New hope for patients unable to communicate

Roy Hayim Roy Hayim could communicate only by moving his thumb

Related Stories

The thought of being trapped in a lifeless body, unable to communicate, is a terrifying prospect. It happened to Roy Hayim, a surveyor, who became dangerously ill after eating an airline meal.

Mr Hayim contracted botulism, a rare bacterial infection.

He was left paralysed and blind for several days, although he could hear everything that was happening - even a news report on the radio which said he was fighting for his life.

After about 10 days Mr Hayim was able to move his thumb and for the next eight months he used this method to communicate with his wife Caroline and hospital staff.

He spent nearly a year in hospital but made a full recovery. This all happened 20 years ago, but Roy remembers it vividly.


"I felt trapped, afraid and terribly concerned. I didn't know whether I would survive or not," he said.

I went to meet Mr Hayim to get his insight on what it is like to be unable to communicate. My visit was prompted by research in the Lancet which shows that electroencephalography - EEG - can be used to communicate with some patients who were diagnosed as vegetative.

Awareness was detected in three of the 16 patients.

Fergus Walsh Close your eyes and imagine wiggling your toes...

I was curious how EEG could be used to "read" thoughts so volunteered to test out the system in Cambridge at the Medical Research Council brain imaging centre.

The EEG had 129 electrodes and fits over the head a bit like an elasticated hair-net. From the photo you can see it is not a great look, but it is painless.

I was asked to wiggle my toes or squeeze my right hand when I heard a beep. Then I was asked simply to imagine doing the same tasks.

Thinking about doing something activates the same part of the brain - the pre-motor cortex - as doing it.

It is pretty hard to concentrate when you are simply thinking about wiggling your toes. All sorts of extraneous thoughts kept popping into my head.

Nonetheless I turned out to be an "excellent responder", according to Professor Adrian Owen, who has pioneered the use of scanning and EEG to try to communicate with brain-injured patients.

Start Quote

"The important ethical question is not: are they conscious? It is: in what way are they conscious? Ethically, we need answers to that”

End Quote Julian Savulescu Oxford Centre for Neuroethics

Three of the 12 healthy volunteers used in this study were unable to produce responses that were above chance - giving no concrete indication of a conscious response. Some of the vegetative patients, however, did considerably better.

Clearly the volunteers were aware and conscious. Prof Owen said it showed that a negative result did not mean that vegetative patients were definitely unaware, but a positive result did mean they had awareness.

Prof Owen has already shown that functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) can be used to communicate with a small proportion of vegetative patients.

EEG is cheaper and portable, so could be taken to the bedside of patients in care homes. It has been estimated that around four in 10 patients diagnosed as vegetative have some level of awareness.

Subject to further testing, this new technique might provide a rapid means of detecting awareness in a minority of patients who may have been trapped in an isolated world for years - aware but unable to communicate.

The research raises a multitude of questions - if patients can respond, what level of cognition do they have? Could it be used to help plan their treatment?

Julian Savulescu, director of the Oxford Centre for Neuroethics, said: "This important scientific study raises more ethical questions than it answers. People who are deeply unconscious don't suffer.

"But are these patients suffering? How bad is their life? Do they want to continue in that state? If they could express a desire, should it be respected?

"The important ethical question is not: are they conscious? It is: in what way are they conscious? Ethically, we need answers to that."

Fergus Walsh Article written by Fergus Walsh Fergus Walsh Medical correspondent

Superbugs to kill 'more than cancer' by 2050

Drug resistant infections will kill an extra 10 million people a year worldwide by 2050 unless action is taken, a study says.

Read full article

More on This Story

Related Stories


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 3.

    Would this be able to be used to monitor and adjust medication for anesthetized patients who have been administered paralytics during surgery?

  • rate this

    Comment number 2.

    Fearsome event: "conscience" - but only I seem to know it. It causes me to think of that fearful term called "locked-in syndrome".
    Brain death results in an irreversible disruption of consciousness - for how long? All "loss" of consciousness beg the question: I think therefore I am...but how will other people know THAT I AM thinking?

  • rate this

    Comment number 1.

    Having people around you talking about you as though you are not a person but a poor event outcome with no self determination is a profoundly unpleasant experience which attacks the very basis of human relationship. All the worse if it is family doing the talking. Its the reason medics use jargon.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.