The cat-and-mouse world of US tax

US $100 bills

Related Stories

US companies are involved in chasing a number of headline-grabbing deals at the moment, with rationales that tie-ups would be good for the businesses.

Drugs giant Pfizer is looking to buy UK firm AstraZeneca in a multi-billion dollar deal, and General Electric (GE) is busy pursuing French engineering giant Alstom.

But could tax avoidance be one of the reasons US firms are so keen to buy foreign companies?

Pfizer's deal, for instance, would see it moving its top company to the UK for tax purposes.

US multinationals have big incentives to invest foreign funds abroad, according to tax campaigners.

The US has one of the highest rates of corporation tax in the world - a whopping 35%, compared with 21% in the UK, just 12.5% in Ireland, and zero in tax havens such as Bermuda and the Cayman Islands.

Keeping money offshore is therefore one way to avoid the high US tax rate.

Pfizer drug capsules Pfizer wants to move its top company to the UK to take advantage of a lower tax rate
'More efficient' structure

The proposed Pfizer deal would help the multinational use some of its $69bn pile of offshore cash, according to the Tax Justice Network.

Start Quote

This prevents investment [coming] fully back into the US where it is needed”

End Quote Kyle Pomerleau Tax Foundation economist

"What seems quite clear is that tax avoidance has played an important part in starting the original [Pfizer] bid," Tax Justice Network executive director John Christensen says.

Pfizer told the BBC that there were strategic business reasons for the proposed deal, but admitted it would give "a more efficient tax structure".

The companies would potentially operate as "as [a] new, UK-domiciled combined company" that "would not subject AstraZeneca's non-US profits to US tax, which would be in the best interests of the combined company's shareholders".

In addition, UK companies are "subject to little or no tax on profits generated in non-UK jurisdictions when they are repatriated".

"Consequently, the current contemplated structure would place us on a more even competitive playing field and would again be in the best interests of the combined company's shareholders," Pfizer said.

Structural problem?

US corporations have billions sitting offshore that could be taxed if the money were brought back to the US, Mr Christensen says. For example, General Electric has around $108bn held offshore, according to Bloomberg.

Jeffrey Immelt outside the Elysee Palace General Electric chief executive Jeffrey Immelt leaves the Elysee Palace after Alstom deal discussions with French President Francois Hollande

GE declined to comment on its tax arrangements or the Alstom negotiations.

However, a source close to GE told the BBC that the firm is not chasing the Alstom deal for tax reasons, but for business purposes.

Start Quote

Offshore companies milk the onshore companies”

End Quote John Christensen Tax Justice Network

In addition, the $108bn held overseas has been reinvested and is not held as cash, the source said, adding that while GE does have $57bn cash outside the US, that is held by GE Capital, which uses it for investments.

Commentators agree that the reason companies are so keen to invest abroad lies with the US tax system and the high tax rates it imposes.

As soon as companies try to bring profits back into the US, they may be liable for tax so they go to great efforts to keep them offshore.

"This prevents investment [coming] fully back into the US where it is needed," says Tax Foundation economist Kyle Pomerleau.

Tax avoidance 'games'

US multinationals are involved in a cat-and-mouse game with US tax authorities, and use some very creative strategies to minimise income tax payments, the Tax Justice Network says.

Common tax avoidance strategies include assigning intellectual property rights to foreign subsidiaries, and then paying the subsidiaries to use a brand, trademark, patent or licence.

Jobsons Cove. Bermuda Tax havens such as Bermuda add to incentives for US firms to keep their earnings offshore

"You charge an onshore subsidiary for the use of a brand, but the brand belongs to an offshore company," he says.

Foreign subsidiaries are also used to charge high management fees to a parent company.

"Offshore companies milk the onshore companies," he adds. "These are the kinds of games that are played."

In addition, multinationals load foreign acquisitions with tax deductable debt to move money offshore, he says

Keeping shareholders happy

Companies also use share buyback schemes as part of their strategy. Apple, which has tens of billions of dollars overseas, is in the curious situation of taking on debt for a share buyback scheme to placate shareholders back home missing out on dividends.

In a share buyback scheme, a company can pay a premium price to buy a limited number of shares from each shareholder.

"It's a way of keeping shareholders happy," economist and anti-poverty campaigner Richard Murphy says. "It's not profitable in the US to provide dividends."

A premium price has a positive effect on the value of the company's shares in general, which adds to shareholder contentment, Mr Murphy adds.

Apple customer New York Apple, which makes billions in profits, has taken on debt to finance its share buyback programme.
Reform on the horizon?

Some estimates put the amount of US cash kept abroad at $1.5 trillion.

Nevertheless, multinational firms "would like to be able to bring money back to the US without paying a big tax", says Columbia Law School professor Michael Graetz.

And in fact some US corporations do opt to bring huge chunks of cash home.

Ebay recently said it would repatriate almost $9bn as "it would make more sense to have more cash in the US for mergers and acquisitions".

There are a number of efforts in the US and elsewhere to try to reform tax rules.

Republican congressman Dave Camp has been among US politicians attempting to introduce a draft tax reform act which aims to lower corporation tax.

The OECD is in the process of coming up with rules designed to tackle "base erosion and profit shifting", which involves companies using mismatches in tax rules to make profits "disappear" legally.

However, these efforts may take many years to come to fruition.

In the meantime, the cat-and-mouse game between multinationals and tax authorities continues.

More on This Story

Related Stories

More Business stories


BBC Business Live

    OIL PRICE FALL 11:55:
    A general view shows the PetroChina"s Daqing oil field in China"s northeastern Heilongjiang province

    The price of Brent crude oil has fallen to its lowest level since June 2012. At one point it hit $96.81 a barrel with weak Chinese economic data blamed for the fall. That's because China is now the largest consumer of energy, so a slowdown in economic output, and specifically factory output, dents the price due.

    alibaba sign

    This will be a big deal in the business world later this week. The giant Chinese internet firm Alibaba will sell shares for the first time in New York. On World Business Report, Stuart Miles founder of the technology website says it's not clear how Alibaba will fare outside China, as Chinese firms have often struggled abroad.

    'WINDY' MCKINSEY 11:23:
    Mckinsey website

    Lucy Kellaway skewers McKinsey, the giant consulting firm in her column in the Financial Times today. As part of the firm's 50th anniversary it has written a long piece about the future of business. She describes it as a "sorry exercise in windy platitudes". Her own forecast is that in fifty years "McKinsey won't exist".

    HOUSE PRICES 11:09:

    Within the latest figures from Rightmove is some interesting trend data. Wales, the West Midlands and the North West are lagging behind the rest of England and Wales. The three regions showed falls in asking prices of between 0.8% (the North West) and 1.8% (the West Midlands). The remaining seven regions all saw an increase in property asking prices although London saw one of the most muted rises at just 0.9%.

    OECD WARNING 10:56:

    The OECD, which is a sort of economic think tank funded by the world's wealthy nations, has warned that the euro area is at risk of "prolonged stagnation", unless steps are taken to boost demand. The OECD has welcomed recent action by the European Central Bank but says other measures including quantitative easing are needed.

    Hamburg, Germany

    Some rare positive economic news for the eurozone. The region's trade surplus was 21.2bn euros (£16.9bn) in July. That's the second biggest monthly surplus ever according to Reuters. Strong exports to Britain, the United States and China were behind the healthy numbers.

    India market

    A boost for the newish Indian government of Narendra Modi. In August wholesale price inflation slowed to the lowest rate in almost five years. A drop in the price of fuel and metals helped depress the wholesale price index to an annual rate of 3.74%, from 5.19% in July. Persistent inflation has been a big problem for the economy.


    Vodafone says it's not to blame for the demise of Phones 4U. We "strongly reject any suggestion we behaved inappropriately" during negotiations with Phones 4U, it says. Phones 4U managers told Vodafone that they had little flexibility to negotiate due to the "debt repayment obligations".

    HOUSE PRICES 09:55:
    A row of houses for sale in a London street

    The UK housing market has seen a pick up in activity earlier than usual after the traditional summer break, according to the property website Rightmove. It says asking prices jumped 0.9% between August and September to £264,875 on average in England and Wales. That's the first time property asking prices have risen in September in three years, usually they fall around 0.5% in the month.

    Financial Times

    Senior figures in Silicon Valley are worried about a backlash against the tech industry, according to the lead article on the front page of today's Financial Times. It quotes the well known investor Peter Thiel who says Silicon Valley is "quite oblivious" over concerns about privacy and security, particularly in Europe.

    A Greggs the baker shop front

    It's been a good couple of months for Greggs the baker with like-for-like sales up 4% in the first three months of its new financial year, suggesting its new focus on the lunchtime crowd and meal deals is paying off. Lower commodity prices have helped as well, it said in a trading update earlier this morning. Shares are 12.5% higher to 603.55p in early trading in London.

    GAMBLING WATCHDOG 09:08: Radio 5 live
    Computer, Roulette wheel

    The betting industry is announcing the creation of an independent gambling watchdog and restrictions on advertising. The industry has been "listening to customers" says Carl Leaver, chief executive of Gala Coral on Radio 5 live. There was concern over children being exposed to advertising and sign-up offers, which offered free bets, he said.


    "There is still a lot of advertising money in the newspaper" says FT editor Lionel Barber of the City newspaper's makeover on the Today programme. The makeover of the newspaper is part of a new digital first strategy at the FT. The digital first strategy is "the same as many other newspapers are following," Mr Barber says.

    MARKET UPDATE 08:49:

    European markets generally are lower this morning with investors looking ahead to a meeting of US Federal Reserve policymakers later this week.

    Via Twitter Kamal Ahmed BBC Business editor

    tweets: "Rob Wood, chief UK economist, Berenberg: Yes vote "would make Brexit from EU more likely because Scotland is relatively pro-EU" #indyref"

    Heineken plant

    Heineken has opened 2.6% on the Dutch stock market this morning after its rejection of a takeover bid from rival brewer SABMiller. Shares in SABMiller have jumped 5% in London.

    PHONES 4U 08:25:

    Shares in Dixons Carphone have risen more than 3% following the demise of rival Phones 4U. Vodafone is down 0.9%.

    Lufthansa planes

    There will be no Lufthansa flights from Frankfurt on Tuesday as the airline's pilots are holding an eight hour strike. Pilots are wrangling with the airline over an early retirement scheme. A strike last week grounded flights at Munich airport.

    PHONES 4U 08:11: Radio 5 live

    Network operators like EE and Vodafone are keen to grab the market of independent phone sellers like Phones 4U because other parts of the business are struggling, says Rahul Sharma a retail consultant and director of Neev Capital on Radio 5 live. For example, he mentions that the European Union has cracked down on roaming charges.

    Air France

    Air France expects that more than half of its flights will be cancelled today due to a week-long strike by pilots. Advice for passengers can be found here. The protest, which started today, is over a shift of jobs and operations to a low cost carrier. Many of Air France's European services are transferring to Transavia.

    • Vodafone rejects claim it undermined Phones 4U
    • Striking pilots ground half of Air France services
    • Heineken rejects takeover bid from SAB Miller
    APPLE TV? 07:52: BBC Radio 4
    The new iPhone 6

    "TV is one of those things that if we're really honest is stuck back in the 70's," says Tim Cook, the boss of Apple in a US television interview. "The interface is terrible... Think about how much has changed," he said, fuelling speculation that Apple is planning a big push into the TV business.

    DEVOLUTION 07:44: BBC Radio 4

    "What we are asking for is the full devolution £22.5bn worth of public expenditure in the Greater Manchester area," says Mr Blond. That equates to about 1,000 different funding lines from Whitehall. Manchester could, in time, even raise its own taxes. He claims adding the government already thinks this is "the only way to go".

    DEVOLUTION 07:32: BBC Radio 4

    So if Scotland votes Yes to independence on Thursday, what next for the rest of the UK? More devolution says the think-tank ResPublica. "We're already on the road towards a federal state and we desperately need it," Philip Blond, director of the think-tank tells the Today programme, adding Manchester should go first. "Devolving powers would allow Manchester to become a net contributor to the economy rather than a burden to the State, he adds.

    PHONES 4U 07:28:

    Phones 4U was bought by private equity group BC Partners in 2011. It is particularly upset with Vodafone. Stefano Quadrio Curzio, a representative of BC Partners, said: "Their behaviour appears to have been designed to inflict the maximum damage to their partner of 15 years, giving Phones 4U no time to develop commercial alternatives."

    Via Twitter Adam Parsons Business Correspondent

    tweets: "Phones4U: "All mobile contracts bought through Phones 4u remain unaffected.. networks will continue to provide mobile services" @bbc5live"

    Via Twitter Stephanie McGovern Breakfast business reporter

    tweets: "Phones 4U says orders not already dispatched will be cancelled + payments refunded. Call customer service to find out if dispatched or not."


    "The sort of business people I know, by and large, are not making a political statement but pointing out the outcomes of a Yes or No vote," says Patrick MacDonald the former boss of John Menzies on the Today programme. "They are just trying to be honest with their customers and staff," he adds. He won't be drawn on changes to his own business though. "There will be long period of negotiation [in the event of a Yes vote] and lots of lawyers involved.

    FT, WSJ

    The Financial Times has been through a makeover. The front page has a new layout, with a briefing section on the right hand side of the front page. There's also a new typeface, called Financier. The opinion of the BBC Business desk is that it looks a bit more like the Wall Street Journal - except it's still pink of course.


    The editor of the Financial Times, Lionel Barber, tells the Today programme that business leaders have been "saying privately" for months that shop prices will diverge and that there will be significant economic costs to independence. "We know [Cabinet Secretary] Jeremy Heywood has been on the phone to business leaders asking them to speak up about their concerns, "Mr Barber adds.

    Russia flag

    "They'll definitely retaliate," says Nina Schick, analyst at Open Europe (a think tank which focuses on European Union reform). On Wake Up to Money she was asked whether Russia will hit back against last week's sanctions imposed by the EU. Exports of EU clothing and cars are likely targets she says. Russia may also close its airspace to western airlines. Putin is ready to put his people through economic pain Ms Schick says.

    SCOTLAND PERSONAL FINANCE 06:28: Radio 5 live

    Wake Up to Money looks at what an independent Scotland would mean for personal finances. For example, you are only allowed to invest in an ISA if you live in the UK. The new Scottish government would perhaps set up its own tax free scheme, says Clare Francis, editor-in-chief at

    HEINEKEN TAKEOVER BID 06:13: Radio 5 live
    Heineken beer crates

    So what should we make of this takeover bid from Heineken from SAB Miller? SAB Miller has been considered a takeover target itself, so it could be bolstering its place in the market, says Euan Stirling on Wake Up to Money. There is a strong business logic for brewers to get bigger. They have expensive distribution networks, so plugging in new products is "pretty fantastic" he adds.

    PHONES 4U 06:05: Radio 5 live

    Network operators like Vodafone and EE consider independent phone sellers like Phones 4U as a "necessary evil" says Euan Stirling from Standard Life Investments on Wake Up to Money. But Phones 4U did not have the clout to be necessary he argues. Its collapse leaves Carphone Warehouse (recently merged with Dixons) in a stronger position, says Mr Stirling.

    PHONES 4U 06:00: Radio 5 live
    Phones 4U logo

    So why is Phones 4U facing administration? Well it was "heavily indebted" says Euan Stirling from Standard Life Investments on Wake Up to Money. And when the network operators withdrew their support, the company had nothing to sell, he said.

    06:00: Ben Morris Business Reporter

    Welcome to the week. If you want to get in touch, email us at or tweet @bbcbusiness.

    06:00: Matthew West Business reporter

    Morning, we've seen mobile phone retailer Phones 4U announce overnight that it is going into administration and Dutch brewer Heineken has rejected a takeover offer from rival SABMiller. There's more house price data coming up and we'll get the latest health check (of sorts) on Britain's high street shops a little later. Stay with us.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.