Why ministers are walking an NHS tightrope

Man on tightrope The next few months could be crucial for the government in terms of the NHS

In his evidence to MPs, NHS chief executive Sir David Nicholson described the current moment in time as one of "maximum risk".

He was talking about the health service, but the term could equally be applied to the government.

It is easy to forget that just over a year ago ministers were fighting to save their health reforms - and perhaps even the coalition itself.

As Sir David pointed out as he was grilled by members of the Health Select Committee over his handling of the Stafford Hospital scandal, the coming weeks will see the whole structure of the health service redrawn.

More than 160 organisations will be abolished and another 200-plus will be created in their place, including the NHS Commissioning Board, which Sir David will run.

Come 1 April they will take charge of the health service in England with its budget in excess of £100bn and workforce of 1.3m.

Reorganisations on such a vast scale are never easy.

As Sir David testified on Tuesday, the risk is that as they happen - as in 2005-06 when he was in charge of the health authority that oversaw Stafford - eyes are taken off the ball.

In one of the more revealing exchanges, he said the system at the time had lost its focus as it juggled the task of merging organisations. Patients were not put first - and that had catastrophic consequences.

Back then the reform only involved halving the number of primary care trusts and health authorities.

This time round the upheaval is much greater.


Look no further than the furore over the past week over the regulations governing procurement in the NHS for proof of how distracting change can be.

Instead of focusing on patients and introducing the changes, doctors have been up in arms about what they saw as a breach of the carefully structured compromise that won them over back when ministers were trying to get their bill through Parliament.

In return for the profession's support - or at least not outright opposition - ministers provided assurances about the extent to which competition would be pursued.

The regulations are now being rewritten.

When they are put forward again, expect them to be gone through with a fine-tooth comb.

What this all illustrates is how toxic the reforms have become for the government.

But this is unlikely to be the end of it.

Ruth Thorlby, a senior researcher at the Nuffield Trust think tank, predicts the NHS will be a highly political issue for some time.

"The combination of the disorganisation caused by the upheaval and the money running out is destined to come together to create problems."

But it also explains why in many ways Sir David is indispensable despite the calls for him to go.

As one person who has worked with him at the Department of Health says: "He is the man the prime minister trusts to see through the changes."

When the controversy over the reforms were at their peak it was not Andrew Lansley who had a hotline to David Cameron, it was Sir David.

He has been leading the health service since 2006. He has experienced reorganisation, sorted out financial problems and his presence at the helm helped reassure those who work in the NHS that the government's health policy could work.

Without him, ministers fear they will slip from the tightrope they are walking.

Nick Triggle Article written by Nick Triggle Nick Triggle Health correspondent

Savile: Why the risks are real in today's NHS

Jimmy Savile's abuse on NHS premises spanned 44 sites. Most of the cases were decades ago, but how safe is the health service now?

Read full article

More on This Story

More from Nick


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 107.

    The NHS is built on trust:
    - in doctors & nurses, to do their best, work ethically, and blow whistles;
    - in managers (soon to include GPs), to put patients first, not budgets;
    - in strategists & planners, to structure the best services;
    - in MPs, to stop micro-managing and grandstanding; and
    - in ourselves, to challenge and praise more often.

    ... And there's not much trust left.

  • rate this

    Comment number 106.

    Sadly the more money we give the NHS the more it manages to waste. We spend a massive 9% of GDP on healthcare in the UK, compared to 11% in France, which is the world's best. Sure, we should spend more, but not on the NHS which has callously engendered a culture of incompetence, poor management and neglect for too long. How can we see the thousands of deaths in the NHS and blame funding alone? I

  • rate this

    Comment number 105.

    The NHS is a poison chalice. No Secretary of State would welcome it as his chosen brief. It's broken, it's failing, it's plagued with innefficient doctors, nurses and beaurocrats and it's an insatiable money pit.
    It will constantly bring governments, Labour and Tory to its knees.
    Break it up and start again.

  • rate this

    Comment number 104.

    Its becoming clear the whole intention has been and is to open public NHS cash to as much privatised provision as possible. One wonders why some areas of legislation were drawn up as they were & need altering. One wonders why Foundations etc have been allowed to get in debt & fail. As someone said hospitals are not in debt they are not Businesses they are simply underfunded

  • rate this

    Comment number 103.

    It isn't tricky. If the guy in charge of a hospital that is killing people says he has no idea what is going on in the hospital he is in charge of then sack him. Sack him now from supposedly being in charge of the NHS. If he can't cope with a hospital he can't cope with the whole thing. Sack him right now, right this second.


Comments 5 of 107



  • Mukesh SinghNo remorse

    Delhi bus rapist says victim shouldn't have fought back

  • Aimen DeanI spied

    The founder member of al-Qaeda who worked for MI6

  • Before and after shotsPerfect body

    Just how reliable are 'before and after' photos?

  • A man shutting his eyes tightlyStrange light show

    What do you see when you close your eyes?

  • Lotus 97T driven by Elio de AngelisBeen and Gone

    A champion F1 designer and other notable losses

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.