Fashion week: The ordinary people who stole the show

Bryanboy with camera on the front row at New York Fashion Week 2010 Blogger Bryanboy, wearing fashion-guru black, at New York Fashion Week 2010

As New York Fashion Week gets under way, fashionistas will be relying less on magazines and more on bloggers to tell them what they'll be wearing come spring.

Many people might not have heard of Tavi Gevinson, Scott Schuman, Susie Bubble and Bryanboy but they are household names to dedicated followers of fashion.

All four are big players in the blogging revolution that has turned the fashion world on its head.

For years fashion was something written about by a small number of publications whose writers guarded their access to shows and designers as fiercely as their Chanel handbags.

Even those whose sartorial experience amounts to a fraught trip to a shopping centre to replenish their wardrobes with essentials will be aware of the fashion bibles such as Vogue, Elle and Harper's Bazaar.

Fashion-minded

  • A Magazine series getting inside the folds of the fashion industry

These glossies contain expensively-produced adverts alongside picture-heavy reflections on the season's catwalk trends from the likes of Prada, Chanel and Dior, timed to coincide with them filtering into shops. Titles such as i-D, Dazed and Confused and FRUiTS represent the more radical end of the fashion magazine market.

But bloggers have been chipping away at the mainstream media as more and more people want to hear about fashion from people who apply it to everyday life.

Like consumers, the blogs come in all shapes and sizes. Schuman's Sartorialist blog photographs style as it catches his eye on the street, finding inspiration in everything from designer dresses to filthy workwear. Gevinson, who is now 15 and started Style Rookie at 11, has found fame by taking the catwalk and translating it through the mindset of a fashion-obsessed teen in her bedroom.

Bryanboy is the confessional journal and window into the world of Bryan Grey-Yambao, a camp and sometimes caustic commentary on his life and obsessions.

The hierarchical fashion landscape changed beyond all recognition with the advent of digital media.

Blogging stars

Tavi Gevinson with American Vogue editor in chief Anna Wintour
  • The Sartorialist - founded by Scott Schuman who started photographing people he saw on the street whose style he found striking
  • Style Rookie - started by Chicago's Tavi Gevinson (pictured above with Vogue's Anna Wintour) in March 2008, a month before her 12th birthday. She has just launched her own online magazine
  • Style Bubble - Susanna Lau, better known as Susie Bubble, started her blog in March 2006
  • Bryanboy - Bryan Grey-Yambao hails from the Philippines. A former web developer, he started blogging aged 17 from his parents' Manila home
  • Garance Dore - French illustrator turned style icon. Girlfriend of Scott Schuman

The situation was summed up by the flamboyant, meat-dress wearing Lady Gaga in her column for V Magazine: "The reality of today's media is that there are no echelons."

She believes the views of Gevinson are equal to that of Cathy Horyn, fashion critic for The New York Times with 25 years experience, and the Pulitzer-prize winning Robin Givhan of Newsweek and the Daily Beast.

Beyond the written word, online video platforms, digital photography and social networks have revolutionised the relationship between consumers and brands. Now anyone can be a critic.

Fashion brands broadcast their catwalk collections online and people can post an almost instant review on microblogging sites. Others go further and post videos and pictures of themselves flaunting their unique style or latest purchases.

YouTube is awash with videos of teenagers showing off their haul of clothes and cosmetics to their peers.

The phenomenon, known as "hauling", has been big news in the US for the past year and is now going global. It's not gone unnoticed by brands eager to capitalise on the apparently independent recommendation from the sort of person they want to buy their clothes.

The blogs that have stood out from the crowd tend to be chatty - short on analysis, long on opinion - and confessional. But the secret to their success is a quirky individual voice and distinct sense of style.

Robin Derrick, former Creative Director of Vogue UK, argues there are only a few really good blogs out there.

He says they made the meteoric rise to the fashion front row because the traditional print media were slow to fill the vast space emerging online.

Fashion blogger Susie Lau and actress Rachel Bilson at a launch party in 2010 Star attraction: Susie Lau (left) with US actress Rachel Bilson

"Nothing compares to the landscape change. It was an incredible collision of so many things all coming of age at once."

Bryan Grey Yambao - better known as Bryanboy - doesn't see himself as replacing fashion journalists. He says his personality is his USP and that's what drives people to his site.

"It's quite sad how quickly the traditional media were to pigeonhole bloggers as the future of fashion journalism.

"It's a different outlet, just like magazines are completely different from newspapers. It's a complement to what they do."

Lisa Armstrong, fashion editor at the Daily Telegraph, insists that newspapers have always recognised the powerful reach of the web and the need to engage with a younger audience who get their information online.

"We can all do speed, we've all got websites. It's not us against them. Newspaper fashion editors have got enormous experience and know what they're talking about."

She's not intimidated and welcomes bloggers bringing more people to fashion.

"What's great is that you can engage with fashion on every level - you can get all sociological and read 6,000 words in The New Yorker or you can read the blogger saying 'these platforms [shoes] are orgasmic' and I'm fine with that."

For many people fashion is an inhospitable, impenetrable and intimidating world. But bloggers have helped break down that perception of fashion as something that you had to be an insider to understand.

"It's made everything more approachable. When it comes to the traditional media, they have a very strict one dimensional view of things," says Bryanboy.

Top UK haulers

*Compiled by style comparison website stylecompare.co.uk based on a range of measures, including subscribers and views per video.

The old guard, initially undermined by the rise of bloggers with nothing more than a laptop and an internet connection, effectively retaliated by giving the bloggers the two things they didn't have - money and access.

Derrick feels the era of bloggers as an alternative free press, as independent voices, is already coming to an end as they increasingly seek to make a living from their sites and reputations.

Early adopters such as Susie Lau of Style Bubble and Scott Schuman of The Sartorialist have become part of the new digital media establishment, where they face increasingly well-heeled competition from digital editions of Elle and Vogue, as well as the brands themselves.

Schuman's Art of the Trench collaboration with Burberry is considered one of the most successful projects to combine the old and the new.

But the changing role of the star bloggers is not without its ironies, according to Armstrong.

"They do these projects online and then come to the journalists saying will you write about them. They still want the prestige and validation of being in print even though online gets more hits."

While big fashion brands still want the kudos from featuring in glossy magazines, they are trying to make their own websites the first port of call, says Derrick, who left Vogue to set up Spring, an agency specialising in digital fashion and beauty projects.

But Bryanboy says people will still want the views of independent bloggers because they are "more authentic" and "free to say what we want in spite of our commercial ties".

However he admits that the ease of access means it's tougher than ever to make the cut.

"Do we really need another girl taking photos of herself on the street and posting pics every day? In order for a new blogger to make an impact they really have to offer something new."

Here is a selection of your comments.

It isn't just fashion to be honest - after discovering some really wonderful wedding-related blogs online, I stopped buying any wedding magazines six months before my wedding. The blogs were updated daily, there were far more offbeat and budget weddings on them, and best of all they were free!

Jackie, Tonbridge

Who could argue with Tavi Gevinson's stories about "vibey" hats and dresses? Regency maidens would have been at home with such literature. Her pictures of the items she has collected are very pretty.

Ewan Lamont, Edinburgh

Blogging is the way to go, I've actually given up buying Vogue etc as I get the latest fashion news direct from the bloggers you have mentioned. In fact i dont purchase new fashion or beauty products until I see what my fav bloggers have to say. I also have a blog dedicated to beauty more so, and since starting this I have realised just how powerful a force us online writers are to the masses out there.

Seema, Kuwait

How can a 15-year-old or some random person with kooky taste possibly nudge aside fashion editors? Fashion bloggers are just a clear example of corporate social responsibility, designed to make fashion more "accessible" to the average person (however, not even in a tangible sense). Kudos for that I suppose, but their so-called independent opinion certainly doesn't make them journalists or editors; they simply cannot dictate to the fashion world.

Lydia, Singapore

Facehunter is missing from your major fashion bloggers list!

Susan Nguyen, London

I follow most of the style blogs mentioned in this article, however as their popularity and success has grown I find myself as cynical about their content as I do about that of traditional media. The roots of the success of these blogs are in their supposed independent opinion and the originality of the style of their authors, and in their making their style seem somehow more attainable to the common woman whose pockets mostly don't stretch enough to buy the products pushed in Vogue et al.

Denise Ross, Glasgow

I'm 16 years old and I love Tavi's blog, The Style Rookie. I think she is the most original fashion blog around because she doesn't conform to the normal teenage stereotype. I think the relationship between fashion bloggers and the fashion industry/fashion magazines is the same as news websites is to newspapers. Newspapers haven't disappeared off the end of the earth, and I don't think fashion magazines will either. There are a ton of fashion blogs out there and only the most interesting are popular, but it doesn't mean that the smaller ones are not as good. I follow a lot of fashion blogs because I like reading other peoples' opinions on the industry and how they interpret it. Tavi is one of my role models, she took an opportunity and now look at her. I would start a fashion blog but I know it will never reach a large readership level. I will just need to stick to reading other blogs.

Jean, North Berwick

I'm so happy you made the last point as I believe that like reality tv, we are reaching a point of saturation and that we can't possibly do it all as well as fashion bloggers. My strength lies in my writing on the subject of style and fashion, so I focus on that, including carefully selected images of fashion from other sources on My Passport to Style and not daily outfit posts. However I am aware that this move away from traditional fashion blogging, impacts on my following. I want to connect with a broader audience not just fashion bloggers and teens.

Sharon Gibson, Manchester

More on This Story

In today's Magazine

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.