What is it like to keep top state secrets?

Top secret files

A secret world of people in the UK, many of them ordinary citizens, are living extraordinary double lives to help the government. But what is it like to live with the danger and loneliness involved and keep important state secrets, ask Peter Taylor and Richard Knight.

Throughout the many violent years that led up to the Northern Ireland peace process, Londonderry businessman Brendan Duddy and his family lived with an extraordinary secret.

Duddy was, for decades, the secret intermediary between MI6, MI5 and the IRA. Without him it's unlikely that Northern Ireland would be where it is today.

"It took somebody with a lot of brains," says Seanna Duddy, Brendan's daughter. "He had what it took to go into a room, be in danger and keep his cool."

The threat to Duddy's life came not just from some members of the IRA who suspected he might be working for MI5, but from the loyalist paramilitaries who wanted to kill off any negotiations with the IRA - and perhaps anyone associated with them.

So the family could not breathe a word about the meetings between British intelligence officers and the IRA leadership that took place in the "wee room" in their family home.

Find out more

  • Living with Secrets is on Tuesday, 30 August, on BBC Radio 4 at 09:00 BST and 21:30 BST

"People had absolutely no idea," says Larry Duddy, Brendan's son. "Really close friends of my father for 50 years didn't know what he was doing.

"There's part of you wants to let the world know what your father did and there's another part that doesn't want anyone to know. I was quite happy with no-one knowing because it was the end result which was important."

Duddy finally did get the end result he wanted - peace in Northern Ireland. But his children made personal sacrifices as co-inhabitants of their father's secret world.

"When you came home from school you couldn't bring your friends home," says Seanna. "If everybody was out playing in the gardens or the roads nearby and it was our turn [for] our mammy to make tea, that never happened."

Attacks stopped

Most individuals who operate in the secret world do not involve their families. Many, in fact, tell no-one about their hidden lives, not even those closest to them.

Ali, a pseudonym, is a Muslim who was recruited by MI5 shortly after 9/11. When he spoke to the BBC it was the first time he had discussed his work with anyone other than his handlers at MI5.

He said he'd been able to stop some terrorist attacks but did not want to get into "the specifics". The impulse to share his successes or failures must, he says, be ignored.

"If you want to be able to help out doing this kind of work then you just have to hold those feelings in, which could be challenging but you learn with time," he says.

Ali is proud of what he does and of what he believes he has achieved. But he knows some in his community would regard him as a traitor and that his life as a Covert Human Intelligence Source - CHIS - is risky.

'Quiet satisfaction'

"I think it's quite evident that if some people would find out what I'm doing there may be people that probably would ignore it, there would be people who would try to do something about stopping me from helping out as well," he says.

"Therefore I'm careful and my handlers are being careful as well. And I've got my own brain... so I just have to be vigilant."

Man walking by IRA graffiti The IRA, MI5 and MI6 secretly met for years in the Duddy home

Steve, also a pseudonym, is a former undercover Special Branch officer who infiltrated the hard left to counter subversion. Steve adopted a cover story - known as a "legend" - and lived it for four years. He says his work put tremendous strain on both him and his wife, who knew his secret role.

"You're a police officer and you know your role, and you're briefed to do a role, and then you are operating as a political activist. You're living two lives, but you have to remember which is which."

Despite the pressures Steve says his years as an undercover officer were the best of his service. Ali continues to face significant risks but he also says, without hesitation, he would do it all again. The Duddy family made astonishing sacrifices for peace. Now they are able to view the transformation of Northern Ireland with quiet satisfaction.

Whatever you may think about the morality and ethics of those who live in the secret world, many are remarkable men and women. They are prepared to live with secrets, danger and loneliness, for what they believe is a greater good.


More on This Story

In today's Magazine


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 87.

    Everyone spys and everyone keeps secrets, the difference is the purpose and scale which are mostly just a matter of chance. If the secret services are anything like the overt services then God help us.

  • rate this

    Comment number 86.

    Post 83 Rouser. 'The original quote is

    "The first casualty when war comes is truth". Hiram W Johnson, staunchly isolationist senator for California, US Senate in 1917 to his death 1945'

    Johnson died on Monday, August 6, 1945. The day the USA nuked Japan in an attempt to get peace or as Capt JT Kirk says: We come in peace, shoot to kill! This must be true because I found it on the internet!

  • rate this

    Comment number 85.

    Post 80 Richard - Sshhhhhhh watch who you hack off matey or you may find yourself in an Egyptian jail - tak my word for it, you do not...

    Post 67 Fish damn you! You just gave my disguise away too!

    ***Our covers have been blown*** & Mother says we have to RTB to be debriefed - hope she's not feeling vendictive - look at what happened last time....

  • rate this

    Comment number 84.

    There are more people out there besides your 007's, MI5, MI6, SAS, and whatever else secret government yet to be disclosed etc., that cannot talk of their employment than you would believe ;@)

    EG: We do have real extra terrestrial Aliens lifeforms moving amongst & living alongside us I'll have you know.

    Google: UK secret service MI5 & 6 even have a Facebook page! How secret & secure is that?

  • rate this

    Comment number 83.

    truth is the first casualty of war.


Comments 5 of 87



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.