Adoption: David Cameron vows to cut adoption delays

 

Kevani Kanda: "I'm not against inter-racial adoption, but a lot needs to be considered"

Related Stories

The prime minister has vowed to tackle "absurd barriers to mixed-race adoption" which he says trap many children in care.

David Cameron said speed - not ethnicity - should be the key factor in getting children in to loving homes.

He was speaking in west London, ahead of the launch of the government's "Adoption Action Plan".

Local authorities in England are being told not to delay adoptions "in a search for the perfect ethnic match".

White children are three times more likely to leave care through adoption than those from ethnic minorities, the government says.

Of the 65,000 children in care in England at the end of March last year, about 50,000 were white.

Fewer people from ethnic minority backgrounds come forward to adopt.

The latest government figures suggest there are 6,770 children in England who have been identified for adoption in but have not been adopted.

In a speech at a children's centre in West London, the prime minister said he would keep coming back to the issue of speeding up adoptions, which he has made a government priority.

"This is not a prime ministerial flash in the pan," he said.

Mr Cameron said he knew adoption "was not right for everybody", but he wanted to see more children getting "the chance of growing up in a loving home and getting the care they need".

"I want to make sure that speed is the key factor in trying to get children adopted and we should not let issues like trying to find the perfect ethnic match be a factor," he said.

The government has announced three changes which it says will speed up the system:

  • Local authorities will be required to reduce delays and not delay adoptions "for the perfect match"
  • Legal changes to make it easier for children to be fostered by people approved for adoption so that a child might be fostered by someone who goes on to adopt them
  • If an adoptive match is not found locally in three months, local authorities will have to put the child on the national adoption register

Becky, from the English Midlands, recently adopted two young children with her same-sex partner.

They first saw them in a magazine called Children Who Wait, which features children in need of new families, produced by the charity Adoption UK.

Start Quote

The sooner you are out of that home and the sooner you have loving parents, the sooner you have a fighting chance of having a quality of life in today's world”

End Quote Joy Carter, Comedian

Becky says a child might have greater needs than those related to their ethnic background.

"Our children are second generation mixed-race and originally social workers were looking to place them with their other siblings and their ethnicity would have further complicated that," she told the BBC News website.

"I think their social worker did a good job in prioritising their needs. Sometimes, professionals can see ethnicity as a more important match than it should be.

"Some of the cases we heard about, we felt sure that the children had other needs that had to be met - such as a disability. What a child needs is a stable home."

Comedian Joy Carter, who was adopted in Nigeria by white parents, says it is vital to give a child a permanent loving home as early as possible.

She says she grew up in a white community and found some aspects of her childhood difficult and was bullied "because of the ignorance of others".

ANALYSIS

Children in care have the worst chances in life. They often do badly at school and are more likely to become teenage parents or go to prison.

David Cameron and his ministers see adoption as a key way to lift their life chances and have made it a priority to increase the speed and number of adoptions in England. Over the past year they have pulled various levers to try to do this - new guidance, changes to inspections - but the feeling is that this has not been enough and now these legal changes are afoot.

Some say delays are due to court processes and the paperwork social workers have to do, or that adoption is not always best for a child. They also say the desire for speed should not mean that hasty decisions are taken.

There is a high risk that adoptions will break down, but figures show that those which take place when a child is young are the most likely to last.

But the longer a child is left, she says, the more likely they are to suffer psychological harm - and that will make it even harder to adopt them.

"The sooner you're in a place where you can be nurtured and have hope and have love, the better. And what people don't really understand is that this is a very difficult situation for any child anyway, so having that stability, having that hope, is really important. That far outweighs all the grown-up issues hands down."

The government's adviser on adoption, Martin Narey, said black children waited "scandalous periods of time" before being adopted because of the search for an ethnic match.

"Race does matter but nowhere near as much as the system suggests at the moment," he said.

"I have met, for example, a foster carer, white mother of a black child - clearly a good match - child loved the mother, and that woman had to suffer for nearly two years while her local authority tried to find black parents for a child who was happy and contented. We can't allow that to continue."

Start Quote

These are decisions that will reverberate for the rest of the child's life”

End Quote David Holmes British Association for Adoption and Fostering

Matt Dunkley, the president of the Association of Directors of Children's Services, said race was important, as it was central to identity.

"When we balance the needs of the child and their sense of their own identity linked to their race and we look to speed it up and the options of white parents, we need to be careful in the social work we do around that to make sure it is the right thing for that child," he said.

"What I wouldn't want is for anyone to have the idea that issues around a child's identity and their ethnic background in particular are straightforward and can be solved simply by adoption outside their own race."

The Local Government Association, which represents councils across England and Wales, called on the government "to scrap reams of unnecessary paperwork" related to adoption.

David Holmes, from the British Association for Adoption and Fostering, said while decisions needed to be made quickly, they had to be right for the children.

"These are decisions that will reverberate for the rest of the child's life. And we need to make sure that when we find families for children, they're families that are going to last. But no single issue - ethnicity, anything else - should stop a match which would otherwise meet the child's assessed needs."

A fifth of adoptions currently break down, reports suggest, while children wait an average of two years and seven months to be adopted.

 

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 216.

    Very interesting comments by the young lady in the video clip and she really has put her finger on potential problems for mixed race adopters. However, if a child is given both security and love then that must be far better than remaining in care without any family support. No parents can ever get everything right - we are forever learning our parenting skills.

  • rate this
    +6

    Comment number 154.

    When I was adopted in the 70s adoption was often a way out of the shameful prospect of single parenthood. Now that's not an issue, adoption is more kids removed from a family that has broken down. They need undemanding, loving parents who aren't looking for a prop to hide the shame of their infertility. Ethnicity doesn't matter at all. 'Match' doesn't matter. Stability, love and selflessness do

  • rate this
    +14

    Comment number 150.

    I was adopted at 5 months. I am now 44. I am sure at that time there was none of the ridiculus red-tape we have today. Their criteria was to find a stable, loving couple for the child. In my case that is what I had. Sadly my adoptive Parents have passed away. I now want to trace my Birth Parents. The fact remains I had a loving and safe upbringing and thats the best you can hope for.

  • rate this
    +19

    Comment number 101.

    I'm glad I finally agree with something that Cameron says/does. I hope he doesn't stop here and tackles the rest of the inconsistent and often ineffective adoption services across the country. Every child has the right to a loving home and shouldn't be prevented from having one because of bureaucracy that means nothing to them.

  • rate this
    +20

    Comment number 94.

    Call me naive, call me idealistic, call me anything you like, but I truly believe a loving heart is the only qualification needed to be a good adoptive parent. (Or a natural parent.)

 

Comments 5 of 9

 

More Education & Family stories

RSS

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.