Buy British: Why isn't there a new campaign?

 
19th March 1968: A man holds up a plastic carrier bag declaring I'm Backing Britain The 1968 I'm Backing Britain campaign was enthusiastic but short-lived

The British economy is in the doldrums, with the manufacturing sector flagging, so why aren't there more campaigns encouraging people to be patriotic and buy products made in the UK?

When buying a jumper, a piece of furniture or a bag of apples, do you check to see where it has come from?

Do people care whether it was designed, manufactured or grown by British firms or farms?

These are troubling times for Britain's manufacturing sector, once a relative bright spot in the country's lacklustre recovery, which contracted at its fastest pace in more than two years in October, as new orders plummeted.

But there is unlikely to be a clamour for consumers to start buying British.

In the US, people are used to hearing the phrase "buy American". It is seen as one of the ways of putting Americans back to work.

Adverts proudly proclaim how the product was born and bred in America, and closer to home, many French people would not dream of drinking anything other than French wine or driving anything other than a French car.

View from America

American woman dressed up for Independence Day

There was a surge in patriotic "buy American" rhetoric in the wake of 9/11, and it has returned to the fore in recent months as the country struggles to cope with rising unemployment.

But economic nationalism stretches back to the American Revolution. The Boston Tea Party was all about rejecting foreign-made products and there was another upsurge of it in the 1930s during the Depression.

According to a recent poll, 80% of Americans think it their patriotic duty to choose US-made products over foreign ones and there are many websites devoted to helping consumers find them.

But it is not clear how successful such campaigns have been in protecting US jobs.

America's biggest retailer Wal-Mart came under fire in the early 1990s for its "Bring It Home to the USA" marketing campaign after footage of children working in factories in Bangladesh emerged.

There has been a xenophobic undercurrent to some of the rhetoric in the past, such as the late 1970s campaign by auto workers to save their jobs, which flirted with Japan-bashing.

But in a sign of how times have changed, Japanese car giant Toyota is the latest big company to wrap itself in the stars and stripes, in TV ads showing off its American workforce, as it seeks to recover from a recall crisis.

There have been many Buy British initiatives over the years. Perhaps the most famous was the I'm Backing Britain campaign in the late 1960s.

It began in December 1967 when five secretaries at a ventilation and heating company volunteered to work an extra half hour each day without pay to do their bit for the flagging economy. It took on a life of its own and within the week, other companies were following suit.

Union jacks started to appear everywhere, the government endorsed the campaign and popular newspapers threw their weight behind it. But it fizzled out within months.

The then Labour MP Robert Maxwell launched a rival motto Buy British, a record sung by Bruce Forsyth sold just 7,319 copies, and campaign T-shirts were found to have been made in Portugal.

The song's chorus had the line: "The feeling is growing, so let's keep it going, the good times are blowing our way."

Surely British shoppers and workers could do with a similar injection of national pride in these economic dire straits? John Lewis certainly thinks so.

Last week, the retailer launched a new campaign to champion British manufacturing. From early next year, a Made in UK logo will start appearing on ticketing and online product information to highlight British-made products.

Other business leaders have also recently floated the idea, including the managing director of organic food brand Yeo Valley. Earlier this year, Merseyside cooker company Stoves launched a Made in Britain campaign and says some 250 manufacturers are now using the logo.

But it will take more than a handful of firms to change the British consumer mentality, says Vincent-Wayne Mitchell, professor of consumer marketing at the Cass Business School, City University London.

He says the default setting is unpatriotic because shoppers believe "German salami is better than British salami and French wine is better than British wine". Empire and immigration has led to the British consumer becoming "much less parochial".

"It takes a great deal of effort to change consumer consciousness. The government needs to be behind a campaign to give it economic credibility."

John Lewis's Made in UK logo will start appearing on products next year John Lewis's Made in UK logo will start appearing on products next year

But despite daily doomsday reports about high unemployment and low growth, the politicians have not been ordering us to go and buy British. Why?

Political pundit Kevin Maguire says it would be a bit like shooting yourself in the foot.

"It would be very hard for Cameron to stand up and say Buy British, when half of our exports go to the EU. If they did the same half our exports would no longer go there."

The Department for Business, Innovation and Skills says the UK relies on open markets and a Buy British campaign would be counter-productive.

"UK companies need to be able to access global markets so restricting access to the UK or the EU market could all too easily encourage retaliation, which would leave everyone worse off."

Food is one sector where the Buy British idea is having an impact. The farming industry has been trying to reverse a decline in the amount of British produce consumed - it has fallen from 75% in the early 1990s to 60% - through various campaigns.

Manufacturing in the UK

  • The sector is in relative decline. Over the past 30 years, manufacturing shrunk to about 12% of the economy. Banking and business services contribute 32% of what the UK produces
  • The number of people employed has dropped steadily from 5.2m in 1990 to 2.6m in 2009
  • Output reached an all time-high in 2007 though it has been struggling since 2008
  • It is the world's sixth largest manufacturer
  • Third largest sector in the UK, contributing £140bn to the economy in 2009

Source: BIS, ONS and PWC

The Red Tractor logo marks British food regarded as having high standards of safety and hygiene, animal welfare and environmental protection.

"Some food manufacturers have stepped forward and said they are only going to use British ingredients. Country Life is a very good example of that," says Sarah Whitelock, from the National Farmers Union.

Although consumers may be thinking more about where their food comes from and how many miles it travelled to reach their plate, the same cannot be said for their trainers, tables or television sets.

Prof Mitchell says the impulse to buy British tends to be associated with more expensive goods.

This means it can often be a choice between buying a luxury shirt made in the UK from London's Jermyn Street and buying a mass-produced shirt made in China from any High Street retailer.

The production line at the BMW plant in Cowley, Oxford Quintessentially British: The Mini is owned by German firm BMW, which has three plants in the UK

In addition to price, another problem for any Buy British campaign could be that many people assume that nothing is manufactured in the UK.

While the days of millions of people employed in industries producing large volumes of low-value goods may be a distant memory, the UK is the sixth largest manufacturer in the world by output and a leading exporter of high-tech goods.

And there are plenty of other statistics to blow away the rumours of the sector's demise - manufacturing is the third largest sector in the UK, after business services and wholesale/retail, and output reached an all-time high in 2007.

The UK is producing more with fewer people, and like most modern economies, the focus has turned to higher-value items such as aerospace and defence equipment.

Design Britain

A Dyson vacuum cleaner

There tends to be a hue and cry when British brands are taken over by foreign-owned firms or when British companies take their production overseas.

But there has been a trend for design teams to remain behind. One of the best examples was when Dyson shifted production to Malaysia from Malmesbury in Wiltshire in 2002. Manufacturing jobs were lost, while research and design jobs remained.

The latest figures, from the Design Council, show the UK design industry is expanding despite the difficult economic climate.

The design sector has grown over the last five years, with numbers of designers increasing by 29% to 232,000.

And the combined fee incomes of freelances and design consultancies, and budgets of in-house design teams, have increased by £3.4bn to £15bn.

Mat Hunter, chief design officer for the Design Council, says Britain is internationally renowned for its design skills.

"The UK has a great reputation abroad, whether for its architects such as Norman Foster and Richard Rogers, fashion designers or industrial designers."

Mat Hunter, chief design officer for the Design Council, says many people imagine that the UK is devoid of manufacturing since production started to move to the Far East, but there is in its place a rich mix of high-tech manufacturing, such as race-car makers McLaren, and artisanal producers such as furniture makers Ercol.

Terry Scuoler, chief executive of EEF, the manufacturers' association, admits the sector does have an image problem.

"There's an image out there that Britain is not a manufacturing giant. While we have lost a number of iconic brands, we are still a major manufacturer. We might not be making jets but we make very large parts of them.

"Britain is a big car manufacturer. Nissan, Honda, BMW have plants in the UK."

Therein lies another problem - what counts as a British product? Scuoler says this is irrelevant and any campaign should be Made in Britain, not Buy British.

He says foreign-owned firms are a massive part of our economy and are big investors and employers.

"Made in Britain would be a healthy banner and a healthy battle cry. The issue is not British ownership. It's about investing in Britain."

Hunter thinks a Buy British campaign sounds like a throwback to the post-war years and it actually has a different meaning in today's globalised world.

"I don't think it's about spending your money at home in a xenophobic way. It's about dispelling the myth that we no longer make anything and don't develop anything wonderful."

 

More on This Story

In today's Magazine

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    +56

    Comment number 276.

    Unfortunately, Britain's long-standing undervaluation of engineering drove much of our manufacturing overseas. Today, design-led UK companies get their products made in Asia but most of the value remains in the UK. Our challenge for the future is to make sure Britain's history of short-sighted decisions does not export our design industry, too.

  • rate this
    +41

    Comment number 274.

    I manufacture a product in the UK because I want face-to-face business; easier logistics for transportation of materials; and for ethical reasons: it is difficult to check the environmental impact of production or treatment of workers in the far east. Part of the product's material is made in Switzerland, but it is all cut, finished and packed here. I flag the product up as 'Made in the EU (UK)'.

  • rate this
    +14

    Comment number 271.

    I prefer to buy things made by British owned companies but unfortunately I rarely do as at the end of the day, cost matters.

    Perhaps British manufacturers of 'goods that matter' would return to the UK if the government reduced the tax burdens imposed upon these companies.

    And who cares about British companies like McLaren? They aren't exactly producing anything aimed at British consumers.

  • rate this
    +35

    Comment number 266.

    "The issue is not British ownership. It's about investing in Britain." Germany has been able to afford a) its excellent infrastructure and b) the complete renovation of the erstwhile GDR precisely because so many massive German owned global industrial corporations have been paying huge quantities of corporation tax into the German exchequer. There is a real value in home ownership of industry.

  • rate this
    +50

    Comment number 253.

    Do we really want to regress to the extent of becoming an 'import substitution' economy? The real goal is to get the rest of the world to buy British.

 

Comments 5 of 20

 

Features

  • chocolate cake and strawberriesTrick your tongue

    Would this dessert taste different on a black plate?


  • Duke and Duchess of Cambridge and Prince George leaving New Zealand'Great ambassadors'

    How New Zealand reacted to William, Kate - and George


  • Major Power Failure ident on BBC2Going live

    Why BBC Two's launch was not all right on the night


  • Front display of radio Strange echoes

    The mysterious 'numbers stations' left over from the Cold War era


  • A letter from a Somali refugee to a Syrian child'Be a star'

    Children's uplifting letters of hope to homeless Syrians


BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.