Why a nudge is not enough to change behaviour

 
Traffic light food labeling 'More should be done' to ensure the traffic light label system is used, the committee says

Much of what all governments do concerns trying to change our behaviour - but what is the best way to do that?

The government has favoured the "nudge" - persuading rather than telling people to change their behaviour.

But Baroness Julia Neuberger, chair of a Lords' committee which has just published a report on the issue, explains why it has concluded that nudge alone will not work.

Governments want us to smoke less, drink less, eat more healthily and exercise more.

In November 2010 the Health Secretary Andrew Lansley told us that the government would "nudge" rather than "nanny" us to better health.

But after investigating the science of behaviour, our committee found that the government can't rely on "nudging" to do all the work, particularly with a complicated and deep-rooted problem like obesity.

Instead, it must understand that there is a whole variety of influences that shape our behaviour and realise that successful interventions will target a number of these influences, using a whole range of different policies.

"Nudging" emphasises the role of our environment - both social and physical - in influencing our behaviour.

For a policy to be a "nudge" it has to involve changing that environment in a way that doesn't restrict our choices or change financial incentives.

In other words, "nudging" provides a new alternative to regulatory and fiscal measures.

For example, the ban on smoking in public places isn't a "nudge" because it restricts choice, but putting unpleasant pictures showing the impact of smoking is.

'Unimpressed'

There's no doubt that, when it comes to our health, our environment really matters.

But the government must recognise that "nudging" isn't the only way to make a difference.

Sometimes changing the environment will require something stronger.

Start Quote

The science says that 'nudging' won't be enough.”

End Quote

The move to introduce higher alcohol pricing is a good example of how legislation can be used to change our behaviour by changing our environment.

Businesses also have a huge effect in shaping our environment.

The government is also trying to "nudge" businesses to behave differently, through voluntary agreements rather than regulation.

But we were unimpressed by the agreements that have been reached so far under the public health responsibility deal.

'Act now'

So we have urged the government to base agreements on the evidence about what will work to change behaviour, rather than what the businesses are happy to accept.

In particular, we recommend that they take steps to ensure that traffic-light nutritional labels are used on all food packaging and that they extend the restrictions on marketing unhealthy products to children.

Some supermarket chains agree with us on traffic-light labelling, and have shown that it does change behaviour.

If government can't achieve these changes through voluntary agreement, they should use regulation instead, or as well.

Obesity is a major societal problem which requires urgent action.

The same is true of other behaviours damaging to health, like binge drinking.

The government cannot wait and see if "nudging" us, or "nudging" businesses, is going to pay off.

They must act now in the light of what science tells us about how to change behaviour.

And, for the most important problems facing us at the moment, the science says that "nudging" won't be enough.

 

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 47.

    Government is there to protect us, not to nudge and control us like a mother hen. If they got on with doing their proper job we might have an army, navy, airforce to protect us instead of shells incapable of putting up a defence of the Isle of White.
    Make the supermarkets compete, list ingredients and call products by proper names... they aren't chicken slices, they are a pale chemical mush...

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 46.

    We are not getting a nudge in the right direction with the Private Members Bill Oct 28 2010 imposing summertme on the clocks in WINTER. Everyone, including schoolchildren, must start the day one hour earlier than previous winters in Double Winter Darkness. Much work, including banks, starts at 7am (8am Central European Time) in Winter - andl starts one hour still earlier in Summer 6am or 8am CEST

  • rate this
    -1

    Comment number 45.

    (cntd.) Its possible to legislate in ways that don't restrict choice (e.g. forcing retailers to use a standard, simple traffic light system). If customers naturally opt for 'green light' products, that nudges producers of 'red light' products to change the contents to 'green' if they want the best sales. Unhealthy products will still be there to buy - but its likely they'll sell less well.

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 44.

    @ Those misunderstanding the principle of 'nudging', its about rearranging how information is given and the default choice offered so people are 'nudged' into doing the right thing by default, but can opt-out if they wish. The problem is that individuals' best interests clash with companies whose incentive is to nudge towards ways that generate the greatest profit.

  • rate this
    -2

    Comment number 43.

    If a landlord is to refuse to sell alcohol to drunk people, why can't a fast food joint refuse to sell burgers to fat people?

    Pointless to tell a smoker, drinker or a person who is overweight that its bad for them - they already know. The fact that they don't care isn't a government problem - its human nature.

    Those planning on living forever will be disappointed.

 

Comments 5 of 47

 

More Health stories

RSS

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.