Poor white pupils 'need best teachers and long days'

Children with their hands up in a school classroom Schools face a "battle for resources and talent", the report says

Related Stories

White working-class children need schools with incentives to attract high-quality teachers and longer days to allow pupils to do their homework, says a cross-party committee of MPs.

The Education Select Committee has been examining the underachievement of poor white children in England.

Their exam results are much worse than disadvantaged black or Asian pupils.

The MPs' report describes poor white youngsters as "consistently the lowest performing group in the country".

The report - Underachievement in Education by White Working Class Children - identifies this as a "real and persistent" problem.

Attainment gap

Poor white children are already lagging behind when they start primary school, and the gap grows wider as they get older.

As each school year passes, this attainment gap sees them falling further behind wealthier white pupils and poor children from ethnic minorities.

The rising results among poor black and Asian pupils shows "improvements can be made", MPs say.


  • White British 32% (28.3% boys; 37% girls)
  • Indian 62%
  • Pakistani 47%
  • Black African 51%
  • Black Caribbean 42%

Source: House of Commons Education Select Committee.

This report "holds a mirror up to the situation - it does not attempt to solve the problem", but it makes some recommendations to lessen this underachievement.

Poor pupils of all ethnic backgrounds are much more likely to do well in outstanding schools.

The report shows that 50% of pupils eligible for free school meals will achieve a benchmark of five good GCSEs if they attend a school rated by Ofsted as outstanding.

This compares with only 25% in a school rated as inadequate.

The report argues that as a particularly low-achieving group, poor white children would have the most to gain from access to outstanding schools and the best teachers.

Competing for teachers

There should be incentives to recruit high-quality teachers into schools that could help these pupils, argues the report.

"Schools face a battle for resources and talent, and those serving poor white communities need a better chance of winning," it says.

There are practical forms of help, says the report, such as allowing time and space for children to do their homework at school, which could mean extending the school day.

The pupil premium, which targets funds at poor children, was welcomed as likely to make a difference.

Education Select Committee chairman Graham Stuart: "The most important thing is to get children from poor families into the classroom of great teachers"

The committee heard evidence about causes of this underachievement.

Ofsted chief Sir Michael Wilshaw highlighted the importance of supportive parents, irrespective of income.

"Poverty of expectation bears harder on educational achievement than material poverty, hard though that can be. And these expectations start at home."

Representatives of Leicester City Council told MPs that there were parts of the city where "white working class culture is characterised by low aspirations and negative attitudes towards education".

But the Joseph Rowntree Foundation, which has researched poverty, rejected the idea of low parental aspirations, but instead blamed a lack of self-belief among white working-class families.

They wanted their children to be high achievers, but had a much lower expectation than middle-class families that they would be able to "achieve their goals".

Lost 'bedrock'

Prof Alison Wolf, from King's College London, highlighted the link between concentrations of underachievement in school and where traditional industrial jobs had disappeared.

"A lot of the careers and jobs that were the bedrock of white working-class family life for many decades and generations have vanished and have not been well replaced," she said.

Start Quote

Poverty of expectation bears harder on educational achievement than material poverty, hard though that can be”

End Quote Sir Michael Wilshaw Ofsted chief inspector

Committee chairman Graham Stuart said working-class parents might not realise how much the labour market had changed - and that their children would face a tough future if they failed to achieve in school.

"They might have hated school, left early - but still did well for themselves and they mistakenly assume their children can do the same," he said.

The National Union of Teachers said that underachievement was linked to poverty,

"Children from disadvantaged backgrounds will not be as school ready as others for the simple reason if you have not had a meal in the evening, slept in your own bed or had breakfast, that will impact on your ability to learn," said general secretary Christine Blower.

Labour's shadow education secretary Tristram Hunt said: "The report is right to identify that the most important thing for raising standards is to ensure a highly motivated and highly skilled teacher in every classroom."

But he warned that this meant "ensuring that all teachers become properly qualified and continue to build their skills".

"This is how we narrow the attainment gap between deprived children and the rest."

A Department for Education spokesman said the pupil premium was providing £2.5bn per year to support disadvantaged pupils and that schemes such as Teach First were recruiting good teachers for tough areas.

"The over-riding objective of our reforms is to improve the attainment of the poorest children in society - and we are already seeing real improvements," he said.

"We have made it easier for all schools, not just academies and free schools, to extend the length of the school day."


More on This Story

Related Stories


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 327.

    Poverty is no excuse for low achievement at school!
    I was brought up on a council estate in a poor family in receipt of benefits as my father is disabled and my mother is his full-time carer.
    I could read, write and do basic sums BEFORE I started school and now am a Chartered Accountant.
    Caring about your children and their education does not cost a penny.

  • rate this

    Comment number 224.

    What kind of signal does English society send out to them. Look around and you'll see that having a private school education is the only way to succeed, whether its the media, music, company directors, army officers etc etc. Coupled with the fact the working class embrace their lack of aspiration and ambition you have the perfect system for favouring the priviledged

  • rate this

    Comment number 191.

    Our middle class suburb has some working class residents that have 'done well' incomewise . However most of their kids have not done well educationally. Our 4 kids have all graduated from top universities from state education, but they have highly educated, motivated parents who are only low to average earners. Educational attainment depends primarily on your culture not on systems of education.

  • rate this

    Comment number 152.

    Of course, the best teachers should be encouraged to work at schools with the most demanding issues. In this regard, financial reward will obviously play a role. However, if pupils are living in temporary bed and breakfast accommodation, it's hardly going to help the situation, but that then widens the issue significantly to the benefits system, the availability of social housing, etc, etc..

  • rate this

    Comment number 95.

    It's not rocket science. If they're not taught at home to value their education, they won't be bothered to learn.


Comments 5 of 9


More Education & Family stories



  • A very clever little girlBrain gain

    Why are people getting better at intelligence tests?

  • BeefaloBeefalo hunt

    The hybrid animal causing havoc in the Grand Canyon

  • A British Rail signBringing back BR

    Would it be realistic to renationalise the railways?

  • Banksy image of girl letting go of heart-shaped balloonFrom the heart

    Fergal Keane on the relationship between love and politics

  • Don Roberto Placa Quiet Don

    The world's worst interview - with one of the loneliest men on Earth

Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.