Mental health staff to be based in police stations

 

Roger, who has a history of mental health issues, explains the benefits of having nurses on duty

Related Stories

Mental health nurses are to be based in police stations and courts in 10 areas of England as part of a pilot scheme aimed at cutting reoffending.

The nurses' duties will include helping officers to respond to calls and identify those with problems.

Ministers said "too often" criminals with mental health problems were being diagnosed only once they reached jail.

The £25m scheme - being trialled in areas including London and Merseyside - could be extended England-wide by 2017.

Analysis

Where there is crime there is often mental illness, but the criminal justice system has a mixed record in dealing with it in police stations and courts - after all, police officers will never be as good at spotting the signs of depression or psychosis as a trained psychiatric nurse.

But it seems logical that criminals with untreated mental health problems will be more likely to break the law again.

The results from a trial scheme in Cornwall are promising - reoffending cut by 49% for those with a history of poor mental health. It might even work both ways.

While filming at Bethnal Green police station, officers told me that a suspect had been arrested feigning mental health problems - including an apparent attempt to strangle himself.

But the police station psychiatric nurse, who knew his medical history and saw through his act, sent him back to the cell.

The biggest issue is one of resources. Police say there is no point in the mental health nurse being there only 9 to 5.

The government has provided limited funding for pilot schemes -partly to try to work when the peak demand occurs. Providing cover 24/7 across England won't be cheap.

Support and treatment

The Department of Health says most people in prison have a mental health problem, a substance misuse problem or a learning disability, and one in four has a severe mental health illness such as depression or psychosis.

It has been estimated that police officers spend 15% to 25% of their time dealing with suspects with mental health problems.

Being diagnosed with a mental health, learning difficulty or substance abuse problem will mean people can be offered treatment or support, and could affect how they are dealt with by the criminal justice system, ministers say.

The pilot mental health "liaison and diversion" teams will run in:

  • Merseyside
  • London
  • Avon and Wiltshire
  • Leicester
  • Sussex
  • Dorset
  • Sunderland and Middlesbrough
  • Coventry
  • South Essex
  • Wakefield

Similar arrangements have already been successfully tried in Leicestershire and Cleveland.

Start Quote

This scheme may not be a panacea but these liaison and diversion teams are definitely the best opportunity we've had to do things differently”

End Quote Paul Jenkins Rethink Mental Illness

Health minister Norman Lamb told BBC News: "There are so many people in our prisons with mental health problems which haven't been diagnosed and yet, if we diagnose them and deal with them, we can reduce reoffending.

"It just makes so much sense from everyone's point of view."

Policing minister Damian Green added: "Police officers should be focused on fighting crimes and people with mental health conditions should get the care they need as early as possible.

"These pilots will not only ensure that happens but, in the longer term, will help drive down reoffending by individuals who, with the right kind of treatment, can recover fully."

Vital skills

Paul Jenkins, chief executive of the charity Rethink Mental Illness, said: "All too often, the way our criminal justice system deals with people with mental health problems leads to poor outcomes for individuals, frustration from police officers, magistrates and others, and such a waste of resources as people are needlessly sent to prison through a failure to respond to some of the underlying issues in their lives.

"We welcome this initiative, which has the potential to stop people going unnecessarily to prison, reduce reoffending rates and save millions in taxpayers' money.

"This scheme may not be a panacea, but these liaison and diversion teams are definitely the best opportunity we've had to do things differently."

Dr Peter Carter, general secretary of the Royal College of Nursing, said the organisation had been involved in developing the scheme alongside the government.

He added: "Nurses bring vital skills and knowledge to these complex and challenging cases and we know that the police greatly value working in partnership with nursing staff.

"Having more nurses in liaison and diversion services will improve the health care that people in the criminal justice system receive and it will also support the police's public protection work."

 

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 285.

    I believe this scheme is a good idea and could well be the way forward, provided that adequate resources are provided to MH services to enable them to correctly handle and treat these individuals. Provided that is in place, it should cut reoffending, reduce inappropriate prosecutions, and reduce some of the strain on our prison/probation services.

  • rate this
    +7

    Comment number 181.

    This has to be a step in the right direction. The Police are overloaded and having immediate access to mental health services will greatly streamline the process. It will optimise the assessment of those in custody and will direct them to the most appropriate facility.

    This will ease the burden on the Police and their facilities so it makes sense to trial this proposal.

  • rate this
    +30

    Comment number 118.

    Who will the staff be working for, the Government, the mentally ill or the Police?

    I see plenty of potential for conflicts of interest here especially given the reduction in criminal legal aid.

  • rate this
    +34

    Comment number 105.

    Once again society is dealing with the symptoms instead of dealing with the issues.
    Mental Illness should be dealt with before it gets to the stage of society suffering because of it.

  • rate this
    +65

    Comment number 50.

    Care in the community not working again then :( If you have a mental health problem you are shoved from pillar to post from dept to dept. I know of a suicidal chap who has been waiting for an urgent referral since OCTOBER. So wheres the staff coming from for this? Mental health spending has been cut to the bone and then cut some more

 

Comments 5 of 7

 

More Health stories

RSS

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.