Group of GPs warns of 'peril' if NHS changes fail


Dr Shane Gordon: "The NHS must change and adapt"

More than 50 GPs in new clinical commissioning groups have warned that the NHS in England may be "in peril" if government changes are derailed.

In a Daily Telegraph letter, they say opposition from the British Medical Association is not representative of GPs already leading such groups.

Clinical commissioning groups will control large parts of the NHS budget.

The Health and Social Care Bill, which also increases competition with private firms, is going through Parliament.

Health Secretary Andrew Lansley is proposing the biggest shake-up since the NHS was founded in the 1940s.

The existing Primary Care Trusts (PCTs), which manage hospitals, would be abolished and replaced by the clinical commissioning groups (CCGs).

The BMA, the Royal College of Nurses and the Royal College of Midwives have all opposed the proposals, with some critics claiming it is unworkable and "backdoor privatisation", forcing Prime Minister David Cameron to "pause" the proposed shake-up in April last year.

The BMA says government policy is incoherent and major changes are taking place on the ground before the bill has even been passed.

It also says "unanswered questions remain in many crucial areas such as practical implementation and how individual components within the reforms will work together".

But the 56 GPs, part of a coalition formed by the NHS Alliance and the National Association of Primary Care, wrote to the Telegraph claiming previous changes had not gone far enough and the NHS had "paid the price".

'All pull together'

The letter says: "Without strong clinical leadership and the co-ordinated efforts of local clinicians, the NHS itself may be in peril; local services can only be improved if we all pull together."

It adds: "Blanket opposition to the NHS reforms by the British Medical Association and the Royal College of Nursing is not representative of the views of GPs who, like us, already lead CCGs, and the large numbers of GPs and nurses who support us."

The NHS Alliance, which was set up in 1998, describes itself as "an independent non-political organisation".

Aneurin Bevan visits the first NHS hospital The NHS is facing the biggest shake-up since it was founded by Aneurin Bevan in 1948

It lobbies on behalf of GPs in clinical commissioning groups, to ensure they remain at the heart of decision-making in the health service.

But the Medical Practitioners' Union - a sub-section of union Unite, questioned how representative the coalition was. President Dr Ron Singer told the BBC that the number of GPs who had signed its letter was "infinitesimal".

Dr Singer said that in just six weeks before the Health and Social Care Bill went to the House of Lords his union had collected the signatures of more than 500 GPs involved in CCGs who wanted the Bill to be withdrawn, or time given to amend it.

The union's petition stated: "Poor law, on top of the £20bn efficiency savings target for the NHS over the next five years, will put more lives at risk now and in the future."

Dr Singer said GPs had joined CCG's "because they want to protect their patients - not because they agree with the Bill".

The NHS has been asked to make savings of up to £20bn by 2015.

On Thursday, the government escaped a potentially damaging rebellion over the bill, when the Academy of Medical Royal Colleges decided against releasing a statement critical of it.

Its decision followed last-ditch phone calls from ministers.

However, a poll carried out by the Royal College of GPs suggests 90% of family doctors support calls for the Bill to be withdrawn.


More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 541.

    I organised a petition of GPs actively involved in Commissiong groups who did not support the Bill. Not a mention by BBC. But 50 GPs supporting the Bill gets full coverage. Strange.

    Dr Ron Singer
    President Medical Practitioners' Union-Unite.

  • rate this

    Comment number 319.

    If there's an obvious fault in the NHS it is that it's over administered, layer upon layer of management and admin staff, the bulk of whom should be replaced by a well designed IT system. Yes it's been tried but many with little understanding of IT were allowed too much say in designing it. Result: failure. Politicians continue to fail us in maintaining the NHS well. Improvement not destruction.

  • rate this

    Comment number 314.

    While I agree that changes are required, the way the Government has gone about this does not inspire confidence that the changes are for the right reasons. These changes were not part of either parties manifesto and seem to be driven by the Tories desire to get the private sector involved in every aspect of our lives. As someone who works in the private sector, this fills me with dread!

  • rate this

    Comment number 143.

    There has to be major reform of the NHS and it is incapable of doing it itself - it has to be done to it. The BMA and NCH are fancy named Trade Unions and care mainly about protecting their members and not the patient or the taxpayer. They fight every change. GPs should commission services but hospitals have to be run by managers and clinicians combined with minimum bureaucracy

  • rate this

    Comment number 141.

    The NHS is not getting better. My dad has been admitted to hospital and the care is poor. The nurses seem too busy to care for their patients and can hardly spare the time to take him to the loo (twice I have found him on the floor soiled). Unless I give him water his jug remains untouched. The NHS needs to refocuss on the basics, we can't cure everyone but should be able to care about them.


Comments 5 of 7


More Health stories



Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.