Pension freedoms based on 'uncertain assumptions'

Pensioners in a row More choice for pensioners in the Budget - but at what cost to the taxpayer?

The Budget's pension changes are based on "highly uncertain assumptions", according to a respected think-tank.

The Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) questioned estimates about the increased tax revenue the new scheme would initially generate.

But it said the plan was "one of the biggest shake ups seen in a long time".

IFS Director Paul Johnson said the liberalisation had clear advantages and would give pensioners new freedoms to make choices over their own affairs.

He added: "It will likely increase the incentive to save in a pension."

Chancellor George Osborne expects the pension changes to increase government revenues, at least in the first few years, because more people will be able to make taxable withdrawals from their funds.


It is a familiar Budget ritual.

There are headlines on the day and scrutiny of the detail on day two. The Institute for Fiscal Studies says the Treasury has fallen into "bad habits" by planning tax cuts up front to be funded with less certain revenue-raising measures further down the line.

The IFS says the old chestnut of cracking down on tax avoidance is one example of unpredictable tax-raising assumptions.

There is debate around the Treasury's assumption that the liberalisation of the pension market will raise revenue. But Treasury sources have been out and about defending the numbers in the Budget papers.

They are determined to avoid a repeat of Budgets where measures look flakier the day after the big speech.

The government predicts increased income tax receipts of up to £1.2bn in 2018-19, based on an assessment that 30% of people in defined pension contribution schemes will opt to take out their pension at a faster rate than via an annuity.

'More expensive'

But Mr Johnson, said that "depends on highly uncertain behavioural assumptions about when people take the money".

The IFS calculates that the increased tax receipts will peak in 2018/19 and then decline. Within 20 years the policy will actually be increasing the deficit.

The chancellor's changes are partly a response to worries that annuities - the most common option for current pensions, which offer a guaranteed income for life - are not giving customers the best value for money.

But Mr Johnson said the new rules could create even bigger problems.

"It will likely make annuities even more expensive for those who do want to buy them.

"The market will become much thinner and there will be greater levels of adverse selection - only those expecting to live a long time will want to buy an annuity, thereby driving up the price.

David Cameron and children More generous child care, but the IFS wonders if it makes a difference
Permanent give-away

Gemma Tetlow IFS director of pensions, saving and public finances research said: "The chancellor has been getting into some bad habits of late with a series of policies that weaken and increase the risk to the long run public finances.

"In this latest budget he has a £5bn permanent give-away matched by temporary takeaways and uncertain cuts to spending."

The IFS also said that increased choice for pensioners in the way they managed their pensions could lead to more mistakes.

People aged 60 or 65 are known to underestimate their own life expectancy and especially the likelihood of living to extreme old age, he explained.

The chancellor has dismissed fears people might "blow" their pension pots, adding that pensioners were "responsible people who are capable of making decisions about their future".

An extension to tax-free childcare has also been criticised by the IFS. The scheme has "been made more generous but magically, at no extra cost," Mr Johnson said.

Smoker exhaling Smokescreen - increasing tax on smokers brings in far less than it should

IFS Senior Research Economist David Phillips said that it was debatable whether £7bn spent annually on child care was money well spent, "as there is little evidence as to whether it increases adult employment or improves children's outcomes."

'Chopping and changing'

The IFS said that some of the tax increases would not be as effective as they appeared. An increase in the tobacco duty should in theory raise an extra £795m .

But it said the real number it is only likely to raise £135m because smokers will respond to the increase by cutting down, giving up or smuggling cigarettes.

Mr Johnson praised the "consistency" in increases to personal income tax allowances, and reductions in corporation tax, but criticised "chopping and changing" in business policies like investment allowances.

Cuts in savings taxes were also welcomed, but Mr Johnson concluded the Budget still "leaves us with as little sense as we had before of quite how the very large public spending cuts still in the pipeline will actually be delivered".

More on This Story

From other news sites

More Business stories


Business Live

    08:53: Business Mattes World Service
    Royal Enfield

    Can India's cities become cleaner and greener? Business Matters on the World Service is live from Chennai all week. In the first programme Fergus Nicoll asks whether the infrastructure is fit for purpose - and visits an Indian success story with its roots in Britain: Royal Enfield motorcycles. Listen here.

    08:41: Barclays
    Barclays shares

    Shares in Barclays are down 2.3%, or 6.15p, at 256.6p in morning trading in London. The stock has not moved much over the past 12 months given that it's just 8.7p higher than the price on March 4 last year.

    08:27: Ford BBC Radio 4
    Ford Mustang

    Jim Farley, Ford's European president, tells presenter Simon Jack on Today that he hopes Britain does not leave the European Union. One in three engines made by the company comes from the UK, which he described as the "centrepiece" of its global enterprise. Asked about the Russian market, Farley said Ford believed in it in the long term but admitted that some short-term adjustments were required because of the volatile economy.

    08:14: Taylor Wimpey results

    If you're a house builder and you're not making piles of money, then something is very wrong. Fortunately for Taylor Wimpey that is not the case. Annual pre-tax profits are up two thirds to £450m before one-off deductions as 12,454 homes were completed across the UK - 758 more than in 2013 - with an 11.5% rise in average selling price to £213,000.

    07:56: Barclays results

    While Mr Jenkins takes his first annual bonus with Barclays, the overall 2014 bonus pool for the bank is down £520m to £1.86bn. Most of the total - £1.05bn - goes to the investment bank. Its capital ratio, a measure of strength against unexpected losses, is up to 10.3% from 9.1%.

    07:44: Barclays results BBC Radio 4

    Barclays chief Antony Jenkins is on Today. The bank is the healthiest it has been since the financial crisis, he says. Changing culture at the bank takes a long time, Mr Jenkins adds, but the "vast majority" of his 130,000 bankers "want to do the right thing". He is taking a bonus of £1.1m after the "huge amount of progress" the bank has made. Asked about the topic du jour, Mr Jenkins says he pays all his tax in the UK and as a US green card holder.

    07:37: Barclays results

    Barclays wrote down the value of its education, social housing and local authority loan portfolio by £935m. Last year the portfolio was valued at just less than £16bn, but at that time, the lender reclassified the loans as "level 3" assets. That's City-speak for loans you cannot value easily because they don't sell very often.

    07:24: Direct Line results
    Direct Line website

    It's been a good 2014 for Direct Line, with pre-tax profits up 12% to £456.8m and a windfall of £430m from the sale of its international business. Shareholders will pocket total dividends of 27.2p per share, up from 20.6p in 2013. Harvey Keitel probably pocked a pretty penny too for featuring in its TV ads.

    07:16: Barclays results

    Antony Jenkins will take his first bonus as chief executive of the lender: £1.1m. The bank also said it would increase its provision for payment protection insurance (PPI) by £200m for the last three months of 2014, taking the year's total to £1.1bn. Excluding these provisions and other things the bank considers one-offs, pre-tax profit rose 12% to £5.5bn. But including the nasties, the figure sank 21% to £2.26bn.

    07:03: Barclays results

    Barclays have posted their 2014 results. They have set aside an extra £750m after those investigations for foreign exchange manipulation, taking the pot to £1.25bn.

    06:53: Barclays BBC Radio 4

    Chris Wheeler, of Atlantic Equities, has also popped up on Today. He tells Simon Jack that Barclays is doing only "averagely well ... it's still work in progress". He expects pre-tax profits to be about £5.2bn when the bank reports its annual results at 7am.

    06:35: Markets performance Radio 5 live

    Justin Urquhart-Stewart of 7 Investments is still on 5 live. "We are dealing with companies that make a profit and make things," he says of the Nasdaq's rally. The dotcom boom was based on companies that failed to make money, although "we have to be wary" because markets in 2015 are gorged on cheap money and cheap debt.

    06:23: Barclays results Radio 5 live

    Chris Wheeler of Atlantic Equities is talking about Barclays. £5.2bn pretax profits are on the cards for the bank in its annual results, he estimates - a tad ahead of last year's result. However, "it's the return on equity that counts", he says. The bank is struggling to make 10%, which for a high-risk endeavour like banking is not where you want that figure, Wheeler adds. Results come at 07:00.

    06:11: Markets performance Radio 5 live

    Justin Urquhart-Stewart of 7 Investments is on 5 live as the markets guest. "You have a global economy in pretty good shape and in the eurozone some better figures," he says, following soaring US markets. The FTSE 100 may grow further if there's better sentiment from China, he adds.

    06:02: Mobile World Congress Radio 5 live

    Rory Cellan-Jones, technology correspondent, is in Barcelona at the Mobile World Congress. Sony chief executive Kazuo Hirai is "making some tough decisions" and focusing Sony on things like films and games and camera technology: the areas that make money, he tells 5 live. Like many companies, it's finding mobile phones a tricky market.

    06:00: Chris Johnston Business reporter

    Get in touch via email or on twitter @BBCBusiness

    06:00: Howard Mustoe Business reporter

    Good morning! US stocks hit record levels, with both the Dow Jones and the S&P 500 closing at all-time highs and the Nasdaq breaking the 5,000 barrier for the first time in 15 years. Is that going to last? Stay tuned for more.



  • Mukesh SinghNo remorse

    Delhi bus rapist says victim shouldn't have fought back

  • Aimen DeanI spied

    The founder member of al-Qaeda who worked for MI6

  • Before and after shotsPerfect body

    Just how reliable are 'before and after' photos?

  • Lotus 97T driven by Elio de AngelisBeen and gone

    A champion F1 designer and other notable losses

Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.