Singing up an economic storm: Setting a crisis to music

Estonian singer Iris Oja, conductor Risto Joost and Tallinn Chamber Orchestra You can reach a bigger audience with music, says singer Iris Oja

"Frozen pensions, lowered salaries, internal devaluation - Nostra culpa!" the words come not from an election campaign leaflet, but instead from an opera.

This is a piece of high drama, soaring vocals and intense emotion - not on opera's usual grand themes of love or death, but instead on economics.

Nostra Culpa is the story of the Baltic state of Estonia, the 2008 financial crisis that tore a hole in its economy, and a spectacular row between the country's president and a leading economist.

The crisis and the subsequent recession hit Estonia with dramatic results - its economy shrank by almost a fifth and unemployment rocketed to 18%.

Composer Eugene Birman says one reason for choosing Estonia was because of the central role music has played in the country's culture.

"Music has always played a social role in Estonia. The language was kept alive partly through singing and through music.

"It's a way of not just communicating and performing, but preservation and national identity."

An excerpt from the Estonian opera Nostra Culpa


All the words in Nostra Culpa, which means "our fault" in Latin, come from an epic 2012 row between Estonia's President Toomas Hendrik Ilves, and the US economist Paul Krugman.

Start Quote

Those characters and stories are in a way as legendary and interesting as the great opera stories”

End Quote Iris Oja

First, the Nobel Prize-winning economist criticised the government's response to the crisis in an article.

In reply, the president called the economist "smug, overbearing and patronising" in a series of blistering and often sarcastic tweets.

The very title comes from one of the president's replies.

It was a dramatic story in itself. After all it is not often a country's leader spars with an internationally renowned economist - but why choose this as a topic for an opera?

"Economics is story-telling," says Scott Diel, who wrote the words for Nostra Culpa. "It shouldn't be a topic we avoid."

Eugene says they were jointly entering a work for Estonia's music festival and wanted to make a piece "that is both universal and really personal to a lot of people here".

Throughout the work, it is Estonian mezzo-soprano Iris Oja who takes on the role of both protagonists.

Two violinists with the Tallinn Chamber Orchestra Nostra Culpa is a cantata in two movements for a singer and chamber orchestra

She is adamant that economics can be a compelling subject.

"I think that what's happened in the last 10 years has been quite dramatic," she told BBC World TV's World Business Report.

"And those characters and stories are in a way as legendary and interesting as the great opera stories."

'I love singing'

Start Quote

It's about real people who have real stories”

End Quote Eugene Birman Composer, Nostra Culpa

The secret, says Iris, is to have passion for what you do.

"I love singing, passionately - and if you draw the meaning of any piece close to yourself and make it personal, you will be passionate about it.

"Also the music in it is very dramatic. The music helps a lot to bring out the meaning of the text."

Underpinning many Estonians' resilience to the 2008 crisis has been the 40 years of Soviet occupation - complete with austerity and exile.

"Every family had somebody who was sent to Siberia in the 1940s," says Iris.

Her grandmother's seven brothers and sisters were all sent there, she says. "Some of them came back, some of them died. Most of them died."

Eugene hopes that Nostra Culpa will provoke debate and discussion about a topic "which has not been addressed musically".

A woman lighting candles in Tallinn, Estonia Estonia's 40-year Soviet occupation still figures largely in the country's consciousness
From opera to Ole Opry

Yet it isn't just opera singers who have been choosing the economic crisis as a topic. Take country singer Merle Hazard, for instance.

Start Quote

The same story that might seem tragic to me in daily life might be played for comedy in a song”

End Quote Merle Hazard Country and western singer

Based in Nashville, Tennessee, the home of country music and the Ole Opry concert hall, he has written several songs on the theme, such as Inflation or deflation? and the Greek debt song.

Merle, who in everyday life works as a financial adviser under his real name Jon Shayne, describes himself as "the only country artist to sing about central banking, mortgage-backed securities and physics".

Music can help us understand things better sometimes than a written article or television interview, he says. "It's a bit of a mystery, but rhyming does intensify meaning."

A song allows the prose to be slower, giving the audience time to appreciate a message.

"You can't make as few points in a speech as you can in a song. The deepest truths tend to be very simple."

There is also a deeper layer of meaning in the phonemes - the very sound of the words themselves - which music can tap into, he says.

Opera and country music may not appear to have much in common at first glance but there are similarities, says Merle.

"If you take a country and western song, it's just one emotional moment in somebody's life. And that is similar to an aria in an opera."

Country and western singer, Merle Hazard Merle Hazard - named after country star Merle Haggard and the concept of moral hazard
'Major or minor key'

He insists that in writing humorous songs about recession or economic slowdown, he is not criticising individuals - just their governments and politicians.

"When something is badly broken, in the US, we say 'it's a joke'. Well, there are problems with the economy that cannot be fixed for political reasons.

"They are 'a joke'. To me, joking about them is more fitting than writing an opinion piece asking for a solution that will not come.

"The same story that might seem tragic to me in daily life might be played for comedy in a song," says Merle.

"It is like the idea of a major or minor key in music. The same melody can be played either way."

Country and western singer, Merle Hazard Funny songs are no laughing matter, says Merle Hazard

Back in Tallinn, composer Eugene Birman says the essential truth of Estonia's economic crash is "not just about the numbers".

"It's about real people who have real stories."

The aim of Nostra Culpa, he says, is "to take these terms, and create a much more personal, musical experience".

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Business stories


Business Live

    11:34: House prices
    Image of ONS website

    Want to know how much homes cost in your neck of the woods? The ONS (Office for National Statistics) has recently published this interactive map of house prices for very small areas in England and Wales. You can play with it to your heart's content.

    11:24: Stamp prices

    They are going to cost more. First and second class stamps will go up by 1p, to 63p and 54p respectively. It happens on 30 March. Large letters will also cost more too. First class ones will be 2p more expensive at 95p and second class ones will cost 1p more at 74p.

    11:10: Glasgow Rangers
    Rangers fans

    This is embarrassing for the very troubled football club. It has just issued an announcement to stock market investors clarifying no fewer than six previous announcements. Most relate to the stewardship of Newcastle United by Derek Llambias, who is now running Rangers.

    11:01: Via Twitter Dave Lee BBC technology reporter

    tweets: TalkTalk confirms customer account data stolen; Taking legal action against third-party it says was weak link

    10:56: Greece bailout

    Andreas Scheuer, a senior conservative who backed extending the current bailout, said that "everyone has a feeling that isn't just positive." He said: "We will have to rely on the Greek government delivering now," adding that "this is one of the last chances we are giving Greece."

    10:50: House prices
    Homes in Newcastle

    Delving into the Land Registry stats is a fascinating exercise. Average house prices in London hit a peak last August at £462,000, and have been hovering a bit below that point ever since. By contrast, the average home in the north east of England (the cheapest area) costs just £100,000.

    10:40: Greece bailout
    German Finance Minister Schaeuble

    German finance minister Wolfgang Schaeuble said: "We have to bring Greece into a situation that finance markets trust them again, and that Greece can act without any support, on its own again. It is called competitiveness. And for Greece, there is a longer road to go than for any other European country."

    10:32: Greece bailout
    German Finance Minister Wolfgang Schaeuble addresses a session of the Bundestag

    The German parliament has voted 542-32 to back Greece's bailout extension.

    10:29: Via Twitter Gavin Hewitt BBC Europe editor

    tweets: As expected the German Parliament supports the extension of the Greece bail-out. #Greece

    10:25: Ferries

    Meanwhile, we're sure you're very keen to hear about ferries. Industry body Discover Ferries has said one million more people travelled on ferries in Britain in 2014, up from around 38 million in 2013.

    10:02: British Gas price cut
    British Gas van

    British Gas is cutting its gas prices by 5% today, as announced in January. Competitor E.On was the first of the big six energy suppliers to announce a price reduction in January, which it did with immediate effect, with price cuts in the month rounded off by EDF.

    09:50: Lloyds Banking Group
    Michael Hewson

    Michael Hewson, chief market analyst at CMC Markets, says he sees the glass as being "half full" rather than "half empty" for Lloyds. The dividend of 0.75p per share was slightly less than expected - the markets were expecting a penny, he says. And PPI is an "ongoing sore" for the firm. Yet "the direction of travel does appear to be fairly positive", he says. "Loan growth is up 17% year-on-year, and impairments are down."

    09:42: House prices
    For Sale sign

    The latest figures from the Land Registry represent a continued slowdown in the annual rate of house price inflation. That rate was 7% in December, and January's figure is the fifth monthly decline in a row.

    09:32: House prices
    For Sale signs

    The Land Registry (for England & Wales) says house prices saw an annual price increase of 6.7%, with prices up 1.3% since December. That left the average house price at £179,492.

    09:27: Lloyds Banking Group

    Is anyone worth £11m, Mr Horta-Osorio is asked? "It is not up to me to judge that, I think it is important to focus on pay for performance," he replies. "It is the fact that the share price tripled in these three years, that's what makes the [incentive] plan have a much higher value," he explains.

    09:21: Cash Isa

    Who is offering the best short-term cash Isa at the moment? According to the website Savers Friend it is the Yorkshire bank, paying 2.1% for its fixed-rate, two-year, Isa.

    09:09: Lloyds Banking Group
    Antonio Horta-Osorio

    Mr Antonio Horta-Osorio says he is "really pleased" his bank has resumed dividend payments: "We went from a very, very negative position in terms of profitability to a position where we generated £7.8bn of underlying profitability, [and] we generated £1.8bn of pre-tax profit," he tells BBC business editor Kamal Ahmed.

    09:00: Rightmove

    It's fascinating to see just how much money you can make running a website that dominates its market. Rightmove's total income for the year was £167m. Of that £96m went to the company as after-tax profit. No wonder the recently launched wants to have some of that business.

    08:50: IAG - Aer Lingus
    Aer Lingus plane tailfins

    On the potential IAG takeover of Aer Lingus, IAG chief executive Willie Walsh tells BBC News that the firm doesn't foresee "many if any competition issues" from the EU competition commission. "We remain very excited about an acquisition. We think Aer Lingus is a good company, and we think Aer Lingus can be a significantly better company as part of IAG," he says.

    08:40: FTSE 100 market update
    FTSE 100

    The FTSE 100 has opened up slightly, gaining 2 points to stand at 6952. It's not a shock to see that IAG, which saw operating profits nearly double in 2014, has risen over 4%, while shares in engineering firm Meggitt moved downward, falling 1.72%.

    08:39: William Hill
    Gambling machine

    Annual pre-tax profits fell at the betting business; down 9% to £234m. Shareholders still received a rise in their dividends though, up 5%.

    08:20: Rightmove

    The property website is yet another business rewarding its investors handsomely. Shareholders' dividends will rise by 25% on the back of a 26% rise in pre-tax profits to £122m.

    08:04: IAG - Willie Walsh BBC News Channel
    Willie Walsh

    IAG chief executive Willie Walsh points out the turnaround in Spanish airline Iberia, which was a drag on IAG from 2011 until the summer. "These are fantastic results, particularly the performance in Iberia, which I think has been a concern for a lot of people over the past few years", he tells BBC News. Iberia made an operating profit of €50m in 2014 compared to an operating loss of €166m the year before.

    07:48: Lloyds Banking Group

    The bank has now written to owners of 2.7 million past PPI policies inviting them to lodge a claim. That is one reason why it is expecting a further 600,000 fresh claims this coming year.

    07:42: Lloyds Banking Group
    Lloyds logo

    How much in total has the PPI scandal cost the bank in the past few years? An truly extraordinary £12bn. Not all of that is compensation. The administrative costs of sorting out the payments have been expensive too.

    07:30: IAG results
    British Airways planes

    IAG raised its 2015 profit forecast by over 20% to 2.2bn euros for 2015, compared to the 1.8 billion euros it had said it was targeting. It says it has been helped by lower fuel costs. It expects to increase its capacity as well.

    07:27: Lloyds Banking Group

    The bank has had to set aside another £2.2bn to cover the continued cost of repaying customers who were mis-sold payment protection insurance (PPI). That was on top of the £3.1bn the year before.

    07:21: Lloyds Banking Group
    Antonio Horta-Osorio

    The massive payment to chief executive Antonio Horta-Osorio includes £1m in basic pay and an £800,000 bonus. The rest of the £11m comes from the payout of a "long term incentive plan" which gives him shares in the bank as a reward for steering it out of near insolvency.

    07:19: IAG results

    Meanwhile, IAG's operating profit for the year to 31 December 2014 is £1.03bn, a 95.3% jump on the previous year.

    07:15: Via Twitter Kamal Ahmed BBC business editor

    tweets: Breaking: Lloyds CEO Antonio Horta-Osorio total remuneration package will total £11m after shares rise by 193% since 2012.

    07:10: IAG results

    British Airways owner IAG made a profit before tax from continuing operations of £828m, it says.

    07:06: Lloyds Banking Group

    The dividend will be 0.75p per share, totalling £535m, which will go to three million shareholders. And that means £130m goes to the government.

    07:02: Lloyds Banking Group

    The annual results are out. It has announced pre-tax profits of £1.8bn - up from £415m a year ago - and will indeed resume paying a dividend to shareholders.

    06:50: Lloyds Banking Group BBC Radio 4

    William Wright of capital markets think-tank New Financial tells the Today programme that it was turning out to be a turbulent week for banks: "We've seen continued tax scandals at HSBC, continued restructuring at RBS, all change at the top of Standard Chartered - next week no doubt with Barclays we are going to see more restructuring."

    06:41: Rising rents

    Demand for rental properties is still driving up rents in the private sector. So says Sequence, a network of 300 letting agencies. It reckons that the average monthly rent outside London rose by 5% in the past year - and in London by 7%. "Large cities in particular are seeing a lot of activity as employment increases," it says.

    06:28: Lloyds Banking Group Radio 5 live
    Lloyds Bank bank branch

    Lloyds is expected to announce profits of around £2bn, but banking analyst Alex Potter tells Wake Up to Money that the dividend resuming is the real indicator for a return to health. "Actually, an awful lot of [investment] funds haven't been able to buy Lloyds shares at all while they haven't been paying a dividend, so, actually just the allowance of those potential shareholders onto the [share] register again is going to be a pretty good thing."

    06:19: Pension tax relief

    Will Labour suggest cutting pension tax relief for high earners? It seems this may be proposed by Ed Miliband when he speaks later today on how Labour might cut university tuition fees.

    06:09: IAG results Radio 5 live
    British Airways plane

    We should look forward to hearing strong results for British Airways owner IAG, according to aviation consultant John Strickland. "We should expect to hear a big jump in profitability", he says on Wake up to Money, because the firm is "in a very solid state".

    06:00: Ian Pollock Business reporter, BBC News

    Good morning. It's Friday. Always a good day as far as I'm concerned. Oh, and the Land Registry's house price figures for England and Wales will be out later this morning.

    06:00: Good morning Tom Espiner Business reporter

    Some interesting stories coming up today. Expect full year results from Lloyds Banking Group, which is expected to resume paying a dividend to shareholders for the first time since the financial crisis in 2008. British Airways owner IAG is to post its full year results too.



Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.