Are thin women the enemy?

Angelina Jolie At the Oscars, Angelina Jolie came under fire for her thin frame

From super-skinny celebrities to models with low BMI, people are speaking out about women they perceive to be too thin. But some experts worry this behaviour makes things worse.

This week, Israel passed a law banning models from advertisements or fashion shows if they measure less than 18.5 on the body mass index (BMI). It's part of an effort to promote health for women of all sizes, and to stop glorifying the ultra-thin.

"Beautiful is not underweight," says Rachel Adato, one of the creators of the bill.

In recent years, much attention has been paid to how women are portrayed in the media, whether it's an overly airbrushed magazine model with an impossibly slim waist, or a TV starlet with protruding collar bones.

In an era when pro-anorexia communities congregate on social media sites like Pinterest, it's no wonder that lawmakers are concerned with women's body image.

For sure, reducing the number of images that portray women as very thin is beneficial, says Claire Mysko, director of Proud2BeMe, a website created with the National Eating Disorders Association (Neda) to promote healthy body image.

"There is a danger in being constantly exposed to one image of beauty," she says. "There is a serious lack of body diversity in the media. People are not seeing themselves and their bodies reflected."

Israel's law may be the catalyst needed to help make change. But others say it could make things worse.

'Arbitrary' system

Many magazine editors, modelling agents and casting directors say they want to use more diverse models, but can't because of industry expectations - with each blaming the other group for setting the tone.

"They all feel trapped into producing what nobody individually espouses," says Amanda Mears, author of Pricing Beauty: The Making of a Fashion Model. "Everyone felt individually powerless."

Regulating the types of models that can be used may be a good way to "shock" the system into making changes, she says.

However, she, along with many other experts on eating disorders and body image, worry that the law is flawed.

"Bodies come in different shapes and sizes, and the very idea that there is a concrete qualifying number, and if someone can match it they're considered healthy, is wrong," she says.

What about air brushing?

The Israeli law also requires air brushing to be disclosed, similar to laws in the UK, Spain and Italy. "That's something I can appreciate," says Eric Stice, a scientist at the Oregon Research Institute. "There are a lot of women busting their butt to look like an image that nobody really looks like. Not even the models look like they're portrayed in the magazine."

More disclosure about altered images can also help facilitate conversations with children, which can help build better media savvy, says Matthew Johnson, director of the Media Awareness Network. "Knowing it is manipulated is not enough," says Mr Johnson. "Young people need to have critical thinking skills."

BMI, a ratio of height to weight, is best used as a way to measure the average size of groups of people, but is not a good indicator of personal health, says Margo Maine, a clinical psychologist who has specialised in eating disorders.

"It's arbitrary," she says.

"In the past I would have welcomed [the law] but I am a little leery of the judgment about the correct body type."

Limiting the types of bodies that are permitted to model or considered attractive can backfire, says Matthew Johnson, director of education at the Media Awareness Network, a media education programme in Canada.

"What would be more effective would be encouraging a wider variety of body shapes on TV and in media in general."

Otherwise, the message is not to celebrate bodies of all shapes and sizes, but to reject extreme thinness.

Toxic effect

"We have reduced women to their size," says Dr Maine, author of the The Body Myth.

"By targeting women who are thin, whether they have an eating disorder or are naturally thin, we are focusing on the individual instead of challenging the culture that buys into it."

Modelling laws worldwide

Models in Moscow
  • Spain: Madrid fashion week restricted models who have a BMI of less than 18 (2006)
  • Italy: Government instituted a self-policing code of conduct for the fashion industry, including requiring medical proof that models do not have eating disorders (2006)
  • UK: the Advertising Standards Authority issued guidelines about the use of digitally manipulating photos, saying they will stop ads that are misleading, including those that portray extreme thinness (2011)

Thin women may have an easier go of it than fat women, but they're still subject to attacks about their size. Catherine, the Duchess of Cambridge, is subjected to constant speculation about her health and comments about her weight.

Angelina Jolie's Oscar appearance last month set Twitter alight with criticisms of her thin frame. "Angelina Jolie looks like her arms are ready to snap in half at any moment. Gross," wrote one user.

Speaking out against very thin star celebrities can feel like a satisfying blow against unrealistic body standards, says Raegan Chastain.

As an advocate for fat acceptance she has often heard people criticise women for being too thin.

Still, she warns those trying to come to terms with their own size to leave other people out of it.

"If you want to push against standards, you don't do that by bashing people," she says.

"You can't look at someone and tell how healthy they are. Weight and health are two separate things."

With that in mind, Neda has advocated that models be screened for eating disorders, but not that they be prohibited from working based on a size and weight limit.

They've also launched Proud2BeMe, an extension of a Dutch website designed as a safe space to discuss body issues and health concerns.

"There are people who are naturally thin and people who are naturally heavier, and we need to accept a diversity," Ms Mysko says.

"That's the goal: not to define one body type as attractive and another type as unattractive."


More on This Story

In today's Magazine


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 873.

    Marilyn Monroe was apparently a size 16; other well known & equally beautiful women take a size 8. There's a great spectrum of what is considered the 'ideal' weight - beauty is in the eye of the beholder.
    Personally I think as long as there's no eating disorder (of any type) involved - anything goes.

  • rate this

    Comment number 866.

    I have had anorexia and been an over eater, have a high metabolism, and now as someone in what is classed as Eating Disorder Remission, have to eat more than the average RDA in calories to keep my current weight and size. I've been at both ends of the scale. We need representations of all women, as long as they are healthy in the media. We need to teach that all sizes are natural and acceptable.

  • rate this

    Comment number 824.

    I am a healthy 65 yrs old woman, 5'3'', American size 18 (extra large), who carries her weight well. I do not really care about a model size as long as she is healthy and happy. It might be an issue within the industry but should not even be considered a problem for regular people. You can look great shopping at nickel-and-dime stores. Self confidence, my friends, self confidence.

  • rate this

    Comment number 810.

    My daughter is a model..and although she is a salad fan, is also fond of pizza and chocolate!... She is 5'6inches and 7st 5lbs and at age 17 was told by an ex-model 'booker' to lose a stone! Needless to say she told the booker she wasnt interested. She joined another agency and now has an international career, she is curvier than some .of the girls, but no less successful. Bones dont equal beauty

  • rate this

    Comment number 532.

    I am all in favour of enforcing a minimum BMI for models in order to counteract the growing problem of models being considered unacceptable unless they are extremely thin. Since the BMI is a little fuzzy at the boundaries, you can play it safe by setting a slightly lower BMI minimum, e.g. 17.5 or 18 (anything under 18.5 is considered underweight - it used to be 20).


Comments 5 of 13



Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.