Q&A: Free schools

Church hall, site for St Luke's Church of England Primary School, Camden Many free schools are trying to set up in existing buildings, like this Camden church hall

The coalition government has encouraging parents and independent groups in England to set up their own schools - called free schools. From 2013 there have been 174 open. The BBC News website examines key questions about free schools.

What is a free school?

Free schools are set up by groups of parents, teachers, charities, businesses, universities, trusts, religious or voluntary groups, but funded directly by central government.

They can be run by an "education provider" - an organisation or company brought in by the group setting up the school - but these firms are not allowed to make a profit.

The schools are established as academies, independent of local authorities and with increased control over their curriculum, teachers' pay and conditions, and the length of school terms and days.

How did they come into being?

Free schools were much talked about in the run-up to the general election in May 2010. They were the flagship policy of the then shadow education secretary, Michael Gove.

A month after he was appointed, he invited groups to submit their proposals for free schools.

Free schools were given approval in the Academies Act 2010, which also paved the way for existing state primary and secondary schools to become academies.

What sorts of groups have applied to set up free schools?

In the first round, there were 323 applications; 115 were from faith groups. Chains behind academies also came forward to set up schools. Applicants included the journalist Toby Young, who went on to set up the West London Free School, which opened last September and Katharine Birbalsingh, the teacher who strongly criticised the state education system at the Conservative party conference in 2010.

What do groups have to do to set up a free school?

They must submit a full business case, rather than a broad-brush plan as originally required.

Officials say this requires detailed answers to questions about parental demand, the type of education the school will provide, its ethos and the capacity and capability of the groups themselves.

These business cases are then judged against other free school proposals and scored for strengths and weaknesses.

Short-listed applicants are called for an interview to discuss their proposal.

What money is available for free schools?

Free schools will receive no additional money per pupil for their day to day running. Funding is worked out on a per pupil basis, like other schools.

A total of £50m - taken out of an axed technology fund for schools - was initially allocated for free schools for the first year of the policy, up to April 2011. And in November 2011, the government announced it had ear-marked an extra £600m on building 100 new free schools in England over the next three years.

The Department for Education said last year that the first 24 schools would cost a total of £110-130m, but many of these were opened in temporary buildings and details of the cost of acquiring many buildings have not been revealed so the cost of permanent accommodation is not clear. Cost vary widely, depending on the size, location and circumstances of the school.

Do free schools exist in other countries?

Similar schools exist in the United States and in Sweden. In these countries, non-profit - as well as profit-making groups - can set up schools funded by the government, but free from its control. These schools are called Charter Schools in the US.

Where are free schools being housed?

Free schools do not need to acquire a site before they apply to become a free school, but they should at least identify one possible site. This may be a disused school site, an old library, church buildings or former local authority buildings.

Several are in renovated listed buildings.

In the United States, some free schools are housed in the buildings of schools which have surplus places. The BBC understands this could be happen for one free school being planned in England.

How will free schools be regulated?

They will be subject to inspections by England's schools watchdog, Ofsted, just as other schools are, usually within two years' of opening.

Their Sats (primary national curriculum tests), GCSE and A-level results will be published in league tables in the same way as those of other state schools.

What are the admissions criteria?

Free schools are expected to operate an inclusive, fair and transparent admissions policy. They cannot be academically selective, and take part in their locally co-ordinated admissions process, so parents apply for a place for their child in the same way as for other maintained schools.

If a faith-based free school is undersubscribed, every child who has applied must be admitted, whether they are a faith or non-faith applicant. If it is oversubscribed, its oversubscription criteria must allow for 50% of places to be allocated to children without reference to faith.

Free schools are expected to abide by the Admissions Code, which applies to all state schools in England, with the exception that the government has said the children of free school founders should be able to get a place at the school automatically.

Under their funding agreements (the contract signed between the education secretary and those setting up the school), free schools must "use their best endeavours" to meet any special needs of pupils, while disability legislation requires them to make "reasonable adjustments" to provide for disabled students.

What do critics say?

The government says the free schools programme gives parents and teachers the chance to create a new school if they are unhappy with state schools in a local area, and that competition will drive up standards.

But critics - including the Labour party and several teachers' unions - say they will prove divisive, are likely to be centred disproportionately in middle-class neighbourhoods, to weaken already weak schools by attracting the best performing pupils, and will contribute to creating a two-tier system.

There are also fears the changes will give too much freedom to faith-based schools or fundamentalist agendas - although schools must show their curriculum is "broad and balanced" and government guidelines say creationism must not be taught as a valid scientific theory.

And some critics are angered by the funding and administrative time going into what they consider to be a "pet project" promoted by the education secretary, which looks likely to benefit relatively few children at a time of spending cuts in education and youth services.

Teachers' unions are also critical of the fact that free schools do not have to employ qualified teachers.

Meanwhile, others say Mr Gove has missed an opportunity by not allowing free schools to be run for profit.

More on This Story

Academies and free schools

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Education & Family stories



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.