Co-op Bank and Britannia merger 'should never have happened'

Sir Christopher Kelly: "It's easy to blame individuals... but what I've tried to show is that this was a systematic failure"

The Co-operative Bank's merger with the Britannia building society in 2009 should never have happened, a major review of the organisation has said.

Sir Christopher Kelly's report blames the deal for the bank's near-collapse last year.

His report states both companies had problems that were exacerbated by the merger.

It also points to failings in management and governance "on many levels".

Sir Christopher added the deal might have worked had the organisation received first-class leadership, but "sadly it did not".

Sir Christopher told the BBC's Radio 4 Today programme: "It is the merger [between the Co-op Bank and the Britannia], not the Britannia itself that caused the problems."

He said both organisations brought problems to the deal.

In Britannia's case, it was the vast size and unwieldiness of its commercial property loan book.

But the Co-op Bank had several problems of its own, including its approach to risk when lending money to customers and a large IT project that was already under way, which the merger "vastly complicated" and which ultimately contributed £300m to the bank's eventual capital shortfall .

Sir Christopher added that the Co-op Bank "had a legacy of mis-selling payment protection insurance (PPI), which was not unusual at the time, but is particularly disappointing for an ethical bank".

Infographic showing the businesses that make up the Co-op Group
Financial crisis

Among other reasons for the near-collapse of the bank identified by the report are the economic environment following the 2008 financial crisis and the demand from financial regulators for banks to hold increased levels of capital that followed.

Niall Booker, chief executive of the Co-operative Bank said he broadly accepted the findings of the report, which he admitted would "make difficult reading for our customers".

But Mr Booker added: "We do believe there are many more positive aspects of the Co-operative Bank's culture that are not reflected in the report - for example, not enough credit is given to the service ethic and empathy of our employees."

He apologised again for "past failings" and reiterated his commitment to "restoring the bank to financial health".

Richard Pennycook, interim group chief executive of the Co-operative Group, said: "Following the wake-up call of our recently announced £2.5bn loss, Sir Christopher Kelly's report today lays bare the failings of management and governance that caused it.

"It is a sobering assessment which shows clearly that the Co-operative Group's loss of control of its bank could have been avoided."

Profits hit

The report added that the financial crisis and the response to it by regulators and policymakers were the only factors outside the Co-op Bank's control.

Co-operative Bank sign, Derby Sir Christopher Kelly's report says the Co-op Bank's had its own problems before the merger with Britannia

Unlike a number of other financial institutions, before the merger, the Co-operative Bank obtained most of funding from its own customers' deposits.

As a result, it was not adversely affected when the international money markets dried up during the financial crisis and considered itself as having "weathered the crisis well".

But the bank was hurt by the prolonged period of low interest rates introduced by the Bank of England, which depressed its net margins and profitability.

The bank's problems were further complicated by the fact that some of its customers ran into difficulties, particularly business customers involved in commercial real estate - a market that itself all but collapsed following the financial crisis.

That depressed the value of the bank's assets and made it more difficult for its clients to refinance, limiting the Co-op Bank's ability to reduce its own heavily concentrated exposure to the sector.

The commercial loan book that the Co-op Bank inherited as part of its merger with Britannia stood at £3.7bn and accounted for as much as half of its lending and a greater proportion of its regulatory capital, the report added.

The Co-op Bank wanted Britannia's personal customers and retail branches. But in acquiring them, it was also saddled with a "substantial volume of assets well outside its risk appetite in terms of type, loan-to-value or concentration risk".


Equally troubling, for the bank and the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) alike, the regulator admitted to the bank's board in July 2011 that it did not believe Britannia would have survived, had it not been for its takeover by the Co-op.

In fact, so concerned was the Financial Services Authority (FSA) - the FCA's predecessor - about Britannia's financial position that at the time of the merger between the Co-op Bank and the building society, it had placed the mutual on a watchlist.

It was not the FSA's policy, however, to advise all firms of their inclusion on a watchlist, the report added.

The Co-op Bank's small capital base also meant that it would be less resilient than some others to significant shocks, including "self-inflicted" ones, Sir Christopher found.

Neville Richardson, the former chief executive of Britannia who became the boss of Co-op Bank in 2009 - Co-op Financial Services as it was at the time - is also heavily criticised by the report, which points out he had never worked at the bank before taking on his role.

In his evidence to the Treasury Select Committee, Mr Richardson argued one of the reasons for the difficulties the Bank faced after he left in 2011 was that a number of senior ex-Britannia staff also left at the same time.

But Sir Christopher said there was "overwhelming evidence" that the bank was already in difficulty by 2011.

"The capital position only looked reasonable because problems had been pushed into the future. The risk management framework was poor. The IT project was floundering; and there was little sign of a coherent strategy towards the non-residential mortgage portfolios inherited from Britannia other than to wait for things to get better," the report stated.

More on This Story

Related Stories

More Business stories


BBC Business Live

    SAT NAV 11:10:

    With the planned launch of two satellites aboard a Soyuz rocket from French Guiana later this month, Europe is pushing ahead with its own satellite navigation system, known as Galileo. How will it change our lives? A fascinating insight here from BBC reporters Tim Bowler and Matthew Wall.

    Via Email Ilya Spivak Currency Strategist at DailyFX

    "A lull in fundamental event risk in Asia and Europe has left currency markets rudderless, with investors looking ahead to the Kansas City Federal Reserve Economic Symposium. A gathering of so many policy heavy-hitters in one place all but guarantees that someone will invariably say something market-moving at some point before the affair is through. Needless to say, traders will be all ears."

    HOUSE PRICES 10:41:

    Asking prices for homes across Wales and parts of the North of England are still significantly lower than before the financial crisis, according to property website Rightmove. Prices in County Durham are still more than 13% below levels seen at the pre-crisis peak of May 2008. No prizes for guessing that the biggest price increase in the period was seen in central London - a rise of 41.9%

    SCOTTISH VOTE 10:29:
    Douglas Flint

    A vote in favour of Scottish independence could lead to "capital flight" from the country, HSBC chairman Douglas Flint has told the Daily Telegraph. He said this could leave Scotland's financial system in a "parlous state". Writing in the paper, Mr Flint says the sterling currency union has been an "anchor of financial stability" for Scotland.

    AGA RESULTS 10:16:

    Aga, the oven maker, has said revenues for the first half of the year were up 3.3% to £123.5m. Operating profits were up 60% to £2.4m. "Our markets have picked up but remain inconsistent and variable. Uncertainties around mortgage availability and interest rates are a contributing factor," it said.

    MARKET UPDATE 10:03:

    Shares in Vodafone have risen 0.8% this morning following a report that it could be a bid target for US telecoms firm AT&T. AstraZeneca shares are up a further 0.7% so far today. Shares in Astra jumped 3% yesterday on speculation that US rival Pfizer could be preparing another bid for the pharmaceutical firm, following its failed takeover attempt earlier this year.

    ADVERTISING 09:49: BBC Radio 4

    Kate Robertson, co-global president and UK chairman of Havas Worldwide - one of the world's largest marketing communications agencies, was the Friday boss on the Today programme. She says her industry is a barometer of economic conditions - in 2009 its UK business saw revenues drop 9% from the year before, but this year UK revenues are up about 12% so far.

    YELLEN SPEECH 09:34: BBC Radio 4
    Janet Yellen

    All eyes will be on US Federal Reserve chair Janet Yellen later when she addresses a gathering of central bankers and other policymakers at Jackson Hole, Wyoming. Analysts will be studying the speech for clues as to when the US might raise rates. James Bevan at CCLA Investment Management tells Today that she wants to see wage inflation picking up before taking action.


    In addition to setting out plans for a rights issue, the London Stock Exchange has also announced a big rise in quarterly profits following a "resurgence in the IPO market". The surge in the number of firms floating shares on the market helped to push pre-tax profits for the three months to June to £83.6m, up 40% from a year earlier.

    AIRPORT SURVEY 09:05: BBC Breakfast
    BBC Breakfast

    Some of Britain's biggest and busiest airports have been named as the worst for customer satisfaction by the consumer group Which?. Smaller airports did much better, including Doncaster Sheffield airport, where Dominic Laurie is for BBC Breakfast. Aviation analyst Laurie Price says smaller airports have a great opportunity but are hard pressed to compete with bigger airports which have the greater volume of flights.

    MARKET UPDATE 08:50:

    European stocks are largely up before a key speech from US Federal Reserve chief Janet Yellen. She is due to speak at a gathering of central bankers in Jackson Hole, Wyoming, as investors continue to speculate on the direction of US interest rates.

    • London's benchmark FTSE 100 index rose 0.04% to 6,780.08 points
    • Frankfurt's Dax gained 0.12% to 9,390.29
    • The CAC 40 index in Paris fell 0.04% to 4,291.06
    EDF ENERGY 08:36:
    Gas rings

    "We recognise that for a period of time the service to our customers was not up to the standards they deserve," says Beatrice Bigois from EDF Energy following this morning's announcement from Ofgem that it will pay out £3m. "We apologise to those customers who were impacted during this period. We have co-operated fully with Ofgem and have taken this matter very seriously."

    MARKET UPDATE 08:17:

    After nine consecutive days of gains, Japan's Nikkei share index has closed lower. The benchmark index ended the day down 47.01 points at 15,539.19. In Hong Kong, the Hang Seng is up 104.96 points at 25,099.06.

    CO-OP BANK RESULTS 08:08: Radio 5 live

    Chris Wheeler, a banking analyst at Mediobanca, is on 5 live talking about the Co-op Bank results. He says "there are signs of progress" but still "problems they have to deal with," including a drop in deposits. A reduction in money set aside for bad debts "flattered" the profit figures, he said.

    BANK OF AMERICA 08:01: Radio 5 live

    Bank of America can easily afford the record $16.7bn (£10bn) settlement with US authorities for misleading investors about the quality of loans it sold, US investment expert George Conboy tells Radio 5 live. He says the bank is likely to make $10-15bn over the next 12 months.


    An offer of shares to the public via a stock market listing is "logistically unlikely" before the end of 2014, the Co-op Bank says. It is setting up a committee to work out when it will do that. The Prudential Regulation Authority "has indicated it would be concerned if an IPO were to distract focus from the primary goal of delivering the Bank's Turnaround Plan," it said.

    ARGENTINA DEBT 07:46: BBC Radio 4

    Argentina risks becoming an "international financial pariah" again over its latest debt row, James Bevan, chief investment officer at CCLA Investment Management tells the Today programme. "The problem is that investors won't trust them, [so] they won't provide money," he says.

    LSE sign

    The London Stock Exchange has said it plans to raise £938m through a rights issue. The money is to be used to part-fund the acquisition of Frank Russell Company. The LSE announced in June it was buying the US asset manager for $2.7bn (£1.6bn).

    PPI SPENDING 07:25: Radio 5 live

    Consumers have about £23bn of payment protection insurance redress from banks, says James Bevan, Chief Investment Officer at CCLA Investment Management on Wake Up to Money. When that dries up, it may have an effect on spending, he says.


    Ofgem said it found that between May 2011 and January 2012, "EDF Energy did not have appropriate procedures in place to properly receive, record and process all customers' complaints in accordance with complaints handling rules". However, it adds EDF took action quickly to rectify the problems. It also says EDF "has acknowledged that their customers were caused significant disruption" and has apologised.


    Co-operative Bank has reported a loss of £75.8m for the six months to the end of June. That compares with a loss of £845m the year earlier. The bank says it has cut staff numbers by 21% from a year earlier to 5,860.

    EDF ENERGY PENALTY Breaking News
    EDF bill

    EDF Energy is to pay £3m after an investigation by energy regulator Ofgem found that the company breached complaint-handling rules. The company will pay the money "to benefit vulnerable customers", Ofgem says.

    BANK OF AMERICA 06:55: BBC Radio 4

    Chris Wheeler, an analyst at Mediobanca, has been discussing Bank of America's massive $16.7bn settlement with US authorities. He told the Today programme that while banks were at fault, investors were also "in a hurry" at the time, and failed to carry out proper credit analysis of what they were buying.

    EUROZONE 06:44: Radio 5 live
    ECB headquarters

    James Bevan is chief investment officer at CCLA Investment Management and he's on Wake Up to Money talking about the eurozone's performance. "Interest rates are so low" in some of the countries that when you factor in the risk of investing the rates are negative, he says. Sustainable growth in the UK hasn't yet been seen either, he says. with house price growth and PPI repayments from banks driving consumer spending.

    GAP IN INDIA 06:30:
    Gap logo

    US clothing store Gap is bringing its brand to India, aiming to open 40 outlets. It will launch its first two stores there early next year in Mumbai and the capital Delhi - India's biggest and busiest cities.

    BANK OF AMERICA 06:20: Radio 5 live
    Bank of America

    Chris Orndorff, a fund manager at Western Asset Management is on Wake Up to Money talking about Bank of America's record $16.7bn settlement. The penalty dates back to the behaviour of a company it purchased, Countrywide. "The timing of the Countrywide purchase has to be one of the worst in history," he says. The fine wipes out the cumulative net income of the bank for the last three years. The bank is very safe though, he says.


    Argentina's plan to exit its debt default by asking investors holding defaulted bonds to swap them for new locally issued debt has been ruled "illegal" by a US court. New York Judge Thomas Griesa said the plan was "lawless". Argentina was trying to get around an earlier court ruling banning it from paying interest to investors who had accepted restructured bonds.

    OIL PRICE 06:00: Radio 5 live
    Oil barrels

    After rising sharply in June, oil prices have now slipped back to 14-month lows. Amrita Sen from Energy Aspects tells Wake Up to Money. She says that "the initial price rise was on the back of the fears should any disruptions come at peak demand". However, despite geopolitical risks, supply has remained undisrupted while demand has fallen.

    06:00: Nick Edser, Business reporter

    Good morning. Get in touch with us via email: or on twitter @BBCBusiness.

    06:00: Howard Mustoe, Business Reporter

    Hello! We'll be bringing you all the latest business news, data and analysis. Stay with us.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.