MP likens Bank of England to 'unreliable boyfriend'

Mark Carney Mr Carney said that any increases in interest rates would be "limited and gradual".

The Bank of England has acted like an "unreliable boyfriend" in hints over interest rate rises, according to MP Pat McFadden.

The Treasury committee member accused the Bank of a lack of clarity about possible rate rise timings.

The governor of the Bank of England, Mark Carney, said the Bank's guidance had reinforced economic recovery.

He said the timing of an interest rate rise will be fluid, and will be "driven by the data".

'Hot and cold'

Mr McFadden said that businesses and consumers had been "left not really knowing where they stand" by statements made by the Bank.

"We've had a lot of different signals," he said. "I mean it strikes me that the Bank's behaving a bit like a sort of unreliable boyfriend.

"One day hot, one day cold, and the people on the other side of the message are left not really knowing where they stand."

Analysis Simon Jack, BBC economics correspondent

The Bank of England was likened to an unreliable boyfriend today as some MPs felt it had sent mixed signals over the timing of future interest rate rises.

Labour MP Pat McFadden pointed out that guidance had changed from 2016 to 2015 to possibly this year creating confusion.

The Governor Mark Carney defended the banks record saying it had changed its guidance as the facts changed and said unemployment had fallen faster than expected while wage growth had been slower.

Deputy Governor, Sir Charlie Bean, in his last meeting before the Treasury Select Committee, said he expected pay to start rising more quickly in the second half of this year.

The financial bookmakers now make the turn of the year as favourite for the first rate rise in over 5 years.


Guidance from the Bank was initially that rates wouldn't rise until 2016, but then market expectations shifted to rates going up in 2015, he said.

A further hint from Mr Carney that rates may go up before 2015 had left businesses and consumers confused, he said.

Mr Carney said that bank guidance had helped to strengthen the economy.

"Businesses understood the first phase of guidance and acted on it. Many of them acted on it [with] hiring and investment that reinforced the strength of the recovery and the balance of the recovery."

Mr Carney told the Treasury Committee that his earlier hint of a rate rise before the end of the year was intended to spur markets to adjust expectations.

The bank also intended markets to tighten as a response to the hint.

He added that the economy had beaten expectations, but that certain elements of the economy, such as earnings, had still not really grown.

'Take the stabilisers off'

Mr Carney hinted earlier this month that a rate rise "could happen sooner than markets currently expect".

He explained to the committee that his comment had been designed to spur the markets to assess and re-assess the likelihood of a rate rise based on shifting economic data.

In a research note investment bank RBC Capital Markets said that Mr Carney wanted investors to be more responsive to economic volatility.

"Our analogy of his message would be that it is time to take the stabilisers off the bikes of market," said RBC economist Sam Hill.

"For all the criticisms of forward guidance the governor appears to be feeling the need to remind markets that in the post-threshold guidance world, the formulation of market rate expectations should be more sensitive to volatility in the data than it has been," he added.

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Business stories


BBC Business Live

    PPI SPENDING 07:25: Radio 5 live

    Consumers have about £23bn of payment protection insurance redress from banks, says James Bevan, Chief Investment Officer at CCLA Investment Management on Wake Up to Money. When that dries up, it may have an effect on spending, he says.


    Ofgem said it found that between May 2011 and January 2012, "EDF Energy did not have appropriate procedures in place to properly receive, record and process all customers' complaints in accordance with complaints handling rules". However, it adds EDF took action quickly to rectify the problems. It also says EDF "has acknowledged that their customers were caused significant disruption" and has apologised.


    Co-operative Bank has reported a loss of £75.8m for the six months to the end of June. That compares with a loss of £845m the year earlier. The bank says it has cut staff numbers by 21% to 5,860.

    EDF ENERGY PENALTY Breaking News
    EDF bill

    EDF Energy is to pay £3m after an investigation by energy regulator Ofgem found that the company breached complaint-handling rules. The company will pay the money "to benefit vulnerable customers", Ofgem says.

    BANK OF AMERICA 06:55: BBC Radio 4

    Chris Wheeler, an analyst at Mediobanca, has been discussing Bank of America's massive $16.7bn settlement with US authorities. He told the Today programme that while banks were at fault, investors were also "in a hurry" at the time, and failed to carry out proper credit analysis of what they were buying.

    EUROZONE 06:44: Radio 5 live
    ECB headquarters

    James Bevan is chief investment officer at CCLA Investment Management and he's on Wake Up to Money talking about the eurozone's performance. "Interest rates are so low" in some of the countries that when you factor in the risk of investing the rates are negative, he says. Sustainable growth in the UK hasn't yet been seen either, he says. with house price growth and PPI repayments from banks driving consumer spending.

    GAP IN INDIA 06:30:
    Gap logo

    US clothing store Gap is bringing its brand to India, aiming to open 40 outlets. It will launch its first two stores there early next year in Mumbai and the capital Delhi - India's biggest and busiest cities.

    BANK OF AMERICA 06:20: Radio 5 live
    Bank of America

    Chris Orndorff, a fund manager at Western Asset Management is on Wake Up to Money talking about Bank of America's record $16.7bn settlement. The penalty dates back to the behaviour of a company it purchased, Countrywide. "The timing of the Countrywide purchase has to be one of the worst in history," he says. The fine wipes out the cumulative net income of the bank for the last three years. The bank is very safe though, he says.


    Argentina's plan to exit its debt default by asking investors holding defaulted bonds to swap them for new locally issued debt has been ruled "illegal" by a US court. New York Judge Thomas Griesa said the plan was "lawless". Argentina was trying to get around an earlier court ruling banning it from paying interest to investors who had accepted restructured bonds.

    OIL PRICE 06:00: Radio 5 live
    Oil barrels

    After rising sharply in June, oil prices have now slipped back to 14-month lows. Amrita Sen from Energy Aspects tells Wake Up to Money. She says that "the initial price rise was on the back of the fears should any disruptions come at peak demand". However, despite geopolitical risks, supply has remained undisrupted while demand has fallen.

    06:00: Nick Edser, Business reporter

    Good morning. Get in touch with us via email: or on twitter @BBCBusiness.

    06:00: Howard Mustoe, Business Reporter

    Hello! We'll be bringing you all the latest business news, data and analysis. Stay with us.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.