Louis Theroux on dementia: The capital of the forgetful

Louis Theroux

With an ageing population, a wave of dementia is approaching. Caring for those afflicted isn't easy, writes Louis Theroux.

Nancy Vaughan is a charming and lively conversationalist, a friendly host, and at nearly 90, still has much of the sparkle and attractiveness that must have turned many heads when she was in her heyday as a model in New York.

But she also has trouble remembering her own name, or the fact that she is married (62 years and counting), or indeed, much of the time, some of the basics of the English language.

Nancy is in the advanced stages of Alzheimer's.

On a sunny late autumn day I visited Nancy and her husband, John, at their home in Phoenix, Arizona. We made friendly conversation in the kitchen and for moments I could have believed that she was mentally well.

Her smile is still engaging, she is physically fit, and she can sometimes carry on brief exchanges. When I asked if she had any problems with her memory, she said an emphatic "no".

Find out more

  • Louis Theroux - Extreme Love: Dementia is on BBC Two on Thursday 26 April at 21:00 BST

But when John posed the question directly "Nancy, what is your name?" she looked a bit baffled. Asked for her surname, Nancy said "Bread", a little uncertainly. I wondered whether this might be her maiden name, but was told that was Johnson.

Nancy and John's life has become surreal and stressful in many ways. John has taken to wearing a name tag with his name on it to help Nancy identify him.

He has also stuck a copy of their wedding photo up in the kitchen so that, in her confused moments, he can prove to her that they are married.

John cares for Nancy fulltime. They have no children, so there is no family help take the strain - and they are not in the financial position to have Nancy go into a care home.

Aged 88, John is the full-time carer for someone with many of the same needs as an adult-sized toddler.

John and Nancy are by no means exceptional. There is a slow-moving tsunami of dementia advancing towards us as our population ages.

Louis Theroux and Nancy Looking after those with dementia can be a full-time job

It's reckoned that one in eight Americans aged 65 and over has Alzheimer's - the most common cause of dementia. Nearly half of the over 85s has the disease. As medical science has become better and better at prolonging our lives, the mental side of things hasn't kept pace.

Nowhere is this more in evidence than in Phoenix. For years Phoenix has been a mecca for America's elderly, who are attracted by the year-round sun and dry desert heat.

Now increasingly it is a kind of capital of the forgetful and the confused.

Not coincidentally, Phoenix is also pioneering the way dementia sufferers are cared for and treated.

One of the top destinations for people in need of round-the-clock care is Beatitudes, a gated retirement complex, which has, tucked among its many buildings, a memory support annex.

Most of the residents at Beatitudes have seriously impaired memories, to the point where they can no longer look after themselves, are quite often confused, and occasionally have delusions.

Alzheimer's disease

  • Memory and the ability to think clearly are gradually lost over time
  • There may also be a change in personality
  • Behaviour problems and communication difficulties may also occur
  • People with severe Alzheimer's may find it difficult to perform everyday tasks, such as dressing, washing and eating
  • As time passes they may not recognise people or their surroundings, so it's common for them to go for a walk and get lost
  • There is no cure, but drugs can slow loss of mental function for some patients

It's not uncommon for a resident to imagine that they've seen a non-existent intruder, or to suppose that because they cannot find a purse or wallet, that someone has stolen it.

Partly under the influence of a Bradford University-based psychologist, Tom Kitwood, Beatitudes' carers have a policy of not contradicting - and even playing along with - the delusions of the residents, avoiding confrontations, de-escalating conflicts, and "redirecting" the attention of those in distress, using distractions and pleasurable activities.

Beatitudes staff use medication as little as possible. They try to be flexible and adapt to the quirks of the residents and the symptoms of their condition, letting them wander the corridors at night should they feel urge, letting them bathe, eat and sleep on their own schedule, and offering them snacks and chocolate at any time of the day or night.

I spent the best part of two weeks at Beatitudes, observing their practices first-hand.

One of the people I got to know was Gary Gilliam. A 69-year old, Gary had been a successful dentist in his younger years, as well as doing time in the army.

He'd been at Beatitudes several months when I met him, and though his memory came and went, he spent much of his time under the misapprehension that he was still a practising dentist, stationed at a military base.

Gary was genial and playful, constantly cracking jokes, and so it took me a while to realise quite how advanced his dementia was.

He told me he'd been having some problems with his short-term memory but he had no idea he might be in any kind of care home. But rather than contradict him, the staff would gently go along with Gary's version of reality.

Louis Theroux with Gary One technique is to avoid challenging those with memory loss

Quite often, especially in the evening, Gary would imagine that his time on "the base" was up. He'd pack his bags and start looking for the exit.

Staff would cajole him into staying another night, saying it was a little late now, it was dark out, better to leave it until morning. Or they might ask Gary to look at their teeth, at which point he would switch into dentist mode and forget his plan.

Gary also had a habit of forgetting that he was married, despite the fact that his wife of nearly 30 years, Carla, was alive and well, and a frequent visitor.

Being one of the few men on his unit, Gary's company was much in demand. He had two girlfriends, who enjoyed cuddling with Gary, though the exact extent of their intimacy wasn't clear.

I had the chance to observe this rather odd love triangle - or "love square", if you include the second girlfriend - when I accompanied Carla on a visit. To my surprise, she suggested that Gary bring one of the girlfriends with him.

Start Quote

The ravages of dementia can be unbelievably upsetting to see”

End Quote

She said this would make the visit run more smoothly - seeming to imply that Gary might prefer the company of his new friends over hers - but I was also struck that Carla was keen for me to see and understand the pain and the strangeness of loving someone with Alzheimer's.

Perhaps the most extreme visit I observed during my time at Beatitudes took place between a young man called David Watson and his mother Gail.

Though she wasn't very old, Gail's dementia had progressed very quickly. She was on the fourth floor of the Beatitudes memory support building, home to the most advanced cases.

Gail could no longer speak at all, though she was physically well, and would wander the corridors often picking up objects and approaching people, endlessly repeating a sound that sounded like "gulla".

David tried showing old photos to his mum. He tried stopping her on her perambulations for a hug. There wasn't much sign of recognition that I could see.

David explained that his sisters no longer visited. "Because this is hard," he said. But then, a moment later, David's mother leaned in and held his face in her hands. "So that's why I come and visit," he said, visibly moved. "Because sometimes that happens, and then that's good."

Near the end of my stay in Phoenix, egged on by John, I volunteered to care for Nancy for half a day, hoping to give him some small respite but more importantly to have a small glimpse of what John goes through on a daily basis.

Louis Theroux with 49-year-old Selinda Border, who is suffering from early onset Alzheimer's, her husband Glen and nine-year-old daughter Caleigh Selinda Border, 49, is suffering from early onset Alzheimer's

I discharged my duties as carer with mixed results. We played ball in the kitchen and broke a glass. We started a walk and then abandoned it.

Some of the time, she was baffled as to who I was and exactly what I was doing in the house. But along the way, we also managed to enjoy ourselves, listening to music, eating lunch together, looking at photos, and indeed chuckling together over the minor calamities that befell us.

When John returned and relieved me of my position, I asked him how much of Nancy he thought was left. He answered in the spirit of the engineer he'd been, with an exact number.

"Thirty per cent," he said, and then he tapped his head, and said that the rest was still preserved safely in his memory.

It was an oddly romantic moment.

The ravages of dementia can be unbelievably upsetting to see. No one would wish the confusion and forgetfulness that goes along with the disease on another person - though sadly, for demographic reasons, they are likely to be an ever-increasing part of our lives.

But my stay in Phoenix also taught me to be mindful of certain positives.

However much is taken by dementia, something always remains. There can still be a person beyond their words and their memories, a spirit, for want of a better word, and a continuity with the person they were.

Faced with the disease, and with the right support, most people can learn and adapt, finding new ways to love their parents and partners.

Here is a selection of your comments

My late father suffered from dementia and for many years when we visited him in his care home we hardly got a peep out of him , on the many occasions I visited I tried to make conversation about the most mundane events of the past week but never received the slightest response One day stuck for something to say, I mentioned that our old cat that my father had been fond of had died and that I was quite upset. Incredibly my father started crying like a baby, it was all so upsetting mainly because I knew then that Dad must have been able to understand my earlier conversations but was unable to respond, somehow the death of our cat had unlocked something. Dad died peacefully a short time after ,so I'll never know what want on in his mind. I wonder if any other readers have had any similar experiences.

Lawrence Berg, London

My mother has dementia and is in a nursing home. Although my mother in law had Alzheimer's it wasn't so bad because she forgot why she didn't like me. Seriously,her demeanour prior to this was quite nice. However,my mothers demeanour was not as pleasant and the longer she had it the personality got quite nasty. Very sad. Why must life be so cruel at times?

George Altschul, St.Marys, Australia

The ratio of nurses to patients has to be very high. Not only do these people suffer with Alzheimer's, but usually have an assortment of other illnesses that generally accompany old age. It's not an easy job and the pay is disgraceful. I qualified and work in Germany, which is light years away in its care of dementia, along with Switzerland and Holland.

Maggy Schoettler, Luedenscheid, Germany

Is there any research to show a relation between the increased lifespans of humans and dementia? Meaning, are we physically outliving our brain's lifespan?

Murthy, Hyderabad, India

With a mother who is probably an undiagnosed Alzheimer's patient (a bad fall down a flight of stairs has sped up things), the most difficult thing about the disease is when you think of what the patient used to be. My mother was an active, retired schoolteacher, who as long as I can recall, ran a wonderful house. And in a strange way, she has now become extremely lovable, and very much more demonstrative about her emotions, a sea change from the reserved person that she used to be.

Roopa, New Delhi, India

How can I make a legally binding request that, if and when I lose my marbles, I am to be put down? To be euthanased, if a non-animal euphemism is preferred. I am middle-aged, not at all religious, and of sound mind. For me, there is no sanctity without dignity, and this loss of mind would too diminish my dignity.

Julian D. A. Wiseman, London

I work as a hospital cleaner in a geriatric ward. A lot of of them never have visitors. Despite their dementia they all do remember well that they have a family that is never here for them. They call their names into emptiness, get angry and cry at the thought of abandon. That does not help them "organize" their thoughts and they drown further away from reality.

Luc, Montreal, Canada

My husband has Alzheimer's and I have no family to turn to for help. I would just like to say that there is no one out there to help the carer of the Alzheimer's person and it is very very hard trying to cope on your own when I am 5.ft 1" and my husband is 6ft 6" and does become very aggresive. I get so desparate for some kind of support. I am just told to ring the police!

Lyn Nailer, Stratford upon Avon, Warwickshire

My mother died 30 years ago after suffering dementia for 10 years. In those days we didn't know what it was and consultants would not tell the family anything. We really kept in the dark and did not know what it was until just before she died. In those days the only advice we were given was to act as if she was well. This was the wrong approach and made life even more stressful. My father cared for my mother and I didn't really understand the hell that he was going through, until recently.

Jim McCarthy, Wainfleet St Mary, UK

My dad has vascular dementia where your memory goes down in stages and over the last 12 months since having to put him into a home we've watched him disappear from us almost completely. My advice to anyone who has a relative or friend with this disease is keep going and enjoy your time with that person. Hearing that 'old story' for the umpteenth time isn't so bad as you will miss hearing it when they are lost to you and it's just a shell that looks and sounds like them with a totally different personality to the one you have known and loved. RIP dad and know we will look after your shell properly until it passes away.

Ian H, Bury St Edmunds

The programme didn't show any of the aggressive side of Alzheimer's or give people a real idea of what it is like to care for someone with the disease. The nursing home looked on the surface incredible but how many people could afford that?

Karen Street, Somerset

I am a registered nurse in Phoenix and am so happy to read that people are learning not to try and reorient patients with dementia. I was always taught in school to reorient these patients, and I never quite understood why. It would be terrifying to have someone tell you that what you are seeing or thinking is not real. Instead, I have usually played along with these patients and it seems to work much better.

Carrie, Phoenix, USA

The tragedy for those of us in our 30 and 40s is that we have not adequately addressed the question of who will take care of us when our time comes? Will there be enough money in the government coffers to subsidize the care? Will there be enough skilled manpower (nurses, attendents, aides)? We're all so busy making money, working hard at various jobs, entertaining ourselves with hobbies. Who will be there to help us if we also suffer from dementia? What is generation X doing about planning for the future? Or are we expecting a miracle?

Lorraine Pigeon, Toronto, Canada

I was reading somewhere that adding coconut oil to a patient's diet can help to either prevent or slow the effects of Alzheimer's/dementia or even to reverse them. My friend's mother has Alzheimer's and his dad has started her on coconut oil, but it remains to be seen if it helps.

Amy M, Whistler, Canada

More on This Story

In today's Magazine


Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.