New pensioners to get independent guidance, Treasury says

Chancellor George Osborne with his red dispatch box ahead of the Budget on 19 March 2014 The chancellor unveiled the pension changes in the Budget in March

Savers are to receive free independent guidance when given unfettered access to their pension pots from next year, the government has said.

The plan changes an aspect of the major liberalisation of defined contribution pensions unveiled in the Budget.

Critics had raised concerns a proposal to make providers give advice could see unsuitable investments recommended.

The guidance will now be through independent organisations, paid for by a levy on regulated financial firms.

It will it not always be face-to-face, as first indicated, but could be provided online or by phone.

Start Quote

It is not going to be a deep and interactive process that gives you very personalised advice”

End Quote Tom McPhail Hargreaves Lansdown

Up until now most people in defined contribution schemes - where the final pension depends on the amount of investment returns - bought an annuity, a pre-set income for life, from a provider when they retired.

But from next April, savers will be able to use their pension money as they see fit, from the age of 55.

Chancellor George Osborne told the BBC: "This is going to be free and impartial guidance for millions of people who for the first time are going to have access to the money they've saved through their life.

"We're going to work with people like the Citizens Advice Bureau, with Age UK and others to make sure people get the best possible guidance and that this is genuinely impartial."


Analysts have cast some doubt over the nature of the guidance on offer.

"It is going to be pretty superficial. It is not going to be a deep and interactive process that gives you very personalised advice. That would be very expensive, so it can't do that," said Tom McPhail, head of pensions research at Hargreaves Lansdown stockbrokers.

Malcolm McLean, senior consultant at Barnett Waddingham, said that there was still a risk of people making inappropriate choices as extra complexity was added to the already complicated pension system.

"It is still not completely clear how this [guidance] will work in practice and what the interfaces and overlaps might be with providers and fully qualified financial advisers," he said.

Pound coins on bank notes The Money Advice Service already runs a website explaining financial choices
'Vested interest'

The Treasury carried out a consultation after the Budget in March and has now published the final rules for the changes.

It said the plans were "overwhelmingly well received", with savers backing greater freedom and choice, and the pensions and insurance industry ready to create new products better suiting individuals' needs.

Mr Osborne had acknowledged from the start that advice given to savers through the providers themselves might not be seen as impartial.

The guidance will now be delivered by organisations including the Pensions Advisory Service and the Money Advice Service.

George Osborne: "Millions" of savers to benefit from independent pensions advice

Concerns have also been raised on how a nationwide pensions guidance service could be set up by April next year.

The Association of British Insurers, which represents a number of pension companies, said that there was an "aggressive timeline" to get the service up and running by April 2015.

And Jackie Spencer, pensions expert at the Money Advice Service (MAS), said the deadline was "challenging". She said that the MAS already oversaw the work of more than 100 face-to-face advisers on financial matters, and had a website explaining pension choices.

However, there was no precedent in other countries of a guidance service of this kind.

The process would mean:

  • Pension providers would have to tell people approaching retirement that guidance is available
  • Information about pension choices will be offered through websites and on the telephone
  • Retirees will then be able to request impartial, face-to-face guidance

The Treasury said: "The government wants to ensure that guidance is trusted by consumers, and the vast majority, including most of the financial services industry who responded, said that consumers would not trust guidance given by a person or organisation with a vested interest in selling a financial product or service."

The Treasury said about 300,000 people with defined contribution pension savings would be able to access them as they wish next April, although only the first 25% of money taken out of their schemes would be tax-free.

Pensioner couple The system will mean people can request face-to-face advice as they approach retirement
Retirement spending

Some have suggested, since the original plans were announced in the Budget, that the new freedoms could mean people spending large sums early in their retirement and falling back on state support later.

But Mr Osborne said those concerns were unfounded.

"I think that approach is frankly a bit patronising to say to people you don't know how to spend your own money," he said.

"I take the view which is: you have worked hard, you have been responsible, you have saved for your retirement. You know better than anyone how you want to use that money. And if you have this new free and impartial guidance you can be directed towards the right choices for you."

The pension reform plans have also led to some financial analysts questioning how the insurance industry will be affected by a potential fall in demand for annuities.

The Treasury also confirmed that the government would allow new pensioners in private sector defined benefit schemes to transfer into defined contribution pension schemes. But it decided to introduce two new safeguards - a requirement to take advice and new guidance for trustees of the existing schemes.


However, the chairman of the House of Commons Treasury Committee, Andrew Tyrie, has written to Mr Osborne to voice concern over MAS's involvement in the delivery of guidance.

Mr Tyrie said: "The Treasury Committee was clear that guidance provided under the guidance guarantee should be demonstrably impartial between insurance providers. Today's announcement by the Treasury that the guidance guarantee will be provided by independent bodies appears to meet this requirement, and is a step forward.

"It is concerning, however, that the MAS may play a part in the delivery of the guidance. The Committee has expressed serious concerns about the ability of the MAS to perform its functions, and has recommended that an independent review consider whether the MAS should exist at all as a statutory body.

"I have written today to the Chancellor, asking him to clarify the scope and limits of the role proposed for the MAS."

Mr Tyrie added: "Furthermore, the independent review should be allowed to consider both immediate improvements to the MAS and the question of its future as a statutory body. Without such an undertaking, the Committee would have reservations about a role for the MAS in an area as important as the guidance guarantee."

In a separate announcement, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) said, following a review looking at nearly 300 cases from bulk pension transfer advice exercises between 2008 and 2012, poor advice had led to a risk of people losing out on retirement income.

People were offered enhancements to encourage them to leave their employers' defined benefit pension schemes but unsuitable advice had been given in some cases.


More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 633.

    I once received some 'free financial advice' on my pension, I discovered later I had been miss sold to the tune of 75%. Be very careful about so called ' Financial Advisers'. They are sometimes crooks and sometimes just trained to sell product that only benefit the company they work for. Pensions are a minefield.

  • rate this

    Comment number 584.

    Since pension funds represent money that people have spent their lives saving why shouldn't they be entitled to spend it supporting themselves in retirement? Interest rates are so low that buying an annuity is a complete waste of money, and interest on ordinary savings, which used to be a source of retirement income, is pitiful. The only people this is going to hurt are the fund managers.

  • rate this

    Comment number 356.

    Another desperate attempt to boost the economy.

    This time, instead of ultra cheap credit and a housing boom, its opening up peoples pension pots to boost short term spending and worry about the consequences down the line.

    Short term thinking for short term political advantage.

    When are politicians going to start acting in the long term interests of the British people?

  • rate this

    Comment number 354.

    It is not advice that is being offered. It is guidance. There's a very important distinction. If the banks had only offered guidance re PPI. There would be no compensation, no PPI scandal.

    The govt is not offering advice, no disrespect to CAB, there's no suggestion yet the people giving guidance will be required to have any formal financial/wealth mngt knowledge.

  • rate this

    Comment number 346.

    I paid £120 a week into a pension fund over a number of decades,trust me the only people that have made money on my money are Scottish life,My advice would be to enjoy it now dont save the return is disgusting


Comments 5 of 9


More Business stories


BBC Business Live


    Lufthansa pilots have launched a strike. That's just after a rail strike in Germany during the weekend. Business lobbyists aren't pleased. The German Industry Federation said the pilots strike, following the "disproportionate" railway stoppage, "harms the entire economy" by slowing logistics, tourism and business travel.

    BANK OF ENGLAND 12:20: Via Email Jonty Bloom Business correspondent, BBC News

    The Bank of England has stopped transfers between banks including individual mortgage payments because of a technical problem with its CHAPS electronic payments system. After routine maintenance over the weekend the system developed a problem and has been taken down while it is being fixed, the Bank of England hopes to have it up and running before the end of the day and can extend its opening hours and increase its capacity if necessary, to make all the transfers. The most important payments are being made manually, and the Bank of England said in a statement that "we can reassure the public that all payments made today will be processed."

    Via Twitter Douglas Fraser Business and economy editor, Scotland

    tweets: "Bank of England suspends RTGS system, used for immediate transfer of big payments, due to 'technical issue'"

    11:56: LENDING

    The Bank of England's October Trends in Lending survey has found monthly net lending to businesses has been "volatile" over the last six months, but "on average was broadly close to zero". The upshot of this? Well, to put it simply it's another reason not to raise interest rates anytime soon. The Bank adds: "Much of the weakness in lending to businesses reflects a contraction in lending to the real estate sector which accounts for around 30% of" That has been offset by lending to other service providers and manufacturers but the point remains. Lending, and consequently business investment is not rising as much as perhaps it should.

    11:40: MARKET UPDATE

    Markets have fallen, after Friday's rise. The UK FTSE 100 fell 0.76%, while the French Cac and German Dax fell 0.7% and 1%.

    • Tesco rose 2.5% on bid speculation for its Asia assets.
    • HSBC fell 0.9% as Citigroup elected to trim its price target on the stock to 675 pence from 685 pence
    • BG Group was the biggest faller with a 3% drop
    An easyJet aircraft takes-off

    Well, this puts easyjet's baggage policy into perspective. The Daily Mail reports passengers on a flight from "London" Southend airport bound for Malaga were asked to volunteer to get off an easyJet plane because it was too heavy. The airline blamed weather conditions for the problem. Cabin crew asked for volunteers while the aircraft sat on the tarmac for more than an hour. Eventually ten people selected to leave and were offered £250 compensation each.

    LENDING Via Email Howard Archer, chief UK and European economist at IHS Global Insight

    writes: "The Bank of England found small- to medium-sized enterprises operating in sectors like house building or leisure continued to struggle to obtain finance." He adds: "It is vitally important for sustained, balanced UK growth that all companies who are in decent shape and who do want to borrow - whether it be to lift investment, explore new markets or generally support their operations - can do so, and at a non-punishing interest rate. This applies to all companies, whatever their size."

    10:47: HOUSE PRICES

    Rightmove's latest asking price data for England and Wales suggests home owners are asking 2.6% more for their property this month compared with the previous month. That takes the average asking price to £271,669 on average. Believe it or not the rise in asking prices this months is the slowest for the time of year since 2008.

    10:31: HOUSE PRICES
    Graph showing changes in property asking prices over the last year

    There's a little more on house prices today. According to property website Rightmove house price growth in the South East is set to surge in the next few years as London buyers look outside the capital. It is tipping Southampton, Luton and Brighton as hotspot after seeing signs of the ripple effect of house hunters who have been priced out of London.

    10:19: CHINA MOBILE

    China Mobile the nation's largest telecom provider, said net profit for the first nine months of 2014 fell 9.7% to 82.6 billion yuan (£8.38bn,$13.49bn) amid rising competition from rival carriers and Internet-based service providers.

    A row of terraced houses in south London

    Mortgage lending for the three months to the end of September was £55.5bn. That's 8% higher than the previous three months and 13% higher than the same period a year earlier. So, not a huge amount of evidence of a slowdown in the property market, really. Bank of England chief economist Andrew Haldane's comments that interest rates might not rise until after the general election may also mean people feel a little less nervous about taking out a mortgage. But then again, if stock markets continue to tumble then mortgage activity might slow as confidence evaporates. Serious question: Who'd be an economist?


    Mortgage lending in September stood at £17.8bn - 1% lower than August's £18bn figure, but still 10% higher than the £16.2bn advanced to mortgage borrowers in September 2013, the Council of Mortgage Lenders (CML) has said. The body which represents 95% of mortgage lenders in the UK reckons uncertainty about the timing of an interest rate rise by the Bank of England was one of the key factors in the slight slowdown in lending.

    09:35: ROYAL MAIL JOBS
    Royal Mail staff at the St. Rollox sorting office in Glasgow,

    Incidentally, Royal Mail has also started its annual recruitment drive to help with the Christmas post, saying 19,000 temporary jobs will be available. Now all we need is the first Christmas ads and John Lewis to put its Christmas decorations up in store, and we're all set for the traditional retail frenzy that embodies the spirit of the festive season. That's right, isn't it?

    AMAZON JOBS Via Twitter Ben Thompson Business correspondent, BBC News Channel

    tweets: "Amazon to create 13,000 seasonal jobs in run up to Christmas. On busiest day last year, customers ordered 4.1m items - 47 every second."

    09:07: SAP DOWNGRADE

    German software developer SAP has fallen 3.9% this morning in Frankfurt after letting on that 2014 profit will be lower than previously forecast. Services in the cloud are putting pressure on profits.

    08:50: FORD INVESTMENT Radio 5 live

    Ford is investing about £200m at its Dagenham plant creating about 300 jobs to make diesel engines. Mark Ovenden of Ford is on 5 live. Engines are Britain's strength in vehicle manufacture, he says.

    08:39: MARKET REPORT

    The FTSE 100 is behaving a bit oddly in early trading. It opened up 8 points this morning then promptly remembered the eurozone is teetering on the edge of a third crisis and there's less global economic growth out there and fell again. Now it's up 3 points again at 6313.64 . The situation is a bit worse for Germany's Dax - down 52 points to 8797.85 - and France's Cac-40 - down 23 points to 4010.12.

    08:28: TAX MARK

    SSE is touting its award of the new Fair Tax Mark, which has been set up to show companies are being open about what tax they pay. Other recipients include Go-Ahead Group , Midcounties Co-operative, Phone Co-op and Unity Trust Bank. Margaret Hodge, chair of parliament's Public Accounts Committee, said she hoped other companies would follow SSE's example.

    Computer generated image of the floating cycle route

    Is the floating bike path a sustainable solution or an expensive distraction? We think you probably just need to look at the picture (above) for the answer to that question. But if you really feel the need to read about one of the more outlandish proposals being considered by Mayor of London Boris Johnson then by all means take a look. Some have baulked at the £600m price tag. But no doubt the team behind the 'Thames Deckway' thought "Boris. Keen Cycler, loves things that float (think airports), it's bound to be a winner."


    Drugs firm Shire has announced that interim chief financial officer James Bowling has resigned after ten years with the firm. He is joining Severn Trent as CFO and will leave Shire at the end of March 2015. Shire saw more than 30% of its share value wiped out last week after the collapse of a £32bn takeover from US rival AbbVie. Shire will start the search for a new CFO immediately.

    The badge of Greene King brewers on a pub wall

    Spirit pub company, which runs about 750 pubs, says Greene King has made a better offer to take the company over. They would get 0.1322 Greene King shares per Spirit share and a cash payment of 8 pence, worth a total of about 109.5 pence. Spirit's board says it may recommend the offer once a few details have been ironed out.

    Chancellor of the Exchequer George Osborne

    Don't expect any traditional tax giveaways ahead of the general election. In a move akin to "good luck, there's no money left", Cabinet ministers have been warned by the Treasury that it is likely they will have to rein in their spending in the run-up to the election because of a shortfall in tax revenues and concerns about the global economy, the Financial Times has reported today. Treasury secretary Danny Alexander has told the Cabinet tax revenues are not recovering as quickly as the economy so he might have to impose new spending controls in the Autumn Statement. Yikes.

    07:21: BANK OF JAPAN

    Japan's central bank has maintained its economic assessment for eight of the country's nine regions in its quarterly report, saying they continue to recover. The north-eastern Tohoku region cut its assessment from July, to say that the recovery trend is slowing.

    07:07: IBM NEWS

    IBM says it will make a "major business announcement" today. Various newspapers including the Wall Street Journal think it will sell off its loss-making microchip-making business. IBM will pay Globalfoundries $1.5bn (£931m) to take the chip operations off its hands, says the WSJ.

    06:50: UK GROWTH BBC Radio 4

    Peter Spencer, economic adviser to the EY Item Club, tells the Today programme housing investment along with business investment has been responsible for "about half of the economic growth" we have see in the UK since the start of the recovery. But people are beginning to worry about global growth and the UK's economic outlook. Concerns about economic developments at home and abroad has meant there are already signs of "a return to caution by both borrowers and lenders in the mortgage market".


    Last week's stock market sell off is on the business agenda today. "Everyone was feeling nervous. We just need a very small straw to break the camel's back I think it was the Ebola virus," James Bevan chief investment officer at CCLA Investment Management tells the Today programme. "We had a lot of other things going on but I think Ebola was the thing that made investors say to themselves 'let's sit this one out'. There has been no real change in the hard economic data." He is worried about bond yields spiking "as they did in 1987" though.

    06:24: EUROZONE ECONOMY Radio 5 live
    Jose Manual Barroso

    Jose Manual Barroso, outgoing President of the European Commission, has told the BBC he doesn't think another recession in the eurozone is likely. Official statistics suggest a "weaker recovery than anticipated. Elmar Brok, a German member of the European Parliament is on Radio 5 live and says Britain should be "more positive towards the eurozone"

    06:13: INTERN PAY Radio 5 live

    Christian May from the Institute of Directors is on 5 live talking about employment reform, including reforms to how interns are paid, or otherwise. "It's worth considering it's unlikely to be a silver bullet," he says. There's a chance restrictions could be gamed to allow employers not to pay interns. While 25% of businesses have interns they don't pay, "in this day and age its getting difficult to justify having someone work for them and not paying them."

    06:03: ETHICAL INVESTMENTS Radio 5 live

    Justin Urquhart Stewart of 7 Investment Management is on 5 live talking about ethical investment. "It's very badly marketed so people don't understand it ," He says. But because such investments strip out companies such as tobacco, alcohol, arms and oil, returns can also be slim.

    06:01: Howard Mustoe Business reporter

    Good morning. Get in touch via email and twitter @BBCBusiness.

    06:00: Matthew West Business reporter

    Morning folks. It's a gloomy start to the day with the EY Item Club downgrading its 2015 UK economic growth forecast quite sharply this morning as a result of the global slowdown and uncertainty over interest rates. There's more housing market data out later and the Prime Minister is going to be pushing for more apprenticeships today too. We'll bring you more as it happens.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.