Who has benefited from record low interest rates?

The Bank of England, fulcrum of the attempts to stave of a depression

It is now five years since the Bank of England's Monetary Policy Committee cut its bank rate to a historic low of just 0.5%.

The key interest rate, which influences the cost of borrowing throughout the banking system and the wider economy, has stayed there ever since.

As a Bank official once explained to me, it has been an "extreme policy setting". It is still with us and has had a profound impact on the UK.

However things are certainly not back to normal.

So what has the impact been?

Dr Ros Altman, an economic policy expert, says there is a very long list of people who have not benefited from this policy of ultra-low interest rates.

"Small businesses, who still are unable to borrow on decent terms, youngsters struggling to pay increased rents as house prices have kept being pushed up, older generations whose pensions and savings income has been hit," she says.

"All savers have lost out because the income they might have previously got on their savings has been cut dramatically [and] anyone buying an annuity has lost out significantly."

Who benefited from five years of record low interest rates, asks Dominic Laurie

Lost savings

Anyone with a bank or savings account will be familiar with the derisory rates on offer, sometimes as low as 0.1% for an ordinary cheque account.

Start Quote

Unfortunately there isn't an alternative, but there is little incentive to save”

End Quote Anna Bowes Savings Champion website

The savage drop in savings rates is best illustrated by looking at what is on offer to people who want to put money away in the highly popular tax-free cash Isas (individual savings accounts).

According to the Bank of England's statistics, the average rate on a cash Isa back in 2007 was more than 5%. Now it is about 0.6%.

How much have savers "lost" because of this regime of what some economists call "financial repression"?

A recent study by the management consultants McKinsey puts the sum foregone by UK savers at £66bn between 2007 and 2012.

Anna Bowes, who runs the financial comparison website for savers called Savings Champion, says would-be savers are having to scratch around to make sure their savings even keep up with inflation.

"The very best instant access rates currently available are about 1.4% or 1.5% - it's really poor, though you can get 3.25% for locking your money away for five years.

"Unfortunately there isn't an alternative, but there is little incentive to save."

Mortgage application and piggy bank Low rates have had very different effects for borrowers and savers
Lucky mortgage holders

The most obvious beneficiaries of low interest rates have been people with mortgages - currently about 11.2 million people have one.

Start Quote

The truth is, the scale of the credit crunch was even larger than we appreciated at the time”

End Quote Kate Barker Former MPC member

In mid-2008, the average interest rate for someone fixing their mortgage for two, three or five years - and with a 25% deposit - was about 6.4%.

Those rates have since slumped, and in January this year they stood, according to the Bank of England, at an average of 2.4% (for a two-year fix), 2.9% (for three years) and 3.3% (for a five-year deal).

Remarkably, in the past couple of years it has been possible to borrow at less than the prevailing rate of inflation.

Low mortgage rates have also helped keep thousands of people in their homes when they might otherwise have had their properties repossessed for falling into arrears on their repayments.

How much have mortgage holders saved in the past five years, compared to what their repayments would have been if the financial crisis had never happened and the bank rate had stayed at 5%?

Bob Pannell, chief economist at the Council of Mortgage Lenders (CML), estimates that it comes to roughly £100bn.

Staving off collapse

So what exactly was the point of cutting interest rates so swiftly, from 5.0% in April 2008 to just 0.5% less than a year later?

ARCHIVE: Bank governor Mervyn King explains what he hoped to achieve by cutting bank rate to 0.5% and starting the policy of quantitative easing.

Along with the new-fangled policy of quantitative easing - printing massive amounts of electronic money - the aim was to stop the supply of money in the banking system and the wider economy drying up altogether.

This might have led to an even more devastating credit crunch where banks could not lend at all and borrowers could not borrow.

Kate Barker, a member of the MPC at the time, recalls the reasoning: "We had just had a quarter in which output in the economy had fallen by about 1.5%, we had a collapse in world trade.

"We knew that just cutting rates probably wasn't enough, and we introduced quantitative easing, really to try to help companies go round the banks and borrow money more directly on the bond markets."

The economy is now growing again but the bank rate is still at 0.5% and the Bank of England has now chucked nearly £375bn at the banking system via its policy of QE.

So has the policy worked?

Kate Barker says, emphatically, yes. "The truth is, the scale of the credit crunch was even larger than we appreciated at the time, and then on the back of that we had the very extreme difficulties in Europe," she says.

"We were trying to offset what we thought at the time was a very big risk of the economy moving into some appalling downward spiral. It did succeed in doing that and to that extent I'm really glad we did it and it was a success," she adds.

Anyone with savings, however, may not agree.

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Business stories

RSS

BBC Business Live

  1.  
    Via Twitter Rory Cellan-Jones Technology correspondent

    tweets: "Unusual alliance - Nat Rothschild & Ken Livingstone unite against Uber, backing community ride-sharing app Maaxi"

     
  2.  
    ROCKET CRASHES 10:07:
    Rocket internet

    Oh dear. Shares in Rocket Internet have fallen up to 14% on their debut on the Frankfurt Stock Exchange. The Berlin-based internet firm owns a host of online businesses, including food delivery, taxi hailing and a fashion retailer. The share sale raised €1.4bn.

     
  3.  
    OFCOM BOSS LEAVES 09:56:
    Ed Richards, Ofcom chief executive

    Ed Richards is standing down as chief executive of Ofcom, the regulator of television, radio and internet services. Patricia Hodgson, Ofcom chairman, said: "Under his leadership, Ofcom has helped to deliver superfast broadband, 4G, lower prices, innovation, competition, and sustainable public service broadcasting in the UK."

     
  4.  
    WONGA 09:52:

    The Financial Conduct Authority is sending a message to the payday loan industry. Clive Adamson, director of supervision, said: "We are determined to drive up standards in the consumer credit market and it is disappointing that some firms still have a way to go to meet our expectations. This should put the rest of the industry on notice - they need to lend affordably and responsibly."

     
  5.  
    Via Twitter Adam Parsons Business Correspondent

    tweets: "FCA says did deal with Wonga requiring company "to make significant changes to its business immediately....should put industry on notice""

     
  6.  
    Via Twitter Neil Hume, Financial Times Commodities Editor

    tweets: "It's turning into a rout. Brent down 1.4% to $92.86 this morning in the wake of the latest Saudi OSPs [oil sales price] "

     
  7.  
    WONGA 09:21:

    Payday lenders like Wonga were criticised last year by the Office of Fair Trading for the number of times debt was rolled over, extending the amount of time a borrower has to repay, but also increasing the overall cost of the loan. Earlier this week, Wonga said 2013 profits fell by 53% to £39.7m due to "remediation costs" - money it had to pay back to customers as a result of its own mistakes.

     
  8.  
    WONGA 09:09: Breaking News
    Wonga logo

    Wonga will write off the debts of 330,000 customers who are in arrears of more than a month. Another group of 45,000 customers who have been in the red for less time can pay their debt without interest and charges. Wonga is doing this following "discussions" with City watchdog the FCA.

     
  9.  
    DOMINO'S PIZZA 08:58:
    pizza

    Shares in Domino's Pizza are up 2.2% after the fast food firm said third-quarter sales were up 12.9%. The company says it has been helped by a shift to online sales.

     
  10.  
    CONSERVATIVE CONFERENCE 08:37:
    Prime Minister David Cameron

    The Daily Telegraph is swooning over Prime Minister Cameron's conference speech. "Electrifying," is how it describes the PM's pledge to raise the 40p tax threshold. The Telegraph doesn't quite claim credit for the move, but does remind us that it has been campaigning for such a reduction.

     
  11.  
    MARKET UPDATE 08:27:

    The FTSE 100 is down 0.24% in early trading following a 1.4% loss for the Dow Jones in on Wednesday.

     
  12.  
    PARIS MOTOR SHOW 08:11: BBC Radio 4
    Discovery Sport

    Jaguar Land Rover has plenty to boast about at the Paris Motor Show. It has doubled sales volume and employment in five years. On Today Andy Goss, global sales director says that 80% of its output is exported. But to compete it has to build plants abroad, he says. A new plant opens in China at the end of this year and one in Brazil around a year later.

     
  13.  
    VIRGIN MONEY FLOAT 08:03: Via Email Kamal Ahmed BBC Business editor

    emails: "Virgin Money's announcement of its intention to sell a stake on the London stock exchange brings to an end another chapter in the sorry story of Northern Rock. The functioning bits of the bank, which spectacularly collapsed in 2007 and was bailed out in February 2008 with £1.4bn of tax payers' money, were bought by Sir Richard Branson and US investor WL Ross for £747m in 2011."

     
  14.  
    MARKET REPORT 07:50:
    Share price board, Tokyo

    It has been a shaky session for shares in Tokyo, the Nikkei 225 index closed 2.6% lower at 15,661. The Hang Seng in Hong Kong, which has fallen more than 9% since hitting a six-month peak in September amid pro-democracy protests, is closed for a public holiday.

     
  15.  
    Via Twitter BBC Radio 4

    tweets: "'Downgrade could follow Brexit' says Standard and Poor's Mortiz Kraemer @EthicalMan"

     
  16.  
    HEADLINES
     
  17.  
    LORD HILL 07:33: BBC Radio 4
    Lord Hill

    "He showed no grasp of the issues," is the verdict of Phillippe Lamberts, co-chair of the Greens in the EU parliament, on Lord Hill's appearance before European members of parliament on Wednesday. "Behind his charm there was apparently little knowledge of the subject matter at hand," Mr Lamberts said on Today.

     
  18.  
    VIRGIN MONEY FLOAT 07:26:

    So, will ordinary folk be able to buy shares in the Virgin Money offering? Not until they start trading. The offer is open to "certain institutional investors". Although they are giving staff £1,000 of shares apiece.

     
  19.  
    VIRGIN MONEY FLOAT 07:11:

    Virgin Money has announced details of its share sale. The firm hopes to raise £150m from the sale of about 25% of the bank, it said. If the sale is successful the Treasury will receive £50m, which was part of the deal when Virgin Money took over assets from Northern Rock.

     
  20.  
    ECB MEETING 06:57: BBC Radio 4
    Eurozone sign

    The European Central Bank (ECB) hosts its monthly meeting in Naples today, amid worries that the eurozone economy is deteriorating. "The ECB can buy time for governments to act... but it cannot generate lasting growth," says Moritz Kraemer from Standard & Poor's on Today. He says Europe needs to reduce the debt load of households, firms and governments.

     
  21.  
    PIMCO EXODUS 06:48: BBC Radio 4

    Investors have taken £14.5bn out of the investment firm Pimco since its founder Bill Gross resigned last week. Andrew Balls, chief global investment office at Pimco, says "it's calmed down very quickly though". The departure was not a huge surprise, he reckons. Mr Balls reminds listeners to Today that Mr Gross was 70 "and wouldn't be there [Pimco] for ever". Ouch.

     
  22.  
    PARIS MOTOR SHOW 06:40: BBC World News
    Rolls Royce chief executive, Torsten Muller-Otvos

    "We are on the roll ja," says the German chief executive of Rolls Royce Motor Cars, Torsten Muller-Otvos on World Business Report. He expects the company to have another record year. He is standing in front of a limited edition Rolls-Royce Phantom, only 20 were made and, sorry readers, they are all sold out.

     
  23.  
    SHARING ECONOMY 06:31: Radio 5 live

    What is the sharing economy? "The sharing economy defines the assets you own and skills you have" says Debbie Wosskow, chief executive of Love Home Swap on 5 live. (Are we clear now?) Customers need protection, but regulation needs to keep up with this emerging market, she says. She's writing a review into the sharing economy.

     
  24.  
    CONSERVATIVE CONFERENCE 06:17: Radio 5 live

    Lord Digby Jones, the crossbench peer and businessman is on 5 live after his appearance at the Conservative Party conference. He is worried people think money grows on trees, rather than coming from business, but also says business should mend its image: "I don't want chief executives paying themselves big bonuses [right now]. They may deserve it, but it sets a lousy example."

     
  25.  
    ARGENTINA 06:13: Radio 5 live
    President Cristina Fernandez

    The boss of Argentina's central bank has resigned. Juan Carlos Fabrega had been calling the government to tackle inflation and rein in spending. That created conflict with the nation's economy minister. The BBC's South American Business Reporter Katy Watson says the resignation doesn't make President Cristina Fernandez de Kirchner look good either.

     
  26.  
    PARIS MOTOR SHOW 06:07: Radio 5 live

    Jurgen Stackman, chairman of carmaker Seat is on Radio 5 live. Ten years ago electric vehicles were seen as the future, so what went wrong? Industry watchers were very optimistic about the speed of people picking them up, he says. Electric cars still have mileage and range limitations and families with one car don't want to rely on an electric car, he adds.

     
  27.  
    US SHARES SLIDE 06:00: BBC World News
    New York Stock Exchange

    There were sharp losses for US shares overnight. On World Business Report, Michael Hewson, chief analyst at CMC Markets reminds us that the US market has had a good run recently. But there is not much to be positive about at the moment, he says. The recent economic data from China and Japan has not been great. Traders are also preparing for higher interest rates in the US, Mr Hewson says.

     
  28.  
    06:00: Howard Mustoe Business reporter

    Good morning. You can get in touch via email bizlivepage@bbc.co.uk and on twitter @BBCBusiness

     
  29.  
    06:00: Ben Morris Business Reporter

    There were sharp losses for US shares overnight, so it will be interesting to see how Europe responds to that later. Plus we'll have reports from the Paris Motor Show. It should be a fun morning, so stay with us.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.