Nursery ratios raised 'to improve standards'

 
Nursery class The government says mandatory staff ratios are tighter in England than in much of Europe

Related Stories

Nurseries and childminders in England are to be allowed to look after more children, in a package ministers say will improve quality and cut costs.

The ratio of children to carers can be raised, but only if carers' qualifications meet new standards.

Children's Minister Liz Truss said the proposals would make more childcare places available and reduce costs for parents in the "long term".

Critics warn the change in ratios could actually compromise quality of care.

They also predict the changes - which are due to come into force in the autumn - will be unpopular with parents and are unlikely to reduce the overall costs of childcare.

England's nursery ratios

  • CURRENT
  • Under one and one-year-olds - 1:3
  • Two-year-olds - 1:4
  • Three-year-olds and above - 1:8 or 1:13 (teacher-led)
  • PROPOSED
  • Under one and one-year-olds 1:4
  • Two-year-olds - 1:6
  • Three-year-olds and above - 1:8 or 1:13 (teacher-led)

Statutory ratios for carers per child vary depending on age and setting. Ratios for two-year-olds are set to rise from four children per adult to six children per adult, and for ones-and-under to rise from three children per adult to four children per adult.

Ratios for three-year-olds and over would remain at eight or 13 children per adult, depending on whether a qualified graduate was present.

Ms Truss says the changes will bring the UK in line with countries such as France and Sweden. England's higher ratios lead to higher costs for parents and lower pay for staff, she says.

Ms Truss told the BBC the proposals were about raising standards and only those nurseries that hired staff with higher qualifications would be able to take on more children.

"It will make it higher quality, more available and more affordable. It will take time to recruit new people and expand nurseries. In the long term it will be more affordable," she said.

Liz Truss: "We're raising the standards so that parents will be able to get more available nursery places."

Britain has some of the highest childcare costs in the world, with many mothers with two or more children saying it does not make financial sense to work.

An earlier report by Ms Truss suggested the average family spends 27% of their income on childcare.

Ms Truss said childcare professionals should be better qualified in the UK.

Start Quote

Research also overwhelmingly indicates that introducing young children to quasi-formal academic learning too young has lifelong negative consequences”

End Quote Richard House Early Childhood Action Campaign founder

"When parents hand their child over to the care of a childminder or nursery, they are not just entrusting them with their child's physical safety, they are also entrusting their child's brain," she said

"With this in mind, it is no longer acceptable that childcare professionals are not required to have a GCSE grade C or above in English and maths."

This will apply to new nursery staff only, however.

'Very difficult'

Shadow education secretary Stephen Twigg said the plans to increase the ratios would undermine the quality of childcare in the UK.

Stephen Twigg: "Saying that more children will be in each setting risks undermining quality and even risks undermining safety."

"I think this is one area where we've actually got something to teach other countries.

"If you look at France, there's actually quite a big public debate about whether they've got this right. I don't think you can compare the situation with Sweden where they have very, very generous parental leave so very few young babies are in these sorts of settings."

Kent-based nursery manager Josie Lait is sceptical about the plans, saying fewer adults would jeopardise the quality of care and the safety of children.

"I feel it isn't realistic to change the ratios because the quality will go down dramatically.

"And if you have people who are better qualified, costs will go up, so how will parents benefit?

"I wouldn't want to enforce it [new ratios] myself, I wouldn't want my setting to change."

Anand Shukla, from national childcare charity Daycare Trust, said: "No matter how well qualified the members of staff, there are practical considerations when you increase the number of children that they have to look after," he said.

"For one person to look after six two-year-olds, for one person to talk to six two-year-olds, to help their language development, we think is going to be very difficult."

National Day Nurseries Association chief executive Purnima Tanuku welcomed the commitment made by the government to improve childcare but said the "quality of childcare and early education must not be sacrificed".

She said: "Many parents do not want an increase in the number of children nursery staff are allowed look after. They are worried it will have a negative impact on the individual attention and care their child receives."

Anne Longfield, chief executive of children's charity and nursery provider 4Children, said: "The welfare of the child must be our first concern throughout, but with highly qualified early-years teachers and a better inspection regime, there is an opportunity to review current arrangements and provide simpler information for parents and better incentives for providers to concentrate on what matters - children."

In Wales, the maximum number of children a child minder can care is six children under eight years of age. Of those six children, no more than three may be under five years of and of those three children, normally no more than two may be under 18 months of age.

In Welsh nurseries, there should be one adult to three children under two years, one adult to four children aged two years and one adult to eight children aged three to seven years.

International comparison

Ratios of children to childcare professionals

Source: OECD * Allows teams of carers to look after extra children as part of a group

Denmark

France

Ireland

Italy

Norway

Portugal

Sweden

UK

United States

1-year-olds

1:3.3*

1:5

1:3

1:7

1:8

1:11

1:5.5*

1:3

1:5

2-year-olds

1:3.3*

1:5

1:6

1:7

1:8

1:11

1:5.5*

1:4

1:5

 

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 800.

    Am amazed at the number of negative comments directed at working mothers (particularly by men). Both my children attended nursery full time and are extremely bright, sociable, loving and well mannered.

    Could my children's positive experience of life have been enhanced by a stay at home mum?

    Are my children representative of a "broken society" as implied by another user?

    Load of rubbish!

  • rate this
    +6

    Comment number 796.

    This is all about adding to the bottom line for the providers and does nothing to add to available child day care places or drive down costs for parents. There are some areas of human life that the free market should not be allowed to exploit and the result in child day care for hardworking parents in the UK is some of the highest costs on the planet!! Whats next the NHS perhaps??

  • rate this
    -21

    Comment number 485.

    A lot of people moaning here but if you check the figures you will realise the ratio has only risen by one and in fact are still lower than most of the countries around us which means our system still has more "dedication" than most other countries. I am not sure if this is totally "terrible!!!"

  • rate this
    +38

    Comment number 304.

    A retrograde step. What you will see is a reduction in care quality, safety put at risk, job losses and fees remaining static. An ill-thought out and rushed policy based on nothing but ideology.

  • rate this
    +61

    Comment number 292.

    My wife is a nursery nurse, hearing this over the radio this morning she ranted for an hour at the stupidity. Both my wife and her fellows work hard everyday in a low paid profession that demands constant attention. A couple of years ago she worked in a nursery which was in dire need of upgrades the managers preferred to spend the income on two houses in Spain. General Election please, NOW!

 

Comments 5 of 9

 

More Education & Family stories

RSS

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.