Failing hospitals: Is the glass half-full or half-empty?

Jug of water

Health Secretary Jeremy Hunt's glass was certainly half-full when he gave an update on Wednesday on how the special measures regime for failing hospitals has worked out.

A year to the day since the first 11 were placed in the failure regime, he said he was encouraged hospitals were on the "road to recovery".

Five of the 11 have come out of special measures or are in the process of doing so. But is that really a story of success?

After all, three of those - East Lancashire, Buckinghamshire and North Lincolnshire / Goole - are continuing to get support from the wider system and are being kept under a watchful eye by inspectors.

And if you look at Basildon and Thurrock Trust - one of the two that is fully out - the picture is still not straight-forward. It actually escaped special measures after an inspection in March led to it being given a good rating, with its maternity services becoming the first in the country to be rated as outstanding. That is just eight months after it was placed into the failure regime. A remarkable turnaround you may think? Not quite.

Early days

The trust was already well on the way to addressing the problems when the announcement was made last July. A new chief executive, Clare Panniker, had been in place since the autumn of the year before and extra staff, and new governance arrangements were being put in place.

Jeremy Hunt: "Every older person has a right to be treated with dignity and respect"

She told me special measures had helped the trust address the problems by giving people a "licence to talk" and giving greater transparency about the problems, but it is clear the improvement journey had already started by the time Mr Hunt stood up in the House of Commons last summer to list the trust's failings.

Of the remaining six trusts, we are yet to hear anything about two, while there are signs of improvement at three, but obviously not enough to warrant escaping special measures.

However, in the case of one - Medway Maritime Hospital in Kent - there seems to have been little improvement. It was given an inadequate rating less than a week ago, with inspectors noting there were still too few junior doctors and nurses on duty and raising serious concerns about the quality of surgery and A&E.

This is not to say that special measures has no role to play - it has been widely welcomed by those inside and outside the health service - but at this stage it seems too early to tell just how effective it is.

Since the first 11 trusts were put into special measures, another six have followed suit - and the Care Quality Commission still has 60% of England's hospitals to inspect. The process is barely half-way through, no wonder it is hard to tell whether the glass if half-full or half-empty.

Nick Triggle Article written by Nick Triggle Nick Triggle Health correspondent

Is another NHS scandal brewing?

The Morecambe Bay inquiry has chilling echoes of one into Stafford Hospital. So could there be another scandal happening elsewhere?

Read full article

More on This Story

More from Nick


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 101.

    "even more
    dishonesty &

    Fear so. Whichever party or coalition accepts or takes power, what is left of the idea & structure of the NHS, the circulation of talent & trained skills to meet need as well as some insurance against worse in private practice, the arms-length dealing between public & private sectors ever more compromised, in NEITHER of supposed 'two tiers' the ideal.

  • rate this

    Comment number 100.

    79. imemomeme

    Those involved in PFI have a cup that overfloweth.


    Indeed. These PFI contracts are crippling the NHS and were largely the creation of the Caledonian half wit who liked them because he could keep so much more debt off balance sheet and pretend things were much better then they were.

    Return Labour next year and we will get even more of this dishonesty and incompetence.

  • rate this

    Comment number 99.

    Part of the trouble with much of the PFI is that we will have just about paid it off when we need a new hospital. Ours has been open about 3 years, cost around £290m to build and will be costing us between £40m and £90m a year for the next 30 years. Oh and it doesn't have enough dialysis equipment.

  • rate this

    Comment number 98.

    Oracle @96
    "fair enough?"

    No. Post-war leaders did what they could, nationalising without securing equal partnership, in the NHS not even securing normal management-employee relations, leaving hospital consultants free to spend a tenth of their time seeing a third of their patients 'privately', NHS to pay for their other activities, teaching, training and 'service management': vive la différence!

  • rate this

    Comment number 97.

    We seem to be in a position where the General Public have a choice.
    The choice is do we want affordable HEALTH CARE ..or a system that helps people make lots of money.
    Bit like buying a Train Fare or a commercial TV subscription.
    Or any other product>


Comments 5 of 101



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.