Do typefaces really matter?

Typefaces

To most people, typefaces are pretty insignificant. Yet to their devotees, they are the most important feature of text, giving subliminal messages that can either entice or revolt readers, says Tom de Castella.

When Avatar, the biggest grossing movie of all time was released, one section of the audience was immediately outraged.

Graphic designers hated it. Why? They didn't like the font that director James Cameron had chosen for the subtitles.

"I hated it on the posters and then threw up a little in my mouth when I realised I would have to read that ugly font throughout the film in the subtitles," one blogger commented.

"After the hundreds of millions of dollars spent on CG effects, did he just run out of money for a decent graphic designer?"

And yet fonts are not just for geeks. Otherwise why would organisations around the world spend so much time and money changing their typeface?

A new look

In April, the Mail on Sunday reported that the Foreign and Commonwealth Office spent £80,000 changing its typeface to one that was almost identical.

Last month Gatwick Airport unveiled a new logo, replacing a rather austere style with a custom-made, handwritten script. A spokeswoman said the change was an attempt to emphasise the airport's "personal touch". And in the past week the BBC website has taken on a new look, replacing Verdana font with Arial (on PCs) and Neue Helvetica (on Macs).

But can different shaped letterforms really convey those values?

Old Gatwick logo The old Gatwick logo, in Frutiger, was said to be 'uncompromising'...
New Gatwick logo ...but under new ownership it embraced a more 'personal' style

The power of the font goes back to the Greeks, says Julie Strawson, director of Monotype Imaging, an international type-design company. "The Greeks created handwriting and that's one of the most personal ways of communicating."

A typeface may never quite be able to replicate the intimacy of pen and ink but with an estimated 200,000 fonts to choose from today, there are no shortage of different styles to choose from.

Selecting a font is like getting dressed, Ms Strawson says. Just as one chooses an outfit according to the occasion, one decides on a font according to the kind of message you are seeking to convey.

One of the crucial dilemmas is whether to opt for serif or sans serif. In a serif typeface the letters have extra curls and bobbles, reminiscent of calligraphy, whereas in sans serif (literally without serif) the letter forms have clean lines without any protruding bits.

"Some people find serif best because, like handwriting, it helps the eye to link the letters," Ms Strawson says. "With sans each character is completely separate, there's more white space which is why some find it more readable."

Typeface or font?

  • A typeface is the specific letterform design of an alphabet
  • A font is a collection of all the characters of a typeface, including capital letters and lowercase letters, numerals and punctuation marks
  • For letterpress printing, using hot metal, a font was produced for every size and style of typeface, but today fonts are delivered as a digital software file that caters for all sizes of a typeface.
  • That is why the words font and typeface are often interchanged

The typeface matters because of its power to create a sense of recognition and trust, she argues: "Everyone recognises the BBC just from three characters in Gill Sans. It's an icon. If you wrote BBC in a flowery font people wouldn't recognise it."

Banks are particularly aware of this, with companies like Barclays creating their own branded font to reinforce a sense of security at a time when fear of fraud and scamming is high.

But Jonathan Barnbrook, founder of the website Virus Fonts, believes the power of typography goes beyond such utilitarian aims.

"A good typeface creates an emotional response in relation to the message it is conveying. You're trying to get that tone of voice right - you can shout or whisper. And you want to sum up the spirit of the age, because they do date quite quickly."

People have become more aware about the impact of fonts because of computers, but the power of a typeface is still largely subliminal, he argues. Mr Barnbrook is best known for producing provocatively named, subversive fonts such as Exocet, Bastard, Prozac and Nixon. He also designed the cover of Heathen, David Bowie's 2002 album.

"I talked a lot with Bowie - the discussions went back and forth. He's the creator and you're trying to get the atmosphere of the music across in the design. I chose one of our own fonts - Priori - which is formal but playful, as the album was quite dark."

Source: Nadine Chahine, typeface designer, Linotype
image of Neue font image of Gill font
The Swiss typeface Neue Helvetica, by Linotype Design Studio, appears to be drawn with uniform thickness (a Sans-Serif), and its finishing stroke curls back up onto itself. It is neutral in design, which is why Neue Helvetica has lent itself to designs worldwide. The Gill Sans, designed by the artist Eric Gill, is quirky and full of character. This typeface is a solid British institution, and can be seen all over the UK. Its unique design has made it a staple of British typography for many decades now.
image of Times font image of Zapf font
Another British work horse is the serif typeface Times New Roman. Designed for the Times newspaper, London, by Monotype, this is a typeface you trust. The outlines here vary from thick to thin, and the overall design is meant for fast newspaper production. The Zapfino Extra typeface by Professor Hermann Zapf is a script typeface full of beauty, elegance and harmony, with soft and elegant curves. The writing style is that of excellent penmanship. A feminine, classy design that is ideal for advertising.

Indeed there's no limit to the emotional range a typeface can reflect. "Typography is so closely associated with language so you can express irony and get the whole complexity of emotion in there," adds Mr Barnbrook.

It's part of a typeface designer's essential make-up to get hung up on tiny details. And sometimes that can be downright annoying, he admits: "The problem is you're watching a film and you notice a sign. You realise that the letterforms are 20 years later than the era the film is supposed to be set in."

Indeed for some, fonts take on almost life and death significance. The Swiss font Helvetica has a cult following celebrated by the 2007 documentary of the same name.

Helvetica = cheap

But for Bruno Maag, managing creative director of typeface studio Dalton Maag, Helvetica is a cultural blight.

"If you think of ice cream, it (Helvetica) is a cheap, nasty, supermarket brand made of water, substitutes and vegetable fats. The texture is wrong and it leaves a little bit of a funny aftertaste."

Rather than being the modernist font supporters say it is, he argues that Helvetica is based on "antique" designs and made up of badly executed letter forms, although he admits these are "tiny details" most people will never spot.

"Lower case Ss are notoriously difficult to get right. But in Helvetica it's not straight - you want to go in there and tighten it up. And the 'a' looks so woolly and ill-conceived, it really winds me up."

Start Quote

When you're reading an article you're not thinking about the font”

End Quote Mike Battista Canadian blogger

As much as he hates Helvetica, he loves Univers, another Swiss-invented design. "It's the true modernist typeface. There's no fuss and schmuss about it, it's a clean, tight design. If Helvetica is Julia Roberts - pretty enough - then Univers is Uma Thurman - really cool."

But the Canadian blogger Mike Battista, who blogs at phronk.com, has had enough of the font police. He was first alerted to the problem when the graphic design community reacted angrily to the use of Papyrus for the subtitles in Avatar.

"I follow a lot of the graphic design community on Twitter and there were so many people querying Papyrus. They jumped on it because they think it's too flashy and gimmicky. But subtitle fonts don't matter as long as you can read them."

Mr Battista concludes that the font has been elevated to an absurdly high cultural status by a small, self-indulgent elite.

"These people remind me of wine snobs - they can detect all these subtle notes and flavours but the average person probably won't notice all these tiny flourishes on a font. When you're reading an article you're not thinking about the font. You have to be looking at fonts all day before you start getting emotional about them."

An obsession with typefaces may even be reducing our productivity, he warns.

"The other day I heard that people are getting 'font paralysis'. They couldn't move forward with their work because they were unable to decide on which font to use."

Below is a selection of your comments

I think that font choice is very important in some situations. Within e-mails it can brand a company or person. I know in my company (medical) that the use of Arial is used to be conservative, neutral, and also professional.

Matthew, London

I am one of those poor people who struggle to decide what font to use - I end up settling with Arial as it's a clear font to read, but I wonder what impression that is giving the person reading what I've typed.

Jennifer Martin, Bradford

When you're reading an article you're not thinking about the font consciously. It's the unconscious that has the emotional influence, as with shapes, as with colours. It is the designers job to consider the impact of all the above.

Brian Wild, Surrey

Yep, some pedantic, obsessive typographers border on the obsessive. True. But only the ignorant would dismiss the subliminal power of typography in advertising or deny the practical benefits of careful type setting in reading material.

Simon, London

Some people really, really don't like certain fonts. There's even a Hitler Downfall parody on YouTube regarding Comic Sans.

Nellie, Oxfordshire

My favourite has to be Gill Sans. It just works in so many applications and is beautiful to look at. Based on the Johnson font used for the Underground, it is a British institution and a pure design classic.

David Moody, Staffordshire

I'm a freelance web and graphic designer, and cannot stress enough the importance of choosing the right font for the right client / scenario. The difference between using Helvetica / Arial as opposed to say Verdana or Tahoma could be the difference between securing future work from the client or not.

Christian, Wrexham, Wales

There is no "best" font, only fonts that are well-suited to certain situations. For instance, Gill Sans, Frutiger and "Transport" are all excellent fonts to make a clear message come across, hence their use on road signs and in airports. Consider for instance this new Gatwick logo - at a distance, it is hardly legible. I would be able to make out "Your London Airport" because it is in sans-serif but "Gatwick"? Never.

JP, Geneva, Switzerland

According to Simon I'm ignorant. I honestly hadn't noticed the typeface had changed on the BBC website. All I'd noticed is the layout is much clearer. Layout is the key in my opinion and has a vastly greater impact than font, which ultimately just had to be legible. The same for adverts, it's the layout and what's written which captures me, rather than how it's written.

James, Southampton

Of all the fonts, I can't stand Times New Roman. It just seems lazy to me, as if a person has just stuck with the first font that The word processor presented. I personally prefer Arial. It's clear, concise and easy to read.

Matt Dougherty, Gosport, Hampshire

Times New Roman for elegance, stability & truth and Univers for a clean sans serif ~ more sympatico than Helvetica. Had a more than brief flirtation with Romic ~ lots of fun. Love fonts, retired graphic designer so out of date now :( Can remember "drawing" letter-shapes in school when learning to write. Mine were better than the teacher's IMHO :)

Angela Elliott, Hove, England

inally I understand what it is I haven't liked about the BBC's new look this last week! I often change documents from Arial to something "friendlier/ warmer", such as Calibri. And I'd never send an email in Arial or Times New Roman. I find them cold. I also think the latter looks messy, or like it's come from someone who doesn't know how to change the font!

Antonia, Nottingham

I admit being amongst the anti-Papyrus crowd. When this typeface was used in Avatar. However I'm beginning to suspect that Papyrus is becoming deeply embedded in our culture. I see it on cookbook binders, funeral home signs, beauty salons, church bulletins, and block-buster sci-fi movies. Look for it and you will see it everywhere. I wonder why? Exotic? Warm? Transcendental? Peaceful?

Darwin Godwin, Tucson, Arizona, USA

Twenty-five years ago I had the privilege of watching the skilled compositors at work on linotype and monotype machines in a printing house. They were incredibly skilled guys who showed great pride in their work. They really understood fonts. My job at the time? I was a technician introducing a computer typesetting system to replace those old machines.

Charles Smith, London

Typography and the selection of fonts is the single most important aspect of Graphic Design aesthetics. A slight weight or stroke discrepancy or, as so often seen a very slightly stretched font can wreck an entire design. When you get it right you will know...although you may not know why!

Jamie Smith, London

More on This Story

In today's Magazine

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

Features

  • Shiny bootsMarching orders

    Where does the phrase 'boots on the ground' come from?


  • Almaz cleaning floorAlmaz's prison

    Beaten and raped - the story of an African servant in Saudi Arabia


  • Train drawn by Jonathan Backhouse, 1825The first trainspotter

    Did this drawing mark the start of a misunderstood hobby?


  • MarijuanaHigh tech

    The start-ups hoping to transform the marijuana industry


  • Child eating ice creamTooth top tips

    Experts on ways to encourage children to look after their teeth


BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.