Indonesia's presidential elections: What's at stake?

Indonesian women buying food at stall, in headscarves What's on the menu for Indonesian voters in this month's election?

The world's third largest democracy, Indonesia, is going to the polls on 9 July. These presidential elections could determine whether the world's fourth most populous nation will continue to grow in a "virtuous circle" or end up spiralling downwards in a "vicious circle".

A virtuous circle is when a country grows and accumulates savings that become investment funds which boost capital and growth. More growth means more income and savings, which in turn means more capital that supports growth.

The opposite of this is a vicious circle. That happens when a country is poor, and it doesn't generate enough money for savings, since most income is consumed. Lacking funds for investment, capital can't be accumulated and growth is slow. Slow growth means poor income growth and therefore few funds for saving and thus not much more investment and growth.

Construction worker up a building Indonesia hopes to construct the kind of economy that will spiral upwards

The key is whether Indonesia can transform its economic growth from one that is driven by the boom in commodity prices into one based on the sustainable expansion of its new middle class. In other words, if the virtuous circle was kick-started by the global commodity boom, then can it be sustained once that boom ends? The danger is that Indonesia could fall into a vicious circle. After all, half of all households are still clustered around the poverty line, so there is a risk of a lack of savings for investment.

Linda Yueh reports on how economic growth has become a key issue in Indonesia's presidential race

As Indonesia's finance minister Muhamad Chatib Basri told me, Indonesia needs to grow by 7% to reduce poverty and create jobs. But, that requires investment to be 37% of GDP. National savings stand at (a pretty impressive) 32% of GDP, so the difference must come from foreign investment.

Attracting foreign investment equivalent to five percentage points of GDP requires getting the basic infrastructure right.

Hot potato

As I said in my blog on Monday, traffic jams in Jakarta alone are estimated to cost a sizeable 0.6% of Indonesia's GDP.

But fuel is cheap. A litre of petrol costs just $0.50 or 30 pence. That's because 27% of the 2014 budget is spent on fuel subsidies. The bill for that is 210.73 trillion rupiah ($18.2bn), which is more than the 206 trillion rupiah intended for all capital expenditure, including spending on improving infrastructure.

It is a political hot potato, as raising fuel costs would add to inflation and squeeze incomes for an emerging economy with a newly formed middle class.

But both presidential contenders have vowed to cut the subsidy.

Joko "Jokowi" Widodo has vowed to eliminate it, while Prabowo Subianto - an ex-general and son-in-law of former Indonesian dictator Suharto - would reduce it.

Indonesian salt workers pushing bags of salt on bicycles, reflection in water Time for Indonesians to reflect on what they want for the future

Of course, the money spent on fuel subsidies is not the only constraint. Indonesia struggles with corruption and getting the business environment right.

But, if it can succeed with these basics, then it has a huge potential domestic market of nearly 240 million people. That's about the size of the US in 1980, when it was the main engine of global economic growth.

Driving the whole world economy would be hard for Indonesia to achieve. But, if foreign investment could be encouraged to continue to pour into the country, even with the end of the commodity boom, and was invested in consumer goods and production, then that could provide much-needed investment funds and be the catalyst to maintain the virtuous circle.

Otherwise, a shortfall in investment and savings could mean slower growth that plunges households back into poverty. And Indonesia could wind up in a vicious, rather than virtuous, circle.

Getting the policies right on the business climate will be crucial for the country. There's a lot at stake with the upcoming presidential elections.

Linda Yueh Article written by Linda Yueh Linda Yueh Chief business correspondent

The Bank of England's theory of everything

Setting interest rates is not the only thing the Bank of England focuses on anymore. But what does the newly expanded powers of the central bank mean for rates?

Read full article

More on This Story

More from Linda


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 10.

    This is a failed country that is still far way from being a civilised place.

    Until this nation learns how Malaysia respects and appreciates the hard-working minority the Chinese who contribute more than 70% of her GDP making Malaysia as one of successful countries in the region, this nation has no hope but a poor & dump place for extremists.

  • rate this

    Comment number 9.

    The virtuous/vicious circle model is overly simplistic.What's more important is whether Indonesia is producing high value products and services or just selling cheap labor like banana republics sell raw materials.My guess, this is what's largely happening as the cost of labor rises in China and it becomes more militarily aggressive investors needing cheap labor with no regulations look elsewhere.

  • rate this

    Comment number 8.

    Investors will follow their nose whenever and wherever there is opportunity to make money. In the US one can set up a business within hours and ...the business is running. This includes entity selection and registration, business license number, tax ID number all the way to the bank account set up. In Indonesia it can take as long as 6 months to accomplish the above and ungodly grease money.

  • rate this

    Comment number 7.

    I've visited a small part of Indonesia a few times and the contrasts are interesting. International companies build world class manufacturing centres, but I've also seen 3 kids balanced on a plank lashed to the back of a moped as Mum does her best to transport the whole family cheaply. As far as I can Indonesians work diligently for long hours without losing a sense of fun and deserve a break.

  • rate this

    Comment number 6.

    "so the difference must come from foreign investment."

    Well, provided Indonesia does not have a curency peg or similar, the govt can simply expand it's deficit to meet most of that difference.


Comments 5 of 10



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.