Are Europe's banks being prosecuted - or persecuted?

Sudanese rebel fighter and flames Terrorism in Sudan in 2004: US sanctions on the country imposed in the 1990s were broken by BNP Paribas

Related Stories

Even BNP Paribas cannot shrug off a $9bn (£5.1bn) fine.

The bank is the fourth biggest by assets in the world and has been found guilty of violating US economic sanctions against Sudan, Iran and Cuba.

It had repeatedly protested that it did not violate any European law, but US prosecutors say that is beside the point.

BNP Paribas operates in the US through Bank of the West and First Hawaiian Bank, and is therefore bound by US law.

It is not the first to fall foul of the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) that prohibits trading with sanctioned governments.

HSBC, Standard Chartered, ING, Barclays, Credit Suisse and Lloyds have all been hit with fines for violations since 2009.

It's not gone unnoticed that they are all European banks.

And the penalties are getting bigger.

Further inquiries

Biggest fines for European banks by US regulators

Bank Fine Reason

Credit Suisse

$2.6bn (£1.5bn)

Tax evasion


$1.9bn (£1.1bn)

Money laundering


$1.2bn* (£702m)

Libor manipulation


$780m (£456m)

Tax evasion


$740m** (£433m)

Libor manipulation

Standard Chartered

$674m (£394m)

Violating US sanctions


$619m (£362m)

Violating US sanctions

*Does not include UK FCA fine or Swiss fine.

**Does not include UK FCA or Dutch fine.

Source: DOJ, Securities & Exchange Commission

Now other European banks fear this latest fine shows American prosecutors are targeting them with increasing aggression.

Commerzbank of Germany, Credit Agricole and Societe Generale of France and Unicredit of Italy are all under investigation over suspected sanctions violations or money laundering.

Deutsche Bank faces investigations into the rigging of interest rates and foreign exchange manipulation.

Although it says it does not believe it has violated US laws, it is raising $11.6bn in extra capital, partly as a cushion against any future legal costs.

John Raymond, senior analyst of European banks at CreditSights Research, says: "The European banks are worried.

"You have to remember they are undergoing stress tests and the possibility that they might receive heavy fines means the tests may demand they have extra capital to meet those fines."

Mood change

However, the truth is the US authorities are still fining American banks far more than European ones.

A Financial Times study in March of 200 fines and restitutions since 2007, showed that of a total of $99.5bn in penalties, only $15.5bn came from foreign banks.

US Attorney General Eric Holder US Attorney General Eric Holder: "There is no such thing as too big to jail."

In fact there is a pattern to the prosecutions.

The European banks have hit the headlines with their sanction-breaking activities and tax evasion for which they have received fines.

The Americans have been have been forced to pay fines and compensation for issues over mortgage-backed securities and home loan fraud where victims have had to be compensated.

But both European and American banks have fallen victim to a change in mood among the US authorities.

Over the past few years many believed the Department of Justice (DoJ) had gone soft on big banks.

In March last year, US Attorney General Eric Holder seemed to confirm this to the Senate Judiciary Committee.

He said: "I am concerned that the size of some of these institutions becomes so large that it does become difficult for us to prosecute them when we are hit with indications... it will have a negative impact on the national economy, perhaps even the world economy."

French politicians were swift to exploit this, with the finance minister and the governor of the bank of France publicly stating that a massive fine would cripple BNP Paribas' lending ability and slow down lending worldwide.

But Mr Holder has been back on the offensive. Last month on the Department of Justice's website he insisted: "There is no such thing as too big to jail. To be clear: no individual or company, no matter how large or how profitable, is above the law."

Benjamin Lawsky New York State's first Superintendent of Financial Services Benjamin Lawsky - a force to be reckoned with as New York State's most senior financial regulator

And then there is Benjamin Lawsky.

He is the 44-year-old superintendent of New York State's Department of Financial Services (DFS).

The DFS cannot criminally charge a bank or individuals, but Mr Lawsky has been loud and influential in his demand for accountability from the banks.

It is thought the DFS's own investigation into Credit Suisse in March pressurised it into pleading guilty to aiding tax evasion and paying penalties of $2.6bn just two months later.

Back in 2012, he forced Standard Chartered to a settlement by the radical measure of threatening to withdraw its banking licence.

Known by Le Temps newspaper in France as "Le Bete-Noire des Grandes Banques" he has been urging the resignation of senior executives at BNP Paribas.

In the face of this new assertiveness, the French bank has been caught on the back foot.

As the US authorities opened early negotiations, reportedly threatening a $16bn fine, the bank offered to pay a mere $1bn.

That may just be bargaining chutzpah, but the bank put aside just $1.1bn to cover legal costs. In April it admitted: "There is the possibility that the amount of the fines could be far in excess of the amount of the provision."

It had utterly failed to grasp the seriousness of the situation.

Paying the price

And the situation was serious, particularly the accusations of "stripping" - the deliberate removal of key details, to keep sanctioned transfers of money away from the prying eyes of regulators.

Investigators eventually found that even as late as 2011 while the bank was insisting that it was co-operating with the authorities, it was continuing to break rules on sanctions.

Again the bank appeared not to have taken the litigation threat seriously. It is now paying the price.

In sharp contrast JP Morgan Chase, facing some $20bn in penalties in the past year, has been steadily building up a war chest of more than $28bn to meet the legal pay-outs.

The New York Times recently described how chief executive Jamie Dimon personally negotiated with the Attorney General hours before the DoJ was due to announce civil charges. "A move," it reported, "that averted a lawsuit and ultimately resulted in the brokered deal."

And the American banks are still as much in the firing line as the Europeans.

The DoJ is demanding $10bn from Citigroup to settle investigations into its sale of worthless mortgage-backed securities. It is also negotiating a $13bn settlement with Bank of America.

There is much more to come, for instance the probes into interest rate and foreign exchange market manipulation. European and US authorities are both investigating a raft of banks, blind, it seems, to which side of the Atlantic they come from.

More on This Story

Related Stories

More Business stories


BBC Business Live

    Tweet from Tory party chairman Grant Shapps

    Conservative party chairman Grant Shapps has welcomed the latest unemployment data today. Taking to Twitter to do so. See if you can spot the deliberate mistake in his tweet though: "UK unemployment tumbles by a further 146,000. A good moment to recall that every Lab govt in history has left more people on the doll."

    MOTOR INSURANCE FRAUD 11:17: Radio 5 live

    For the first time, the Association of British Insurers (ABI) has collected data on the extent of fraud on motor insurance applications. It detected more than 180 thousand fraudulent applications last year. Often applicants are failing to disclose full information about their driving record. Aidan Kerr, head of fraud at the ABI tells Radio 5 live that it is hard to calculate the extent of the practice, as many people give up a claim when challenged.

    Airbus A380

    Qatar Airways has taken delivery of its first A380 superjumbo, following a three-month delay, during which it wrangled with Airbus over cabin fittings. Airbus has also been trying to fix an issue with seals around the doors of the jet. Qatar will be the first customer for the Airbus A350 and Airbus says it will deliver the first plane by the end of the year.

    A  general view of a Jobcentre Plus in Glasgow.

    The ONS data also shows the claimant count - the number of people claiming Jobseeker's Allowance - has fallen below 1 million for the first time since September 2008. It now stands at 966,500.

    'SICK' FRANCE 10:36:
    Emmanuel Macron

    "France is sick," the country's new economy minister Emmanuel Macron has told French radio. He said France has no choice but to "reform the economy". Unemployment is currently at a record 10% and there's been no growth for two quarters. Meanwhile the government budget deficit is expanding. The Business live page wishes Mr Macron good luck.

    Iain Duncan Smith

    Work and Pensions Secretary Iain Duncan Smith tells the BBC News Channel that pay in the financial services industry is distorting current average wage growth statistics. He says pay rises in the manufacturing industry are up 2% year on year. He also points out that food prices are coming down and inflation generally is falling.

    Via Twitter Andrew Sentance, former member of Monetary Policy Committee

    tweets: "UK unemployment rate at 6.2% & still falling sharply. At current rate of decline it'll be <5% next summer - pushing up pay & inflation."

    WAGE GROWTH 09:58:
    Hand and coins

    The ONS data shows average pay was 0.6% higher in the three months to July, compared to a year earlier. That's an improvement on the previous figure which showed a 0.2% decline. Pay excluding bonuses also rose slightly by 0.7%, the previous figures was 0.6%. Pay rises are still running well below the rate of inflation. On Tuesday data showed consumer price inflation running at 1.5% in August.


    There was no change in voting patterns at the Bank of England's Monetary Policy Committee at September's meeting. Two members voted in favour of raising interest rates to 0.75%.

    UNEMPLOYMENT 09:32: Breaking News

    The unemployment total fell by 146,000 to 2.02 million in the three months to the end of July, official figures show. The Office for National Statistic said the unemployment rate for the period was 6.2%, down from the previous level of 6.4%.

    The new body of the Volkswagen Passat

    Car sales across Europe rose for the 12th month in a row industry figures show today. They were 1.8% higher at 701,118 in August, from 688,464 a year-earlier the Association of European Carmakers (ACEA) says. Volkswagen, Ford and Opel all benefited from improved demand in Spain, Portugal and Ireland. But car sales in Germany - Europe's largest car market - were 0.4% lower.


    At 09:30 the Bank of England publishes minutes from the interest rate policy meeting in September. In August's meeting two members of nine-strong monetary policy committee voted to raise interest rates. Will others have joined them in September? Watch this space.

    Via Twitter Kevin Peachey Personal finance reporter, BBC News

    tweets: "Hold music among biggest consumer service irritations says @WhichUK survey - any views on the most annoying?"

    imagination technologies

    Shares in two of Britain's most successful technology companies are sharply higher this morning. Imagination Technologies, which designs chips for mobile devices, has seen its shares jump 6%. That's after the company forecast a strong performance in the second half of the year. Fellow chip designer, ARM Holdings is leading the FTSE 100 higher with a 1.9% gain.

    MARKET UPDATE 08:34:

    Shares in London are higher in early trading with the FTSE 100 up 16 points

    • Smiths Group slumps 5.4% after sales fall
    • JD Sports up 2.7% following half year results
    • Pound slightly higher at $1.6296

    Former Bank of England Deputy Governor, Sir John Gieve says the Bank is "a creature of Westminster" and will be an adviser in any currency negotiations. "I think it could work, " he says of currency union but adds it "relies on careful negotiation". A lot of policy decision would remain in London, he adds. If the economies of Scotland and the rest of the UK began to diverge more than they do at present that could be a problem.

    INTERNET OF THINGS 08:17: BBC Radio 4

    The Internet of Things is a phrase bandied around. ARM Holdings boss, Simon Segars is fresh from a conference about it - but it all sounds a bit pedestrian. Mr Segars says one example is a coffee cup that has a microchip in it that could tell you if you're consuming too much coffee. There is already a fork that can tell you if you are eating too quickly. On Today he also mentions apps that help you find a parking space.

    JD SPORTS 08:11: Radio 5 live

    We're not far off being saturated with sports shops in the UK says Peter Cowgill, executive chairman of JD Sports on Radio 5 live. But the company is having "significant success" competing in Spain, German, France and the Netherlands.

    PHONES 4U RESCUE 07:57: BBC Radio 4

    It is "perhaps not surprising" that Vodafone and EE are looking at buying parts of Phones4U now that it is in administration, says Laura Lambie of Investec Wealth and Investment on Today. Both EE and Vodafone had been approached by Phones 4U which tried to interest them in buying the retailer, she says. After refusing that approach, Vodafone and EE are now looking "to pick up assets on the cheap", according to Ms Lambie.

    xperia phones

    The profit warning at Sony is the result of a review of its mobile phone business. It says there has been "a significant change in the market and competitive environment". As a result, it has taken a £1bn charge to reflect the loss of value of the mobile business. It is reducing the number of models it produces and is concentrating on a premium lineup.

    JD SPORTS PROFITS 07:36: BBC Radio 4

    "The high street is alive and well," says Peter Cowgill, executive chairman of JD Sports on Today. The retailer has a strong presence in shopping malls and online but Mr Cowgill says a high street presence is "still very important to JD Sports". The retailer has a contingency plan if Scotland votes Yes to independence. But he adds: "We don't think there will be a major impact on our trade. We think there will be no change to prices [if Scotland votes Yes]."

    SONY PROFIT WARNING 07:32: Breaking News
    Sony office

    Sony expects to report a much deeper loss this year than originally forecast. The firm now expects a loss of 230bn yen (£1.3bn) for the year which ends 31 March. Its previous forecast was for a 50bn yen loss.


    Profits at retailer JD Sports doubled in the first half of the year. Before exceptional items it made a pre-tax profit of £19.9m. Sales at stores open for more than a year rose 13% from the same period a year ago. But its fashion business which includes Scotts and Bank had a "disappointing" first half, the company said.

    Zara store

    The world's biggest clothing retailer, Inditex has posted a 2.4% fall in first half net profit. The owner of Zara, made 928m euros (£738m). That was not as bad as some analysts were expecting. The company also said that sales for the start of the third quarter rose 10%.

    SPACESHIP CONTRACT 06:56: Radio 5 live
    Space X Capsule

    Nasa has awarded up to $6.2bn (£3.8bn) to Boeing and SpaceX to develop space vehicles that can take crew into space. The firms are aiming to have their spaceships ready by 2017. Since the space shuttles were retired in 2011, the Americans have relied on Russia and its Soyuz vehicles to get to the International Space Station.

    Scottish bank notes

    Former Bank of England deputy governor Sir John Gieve tells the Today programme he expects Bank staff to be at work very early on Friday morning to try to calm markets, whichever way Scotland votes in the independence referendum. In particular, the Bank will be busying itself with the possibility of "deposit flight" so that "we don't get the sort of panic that there was with Northern Rock". That means for starters making sure that cash machines remain fully stocked.

    ARM CHIEF EXECUTIVE 06:27: Radio 5 live
    Arm processor

    It's arguably Britain's most successful technology company, but you may have never heard of it. ARM designs computer chips and is worth almost twice as much as Marks and Spencer. On Wake Up to Money chief executive Simon Segars says most of the firm's customers are in California, China, Taiwan and South Korea. "It's a shame" there are not more technology companies in the UK, he says. People have been keener to go into financial services, Mr Segars says.

    SCOTTISH REFERENDUM 06:16: Radio 5 live

    Whichever way the Scottish independence vote goes, the business impact "remains unclear" says Nora Senior, chair at Scottish Chambers of Commerce on Wake Up to Money. Big questions over currency, Europe, debt, pensions and tax were raised in the run up to the vote, she says. "Business wants a decision that is clear and swiftly executed," Ms Senior says.

    BEREAVEMENT AND WORK 06:10: Radio 5 live

    A third of employees who have suffered bereavement in the past five years felt that they had not been treated with compassion by their employer, according to a survey by the Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service (ACAS). It is launching guidance for companies. "Managers need appropriate training and support," said Sir Brendan Barber, ACAS chair on Wake Up to Money.

    PHONES 4U RESCUE 06:00:
    Phones 4U sign

    The Financial Times is reporting that Vodafone and EE have approached the administrators of Phones 4U about buying parts of the failed business. Around 550 shops and 6,000 jobs are at risk. The private equity owners of Phones 4U and its founder, John Caudwell have blamed the aggressive tactics of EE and Vodafone for the collapse of the firm. Both network operators deny those accusations.

    05:59: Matthew West Business Reporter

    Morning everyone. As always you can get in touch with us via email on or twitter @bbcbusiness.

    05:59: Ben Morris Business Reporter

    We'll get the latest unemployment figures and data on earnings at 09:30 this morning. Plus the Financial Times says that Vodafone and EE are looking to buy parts of their former customer, Phones 4U. Stay with us.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.