Royal Opera House shrugs off first-night catcalls

Scene from Rusalka. © ROH 2012 / Clive Barda Some audience members were said to have found the production vulgar

The Royal Opera House has shrugged off the boos and walkouts that greeted a modern-dress staging of a Dvorak work.

"It is OK to have divided opinion when you try to move the boundaries," said director of opera Kasper Holten.

The decision to set Rusalka - a version of The Little Mermaid - in a brothel populated by provocatively dressed prostitutes perplexed some critics.

"Girls run around in their scanties... and it's all quite nasty," wrote Rupert Christiansen in the Daily Telegraph.

"Imported from the Salzburg Festival, it is a prime example of the pompous intellectualism which now dominates eurozone theatre."

Camilla Nylund in Rusalka. © ROH 2012 / Clive Barda Finnish soprano Camilla Nylund plays the title role in Rusalka

His sentiments were echoed by The Guardian's Andrew Clements, who called the production "an unedifying exercise in postmodern, operatic grunge".

The Times' Richard Morrison also expressed reservations, describing the staging as "crass, profoundly anti-musical and... mind-numbingly tedious".

First staged in 1901, Rusalka tells of a water nymph in love with a prince who gives up her voice in order to be human.

It is often likened to the Hans Christian Andersen fairy tale The Little Mermaid, famously turned into a film by the Walt Disney studio in 1989.

In a statement, Mr Holten admitted there had been some booing on Monday night but said there had been "people shouting bravo at the same time".

"This is not uncommon in opera," said the Danish director, who was appointed last year.

According to Mr Holten, the production of Rusalka - first presented at Salzburg in 2008 - "does not try to pretend [it] is just a pretty innocent story".

"It shows us that a fairy tale can also be about the darker aspects of life, and for me it highlights the pain and longing in the piece," he continued.

Camilla Nylund and feline friend in Rusalka. © ROH 2012 / Clive Barda A giant black cat features in the production, first seen in Salzburg in 2008

"We hope audiences will bring along their curiosity and expect to be surprised and challenged, made to think about new aspects of this well-known story."

The critics were more complimentary to other aspects of the production. Christiansen, for example, applauded Camilla Nylund's "committed performance" in the title role.

Morrison, meanwhile, found US tenor Bryan Hymel "fervent and impressive" as the Prince and praised the music's "sensuous sweep".

Mr Holten said the Royal Opera House was "proud to be presenting such a wonderful cast... who all wholeheartedly believe in and support the production".

Five additional performances of Rusalka are planned between now and 14 March.

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Entertainment & Arts stories



Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.