Taxpayers 'lost £1bn' on Royal Mail sale, MPs say

 
Post box, London The government may have undervalued Royal Mail shares to the tune of £1bn, the committee said.

Related Stories

Taxpayers may have lost out on about £1bn from the undervaluing of Royal Mail, a committee of MPs has said.

The government feared failure and acted on bad advice over the Royal Mail stock market flotation, reports the Business, Innovation and Skills select committee.

The Department for Business said the MPs' report contained "factual errors and misunderstandings".

Royal Mail shares were priced at 330p, but jumped as high as 618p per share, and now stand at around 473p.

Business Secretary Vince Cable told the BBC: "They now have the benefit of hindsight, which we didn't have at the time. We sold at a price that was regarded as the best that could be achieved in the context in which we sold it."

Business Secretary Vince Cable: ''The price of shares is very, very volatile''

He added: "The point we have stressed, and I've stressed over and again, that the price of shares is very, very volatile - these things go up and down and we've seen in the last few weeks the price of Royal Mail shares actually falling like a stone."

His department pointed out that taxpayers had made £2bn from the deal.

'Significant underestimate'

But in its scathing report the select committee said the shares had been undervalued and property owned by the Royal Mail had been mispriced when 60% of the company was floated in October.

A further 10% of shares were given to Royal Mail employees.

"We believe that fear of failure and poor quality advice led to a significant underestimate of the demand for Royal Mail shares," said Labour MP and committee chair Adrian Bailey.

Speaking to the BBC, Mr Bailey said: "I do think if any minister loses that sum of money to the public purse then they really should reconsider their position."

External adviser Lazard, plus co-ordinators UBS and Goldman Sachs oversaw the flotation.

Postal worker, Beeston, Nottingham

"Ultimately the blame must lie with the government. The buck stops with government," said Mr Bailey.

"But it's quite clear they were very badly advised."

Royal Mail

Last Updated at 03 Mar 2015, 08:03 ET Royal Mail twelve month chart
price change %
425.90 p +
+2.60
+
+0.61

In its defence, the Department for Business said: "The committee's views on the share price are based entirely on hindsight and ignore that we were selling 600 million shares.

"They found no evidence that the department or its advisers missed vital information prior to sale."

Future proceeds

The committee also said it was "disturbed" that the taxpayer may not have benefited from valuable assets included in the privatisation.

In particular it highlighted three sites in London which the National Audit Office (NAO) said had a hidden value of up to £830m.

George Osborne: "The sale of Royal Mail secured its future as a company"

According to the select committee, the NAO recommended that those assets should not be included in the privatisation or an arrangement should be made to claw back proceeds of any future sale of those properties.

"The government's inclusion of Royal Mail's 'surplus' assets in the sell-off, without the prospect of clawing back future proceeds, may also mean the taxpayer losing out once again," Mr Bailey said.

The committee also expressed concern about so-called preferred investors who received large blocks of shares, prior to the flotation.

Some were also advisers to the government over the share sale.

Sorting office, Altrincham

Lazard, UBS and Goldman Sachs all had Royal Mail shares allocated to separate parts of their businesses. Lazard and the banks made millions of pounds on the sale on behalf of clients.

"It's very important that when the government does sell off a government asset, it does so through a process that quite clearly demonstrates that nobody selling it, nobody advising it, has a conflict of interest," said Mr Bailey.

'No evidence'

Lazard & Co was paid £1.5m for advising the government. Lazard Asset Management (LAM), which was selected as one of the preferred bidders, made £8.4m for clients by selling shares shortly after the flotation. LAM itself made a profit of around £40,000 from the share sale.

However the Department for Business said: "There is no evidence that the government's independent adviser, Lazard, or any other bank involved in the sale, breached the Chinese walls that existed between different and unrelated parts of the business."

Shadow Business Secretary Umunna: "What we saw here was a first-class short-changing of the taxpayer"

Labour shadow business secretary Chuka Umunna said: "The business department did not attach appropriate value to Royal Mail when they were selling it and what this has resulted in is a first-class short-changing of the taxpayer to the tune of hundreds of millions of pounds.

"This is staggering incompetence on a grand scale by ministers."

BBC business editor Kamal Ahmed said: "If we go back to the run-in to the sale, this whole process was stalked by a fear of failure.

"The advisory banks have been criticised in the Business Select Committee report, but they were constantly urged to be cautious.

"There's only one thing worse I think for the government than the price going up as fast as it did and that would be if the price went down. That was the one thing that could not happen."

On Wednesday, the government announced there would be a review, led by former City minister Lord Myners, of how it handled stock market flotations.

The committee's report is the latest in a series of official criticisms of the sale, including by the National Audit Office and the Public Accounts Committee.

 

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    -9

    Comment number 1122.

    Whether it is the right amount or not the Government gained more that when it was in public ownership. Whatever it was sold for made money for the taxpayer which would never have been made without selling it. Whatever the price nothing was lost only gained.

  • rate this
    -13

    Comment number 1081.

    I just wonder what the comments would have been like if the company failed to sell with too few investors. There was a threat of strike action, Royal Mail was in need of being turned around. You don't shoot the shop keeper because the price of beans fell after the shop ran out, maybe we could have had more investment, but that happens as share prices rise through trading.

  • rate this
    +106

    Comment number 221.

    This is yet another money for mates rip off that is so blatantly the hallmark of this government. They don't even seem to be bothering to try to hide it anymore. The most annoying thing about it is that there seems to be no recourse, and to be honest who believes Labour would be any different.
    This countries leadership is a fiasco.

  • rate this
    +137

    Comment number 124.

    £1Bn lost? Or £1Bn made for their mates in the city?
    It appears they got the value of RM around 25-30% wrong. How much confidence does that give us in their estimates for any of their other schemes?

  • rate this
    -35

    Comment number 105.

    Ah, hindsight. So, is this wondrous committee of MPs so wise that they issued better advice at the time? I suspect not. And would they have nominated a much higher price, and put their jobs and personal wealth on it?

    No, I don't think so.

    Such a marvellous, clever thing to be so very, very wise - after the event

 

Comments 5 of 8

 

More Business stories

RSS

Business Live

  1.  
    13:15: Oil prices
    Oil flare

    Brent crude is up $1.60 a barrel to $61.18 on the back of fighting in Libya, stronger stock markets and firm demand. The gap between Brent and US oil narrowed slightly as West Texas Intermediate rose $1 to $50.59 a barrel.

     
  2.  
    12:58: Twitter results
    Lilly Allen

    Given our celebs' love of tweeting what they had for breakfast and other life-changing events, perhaps it's no surprise that Britain is Twitter's biggest market outside the US. Its UK revenues more than doubled last year to $140.3m (£91.3m), as the company strives to boost profits, the Evening Standard reports. However, Twitter still made an annual loss of $577m. Fact of the Day: Lilly Allen (pictured) has more than 5m followers on Twitter.

     
  3.  
    Treasury Committee Via Twitter Mark Broad Economics reporter, BBC News

    Carney criticises Lord Grabiner's manner in evidence to Select Comm - Grabiner was author of the report into FX conduct of Bank of England.

     
  4.  
    12:30: Barclays results
    Frances O'Grady

    TUC general secretary Frances O'Grady is not impressed with Antony Jenkins' bumper pay package for 2014, particularly given the provisions it has made for potential fines. "It is hard to have a positive view of any organisation that pays its boss £5.5m in a single year - a sum that would take a full-time worker on the minimum wage 465 years to earn," she says.

     
  5.  
    12:13: Market update

    After earlier gains, the FTSE 100 share index in London fell 6.39 points to 6,934.25. In Frankfurt, the Dax has followed the same pattern, down 7.4 points to 11,402.9. The Cac in Paris slipped just under 3 points to 4,914.4.

    • Barclays dips 3.3% after unveiling more provisions for PPI and rate-fixing investigations
    • Tullow Oil bounced back 4% after falling 7.7% yesterday on concerns that a boundary dispute between Ivory Coast and Ghana could delay a project off west Africa
     
  6.  
    PPI Via Email Kevin Peachey Personal finance reporter, BBC News

    Barclays today became the latest bank to add to the amount of money set aside for PPI mis-selling cases. The total bill for the top five banks in the UK is now an eye-watering £24.4bn, says consumer group Which?.

     
  7.  
    Fiat-Chrysler Via Email Russell Hotten Business reporter, BBC News
    Sergio Marchionne

    Fiat-Chrysler's boss thinks it is great that Google and Apple are moving into car technology - but it also makes him feel uncomfortable. Sergio Marchionne (pictured here with a Ferrari) said at the Geneva motor show that the industry needs "disruptive interlopers. It's a good thing. But when you're the guy whose life is being disrupted, it's not necessarily a good feeling."

     
  8.  
    11:29: Australian rates
    Sydney

    The Reserve Bank of Australia left interest rates unchanged at 2.25% today after cutting by a quarter of a point in January for the first time in 18 months. Further easing remains on the cards to help drive down the Aussie dollar and drive growth. Greg Gibbs, an RBS analyst, said "unusually clear guidance" meant the RBA is keen to keep a lid on the dollar.

     
  9.  
    Geneva motor show Via Email Russell Hotten Business reporter

    Aston Martin unveils plans to broaden its range of cars to attract younger and female buyers. New sports cars, a four-seater - and a small SUV - are all in the pipeline. The British carmaker may be synonymous with James Bond, but its buyers are frequently middle-aged enthusiasts. "The brand has to be relevant," says boss Andy Palmer. "Less dependent on a narrow portfolio and one type of customer."

     
  10.  
    11:01: Treasury Committee
    Carney

    Mr Habgood says he never thought that the terms of reference for Lord Grabiner's inquiry were restrictive. Mr Carney agrees that the barrister was able to investigate freely and had unlimited resources to do so.

     
  11.  
    10:49: Treasury Committee

    The Bank's internal investigation, led by barrister Lord Grabiner, began in March 2014 following allegations that a senior member of staff had been told of "attempts to move" the foreign exchange market. It resulted in the Bank's chief foreign currency exchange dealer, Martin Mallett, being dismissed in November. Mr Carney told MPs that Mr Mallett was aware of possible misconduct into the forex market but failed to share that information with his superiors: "He did not escalate these issues."

     
  12.  
    10:43: M&A statistics

    The Office for National Statistics says the number of mergers and acquisitions involving UK companies fell to the lowest figure since 1987 last year. "The downward trend of domestic M&A may be a result of UK political instability as UK businesses experienced uncertainties about the outcome of the Scottish referendum, held in September 2014, and the impending general election," the ONS said.

     
  13.  
    10:27: Treasury Committee

    Bank of England governor Mark Carney and chairman of its court, Anthony Habgood, are giving evidence to MPs on the Treasury committee about the Bank's own foreign exchange market investigation. Labour MP John Mann asks how deeply ingrained the concept of a "nod and a wink culture" is at the Bank. Mr Habgood admits there is a need to professionalise the working practices.

     
  14.  
    Via Email Beef ban Simon Atkinson Editor, India Business Report
    Water buffalo

    Bad news for beef farmers - and for those who like a burger. Cows are holy to Hindus - slaughtering the animals was already illegal. But in Maharashtra state, that ban has now been extended to bulls and bullocks. The beef industry here says thousands of jobs in will be lost. Water buffalo (like the pair above) survive though - or rather - don't …. so the beef substitute will still be available.

     
  15.  
    09:54: China trade Radio 5 live
    Shoes

    Parcelforce Worldwide's ales and marketing director, Helen Wylde, was on 5 live earlier talking about sales to China from the UK. Baby milk, children's clothing, shoes, toys, educational books from Britain all sell well in China. The most odd? Bicycles. Chinese buyers like trusted brands.

     
  16.  
    09:37: Construction data
    Pinnacle

    The purchasing managers' index for the construction sector rose 1 point to 60.1 in February, defying expectations for a fall as growth picked up across the housing, commercial and civil engineering sectors. Tim Moore, senior economist at Markit, says some construction companies think the general election outcome could prove a "temporary bump in the road" for new work.

     
  17.  
    09:21: Paddy Power results
    World Cup

    It's a lucky day for Paddy Power investors after the company said it will return €392m cash to shareholders after failing to find any potential bid targets. Operating profit jumped by a better than expected 19% to €163.8m for 2014, helped by last summer's World Cup, which was won by Germany.

     
  18.  
    Barclays results Via Email Chirantan Barua Bernstein Research

    Dividends were held flat for the fourth quarter at 3.5p as compared to last year and came in lower than consensus at 3.7p. Non-progressive nature will be taken as marginally negative and also highlights that the bank's key focus continues to be capital build.

     
  19.  
    08:53: Business Matters World Service
    Royal Enfield

    Can India's cities become cleaner and greener? Business Matters on the World Service is live from Chennai all week. In the first programme Fergus Nicoll asks whether the infrastructure is fit for purpose - and visits an Indian success story with its roots in Britain: Royal Enfield motorcycles. Listen here.

     
  20.  
    08:41: Barclays
    Barclays shares

    Shares in Barclays are down 2.3%, or 6.15p, at 256.6p in morning trading in London. The stock has not moved much over the past 12 months given that it's just 8.7p higher than the price on March 4 last year.

     
  21.  
    08:27: Ford BBC Radio 4
    Ford Mustang

    Jim Farley, Ford's European president, tells presenter Simon Jack on Today that he hopes Britain does not leave the European Union. One in three engines made by the company comes from the UK, which he described as the "centrepiece" of its global enterprise. Asked about the Russian market, Farley said Ford believed in it in the long term but admitted that some short-term adjustments were required because of the volatile economy.

     
  22.  
    08:14: Taylor Wimpey results
    house

    If you're a house builder and you're not making piles of money, then something is very wrong. Fortunately for Taylor Wimpey that is not the case. Annual pre-tax profits are up two thirds to £450m before one-off deductions as 12,454 homes were completed across the UK - 758 more than in 2013 - with an 11.5% rise in average selling price to £213,000.

     
  23.  
    07:56: Barclays results
    Barclays

    While Mr Jenkins takes his first annual bonus with Barclays, the overall 2014 bonus pool for the bank is down £520m to £1.86bn. Most of the total - £1.05bn - goes to the investment bank. Its capital ratio, a measure of strength against unexpected losses, is up to 10.3% from 9.1%.

     
  24.  
    07:44: Barclays results BBC Radio 4
    Jenkins

    Barclays chief Antony Jenkins is on Today. The bank is the healthiest it has been since the financial crisis, he says. Changing culture at the bank takes a long time, Mr Jenkins adds, but the "vast majority" of his 130,000 bankers "want to do the right thing". He is taking a bonus of £1.1m after the "huge amount of progress" the bank has made. Asked about the topic du jour, Mr Jenkins says he pays all his tax in the UK and as a US green card holder.

     
  25.  
    07:37: Barclays results

    Barclays wrote down the value of its education, social housing and local authority loan portfolio by £935m. Last year the portfolio was valued at just less than £16bn, but at that time, the lender reclassified the loans as "level 3" assets. That's City-speak for loans you cannot value easily because they don't sell very often.

     
  26.  
    07:24: Direct Line results
    Direct Line website

    It's been a good 2014 for Direct Line, with pre-tax profits up 12% to £456.8m and a windfall of £430m from the sale of its international business. Shareholders will pocket total dividends of 27.2p per share, up from 20.6p in 2013. Harvey Keitel probably pocked a pretty penny too for featuring in its TV ads.

     
  27.  
    07:16: Barclays results

    Antony Jenkins will take his first bonus as chief executive of the lender: £1.1m. The bank also said it would increase its provision for payment protection insurance (PPI) by £200m for the last three months of 2014, taking the year's total to £1.1bn. Excluding these provisions and other things the bank considers one-offs, pre-tax profit rose 12% to £5.5bn. But including the nasties, the figure sank 21% to £2.26bn.

     
  28.  
    07:03: Barclays results
    bank

    Barclays have posted their 2014 results. They have set aside an extra £750m after those investigations for foreign exchange manipulation, taking the pot to £1.25bn.

     
  29.  
    06:53: Barclays BBC Radio 4
    Barclays

    Chris Wheeler, of Atlantic Equities, has also popped up on Today. He tells Simon Jack that Barclays is doing only "averagely well ... it's still work in progress". He expects pre-tax profits to be about £5.2bn when the bank reports its annual results at 7am.

     
  30.  
    06:35: Markets performance Radio 5 live

    Justin Urquhart-Stewart of 7 Investments is still on 5 live. "We are dealing with companies that make a profit and make things," he says of the Nasdaq's rally. The dotcom boom was based on companies that failed to make money, although "we have to be wary" because markets in 2015 are gorged on cheap money and cheap debt.

     
  31.  
    06:23: Barclays results Radio 5 live

    Chris Wheeler of Atlantic Equities is talking about Barclays. £5.2bn pretax profits are on the cards for the bank in its annual results, he estimates - a tad ahead of last year's result. However, "it's the return on equity that counts", he says. The bank is struggling to make 10%, which for a high-risk endeavour like banking is not where you want that figure, Wheeler adds. Results come at 07:00.

     
  32.  
    06:11: Markets performance Radio 5 live

    Justin Urquhart-Stewart of 7 Investments is on 5 live as the markets guest. "You have a global economy in pretty good shape and in the eurozone some better figures," he says, following soaring US markets. The FTSE 100 may grow further if there's better sentiment from China, he adds.

     
  33.  
    06:02: Mobile World Congress Radio 5 live
    Kazuo

    Rory Cellan-Jones, technology correspondent, is in Barcelona at the Mobile World Congress. Sony chief executive Kazuo Hirai is "making some tough decisions" and focusing Sony on things like films and games and camera technology: the areas that make money, he tells 5 live. Like many companies, it's finding mobile phones a tricky market.

     
  34.  
    06:00: Chris Johnston Business reporter

    Get in touch via email bizlivepage@bbc.co.uk or on twitter @BBCBusiness

     
  35.  
    06:00: Howard Mustoe Business reporter

    Good morning! US stocks hit record levels, with both the Dow Jones and the S&P 500 closing at all-time highs and the Nasdaq breaking the 5,000 barrier for the first time in 15 years. Is that going to last? Stay tuned for more.

     

Features

  • Mukesh SinghNo remorse

    Delhi bus rapist says victim shouldn't have fought back


  • Aimen DeanI spied

    The founder member of al-Qaeda who worked for MI6


  • Before and after shotsPerfect body

    Just how reliable are 'before and after' photos?


  • A man shutting his eyes tightlyStrange light show

    What do you see when you close your eyes?


Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.