A Point of View: Why sales of stamps flourish in tough times

Gold-painted postbox

As well as being a risk-free investment that guarantee a real rate of return, postage stamps provide a unique way for people to insure against an uncertain future, says John Gray.

Back in April of this year there was a run on postage stamps.

Not the Penny Black variety, rare examples of which can be sought by collectors and sold for large sums at auctions - but the familiar, everyday stamps you stick on your letters. At the end of that month, the price of a first class stamp rose from 46p to 60p, and a second class stamp from 36p to 50p.

The largest rises in percentage terms since 1975 - 30% and 39% respectively - led to people stocking up as many as they could afford to buy.

The window for stockpiling didn't last long, since the Royal Mail rationed supplies to retailers - but one small business owner announced he would buy 10,000 before the rise took effect.

Unknown numbers of people bought extra stamps on a more modest scale.

Those who stocked up on stamps did so for a simple reason- to postpone the impact of the price increase they knew was going to take place. Buying the stamps right away saved them money, and if they bought enough of them they could avoid higher prices for a considerable period of time.

Find out more

John Gray
  • John Gray is a political philosopher and author of False Dawn: The Delusions of Global Capitalism

But maybe there was more to it than that. Perhaps people bought the stamps because the stamps provided something that existed nowhere else. By buying them, they could insure themselves - in however small a way - against an uncertain future.

A risk-free investment that guaranteed a real rate of return, the stamps presented a unique opportunity. Where else can you any longer find any real return on your money?

One of the landmarks of the strange new world we've entered since the crash of 2008 is that interest rates on cash are in many cases practically zero. In reality, of course, they're negative, since inflation is steadily eroding the value of any cash you may have saved. Real interest rates - the rates for savers that you see advertised in banks minus the rate of inflation - have been negative for several years.

You can earn a real rate of return by buying high-yielding shares on the stock market, but only if you're ready to expose yourself to the hazard of large losses in another crash. That's a gamble many people are in no position to take - pensioners who have no prospect of rebuilding their life-savings, young people struggling to save up a deposit on a house and the millions who are worried about losing their jobs.

This state of affairs is a result of what has been described as financial repression - the manipulation of markets with the aim of reducing the burden of government debt. Bailing out the banks was necessary to avoid a catastrophic financial meltdown.

First and second class stamps Stamps - the face of stability?

But forcing interest rates down to a level where they are negative for year after year is a kind of slow-motion debt-write-off. This is what was done with the massive borrowings that were run up during World War I, after which exchange controls were imposed in Britain and other countries, stopping investors from moving their money abroad and compelling them to accept negative returns. Whatever methods they use, policies of this sort are an undeclared tax on savings.

That may not be the intention - governments have no reason to want people to stop saving - but it's the inevitable effect of trying to write off debt by means of inflation. Rightly, these policies are resented as unfair, even though their long-term effects are not immediately visible and few people understand how financial repression actually works.

In fact it's not clear that it will work. We're not in the post-war era when economies were relatively closed and capital was trapped. Today it can move in an instant, and some of the recent financial crises come from capital fleeing banks and governments whose solvency is in question.

Start Quote

Politicians tell you to put aside money for the future, but there seems little point when any money you set aside is certain to lose value over time”

End Quote

Again, though it may not be obvious when you're buying groceries, wages and prices in many areas are being driven down by global markets and the internet, and it's not as easy to stoke up inflation as it may seem.

Unless money is printed on a colossal scale and collapses in value as has happened in countries such as Zimbabwe, the hope that today's levels of debt can be wiped away by a dose of inflation may be just an illusion.

While we don't know whether financial repression will work, it's already clear that it's having an impact on the way we live. Politicians tell you to put aside money for the future, but there seems little point in doing so when any money you set aside is certain to lose value over time.

Even if inflation remains at low levels, your savings will melt away if the return on them is still lower. Worse, if your income is rising more slowly than the rate at which money is losing value, you'll be getting slowly poorer, like many people today.

Previously in the Magazine

Person posting a letter into a post box

Ahead of the UK postage stamp price rise in April 2012, the BBC Magazine went on a hunt to discover which country had earned the dubious honour of being the most expensive place to post a letter.

Find out the result here...

In these circumstances, the very idea of retirement is fast becoming an impractical dream. For younger people, this may seem a remote concern. But if you can't look forward to a time when you can enjoy the fruits of a lifetime's labour, what you have in front of you is a lifetime of chronic uncertainty.

There are economists who will tell you not to bother too much about this situation. Old-age pensions, they point out, are a recent innovation, invented - along with the welfare state - by the German statesman Otto von Bismarck towards the end of the 19th Century. In Britain, it was only in 1908 that Lloyd George brought in the Old Age Pensions Act, which guaranteed a minimum income to people who were over 70.

But the economists who point out that pensions aren't much more than a century old haven't told us what's going to replace them. Until the financial crisis, it was assumed private pensions could do the job. That assumed a stable growth in markets which couldn't possibly last. Sooner or later another market upheaval was bound to come. By shifting all the risk of saving for the future onto the shoulders of ordinary people, governments are forcing them to accept a level of risk that only the very rich can afford.

We're moving into a world we find unfamiliar, but maybe this strange new world isn't so new. Anyone who has read the novels of Charles Dickens knows there was a time when most people scraped a living from day to day, with no protection against hardship other than a miserable subsistence in the poor-house.

Far removed from the struggling majority, the rich inhabited a very different world, but even they could be suddenly ruined and end their days in the debtor's prison. Everyone lived surrounded by uncontrollable danger.

Striking public sector workers march in protest through central London, on May 10, 2012 The security that many enjoyed in the recent past is fading from memory

During the second half of the 20th Century, many of these dangers seemed to have been left behind forever. Two world wars and a great depression stirred governments to build defences against uncertainty - policies of full employment and a welfare state, which enabled people to live without fearing that their plans might at any time be overturned by an economic downturn or personal misfortune. Now, as a result of the huge debts that have been left over from an artificial boom, these defences are being scaled back. The relative security that many people enjoyed in the recent past is fading from memory.

We seem to be reverting to an older past in which a mega-rich minority pre-empts much of the profit of any growth in the economy, while the rest of the population has to scramble for whatever they can get. As has been the case throughout much of history, society is being divided into a majority that is destined to remain pinched and struggling and an oligarchy possessed of vast but fickle wealth.

The era in which the middle classes could plan for their old age and expect their children to enjoy the same security seems to be coming to an end. The run on postage stamps could be a sign that some of us are beginning to suspect that the settled life we took for granted may have been no more than an interlude.

Here is a selection of your comments.

All the developed economies are printing money in an attempt to inflate away debt - clearly it is not working. We appear to be heading towards a global depression which you describe as returning to the days of Charles Dickens. In that case we had better trust in the words of Mr Micawber that 'something will turn up' - even though its difficult to imagine exactly what.

David Hedges, Middelburg, South Africa

Buying and hoarding of stamps before a price rise shows public confidence in our system not he other way round. Your conclusions may be correct. Time will tell. But suggesting that a fiat token with no intrinsic value, priced in a fiat currency and designed to be used to pay for a service in a declining industry does not appear to be a good option of a store of wealth or an insurance against "Hard Times".

Ed, Mauritius

I am 91 and well remember the 70s when the price of oil went from two to 10 dollars a barrel, everyone thought the world was about to come to an end; it did not happen, nor will it happen now.

Reg de Freitas, Port Erin, Isle of Man

What I want to know is how come the Royal Mail can bring out a new Olympic stamp overnight but it often takes them two days to deliver a first class letter!

Terry Byatt, Lincoln, UK

I disagree. Dickensian poverty has long since departed, but we may still have a lesson to learn regarding the inevitability of inflation. Laptops and air travel have all become cheaper in the last two decades, as have many other things. Prices do not, and should not, always rise for no apparent reason, whatever the trade unions and Lady Thatcher seemed to think. The chronically low savings ratio and high level of personal debt in this country is what is really putting the middle classes at risk, and this article applauds such an approach as being inevitable and unavoidable. There is now no shame in having a permanent credit card debt or a mortgage that we all know was unaffordable without subletting every room in the house to pay for it. A country where a retired father is willing to remortgage his house just to give his daughter a deposit for hers, or a brand new car in another case, is a country sitting on a time bomb of unpaid debt, which people ran up because they agreed to spend these ridiculous sums of money buying things they did not NEED and secretly hoping to make a tidy profit in the future just from the roof over their head. It is the massive material expectations, fuelled by greed as much as credit, which speaks volumes about the state of British society today and which is prominent among our new generation of expatriates out here as well who think nothing of taking out huge personal loans here and then running away because they cannot pay.

AC, UAE

Buying sheets of stamps before the postage rate goes up is hardly an investment. For a start, it only applies to those stamps that simply have 1st or 2nd class printed on them. As a single individual or householder, how many postage stamps are you likely to use in a year? Even companies & government departments use franking machines and Business Reply Services rather than stamps. To the stamp collector, these stamps are boring and worthless. How are you going to sell them if you want to realise your investment? Buy gold coins or RARE stamps instead.

Donald King, St Albans

More on This Story

In today's Magazine

Features

  • How ebola spread graphicPatient zero

    Tracking first Ebola victim and how virus spread


  • A young Chinese girl looks at an image of BarbieBarbie's battle

    Can the doll make it in China at the second attempt?


  • Prosperi in the 1994 MdSLost in the desert

    How I drank bat blood and urine to survive in the Sahara


  • Afghan interpetersBlacklisted

    The Afghan interpreters left by the US to the mercy of the Taliban


  • Flooded homesNo respite

    Many hit by last winter's floods are struggling to pay soaring insurance bills


BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.