Shale industry faces global reality check

Shale gas facility The shale industry faces a number of obstacles in the UK and globally

As US energy costs tumble on the back of shale oil and gas, the rest of the world is gripped with envy.

Just four years ago, natural gas prices in Europe were roughly comparable with those in the US; now they are three times higher. In Japan, they are five times higher.

Understandably, countries around the world want a piece of the action.

Governments from the UK and Poland to China and Argentina are dreaming of cheap power and, just as importantly for some, energy security. Shale, many have decided, is the answer.

But can the shale gas revolution in the US really be replicated around the world?

'Failed experiment'
Fuelling the future

Poland was seen as the poster boy for European shale gas but, according to Stuart Elliott, managing editor at the industry information provider Platts, "the Polish experiment has been a failure to date".

Enticed by seemingly abundant reserves and a government keen to kick-start production, US energy majors moved in, hoping to replicate their domestic success on foreign shores.

Thirty to 40 wells were planned for 2013. To date, there is just one well producing enough gas to be economically viable.

Biggest shale gas resources

  • China, 1,115
  • Argentina, 802
  • Algeria, 707
  • US, 665
  • Canada, 573
  • Mexico, 545
  • Australia, 437
  • South Africa, 390
  • Russia, 285
  • Brazil, 254

Source: US Energy Information Administration (EIA). Figures show technically recoverable resources in trillions of cubic feet of gas.

Exxon Mobil, Talisman and Marathon have all pulled out, while Chevron, Conoco Phillips and San Leon are persevering.

Much of the blame has been laid at the door of the government, which got "greedy and stupid", according to Prof Paul Stevens, senior research fellow at the Chatham House think tank.

A punitive tax regime and an insistence that foreign companies work with local partners did much to dampen enthusiasm, although the government has since made its regulatory regime more attractive to overseas investors.

But more significant for the wider shale industry in Europe, says Prof Stevens, were comments made by Exxon's chief executive. The technology that had proved so successful in the US did not work on Polish geology, Rex Tillerson said.

'High suspicions'

The UK government is another that has high hopes for shale, but only a handful of test wells have been drilled in the past four years. In the US, more than 100 wells were needed before the industry was satisfied that shale gas was viable.

This inactivity is largely due to public opposition to fracking - the process of drilling for shale gas - and an 18-month moratorium on drilling following concerns about earth tremors.

How fracking recovers natural gas from shale

"Suspicions are high so the regulatory regime needs to be very robust," says John Williams, senior principal at Poyry Management Consulting. "Everything needs to be gold-plated - any slip-ups and it's game over. This is why we haven't really moved forward."

And opposition will not go away.

Concerns about water contamination, earthquakes and disruption to rural communities have captured the public imagination, but experts suggest we may be worrying about the wrong things.

"The argument that fracking damages the water supply doesn't stack up, and any disruption would be fairly short-lived," says Prof Stevens.

Concerns about earthquakes were always something of a red herring.

"The legitimate concerns," says Prof Stevens, "are 'What do we do with the waste water - there are nasty heavy metals and radioactivity [deep under ground]?' There is also the question of fugitive methane - we simply don't know how much leakage there is."

He also points out that while shale gas may be less polluting than coal and oil, it is still a fossil fuel. "If we have any hope of hitting our two-degree [climate change] target, burning gas is not the way.

"Diverting investment from renewables is also a genuine concern".

Fracking protest in France Anti-fracking protests have taken place in several countries around the world

And opposition is not confined to the UK. Protests have taken place around the world, with activists from more than 20 countries signing up to Global Frackdown day last year. France has banned fracking, while moratoriums have been put in place in Germany, Romania and Bulgaria.

Basic research

But public opposition, partly because Europe is more densely populated than the US, where people are far more familiar with oil and gas operations, is just one of many factors holding back shale development.

For a start, environmental regulation is far stronger in Europe.

Biggest shale oil resources

  • Russia, 75
  • US, 58
  • China, 32
  • Argentina, 27
  • Libya, 26
  • Australia, 18
  • Venezuela, 13
  • Mexico, 13
  • Pakistan, 9
  • Canada, 9

Source: EIA. Figures show technically recoverable resources in billion barrels of oil.

There has also been relatively little government investment in research and development outside America. The US government ploughed millions of dollars into basic scientific research in the early 1980s, while the European Commission wants the industry itself to make these investments in R&D. This is by no means a given.

After all, the US shale industry did not appear overnight, but has developed over the past 25 years.

Property rights are also key, says Prof Stevens. In the US, homeowners usually own the minerals under their land, so they can agree a price and hand over the rights to an energy company. In Europe, the state tends to own the minerals, and no-one is going to let an energy company rip up their land without a fight.

Add to this questions about the suitability of the geology in many countries and the lack of infrastructure and pipelines, and it is clear that the barriers to a shale revolution outside the US are considerable and numerous.

There are also questions about the ultimate impact of shale on energy prices in Europe, which operates an integrated market across the continent.

Forecasts by Poyry suggest wholesale gas prices might be between 6% and 14% lower over the period 2020-50, while electricity prices might be between 3% and 8% cheaper. The impact on household spending would be lower, as the wholesale price is just one component of energy bills.

These figures suggest the impact of shale on energy prices in Europe would be far less significant than in the US.

Ambitious targets

One country where the prospects for shale do look brighter is China.

"Gas demand is set to rocket and they are looking to spend billions on shale," says Mr Elliott. The government plans to produce about one-third of the current US shale gas capacity by 2020.

Shale gas test well in India India drilled its first shale gas test well last November

Experts view this target as ambitious to say the least, but the country has the right geology, a cheap labour market, far fewer regulatory obstacles and, so far, relatively little public opposition.

The main issue is water. Much of China's shale reserves are located in the north west of the country, which is extremely arid. This is a "major sticking point", says Mr Elliott.

And despite the government's grand plans, so far all China's efforts to exploit its abundant shale resources have come to nothing. In fact, while there are thousands of shale wells in the US, there are only a handful producing commercial quantities of gas in the whole of the rest of the world.

Mr Williams thinks it will be eight to 10 years before China is producing a significant amount of shale energy, let alone enough to affect the overall price of gas. And this in a country where there are relatively few barriers to entry.

For the rest of the world, then, any significant shale production within this timescale seems wholly unrealistic. "You can forget about the next five to 10 years," says Prof Stevens. "Fifteen to 20 is a possibility".

Those governments looking to shale as a quick fix for high energy prices and security of supply may, then, have unrealistic expectations. Shale may not be the saviour that many hope it to be.

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Business stories

RSS

BBC Business Live

  1.  
    RBS RESULTS Via Twitter Kamal Ahmed BBC Business editor

    tweets: RBS Ross McEwan says UK recovery "broader than a consumer recovery". Gross lending to businesses up.

     
  2.  
    RBS RESULTS 08:41:

    More market musings on RBS. Chirantan Barua, an analyst at Sanford C. Bernstein, says the reduction in money set aside for bad loans was "extremely strong" compared with City expectations. Sales and capital were better than he expected too, he said. He reckons the shares may be worth 440p apiece.

     
  3.  
    RBS RESULTS Via Twitter Kamal Ahmed BBC Business editor

    tweets: RBS CEO Ross McEwan says there has been a cooling in the mortgage and housing market over the last two months. "That is not a bad thing."

     
  4.  
    MARKET UPDATE 08:24:

    European markets are lower today with investors focused on earnings news and economic data release. The biggest rise on the FTSE 100 is perhaps unsurprisingly RBS - up 10.07% or 33.10p so far to 361.9p after it took everyone by surprise by announcing first-half pre-tax profits of £2.65bn a week early.

    • The FTSE 100 is 0.28% lower at 6806.49
    • The Dax is down 0.22% to 9772.94
    • The Cac-40 has fallen 0.50% at 4138.73
     
  5.  
    RBS RESULTS 08:11:

    Vivek Raja, an analyst at Oriel Securities, is one of the first out of the traps with some insight into what the RBS results mean. "The preannouncement reflects better than expected operating performance on credit performance, in the Bad Bank (RBS Capital Resolution) and on capital ratios," he says. So that means 1) loans are performing better, 2) the worst loans are performing better, and 3) the bank has more capital as a percentage of loans.

     
  6.  
    VODAFONE 07:56:
    People walk past a Vodafone shop

    Vodafone's first quarter trading shows the mobile operator getting no relief from its European market. Group service revenue - that's customers buying handsets and using the Vodafone network to you and me - was £6.4bn in the three months to 30 June, down 7.9% on the same period last year. Competition and regulation "continue to create a challenging operating environment," it says.

     
  7.  
    LLOYDS SETTLEMENT 07:41:
    A general view of a sign for Lloyds Bank

    Lloyds Banking Group has responded to recent stories regarding settlements "with a number of government agencies" regarding rates setting - Libor. It's in "late-stage" discussions, it says.

     
  8.  
     
  9.  
    RBS RESULTS 07:27:
    RBS

    "Asset quality continued to improve in the UK and Ireland," says what was once the world's largest bank. In English, more of their loans are more likely to be repaid in full and on time. The bank has set aside £22.4bn against bad loans, down from £25.2bn in December. Ulster bank posted a modest profit of £55m - that's from a £381m loss a year ago.

     
  10.  
    BSKYB PROFITS 07:20:
    British Sky Broadcasting headquarters

    BSkyB has reported a slight slip in annual pre-tax profit to £1,1bn compared with £1,2bn a year earlier. Tax for the year was £249m compared with £295m in 2013, an effective tax rate of 21% as a result of the reduction in the rate of UK corporation tax.

     
  11.  
    RBS RESULTS 07:16:

    Pre-tax profit was £2.65bn, up from £1.37bn as impairments dropped like a stone -- down to £269m from £2.15bn. Those reductions in bad loan costs far outweighed a rise in restructuring costs and a drop in sales. £150m was added to provisions for Payment Protection Insurance (PPI) and £100m to interest rate swap provisions.

     
  12.  
    RBS RESULTS 07:08: Breaking News

    A turn up for the books. Royal Bank of Scotland Group has put out its first-half results early. They were due 1 August, according to the bank. Operating profit rose to £2.6bn from £708m in 2013.

     
  13.  
    BALFOUR MERGER 07:02:
    A Balfour Beatty workman on a construction site

    UK construction firm Balfour Beatty is in talks with rival Carillion about a potential £3.05bn merger, it has emerged. The two companies confirmed what they described as "preliminary discussions." In a joint statement they said they believed a "merger of the two groups has the potential to create a market leading services, investments, and construction business of considerable depth and scale."

     
  14.  
    DISCOUNT STORES 06:51: Radio 5 live

    Look out for Hussein Lalani, co-founder and commercial director of the 99p stores, on 5 live. He says before the recession suppliers would just give them their leftovers. Now many brands are making products just for the discount market.

     
  15.  
    GDP FIGURES 06:40: BBC Radio 4

    Marian Bell, economist and former member of the Bank of England's Monetary Policy Committee has been talking to the Today programme about the UK's economic recovery. She says it is "people are expecting a 0.9% rise in output and that would be sufficient to surpass the 2008 level." But it has taken more time to achieve that economic recovery than in the past. In fact, she says, it has been "the longest that output has been below its previously level for more than 100 years."

     
  16.  
    GDP FIGURES 06:27: Radio 5 live

    Elaine Coverley, head of equity research at Brewin Dolphin is on Wake up to Money. "We need other markets to keep that going," she says of growing UK gross domestic product. Markets like the US aren't doing so well. The IMF slashed its US economic growth estimate on Wednesday to 1.7% for 2014.

     
  17.  
    GDP FIGURES 06:11: Radio 5 live

    "The consumer is doing a lot of the heavy lifting," in the economy, says economist Alan Clarke of Scotiabank on 5 live. How, when wages are stagnant? The housing market, of course. As the value of homes rises, people are prepared to save less and spend more without earning more. House prices won't go up at the current rate forever, though, he says.

     
  18.  
    GDP FIGURES 06:03: Radio 5 live

    CBI director-general, John Cridland is still on 5 live. The recovery is currently investment-led rather than export-led. Sterling's strength isn't helping but isn't wholly choking things off either, he says.

     
  19.  
    GDP FIGURES 06:01: Radio 5 live

    Director-General of the Confederation of British Industry John Cridland expects growth of 0.8% in the second quarter, he tells 5 live. "We are getting some balance in the recovery, like a boxer in the boxing ring finding his feet," he says. Companies are investing, finally, he says, and that's crucial. This is what will add to wages.

     
  20.  
    06:00: Howard Mustoe Business reporter

    Good morning! Please get in touch via email on bizlivepage@bbc.co.uk or via twitter @BBCBusiness

     
  21.  
    06:00: Matthew West Business Reporter

    Good morning. So, let's catch up from last night: Amazon had a tough second quarter, as did General Motors. And the International Monetary Fund downgraded its global economic growth forecast. Here at home it's as good as confirmed that the UK is richer than it has ever been (you literally have never had it so good, you lucky, lucky people). Do you feel richer than you did last year? How about last week? Or yesterday even? We'll find out at 09:30 with second quarter GDP, so stay with us.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.