Why do so many disabled people embark on dangerous feats?

Walking with the Wounded trek

A new documentary with Prince Harry follows four wounded servicemen on a trek to the North Pole. But why do so many disabled people embark on adventures that most "able" people wouldn't even think of doing?

The foursome accompanying Prince Harry to the North Pole includes Steve, who had his back broken, and 26-year-old Jaco, who is missing part of an arm.

They are far from being the first injured ex-servicemen to test their new bodies when faced with a disability.

In 1947, Denny Denly, who became a wheelchair user after contracting polio while on active service, fancied a holiday in Switzerland. He rode 1,500 miles across the French Alps on a petrol-powered tricycle with a top speed of 30mph.

His journey, which involved climbing to 8,000 feet (2,440m) through mountain passes, was documented by the BBC Home Service. Public reaction to the trip was so positive it led to the launch of the Invalid Tricycle Association, a precursor to today's Disabled Motoring UK.

Left blinded and with part of a leg missing by a landmine in WWII, climber Syd Scroggie refused to be daunted and completed 600 ascents.

Denny Denly. Picture courtesy of Disabled Motoring UK Slow and steady: Denny Denly in 1947

"Whatever we call the hills, it has nothing to do with sight," he once said. "It is an inner experience and can be as poignantly savoured with your eyes shut as open."

It's not just ex-servicemen. All flavours of disabled person seem drawn to pushing themselves way beyond what's called for in their daily routine.

Dave Heely, who went blind at 18, has just completed 10 marathons in 10 days, while travelling between each one on the back of a tandem. That's 750 miles of cycling and 250 miles of running, from John O'Groats to Lands End.

Myles Hilton-Barber, also blind, is arguably the best known disabled adventurer in the UK. He lost his sight at 21 but didn't start his career in adventuring until he reached 50. He now travels the world making a living as a motivational speaker.

He has completed an 11-day ultra-marathon across China from the Gobi Desert to the Great Wall. He became the first blind pilot to undertake a 55-day, 13,000 mile (21,000km) microlight flight from London to Sydney, using a talking navigation device.

So far in 2011...

Eddie Kidd after the London Marathon
  • In April, paralysed adventurer Barry West reached the top of Ben Nevis. He was pulled and pushed up Britain's highest mountain by 18 friends. It took eight hours
  • In May, ex-motorbike stunt man Eddie Kidd walked the London Marathon route in 55 days with the help of a special frame. Eddie received a brain injury in a motorbike accident in 1996
  • In July, soldier Joe Townsend, who lost both legs in Afghanistan, completed the Ironman UK challenge. The event, which took him 13 hours, involves a 2.4-mile swim, a 112-mile bike ride and a marathon

Hilton-Barber believes that conquering these incredible feats of human endurance has changed his perspective on what it means to have a disability.

"Before I started doing this, I thought I needed sight to be happy. Now I realise it isn't about focusing on what you can't do, it's saying what you want to do and then figuring out what you can achieve. I always wanted to be a pilot."

But not all disabled people feel the need to test their physical and mental limits, says disability activist and campaigner Barbara Lisicki.

"I will never be able to climb a mountain or trek across the jungle but I don't care. In the disability arts and culture world we call this phenomenon 'supercrip syndrome'.

"Disabled people doing things that non-disabled people struggle to do and that's what makes them great. Most of us are actually fine the way we are and don't feel the need to prove ourselves."

The need to climb a huge mountain isn't something that comedian Francesca Martinez, who has cerebral palsy, can relate to.

Find out more

  • Harry's Arctic Heroes is on BBC One on Tuesday 23 August at 21:00 BST

"I'm too lazy to do something like that," says Martinez, who was asked to take part in the BBC adventure programme, Beyond Boundaries, but declined.

"I told them, if you have a show called 'lying on the beach in the Caribbean, call me'. My goal every day is to eat three big meals and to get at least 12 hours sleep."

When Denly was driving his trike, disability unemployment was high and those who were in work often held posts in sheltered workshops or similar enterprises. Even today, 70% of blind people of working age are unemployed.


Steve Young (in front) on the North Pole trek
  • In 1998, Tom Whittaker became the first disabled person to reach the summit of Mount Everest. He lost a foot due to overexposure while climbing
  • In 2004, Michael McGrath became the first disabled person to lead expeditions to the North and South poles. He was diagnosed with muscular dystrophy aged 18
  • In 2007, Geoff Holt, who is paralysed from the chest down following a diving accident, became the first disabled person to sail solo around Britain. The 1,400-mile voyage took 109 days

So is taking on adventures a substitute for lack of success in life against ordinary measurements?

Heely believes that his adventures, and the media coverage they create, have helped prevent him becoming a statistic.

"I was made redundant from a sales role in the early 90s and being blind, I knew I wouldn't have a chance of getting another similar job. It is thanks to my challenges that I've become a motivational speaker, working in schools.

"Each time I take on a new adventure and get some publicity off it, it gives me another couple of years employment."

Newspapers regularly carry stories about disabled people pushing their broken bodies to the extreme.

Hilton-Barber believes that media attention is an important motivator for disabled adventurers. He says disabled people who see other people with disabilities pushing the limits are inspired to fight for a new sense of identity.

"It gives them status. Disability robs you of your confidence. I lost my dignity, my independence, but I can jump out of a plane and people will have respect for me."

Disability affairs at the BBC

Ouch! logo

But Lisicki has her own theories on why the media relish these stories.

"The press is always happy to focus on the old tragic but brave stereotype. Earlier this year, 5,000 disabled people marched against government cuts. This got very little media coverage, because people find looking at a collective of disabled people uncomfortable.

"It's much easier for them to focus on one individual and say 'aren't they marvellous?'"

But whether it's for the love of adventure, to prove that disability is no barrier or, as Jaco from Harry's Arctic Heroes says, "to bring back the feeling of being able to do something again", the disabled adventurer phenomenon is bound to continue.


More on This Story

In today's Magazine

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • Comment number 72.

    This comment was removed because the moderators found it broke the house rules. Explain.

  • rate this

    Comment number 71.

    A good example of the general public's blank on relating to disability - today(22.8.11) there is a story on the BBC's site about Autism Alert cards, calling them "new." They have in fact existed at least since 2005, when I was diagnosed, and I actually already have one living in my purse in case of emergencies. Sometimes it takes the outside world a while to catch up, which can frustrate no end...

  • rate this

    Comment number 70.

    The trouble is a lack of ability for some non-disabled people to believe the disabled are not capable of doing great or even normal things. I get told that I don't fit their misapprehension of what an autistic person is "like", and that I'm "amazing" for working, studying and travelling under my own steam. Disabled isn't a genre of person. We're all individuals but folk like to forget that.

  • rate this

    Comment number 69.

    The will to explore, exists for some deep inside the human soul, not in a limb or the mind.

    I find the tone of this artical insulting, as the right to assume risk and responcibility (the basis of all expeditions) is not only our human right, its the key to our survival on planet earth.

    Will be interesting to see what the members of this expedition do next.

  • rate this

    Comment number 68.

    I disliked Beyond Boundaries because of the emphasis on speed at the expense of the people involved. BB could demonstrate an alternative style of expedition, giving people time for sharing creative talents and interests, observing widlife, spending time with local people and developing their relationships instead of being bullied into risking damaging themselves mentally and physically.

  • rate this

    Comment number 67.

    Those with serious injury resulting in disability will be familiar with the concept of goal planning. The trouble with the goal planning is as you achieve a goal you naturally create harder goals. The consequence being the goals becoming more extreme. That said, having been paralysed and gone on to partially recovered my mobility I am less inclined to risk further injury to an extreme activity.

  • rate this

    Comment number 66.

    British service men and women are the most elite armed forces in the world. In often difficult circumstances, they achieve oustanding results in implementing foreign policy dictated by Governments we elect. Sadly, too many end up with injuries and disabilities. Such actions showing they can still take on challenges that others can't or won't in aid of others less capable is humbling and inspiring.

  • rate this

    Comment number 65.

    I am registered 'disabled' after a fall of 40ft from a roof, which left me with severe mobility problems. I was a outdoor person who enjoyed mountaineering and when you can't work no more it effects your head more than your injuries; so to set a goal for yourself no-matter how small gives you a great incentive and also a purpose in life.

  • rate this

    Comment number 64.

    I have a disability, and have had since birth. I always try to do as much as I can when I'm ill. Though in a wheelchair, I have done a Parachute jump and other things. My thought on this article is why SHOULDN'T disabled people have the same opportunity as so-called "Able-bodied" people?

  • rate this

    Comment number 63.

    We're all unique, whether with a life-limiting illness, a disability from birth or completely fit and well. Everyone has different things they enjoy, whether it's an adrenaline rush or watching a beautiful sunset. The mistake we make is to generalise and try to put people in a little box; we're all just people trying to make the best we can of life, with the time we have.

  • rate this

    Comment number 62.

    Every disability comes with limitations and risks. I have a below knee amputation and have to manage my levels of activity otherwise pay the price in associated problems. My main responsibility is to manage my disability so that I can service my employer and in the evenings and at weekends be an active Dad for my kids. For me, pushing my body to the limits would be selfish and irresponsible.

  • rate this

    Comment number 61.


    You are right so right. Life is short and so many of us fortunate to have our health take life for granted Thank you!

  • rate this

    Comment number 60.

    I have a disability; the degree of understanding I get from others is mixed esp as it's a relapse-remit type illness. One of the strangest comments I get is 'I think you're marvelous doing what you do, I couldn't!' referring to the normal stuff such as bringing up a family. It's as if they think I have a choice about living life with an illness (or perhaps disapprove of my having children?).

  • rate this

    Comment number 59.



    Right to be here? We need you and people like you!!!! Fantastic achievement. I hope your daughter gets well soon Thinking of you both.

  • rate this

    Comment number 58.

    For me,having a life-limiting progressive condition (Ataxia) is hugely liberating. Ive been forced to change my perspective-out go all forms of vanity and in comes a rashness that incubates a serene tranquility. In short, lives too short, unpredictable and cruel for hesitation, uncertainty and plans. Not heard of Ataxia ? Please sign the e-petition http://epetitions.direct.gov.uk/petitions/12762

  • rate this

    Comment number 57.

    Why, because may disabled people have a damned sight more backbone than most people - particularly the ones who whinge and moan because petrol's gone up or because they don't like their boss.

  • rate this

    Comment number 56.

    I'm disabled/chronically sick and I did something adventurous last year - I walked the 630miles of the South West Coast Path on my two walking sticks with lots of splints and supports holding me together. I did it to raise money for my very sick daughter, but I also did it for me, not for publicity or attention but because I wanted to and as a result I finally felt that I had a right to be here!

  • rate this

    Comment number 55.

    At the age of 46 I'm getting sick of proving a point. I have had cerebral palsy since birth. I fly a paraglider and I'm sure people think I'm doing it for reasons other than my own pleasure. Well your wrong. I fly because I enjoy it. There are some incredibly patronizing people out there some of which you would have thought are more intelligent than their comments would suggest.

  • rate this

    Comment number 54.

    Everyone enjoys a "Triumph over Tragedy" story. The fact is, that for many people who become disabled, returning to their normal life is a triumph but hardly inspiring to others. One problem for people with disabilities is that the people who are featured in these stories are held up by able-bodied people as being the standard for "the disabled". Frustrating but all credit to those who manage it

  • rate this

    Comment number 53.

    Disabled people should have the same rights as others - including the right to undertake damn silly, dangerous escapades.


Page 1 of 4



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.