Diderot
    The development of Chinese philosophy after Confucius particularly Mencius
    The Swedish Hegemony in the 17th Century


Page 17 of 22



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.