Oxford University: PM incorrect on black student intake

 
Prime Minister David Cameron speaking in Harrogate Mr Cameron was answering questions from members of the public

Oxford University has hit back at the prime minister after he said only one black UK student began a course there in 2009 and called it "disgraceful".

The university said David Cameron had been "incorrect and highly misleading", and that at least 26 black British undergraduates started that year.

Mr Cameron was answering questions about the effect of raised tuition fees on poorer students.

Downing Street said the figure of one black Caribbean student was accurate.

Mr Cameron was answering questions from the public at a "PM Direct" event in Harrogate in North Yorkshire.

"I saw figures the other day that showed that only one black person went to Oxford last year," he said. "I think that is disgraceful. We have got to do better than that."

The university said that it was true that only one British undergraduate from that year's intake identified him or herself as "black - Caribbean".

But this failed to take into account another 26 who identified themselves as either "black - African" or "black - other".

Analysis

It is always important to get your facts straight when challenging the record of a high-profile institution.

Perhaps even more so when you are the prime minister accusing Oxford University of a "disgraceful" record on admitting black students.

During a question-and-answer session in Harrogate, he said: "I saw the figures the other day that showed that only one black person went to Oxford last year. I think that is disgraceful. We have got to do better than that."

The university has accused the prime minister, an Oxford graduate himself, of being misleading because he missed out the word "Caribbean".

A spokesman for the university said that, in the year in question, Oxford admitted 41 British undergraduates of black origin and mixed black descent, but that is out of a total of about 3,000 students.

Downing Street aides admit the prime minister made a mistake but strongly defend what they say is a crucial question: why does Oxford have so few black students?

The answer may have something to do with the fact that just 452 pupils from a black background got the grades necessary to make a successful application to Oxford.

So the problem seems to be one that starts well before pupils get to university.

The prime minister's argument might have had even more impact if he had got his numbers right.

Another 14 described themselves as mixed race with some black heritage, a spokesman said.

And these figures do not take into account postgraduates, non-British undergraduates, or undergraduates who preferred not to identify themselves as belonging to a specific ethnic group, he added.

In total, in 2009 22% of Oxford University students were from ethnic minorities, the institution said.

A Downing Street spokesperson said: "The figure the prime minister used was from a response to an Freedom of Information request submitted by David Lammy - which clearly states that only 1 black Caribbean student was admitted to Oxford in 2009.

"The wider point he was making was that it is not acceptable for universities like Oxford to have so few students coming from black and minority ethnic groups."

Mr Cameron was also criticised by the Russell Group of leading universities for saying that the numbers of state-school students had gone down in the last 20 years.

He had said: "That is a terrible record."

But Wendy Piatt, the group's director general, said it was "simply not true", as the proportion of state-school students at Russell Group universities had risen by 9% since 1997.

"This rate of growth exceeds the growth in the proportion of state school students across all UK universities, which was 8.6% in the same period," she said.

Mr Lammy, the shadow higher education minister, said Oxford University "needs to show more humility about its woeful admissions figures".

Start Quote

This is an issue that is as much about the class and north-south divides as it is about race”

End Quote David Lammy Shadow higher education minister

He said: "It is not acceptable that only one black Caribbean student entered Oxford in 2009. Nor is it clear that Oxford University is really committed to outreach work.

"They targeted private schools for 770 'outreach' events in 2008 and 2009, including 11 at St Paul's and 9 at Eton. This is an issue that is as much about the class and north-south divides as it is about race.

"Oxford is taking more students from Richmond-upon-Thames than they are from Birmingham, Britain's second largest city."

Elite universities are under increasing pressure to boost the numbers of students they attract from disadvantaged backgrounds.

Universities wanting to charge more than the basic £6,000 tuition fees under the new regime, which begins in 2012, must commit to measures to attract poorer students.

Both Oxford and Cambridge failed to increase their share of students from state schools last year, according to data published by the Higher Education Statistics Agency last month.

Both institutions, along with numerous other universities, have said they will charge the maximum tuition fees possible, of £9,000 a year.

 

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    -2

    Comment number 214.

    Some people are missing the point. The issue isn't Oxford's admission policy, it's that 26 out of a University of over 20,000 students is a very low number. This is representative of the gap in quality of education between different demographics, less admissions from black students which is interpreted as lower expectations, and massive under representation of the UK'sblack population.

  • rate this
    -8

    Comment number 183.

    The majority of people on here have quickly asserted their belief that individuals should only gain a place at institutions like Oxford on merit alone, and race shouldn't come into it. The truth is that entry based on A level grades is unfair, because many applicants come from priviledged backgrounds and get reams of extra help, boosting their chances.

    Shouldn't this imbalance be addressed!

  • rate this
    +15

    Comment number 154.

    I have to say that as a blackman I find this a disgrace. No not that Oxford has a relatively small number of 'black students' but that the Prime Minister would produce such a bogus conclusion in order to pay lip-service to those who are agree about his hike in tuition fees. This gives a new meaning to spin-doctory!!

  • rate this
    +13

    Comment number 152.

    Those who think Oxford should represent the British demographic are too short-sighted. British applicants of whatever ethnicity are in competition with the best in the world.

  • rate this
    +4

    Comment number 148.

    I am an Oxford graduate and last year did some interviewing at my former college for a travel bursary, funded by my fellow alumni. We had four candidates, one from Luxembourg, one from Pakistan, one Singaporean and one British (state educated, as it happens). Both sexes were equally represented and three races: white European, South Asian and Chinese. Quite a diverse group!

 

Comments 5 of 10

 

More Education & Family stories

RSS

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.