English councils propose 'Tesco tax'


Derby and 19 other local authorities back the so-called "Tesco tax"

Related Stories

A group of local councils in England is formally asking the government for new powers to tax large supermarkets.

BBC News has learned that Derby City Council has called for the right to bring in a levy as a "modest" effort to ensure supermarket spending "re-circulates" in local communities.

Some 19 other local authorities back a so-called "Tesco tax" on big retailers, which could raise up to £400m a year.

The government said additional taxes on supermarkets would push up food prices.

A similar tax already operates in Northern Ireland and Scotland.

The council has made the suggestion under the Sustainable Communities Act, which allows communities and councils to put forward ideas to government to solve local problems.

In its submission, the council says that while supermarkets bring some benefits, they have an overall detrimental impact on the sustainability of local communities.

"Research has shown that 95% of all the money spent in any large supermarket leaves the local economy for good, compared to just 50% from local independent retailers; this levy is a modest attempt to ensure more of that money re-circulates within and continues to contribute to local jobs and local trade," its report states.

'Already benefiting'

The council wants the right to impose a levy on large supermarkets, retain the money raised, and use it to help small businesses. It said it could also use the money to support community centres and parks.

The extra business rates levy, of up to 8.5%, would affect any large retail outlet with a rateable value of more than £500,000.

Four main supermarkets The tax could affect the four main supermarkets

Ranjit Banwait, leader of the council, said communities in Scotland and Northern Ireland were "already benefiting" from the scheme.

"The revenue that we'll be able to generate will mean that we can support local businesses - especially small businesses," he said.

"We'll be able to improve public services."

The government will have six months to respond. If agreed, the levy would apply not just to the 20 councils seeking change but to all local authorities in England.

And if every one of them took it up, it could cost the big supermarkets alone an extra £190m in tax.

If the levy was imposed on all big out-of-town retailers, including businesses such as Ikea, Homebase and B&Q, it could raise about £400m in total.

But the government has already given an indication of how the idea will be received.

The move would hit low-income families the hardest, said the Department for Communities and Local Government (DCLG).

'Powerful legacy'

"We ruled out such a bid for higher taxes under the last round of the Sustainable Communities Act proposals," it said.

"There are much better ways to support small shops."

Richmond High Street Derby City Council says high streets are suffering

However, the move has been given a cautious welcome by the former retail boss and High Street campaigner Bill Grimsey. He proposed the idea of a levy in his independent review of the High Street last year.

He called for a one-off levy on retailers and pub groups with a turnover of more than £10m to help finance plans to allow struggling town centres to rebuild themselves for the future.

Mr Grimsey said it was right that the biggest retailers put something back into their high streets:

"Used wisely, it could leave a lasting and powerful legacy. But I don't want this introduced as an annual levy that essentially becomes another tax," he said.

"If it's used simply to plug council budget shortfalls, it won't be fair and it'll be anti-business. This has to be about the High Street, not clobbering big business."

Town centre expert Mark Williams said the current rates system would be better than a supermarket levy at improving town centres.

"Ironically supermarkets are not looking to go out of town. Customers don't like them - those big starships that landed in those green areas - they are now being cancelled and we are now seeing announcements by Tesco to convert sites that they've got into residential [developments]."

Heated debate

Supporters of the move, which include Oxford, Brighton and Hove, Preston, Southwark and Sefton councils, believe the supermarkets can afford it, saying it is just a fraction of the costs that supermarkets had to swallow when VAT was raised in 2011.

But retailers are likely to strongly resist the move arguing that they are taxed enough already. They pay more in business rates, a property-based tax, than any other form of taxation and have been urging the government for a complete rethink on the system.

Councillor Ranjit Banwait on his call for a "supermarket levy"

They will also raise concerns about fresh investment and jobs being put at risk.

The British Retail Consortium has said it is consulting its members on the proposed tax.

The levy imposed by the Scottish government on larger shops selling alcohol and tobacco is set to end next year. The aim of the scheme was to make them contribute to public health measures.

It is clear Derby City Council's idea for an additional tax on retailers south of the border will spark even more heated debate.


More on This Story

Related Stories


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 839.

    The Government's claimed 1 billion to help high streets does't go very far. In fact, it's just £15 per head, less than the money that disappears from communities in a single shopping basket.

    Ditch the car, walk or cycle, shop locally with the money you save, and see your cash stay within your own community, rather than the pockets of shareholders who grow rich while your town gets poorer.

  • rate this

    Comment number 116.

    Local councils should concentrate on getting a fairer deal for smaller High St shops by lobbying the government to introduce a 3% levy on turnover, not profit, instead of business rates, which are out of all proportion to takings. All that small businesses ask for is a level playing field

  • rate this

    Comment number 104.

    The problem with any tax targeting the big supermarkets is that it will push the consumer to buy more and more from the big online retailers who pay even less tax...

    Does no one notice the ironic cycle - it happened with book sellers - Waterstones & Dillons came to the high street so the small shops closed; then Borders came so high street chains closed; now Borders has closed for Amazon...

  • rate this

    Comment number 80.

    I believe that these supermarkets already pay a substantial amount of local business tax and rates as well as providing jobs that allow [eople to pay local taxes rather than claiming relief off the council. Time councils stopped being so greedy and looked at expenses and employment of researchers and other outside consultants where most work could be done in-house.

  • rate this

    Comment number 75.

    Its not unreasonable I think to ask a very large business to contribute something back to the community they are making money off. I can see the councils point of view, however the reputation of most local govt is very poor when it comes to fiscal matters. Maybe unfairly I don't know. As for putting prices up I doubt it with Aldi & Lidl pushing them even further down its just an excuse to say no.


Comments 5 of 9


More Business stories


BBC Business Live

    09:35: ROYAL MAIL JOBS
    Royal Mail staff at the St. Rollox sorting office in Glasgow,

    Incidentally, Royal Mail has also started its annual recruitment drive to help with the Christmas post, saying 19,000 temporary jobs will be available. Now all we need is the first Christmas ads and John Lewis to put its Christmas decorations up in store, and we're all set for the traditional retail frenzy that embodies the spirit of the festive season. That's right, isn't it?

    AMAZON JOBS Via Twitter Ben Thompson Business correspondent, BBC News Channel

    tweets: "Amazon to create 13,000 seasonal jobs in run up to Christmas. On busiest day last year, customers ordered 4.1m items - 47 every second."

    09:07: SAP DOWNGRADE

    German software developer SAP has fallen 3.9% this morning in Frankfurt after letting on that 2014 profit will be lower than previously forecast. Services in the cloud are putting pressure on profits.

    08:50: FORD INVESTMENT Radio 5 live

    Ford is investing about £200m at its Dagenham plant creating about 300 jobs to make diesel engines. Mark Ovenden of Ford is on 5 live. Engines are Britain's strength in vehicle manufacture, he says.

    08:39: MARKET REPORT

    The FTSE 100 is behaving a bit oddly in early trading. It opened up 8 points this morning then promptly remembered the eurozone is teetering on the edge of a third crisis and there's less global economic growth out there and fell again. Now it's up 3 points again at 6313.64 . The situation is a bit worse for Germany's Dax - down 52 points to 8797.85 - and France's Cac-40 - down 23 points to 4010.12.

    08:28: TAX MARK

    SSE is touting its award of the new Fair Tax Mark, which has been set up to show companies are being open about what tax they pay. Other recipients include Go-Ahead Group , Midcounties Co-operative, Phone Co-op and Unity Trust Bank. Margaret Hodge, chair of parliament's Public Accounts Committee, said she hoped other companies would follow SSE's example.

    Computer generated image of the floating cycle route

    Is the floating bike path a sustainable solution or an expensive distraction? We think you probably just need to look at the picture (above) for the answer to that question. But if you really feel the need to read about one of the more outlandish proposals being considered by Mayor of London Boris Johnson then by all means take a look. Some have baulked at the £600m price tag. But no doubt the team behind the 'Thames Deckway' thought "Boris. Keen Cycler, loves things that float (think airports), it's bound to be a winner."


    Drugs firm Shire has announced that interim chief financial officer James Bowling has resigned after ten years with the firm. He is joining Severn Trent as CFO and will leave Shire at the end of March 2015. Shire saw more than 30% of its share value wiped out last week after the collapse of a £32bn takeover from US rival AbbVie. Shire will start the search for a new CFO immediately.

    The badge of Greene King brewers on a pub wall

    Spirit pub company, which runs about 750 pubs, says Greene King has made a better offer to take the company over. They would get 0.1322 Greene King shares per Spirit share and a cash payment of 8 pence, worth a total of about 109.5 pence. Spirit's board says it may recommend the offer once a few details have been ironed out.

    Chancellor of the Exchequer George Osborne

    Don't expect any traditional tax giveaways ahead of the general election. In a move akin to "good luck, there's no money left", Cabinet ministers have been warned by the Treasury that it is likely they will have to rein in their spending in the run-up to the election because of a shortfall in tax revenues and concerns about the global economy, the Financial Times has reported today. Treasury secretary Danny Alexander has told the Cabinet tax revenues are not recovering as quickly as the economy so he might have to impose new spending controls in the Autumn Statement. Yikes.

    07:21: BANK OF JAPAN

    Japan's central bank has maintained its economic assessment for eight of the country's nine regions in its quarterly report, saying they continue to recover. The north-eastern Tohoku region cut its assessment from July, to say that the recovery trend is slowing.

    07:07: IBM NEWS

    IBM says it will make a "major business announcement" today. Various newspapers including the Wall Street Journal think it will sell off its loss-making microchip-making business. IBM will pay Globalfoundries $1.5bn (£931m) to take the chip operations off its hands, says the WSJ.

    06:50: UK GROWTH BBC Radio 4

    Peter Spencer, economic adviser to the EY Item Club, tells the Today programme housing investment along with business investment has been responsible for "about half of the economic growth" we have see in the UK since the start of the recovery. But people are beginning to worry about global growth and the UK's economic outlook. Concerns about economic developments at home and abroad has meant there are already signs of "a return to caution by both borrowers and lenders in the mortgage market".


    Last week's stock market sell off is on the business agenda today. "Everyone was feeling nervous. We just need a very small straw to break the camel's back I think it was the Ebola virus," James Bevan chief investment officer at CCLA Investment Management tells the Today programme. "We had a lot of other things going on but I think Ebola was the thing that made investors say to themselves 'let's sit this one out'. There has been no real change in the hard economic data." He is worried about bond yields spiking "as they did in 1987" though.

    06:24: EUROZONE ECONOMY Radio 5 live
    Jose Manual Barroso

    Jose Manual Barroso, outgoing President of the European Commission, has told the BBC he doesn't think another recession in the eurozone is likely. Official statistics suggest a "weaker recovery than anticipated. Elmar Brok, a German member of the European Parliament is on Radio 5 live and says Britain should be "more positive towards the eurozone"

    06:13: INTERN PAY Radio 5 live

    Christian May from the Institute of Directors is on 5 live talking about employment reform, including reforms to how interns are paid, or otherwise. "It's worth considering it's unlikely to be a silver bullet," he says. There's a chance restrictions could be gamed to allow employers not to pay interns. While 25% of businesses have interns they don't pay, "in this day and age its getting difficult to justify having someone work for them and not paying them."

    06:03: ETHICAL INVESTMENTS Radio 5 live

    Justin Urquhart Stewart of 7 Investment Management is on 5 live talking about ethical investment. "It's very badly marketed so people don't understand it ," He says. But because such investments strip out companies such as tobacco, alcohol, arms and oil, returns can also be slim.

    06:01: Howard Mustoe Business reporter

    Good morning. Get in touch via email bizlivepage@bbc.co.uk and twitter @BBCBusiness.

    06:00: Matthew West Business reporter

    Morning folks. It's a gloomy start to the day with the EY Item Club downgrading its 2015 UK economic growth forecast quite sharply this morning as a result of the global slowdown and uncertainty over interest rates. There's more housing market data out later and the Prime Minister is going to be pushing for more apprenticeships today too. We'll bring you more as it happens.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.