NHS care, including knee and hip operations, 'rationed'

Surgeons performing an operation GP magazine received responses from two thirds of trusts

Related Stories

Access to NHS care - including knee and hip operations - is being restricted, data from trusts in England suggests.

The evidence, gathered under the Freedom of Information Act by GP magazine, showed 90% of trusts were imposing restrictions.

The trend was blamed on cost-cutting by some, but the government says there was no justification for that assertion.

NHS managers have defended the practice, saying there were instances when care had to be prioritised.

The magazine received responses from two-thirds of the 151 trusts about the procedures they considered to be non-urgent.

The most common restriction was on tonsillectomies, with 89% of areas rationing the availability of this procedure.

That, in itself, is not that controversial, as many argue the NHS is better to concentrate its resources in most cases on other, more serious conditions.

But the research also found evidence of rationing in other areas.


Rationing is nothing new in the NHS, it has always happened. There is a finite pot of money and so resources have to be managed.

There are national thresholds for how ill you have to be to get help. Restrictions are also routinely put in place to stop those that are overweight or are smokers having treatment if their lifestyles would then undo or limit the effectiveness of that care.

There is also a drive to get the NHS to stop doing procedures for which there is little clinical benefit. Some tonsollectomies fall into this category.

So not all the restrictions highlighted by GP magazine and Labour are necessarily bad.

But what appears to be happening increasingly as well is rationing to save money. A cataract operation on one eye costs the NHS about £900. A hip replacement sets the service back more than £5,000.

With money getting increasingly tight, some areas are delaying referring patients for these type of treatments.

Critics argue it is a short-term measure - patients just end up sicker and often need the treatment in the end - but that, unfortunately, is how some trusts seem to be managing budgetary constraints.

Limits on cataract surgery were in place in 66% of trusts, while more than half of trusts were rationing weight-loss surgery and hip and knee operations.

Another survey published by Labour found similar patterns, prompting criticism of the trust's actions from patient groups.

Clara Eaglen, of the Royal National Institute of Blind People, said: "People should not have to live with a reduced quality of life simply because PCTs are using arbitrary criteria to determine whether they get to keep their sight."

Dr Richard Vautrey, of the British Medical Association, described the situation as a "cost-saving exercise".

"Patients fully understand the NHS doesn't have unlimited resources... but they don't understand, or believe it's fair, when services are provided in one area but not another.

"We're supposed to have a national health service, so there should be national consistency in service availability."

Health minister Simon Burns described such practices as "unacceptable".

"If local health bodies stop patients from having treatments on the basis of cost alone, we will take action against them."

But David Stout, of the NHS Confederation, which represents primary care trusts, said there were sometimes justifiable reasons for rationing.

He said while arbitrary restrictions should not be put in place, trusts had to prioritise care in the current environment and make sure they got the best value available.

"The NHS faces considerable financial pressures and scarce resources have to be used as effectively as possible."

He said most advice given to trusts by the National Institute of Clinical Excellence (Nice) - which is employed to make cost-effective recommendations - was "just advice".

Trusts should not be trying to do everything Nice suggested, he added.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Health stories



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.