Taxpayers 'lost £1bn' on Royal Mail sale, MPs say

 
Post box, London The government may have undervalued Royal Mail shares to the tune of £1bn, the committee said.

Related Stories

Taxpayers may have lost out on about £1bn from the undervaluing of Royal Mail, a committee of MPs has said.

The government feared failure and acted on bad advice over the Royal Mail stock market flotation, reports the Business, Innovation and Skills select committee.

The Department for Business said the MPs' report contained "factual errors and misunderstandings".

Royal Mail shares were priced at 330p, but jumped as high as 618p per share, and now stand at around 473p.

Business Secretary Vince Cable told the BBC: "They now have the benefit of hindsight, which we didn't have at the time. We sold at a price that was regarded as the best that could be achieved in the context in which we sold it."

Business Secretary Vince Cable: ''The price of shares is very, very volatile''

He added: "The point we have stressed, and I've stressed over and again, that the price of shares is very, very volatile - these things go up and down and we've seen in the last few weeks the price of Royal Mail shares actually falling like a stone."

His department pointed out that taxpayers had made £2bn from the deal.

'Significant underestimate'

But in its scathing report the select committee said the shares had been undervalued and property owned by the Royal Mail had been mispriced when 60% of the company was floated in October.

A further 10% of shares were given to Royal Mail employees.

"We believe that fear of failure and poor quality advice led to a significant underestimate of the demand for Royal Mail shares," said Labour MP and committee chair Adrian Bailey.

Speaking to the BBC, Mr Bailey said: "I do think if any minister loses that sum of money to the public purse then they really should reconsider their position."

External adviser Lazard, plus co-ordinators UBS and Goldman Sachs oversaw the flotation.

Postal worker, Beeston, Nottingham

"Ultimately the blame must lie with the government. The buck stops with government," said Mr Bailey.

"But it's quite clear they were very badly advised."

Royal Mail

Last Updated at 18 Sep 2014, 11:36 ET Royal Mail twelve month chart
price change %
434.20 p
0.00
0.00

In its defence, the Department for Business said: "The committee's views on the share price are based entirely on hindsight and ignore that we were selling 600 million shares.

"They found no evidence that the department or its advisers missed vital information prior to sale."

Future proceeds

The committee also said it was "disturbed" that the taxpayer may not have benefited from valuable assets included in the privatisation.

In particular it highlighted three sites in London which the National Audit Office (NAO) said had a hidden value of up to £830m.

George Osborne: "The sale of Royal Mail secured its future as a company"

According to the select committee, the NAO recommended that those assets should not be included in the privatisation or an arrangement should be made to claw back proceeds of any future sale of those properties.

"The government's inclusion of Royal Mail's 'surplus' assets in the sell-off, without the prospect of clawing back future proceeds, may also mean the taxpayer losing out once again," Mr Bailey said.

The committee also expressed concern about so-called preferred investors who received large blocks of shares, prior to the flotation.

Some were also advisers to the government over the share sale.

Sorting office, Altrincham

Lazard, UBS and Goldman Sachs all had Royal Mail shares allocated to separate parts of their businesses. Lazard and the banks made millions of pounds on the sale on behalf of clients.

"It's very important that when the government does sell off a government asset, it does so through a process that quite clearly demonstrates that nobody selling it, nobody advising it, has a conflict of interest," said Mr Bailey.

'No evidence'

Lazard & Co was paid £1.5m for advising the government. Lazard Asset Management (LAM), which was selected as one of the preferred bidders, made £8.4m for clients by selling shares shortly after the flotation. LAM itself made a profit of around £40,000 from the share sale.

However the Department for Business said: "There is no evidence that the government's independent adviser, Lazard, or any other bank involved in the sale, breached the Chinese walls that existed between different and unrelated parts of the business."

Shadow Business Secretary Umunna: "What we saw here was a first-class short-changing of the taxpayer"

Labour shadow business secretary Chuka Umunna said: "The business department did not attach appropriate value to Royal Mail when they were selling it and what this has resulted in is a first-class short-changing of the taxpayer to the tune of hundreds of millions of pounds.

"This is staggering incompetence on a grand scale by ministers."

BBC business editor Kamal Ahmed said: "If we go back to the run-in to the sale, this whole process was stalked by a fear of failure.

"The advisory banks have been criticised in the Business Select Committee report, but they were constantly urged to be cautious.

"There's only one thing worse I think for the government than the price going up as fast as it did and that would be if the price went down. That was the one thing that could not happen."

On Wednesday, the government announced there would be a review, led by former City minister Lord Myners, of how it handled stock market flotations.

The committee's report is the latest in a series of official criticisms of the sale, including by the National Audit Office and the Public Accounts Committee.

 

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    -9

    Comment number 1122.

    Whether it is the right amount or not the Government gained more that when it was in public ownership. Whatever it was sold for made money for the taxpayer which would never have been made without selling it. Whatever the price nothing was lost only gained.

  • rate this
    -13

    Comment number 1081.

    I just wonder what the comments would have been like if the company failed to sell with too few investors. There was a threat of strike action, Royal Mail was in need of being turned around. You don't shoot the shop keeper because the price of beans fell after the shop ran out, maybe we could have had more investment, but that happens as share prices rise through trading.

  • rate this
    +106

    Comment number 221.

    This is yet another money for mates rip off that is so blatantly the hallmark of this government. They don't even seem to be bothering to try to hide it anymore. The most annoying thing about it is that there seems to be no recourse, and to be honest who believes Labour would be any different.
    This countries leadership is a fiasco.

  • rate this
    +137

    Comment number 124.

    £1Bn lost? Or £1Bn made for their mates in the city?
    It appears they got the value of RM around 25-30% wrong. How much confidence does that give us in their estimates for any of their other schemes?

  • rate this
    -35

    Comment number 105.

    Ah, hindsight. So, is this wondrous committee of MPs so wise that they issued better advice at the time? I suspect not. And would they have nominated a much higher price, and put their jobs and personal wealth on it?

    No, I don't think so.

    Such a marvellous, clever thing to be so very, very wise - after the event

 

Comments 5 of 8

 

More Business stories

RSS

BBC Business Live

  1.  
    INTEREST RATES 08:10: Radio 5 live

    "The odds of a February rate rise should be pretty high now," says Ewen Cameron Watt, chief investment strategist at BlackRock Investment Institute on Radio 5 live. He thinks interest rates could move higher as early as November. A rate rise would have been "off the cards" for most of next year, if there had been a "Yes" vote, he says.

     
  2.  
    LLOYDS REACTION 08:07:

    Lloyds Banking Group has made this rather nebulous statement: "Lloyds Banking Group has maintained a neutral stance in this debate as we believe the decision was to be solely a matter for the people of Scotland. The group is proud of its strong Scottish heritage and remains committed to having a significant presence in Scotland. We remain fully focused on supporting households and businesses in Scotland as well as right across the rest of the UK."

     
  3.  
    STANDARD LIFE REACTION 07:55:

    We had to call Standard Life to find out what they actually meant. The insurer told us: "We've no plans to move any of our operations."

     
  4.  
    STANDARD LIFE REACTION 07:54:

    Standard Life, one of the companies that threatened to partially decamp from Scotland in the event of a Yes vote, now says: "We will consider the implications of any changes for our customers and other stakeholders in our business to ensure their interests are represented and protected." It adds it is "now important that we all move forward with respect and work together constructively in the best interests of Scotland and the UK". So that's clear then.

     
  5.  
    SCOTLAND POWERS 07:42:
    Prime Minister Cameron

    Prime Minister David Cameron has promised to come up with plans for new Scottish powers on tax, spending and welfare. The government is aiming to get an agreement by November. The BBC's personal finance reporter Brian Milligan is having a closer look at what that could mean.

     
  6.  
    MARKET REACTION 07:33: BBC Radio 4

    Anne Richards, chief investment officer at Aberdeen Asset Management tells Today: "A very close vote would have been a difficult one for markets." She adds: "I think we have had a reconnection between the political establishment, business and the electorate. And it would be good to see that momentum maintained going into the general election."

     
  7.  
    07:29: HEADLINES
     
  8.  
    ALIBABA SHARE SALE 07:29:
    Alibaba

    Away from Scotland's vote, shares in Alibaba start trading in New York later today. It has raised $21.8bn (£13.2bn) in one of the biggest ever stock market debuts. It is likely to use the money to expand in the US where it has a very low profile. A survey by Reuters showed that 88% of Americans had never heard of China's biggest internet firm.

     
  9.  
    RBS STATEMENT 07:21: Kamal Ahmed BBC Business editor

    Royal Bank of Scotland has given a statement to the BBC's business editor, Kamal Ahmed, it says: "The announcement we made about moving our registered head office to England was part of a contingency plan to ensure certainty and stability for our customers, staff and shareholders should there be a 'Yes' vote. That contingency plan is no longer required. Following the result it is business as usual for all our customers across the UK and RBS."

     
  10.  
    REFERENDUM REACTION 07:14: BBC Radio 4

    Patrick MacDonald former boss of John Menzies, tells the Today programme the debate over Scottish independence has changed the country forever. "Things will never be the same again," he says. There is now "a need to reform our 300 year old constitution" and the country also needs to work at reconciliation to "make sure businesses stay in Scotland".

     
  11.  
    RBS 07:08: BBC Radio 4

    A little more from Mike Amey on the referendum result. He tells Today: " I suspect there's a very large sigh of relief at RBS [over the result] They don't have to worry about where they were going to be based and how they were going to conduct their future business."

     
  12.  
    MARKET REACTION 07:07: BBC Radio 4

    Mike Amey, managing director and portfolio manage at bond trader PIMCO tells Today he expects the markets to open higher as a result of the Scottish referendum result. "It will be back to the data for our traders and what the Bank of England will do [on interest rates]."

     
  13.  
    MARKET REACTION 06:49: Radio 5 live

    Adam Parsons is in the City at the offices of stockbrokers IG with their chief market strategist, Brenda Kelly. She says the opening of the FTSE 100 might be quite as dramatic as some expect. That's because markets have been predicting this outcome over the last few days. However, she says, it could "break through 6930" which would be a record high.

     
  14.  
    06:42: Via Email Linda Yueh Chief business correspondent

    There are other uncertainties now for Scotland after this vote. But, for markets at least, the big uncertainty that could have lingered for a year and half over the currency and the economy is lessened and sentiment is positive as a result.

     
  15.  
    06:33: Louise Cooper, CooperCity market blog

    "So it's up up and away this morning, the question is how far does it [the pound] go before reality sets back in and other political fears begin to dominate: The rows in Westminster over devolution max which has been promised. The General Election and the UK referendum on EU membership. Party conferences season resumes next week so there will be plenty of headlines to be written about the next set of political risks."

     
  16.  
    CITY REACTION 06:27:

    The Lord Mayor of the City of London, Fiona Woolf has welcomed the outcome of the Scottish referendum. "The proposed enhanced devolution that Scotland will experience while remaining in the UK will enable its national spirit to thrive while our entwined economies and business communities prosper together," the Lord Mayor said.

     
  17.  
    YES CAMPAIGN CONCEDES 06:23: BBC Radio 4
    Scottish first minister Alex Slamond

    Scotland's first minister Alex Salmond has hailed 1.6 million votes for independence. He concedes that "we now know there is going to be a majority for the "No" campaign". Scotland has, by majority at this stage, voted not to become an independent country," he adds. He expects devolution promises to be honoured with "rapid force".

     
  18.  
    ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND Via Email Kamal Ahmed BBC Business editor

    With No confirmed as the winner in the referendum, we can expect the Royal Bank of Scotland to say there is now no need to move domicile to London. The bank had prepared for a "Yes" vote by saying last week that it would move its headquarters from Edinburgh. I wouldn't be surprised if Ross McEwan, the chief executive, re-iterated the bank's commitment to Scotland. I am sure RBS's executives are relieved that the upheaval of independence will now not happen.

     
  19.  
    POUND STRENGTHENS 06:12:

    A decisive win for the No campaign could lead to big spike in the Pound. Jeremy Cook, economist at World First says. The obvious risk to the currency markets was a Yes, and that would have caused a big sell off. Now the markets will go back to concentrating on the fundamentals of the UK economy," he adds.

     
  20.  
    SCOTLAND INVESTMENT 06:01:

    Simon Walker, director general of business group the Institute of Directors has given an interview to the BBC. He says he thinks the government will now give the green light to investment projects that had been previously held up because of the uncertainty caused by the independence referendum. He adds the ending of that uncertainty will be positive for business.

     
  21.  
    POUND STRENGTHENS 05:54:
    pound versus dollar

    This chart shows the pound against the dollar over the last month. You can see it dipped to a low of $1.6071 on 10 September. That was after a poll in the Sunday Times showed a lead for the "No" campaign. It is now trading at $1.65. That's a move of 5 cents which is pretty big over two weeks.

     
  22.  
    MARKET UPDATE 05:47: BBC Radio 4

    Asian markets are up nearly 2% overnight BBC business correspondent Linda Yueh, tells Today. The market indications are that the FTSE 100 will open 0.7% higher. That's not exactly a surge but it is a positive reaction.

     
  23.  
    BANK OF ENGLAND 05:42: BBC Radio 4

    Justin Rowlatt is down at the Bank of England for BBC Radio 4's Today programme: He says the lights are on and staff are busy working inside. Although perhaps not quite as frantically as if Scotland was looking on course to vote Yes in the referendum. Bank governor Mark Carney cut short a meeting to fly home overnight. "He may have had a wasted trip," Justin says.

     
  24.  
    POUND STRENGTHENS 05:36:
    Pound dollar

    This chart shows how the pound has faired against the dollar since the polls closed in Scotland on Thursday evening. As you can see it's strengthened from a low of $1.63 to above $1.65, that's its highest point since the start of the month. In currency market terms it's also a huge move in a short space of time.

     
  25.  
    05:30: Ben Morris Business Reporter

    The pound has bounded higher overnight in reaction to the Scotland vote. More reaction through the morning. Stay with us.

     
  26.  
    05:30: Matthew West Business Reporter

    Morning folks. It looks like - with 26 of 32 local authorities now having declared the result of their ballots- that the No campaign is on course to win the Scottish independence referendum. We'll bring you all the reaction from the financial markets and the business community as it comes in. As always if you want to get in touch you can email us at bizlivepage@bbc.co.uk or tweet us @bbcbusiness.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.