Herman Cain: Could he go the distance?

Herman Cain

Herman Cain has stormed to the front of the pack of Republican presidential candidates. So what is the appeal of the former pizza company boss and will this surge of popularity last?

Judging by the attention paid to him by primetime television comedians this week, Herman Cain is the man of the moment.

David Letterman and Jon Stewart both poked fun at the former chief executive of Godfather's Pizza, thereby confirming his arrival upon the American cultural landscape.

It's been a heady few days for the straight-talking businessman, who held his own in Tuesday's televised debate with his Republican rivals in New Hampshire. He sat centre stage, next to the frontrunner Mitt Romney, but got twice as many laughs.

A poll the following day by NBC and the Wall Street Journal suggested Mr Cain had surged to the very front of the field among Republican presidential primary voters, putting him ahead of Mr Romney by 27% to 23%, and continuing a surge of support other polls had indicated in the last week.

He's not the first Republican candidate to attract a section of the party that seems reluctant to support Mr Romney. Donald Trump, Michele Bachmann and Rick Perry have all burned brightly in the role of "perfect torch-bearers", as one commentator put it, only to fade.

Previous 'Not Romney' candidates

  • Rick Perry - support has ebbed after poor debates, but is well financed
  • Michele Bachmann - rowed back on controversial statements and lost ground
  • Donald Trump - pulled out of the race after urging Obama to prove his US birth

But Mr Cain, 65, shares little else with those rivals, and the differences go some way to explain why his sudden rise has raised eyebrows.

He's a man with no electoral experience and a CV which includes Baptist minister, mathematician, a director of the Federal Reserve Bank and radio talk show host.

The Cain campaign has no great financial backing and he has spent more time promoting his book than doing the hard graft in the key early primary states.

"It's definitively Herman Cain's moment and nothing short of astonishing that he's beating Mitt Romney in at least one poll," says John Avlon, author and columnist.

"He's the best communicator in the bunch by far, probably the best orator in the Republican party in recent times.

Living the dream

  • 1945: Born in Memphis but grew up in Atlanta
  • Father was a janitor, chauffeur and barber, and mother a cleaner
  • 1967: Graduated from Morehouse College, Atlanta, with maths degree
  • Early 70s: Begins a stellar career in business as systems analysts for Coca Cola
  • 1977: Moves to Pillsbury and takes over 450 failing Burger King restaurants
  • 1986: Heads Godfather's Pizza, rescuing them from brink of bankruptcy
  • 2000: Brief presidential run
  • 2004: Failed in Senate bid in Georgia

"He's also long been a favourite of the Tea Party and the evangelical community, so he's the ultimate validator of the Republican conservative movement."

The surge could last, says Mr Avlon, but the experience of Mr Trump, Mrs Bachmann and Mr Perry - whose stumble has mirrored Mr Cain's surge - suggests it's unlikely.

But he is a fresh face, he adds, which means he can escape the Republican anger directed at Washington.

That he is now reaching for the White House at all caps a wonderful personal story. Born in Tennessee to a janitor and a cleaner, his parents' hard work enabled him to go to college to study for a maths degree and a master's in computing.

In his 30s he was running hundreds of Burger King stores in the Philadelphia area and then took over the reins at Godfather's Pizza, reversing its fortunes and earning himself a place on the board of directors at the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City.

For many years, he hosted a radio talk show in Atlanta, an experience that political blogger and radio show host Bill Press believes has helped him in recent weeks.

"His talk show host experience has been extraordinarily valuable because you have to learn to get to the essence of things fast, to say things in a provocative way, and in that sense he's a very effective communicator. He's good for the soundbite."

999 plan

  • Scrap capital gains, estate and payroll taxes
  • Corporate tax at 9%
  • Federal income taxes at 9%
  • National sales tax of 9% for all products, on top of any state and local taxes
  • The idea bears similarities with a computer game called SimCity4 but Cain's team deny a link

"Nine, nine, nine," has been the constant refrain from Mr Cain in every TV interview, hammering home his tax policy that would reduce federal income tax and corporate tax code to 9% but - most controversially - introduce a 9% national sales tax that many from within and without his own party have ridiculed.

He's a clown and his 999 slogan is a joke, says Mr Press, because it would be political suicide to increase taxes on the middle class. "It says something about the electorate that they would be so easily guiled."

His straight-talking is part of his appeal, but some of his statements have drawn sharp criticism, particularly his comments in the past about Muslims. He has also implied that the unemployed only have themselves to blame.

He is most comfortable talking about jobs. And a glance at his website underlines his central message - that his success in business equips him to solve the country's severe economic problems.

'Cain will never win'

The Republican race has turned into The Wizard of Oz. Rick Perry wants a brain. Mitt Romney wants a heart. And any number of candidates are Dorothy, realizing there is no place like home and they should have stayed there.

Herman Cain is seeking courage. He needs the courage to face the fact he is never going to be the Republican nominee, no matter how well he does in the polls. He needs the courage to settle for something far better than the presidency: His own show on Fox.

Roger Simon, writing in Politico

Cain is a strong candidate who's bright, articulate and likeable, says polling expert Steve Mitchell, but while his lack of experience works in his favour because he has no record to attack, this could be viewed as a weakness when people cast their votes.

He will need to get an organisation in place, because Mitt Romney has a formidable one, and things don't happen without a strategy, says Mr Mitchell.

"A poll can prop you up and a good debate can prop you up, but when it comes to a campaign, it's dicey how well he can mobilise funds."

The instability in the polls suggests Republican voters are still under-whelmed by the choices on offer, and it could all change, says Shaun Bowler, a political scientist at University of California Riverside.

"The polls are picking up something - Cain comes across as folksy and straight talking which has an appeal.

"But I think the current polls shouldn't be taken as a set-in-concrete guide to how the actual electorate will vote in several months time."

More on This Story

In today's Magazine

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites


BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.