Financial investment success: How much luck is needed?

Three dice on stock market graphs

Related Stories

How much luck do you need to be a successful investor? More than you might think, according to one senior US strategist.

Chance or luck is a vital part of every great investor's fortunes, says Michael Mauboussin, head of global financial strategies at Credit Suisse bank.

"Luck has become more important in defining outcomes today than it was a generation or two ago," he told the BBC's Business Daily programme.

It sounds counter-intuitive, because you might assume that skill is the vital ingredient.

Start Quote

When we see bad outcomes we tend to associate those with a lack of skill”

End Quote Michael Mauboussin Credit Suisse

However, he argues it is important to recognise the relative contributions of both skill and luck when it comes to business and investing.

While, for example, activities such as roulette are pure luck, others - as with chess - rely almost wholly on your skills.

"Knowing where you are on that continuum" allows investors to think much more effectively, Mr Mauboussin says.

People must distinguish between relative skills - "mine versus yours", as he puts it - and "how good we are absolutely".

Risks vs. Reward, on blackboard Investing is all about balancing risk and reward

The past few decades have witnessed an explosive growth of information which is readily available to would-be investors, which Mr Mauboussin says means "our absolute skill has never been higher".

But this flood of information means our relative skills range - the difference between the very best investor and the average investor - is now narrower than it was, he argues in new book The Success Equation.

Start Quote

It's about embracing uncertainty - the flexibility of saying: 'Hold on, it all could be different.'”

End Quote Prof Richard Wiseman Hertfordshire University

In investing, where both skill and luck contribute to outcomes, if the range of skills becomes narrower then by definition "that leaves more to luck", he says.

Taken to extremes, this would seem to leave little room for skilled investors such as Warren Buffett, who once famously remarked that risk "comes from not knowing what you're doing".

'Life is uncertain'

Mr Mauboussin agrees that skill plays an undeniably vital role, but too often many ordinary investors get things wrong when assessing its significance.

"We have part of our brains, which neuroscientists call the interpreter, which means when we see good outcomes, we tend to associate those with good processes or skill.

"When we see bad outcomes, we tend to associate those with a lack of skill."

Stock market display board The skill in investing comes in knowing which piece of information is significant

So, if luck or chance really does play a greater role than we might like to recognise, is there any way to load the dice, as it were - and to boost our own luck?

Yes, says Richard Wiseman, psychology professor at Hertfordshire University, who carried out his own research into behaviour patterns with 400 volunteers.

Crucially, lucky people generate their own good fortune because of the way they think and behave, he says. According to him:

  • They create and notice chance opportunities
  • They make "lucky" decisions based on their intuition
  • Their positive expectations create self-fulfilling prophesies
  • When things go wrong they have a resilient attitude

"Lucky people have a very 'let's do it' attitude, whereas unlucky people tend to go: 'I am not going to do it, because there is not enough payback.'

"Rather than being very analytical, those who are lucky grasp opportunities as they come along - they realise life is uncertain and full of chances," says Prof Wiseman.

Two gamblers How lucky in life do you really feel?

Perhaps unsurprisingly, in personality tests unlucky people come out as more anxious than those who are lucky - and this tension interferes with our ability to notice the unexpected chances that come along.

'Embracing uncertainty'

In an experiment, Prof Wiseman asked one group of volunteers to watch a dot in the centre of a computer screen. Occasionally other dots would flash up on the screen's edges. Almost all of this group saw these dots.

A second group were told they would get a large pay-off for watching the same dot. They became far more anxious; as a result more than a third of this second group missed the other dots.

The lesson? The harder you concentrate on something, the less likely you are to see other opportunities - whether in business or in life.

"It is about openness and creativity - it is quite nebulous, there aren't rules," says Prof Wiseman.

Slogan 'Second Chance Just Ahead' on a green billboard Being open-minded allows you to spot more of life's opportunities

"Mood is important for enhancing your luck. When you are in a good mood or relaxed, your mind becomes more expansive.

"It's about embracing uncertainty, the flexibility of saying: 'Hold on, it all could be different.' The notion of letting go of fixity is really important."

As we increasingly live in an interconnected world that is changing radically, full of disruptive technologies, the key to being lucky is in allowing ourselves to create our own chances, he says.

Superstitious nonsense?

Finally, there is the question of the role superstition can play in how lucky we are.

If you carry around a rabbit's foot or four-leaf clover with you, are you wasting your time?

Yes would seem to be the obvious answer. These totems represent our attempt to impose order on the Universe - and as such this is doomed to failure.

Horseshoe Lucky charms might just be more useful than you think

But a series of experiments by Cologne University suggests there is some role for superstition after all.

In tests, researchers gave some golfers balls, which they told them were "lucky", and in other tests allowed some to carry their own superstitious charms.

In both cases these players performed better than the control group.

The superstitions here seemed to boost the golfers' confidence in their own abilities, and resulting in an enhanced performance.

It is an interesting finding, but none of this necessarily means you should rely just on luck - or your lucky rabbit's foot - when it comes to picking winners from the FTSE, Dow or Nikkei.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Business stories


BBC Business Live

    TESCO PROFITS 09:18:

    Dave Lewis, Tesco chief executive, will not confirm that Chris Bush the managing director is one of the four executives suspended as part of its investigation into its profits reporting. He is speaking to journalists on a conference call.

    MARKET UPDATE 09:16:

    Aside from Tesco the FTSE 100 index is lower by 0.66% at 6,792 just over an hour into the trading day. Tesco is perhaps unsurprisingly the biggest faller. Meanwhile, engineering firm Petrofac is the biggest riser, up 1.72% to 1066p.

    TESCO SHARES 09:11:

    Tesco's share price is beginning to stabilise a little. Having fallen 11.3% on the open to 203.5p, Tesco shares are currently trading 7.99% lower at 211.25p

    TESCO PROFITS 09:01: BBC Radio 4

    James Bevan, chief investment officer at CCLA Investment Management, tells Today the profit warning from Tesco could amount to falsifying accounts. "They have decided to account for profits arising in future periods in the current period, and deferred costs that otherwise should have been recognised. That's really serious."

    TESCO PROFITS 08:57: Via Email

    Richard Hunter, head of equities at Hargreaves Lansdown, says Tesco's profit warning "does not come close to jeopardising overall profitability" at the supermarket, and the market will be happy that at least the bad news is out in the open and being dealt with.

    UK ECONOMY 08:44: BBC Breakfast
    Jeremy Cook

    Breakfast's Steph McGovern is down in London in the financial district talking to Jeremy Cook, chief economist at World First foreign exchange, who says we should be focusing on how strong the UK economy is following the Scottish referendum. Unemployment is down, GDP is growing - "all very very good news".

    TESCO PROFITS Via Twitter

    Sean Farrell on the Guardian's City Desk tweets: "Tesco CEO Lewis: 'This is not in the ordinary course of events. This has been audited by a big reputable firm.'

    TESCO PROFITS 08:35: Radio 5 live

    Four senior Tesco executives including the UK managing director Chris Bush have been suspended, while an investigation into profits reporting is carried out, Adam Parsons says on Radio 5 live. The share price has recovered a bit but is still down more than 9%.

    MINIMUM WAGE 08:21: Radio 5 live

    Shane Brennan from the Association of Convenience Stores says the minimum wage is becoming a "political football" between the main political parties, and warns a rise could hit employees negatively. "When the minimum wage goes up, small retailers cut back on the hours they offer staff," he tells Radio 5 live.

    CHILD BENEFIT 08:18: Radio 5 live

    Ed Balls is talking about the minimum wage on 5 live Breakfast, but he keeps falling off the air. He was half way through explaining how the Labour party wants to extend the child benefit cap - one of those "difficult decisions" necessary to "balance the books".

    TESCO SHARES 08:14:

    Tesco's shares opened down 11.3% at 203.5p - that's its lowest price since May 2003 - more than a decade ago.

    TESCO SHARES 08:09: Breaking News

    Tesco's share price falls by more than 10% in the first few minutes of trading in London.


    Menswear retailer Moss Bros has reported a pre-tax profit of £1.95m for the six months to July. That's slightly lower than their previous guidance and reflects the number of stores that were closed for refit in the first half of this year, the company said. Like for like sales were 6.4% higher.

    TESCO PROFITS Via Twitter Robert Peston Economics editor

    tweets: "Tesco! Oh my giddy aunt. Never thought it would come to this …

    ALIBABA 07:55:

    The Financial Times reports that Alibaba, the Chinese ecommerce group, has boosted the value of its IPO to $25bn (£15bn) by selling extra shares. That makes it the biggest IPO in history. Huge investor demand saw the company's share price surge 38% on its debut on the New York Stock Exchange on Friday.

    TESCO PROFITS Via Twitter

    Richard Hunter from stockbrokers Hargreaves Lansdown tweets: "Profit warning on a profit warning for #Tesco likely to put further pressure on a share price already down 39% over the last year"


    Other news from the stock market this morning: British bank Aldermore says it will float on the London Stock Exchange in October, aiming to raise £75m. Aldermore focuses on lending to small and medium-sized businesses and homeowners.

    TESCO PROFITS Via Twitter Adam Parsons Business Correspondent

    tweets: "Dave Lewis initiated inquiry over weekend. Am told Philip Clarke has officially left Tesco, but remains available to talk to investigation."

    PHONES 4U RESCUE 07:36:
    The Phones 4U shop sign.

    Phone network EE is to buy 58 Phones 4U stores - safeguarding 359 jobs - in a deal with administrator PricewaterhouseCoopers. The phone network was known to have entered negotiations over the weekend. On Friday Vodafone agreed to take over 140 Phones 4U shops.

    TESCO PROFITS Via Twitter Adam Parsons Business Correspondent

    tweets: "Tesco were due to report Interims next week. That has now been cancelled."

    LABOUR CONFERENCE 07:26: BBC Radio 4

    Labour shadow business secretary Chuka Umanna tells Today Labour is pro-business, but says: "What we have been clear about is we can't go back to business as usual and the kind of fast buck culture we saw in some parts of the economy that helped contribute to the 2008/09 crash."

    TESCO PROFITS Via Twitter

    City grandee David Buik tweets: "It never rains but it pours dear old Tesco. It appears profits have been over-stated by £250 mn - shares could be down 5% at the opening."

    TESCO PROFITS 07:15:
    A group of Tesco shopping trolleys

    "We have uncovered a serious issue and have responded accordingly," said Dave Lewis, who took over as the boss of Tesco last month. "The chairman and I have acted quickly to establish a comprehensive independent investigation. The board, my colleagues, our customers and I expect Tesco to operate with integrity and transparency and we will take decisive action as the results of the investigation become clear."

    TESCO PROFITS 07:11: Breaking News

    Tesco has released a statement saying it over-stated its expected profit for the six months to 23 August. In a trading statement on 29 August it said it expected half-year profits to be £1.1bn. It has now revised this down by £250m.

    LISTEN AGAIN Via Twitter Adam Parsons Business Correspondent

    tweets: The #WUTM podcast. All yours:…

    AIR FRANCE 07:03:
    Air France planes

    Pilots at Air France are looking ahead to a second week on strike this morning. France's transport minister Alain Vidalies says the fate of Air France is at stake in the dispute. Pilots are angry that the airline is expanding its budget carrier, which pays pilots less.

    LABOUR ANTI-BUSINESS? 06:55: BBC Radio 4

    Lord Jones tells Today that Labour has not given business the credit it deserves. "Without the wealth that business creates you have no public sector, you have no taxation, you don't have one job in the country. That's how important business is," he says.

    LABOUR ANTI-BUSINESS? 06:51: BBC Radio 4
    Digby Jones

    Lord Digby Jones, former head of the CBI and member of the last Labour government tells Today that Labour is casting doubt on its support for the UK business community. "Whatever the current shadow cabinet say - let's nationalise the banks, let's have a social market in energy, lets increase business taxes, whatever it may be - they are showing by their actions that they actually don't get it," he says.

    DEVOLUTION 06:42: Radio 5 live

    Wake Up to Money has been discussing the prospects for more devolution across the UK in the wake of the "No" vote in Scotland. Tony Travers from the London School of Economics says the UK is one of the most centralised democracies in the world - 95% of tax revenues go straight to the exchequer.

    MINIMUM WAGE 06:35: BBC Radio 4

    Is Labour leader Ed Miliband's pledge to raise the minimum wage to £8 per hour by 2020 anti-business?Simon Walker, head of the Institute of Directors, tells the Today programme he shares many of the Labour party's concerns - on energy prices, zero-hours contracts and wages. "But... we don't agree with Labour's instinct to legislate or regulate on these matters," he says.

    MARKETS 06:29: BBC Breakfast

    Breakfast's Steph McGovern is in the City in London before dawn this morning, talking to analysts and market traders about what's moving the markets after the "No" vote in Scotland last week. She'll be talking to a currency trader later to find out what's going to happen to the pound.

    MINIMUM WAGE 06:18:

    Labour's leader Ed Miliband says Labour will put the minimum wage up to £8 an hour if they win the election next year - up from the £6.50 is due to rise to this October. The unions say that's not enough, and want £10 an hour, while the CBI warns any rise will "put jobs at risk".

    Labour shadow  chancellor Ed Balls

    Ed Balls is expected to say that Labour will reinstate the 50 top rate of tax in his speech to the party conference later today. That's not necessarily news. But Labour haven't been completely clear on whether they would reinstate the 50p tax band until now. The inclusion of the proposal essentially amounts to an election promise eight months out from the general election.

    Phones 4U 06:02: Radio 5 live

    EE has confirmed it's looking into buy a few of those Phones 4 U shops now on the market. Judy Palmer from Begbies Traynor defends EE and Vodafone, the operators accused of helping to put the mobile retailer out of business, on Wake Up to Money calling their actions "commercial hardball".

    06:01: Edwin Lane Business reporter, BBC News

    Hello all. We're also getting the latest on the fate of Phones 4U, after it went into administration last week. Get in touch with us on or tweet us @BBCBusiness.

    0600: Matthew West Business Reporter

    Morning folks. We start the day with news that luxury shoe brand Jimmy Choo is looking at a stock market float in London, there are also half year results from Moss Bros. The Labour party conference goes into its second full day with a speech from shadow chancellor Ed Balls. It's his last conference speech before the election so we'll bring you any nuggets from that too. Stay with us.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.