Flexible working rights for all - could they backfire?

Woman working from home

Related Stories

Fancy working from home? Wishing you could drop down to a four-day week?

Well, don't just sit there. Ask!

From now on, providing you are a UK employee, you will have a legal right to request this, and your employer will have a legal obligation to answer.

And not just that - they will have a legal obligation to provide a valid reason if they cannot say yes.

Until now, parents of children under the age of 16, and those registered as carers for children or adults have had the right to ask for a change in work patterns that better suits their home life.

Start Quote

It's only a right to ask, and certainly not a right to have”

End Quote Steve Williams Head of equality services, Acas

But now the same rules will apply to all employees, regardless of their dependants, provided they have worked for their employer for at least 26 weeks.

It allows them one "flexibility request" per year.

'Cost to businesses'

The government says it wants to remove the "cultural assumption" that flexible working only applies to parents or carers, and that in bringing in these changes it wants to make workplaces "fit for the 21st Century".

But employers' groups are worried things could backfire, making it harder for those more in need of flexible working, increasing the risk of discrimination claims, and adding unnecessary red tape.

"One of the main questions we're getting from our members is: will it become illegal for me to give priority to people who are parents or carers?" says John Wastnage, head of employment at the British Chambers of Commerce (BCC).

Child at a nursery The right to request flexible working previously only applied to parents or carers

"And the answer is yes.

"A lot of our members already offer flexible working anyway, often informally, so this change is unnecessary and it could just push up time and cost to businesses," he says.

'Negative dynamic'

The Federation of Small Businesses (FSB), while encouraging flexible working, is worried that this change in the law is sending the wrong message to workers.

"While the new procedure is designed to be light-touch, inevitably it will entail additional administration that the smallest of businesses will have to learn and may struggle to apply," says FSB chairman, John Allan.

Types of flexible working

  • Part-time working
  • Flexi-time - scope to change work hours outside of "core" business periods
  • Job-sharing
  • Working from home or remotely
  • Compressed hours - for example, fitting a five-day week into four days
  • Term-time working - paid or unpaid leave during school holidays
  • Annual hours - agreed hours split into "set" and "reserve" shifts, worked as demand dictates

"Where requests are declined, our experience shows 'the right to request' can introduce an unwelcome negative dynamic into the workplace."

That "negative dynamic" could be exacerbated when an employer is faced with multiple, conflicting requests.

The UK's leading business lobby, the Confederation of British Industry (CBI), says it has called for better guidance on what employers should do in this situation.

And when the BCC asked for clarification, the response was to "put the names in a hat", says Mr Wastnage.

"That's no way to run a business," he adds.

"I think there's a risk that some businesses will take a view that they're not going to accept any requests because of the risk of discrimination."

Litigation concerns

That risk of discrimination, say employers' groups, leads to the risk of costly employment tribunals, should workers not get their way or feel hard done by.

The conciliation service, Acas, is not expecting the change to generate a flood of new cases, bearing in mind a tribunal's potential risks and rewards.

"I don't think many employees will risk their work relationship for the sake of eight weeks' pay compensation," says Steve Williams, Acas head of equality services.

Courtroom There are fears the changes could lead to more employment tribunal cases

"It's only a right to ask, and it's certainly not a right to have - and this is a key element."

Nevertheless, the government has estimated the change could bring up to 150 extra tribunal cases every year, each costing employers an average of £5,900.

That would be an increase of more than 50% on the 277 tribunal cases brought for these reasons in 2010-11.

It is, however, a tiny fraction of the 190,000 claims taken to tribunal in 2012.

Culture change

A spokesman for the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills, says: "We want these reforms to bring about a culture change in Britain's workplaces.

Grounds for refusing requests

  • Burden of additional costs
  • Inability to reorganise work among existing staff
  • Inability to recruit additional staff
  • Detrimental impact on quality
  • Detrimental impact on performance
  • Detrimental effect on ability to meet customer demand
  • Insufficient work for the periods the employee proposes to work
  • Planned structural change to the business

Source: Acas draft guidelines

"Family-friendly policies and economic growth can go hand in hand. Flexible working really can help employers boost productivity and profits."

In its impact assessment on the rollout of flexible working to all employees, the government estimates that in its first 10 years the new policy will bring overall economic benefits of about £475m.

Most of that, it thinks, will come from increased productivity, lower labour turnover, and reduced absenteeism.

It could be particularly helpful, the government says, for workers who might need to look after grandchildren, or those who want to take part in voluntary work.

And then there are the potential knock-on positive effects - the chance to further reduce unemployment, or the theory that a better work-life balance will improve employees' health.

The change would apply to more than 10 million employees, and the government estimates it would lead to the agreement of more than 60,000 new flexible working arrangements every year.

But according to snapshots of the existing workforce, many employers' doors are already very much open to flexible working requests.

Evolution not revolution

About 96% of firms already offer some form of flexibility - from British Gas to Marks and Spencer - according to a 2012 survey from the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development (CIPD).

Moreover, almost two-thirds already provide a right to request it.

Office building According to the CIPD, 96% of employers already offer flexible working

Perhaps not surprisingly, the smaller the company, the less likely they are to be quite so accommodating, but not by much - about 90% of smaller firms offer flexible working, according to the CIPD survey.

"This is an evolutionary thing, not a revolution," says Steve Williams of Acas.

"The challenge is making sure managers making these decisions actually get them right, and that they don't approve without thinking, otherwise you'll get a workplace that isn't functional."

The extension to the flexible working rules comes alongside the introduction of "parental leave" which, from next April, will combine maternity and paternity arrangements into one package.

Working couples will have the option to share up to 50 weeks' leave and 37 weeks' pay in the first year of their child's life.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Business stories


BBC Business Live

    Ed Balls

    Ed Balls has been giving his speech to the Labour party conference. So far he has promised to scrap the "bedroom tax" and apologised for not regulating the banks in a "tougher way". The shadow chancellor says Labour must be grown up enough to apologise for mistakes. "We should apologise for it, and I do," he says.

    BARCLAYS Via Twitter Kevin Peachey Personal finance reporter, BBC News

    tweets: "Problems with #Barclays cards today meant some payments turned down at shops & online. Now resolved, bank says"

    TESCO PROFITS Via Twitter Simon Jack Business correspondent, BBC News

    tweets: "Just interviewed Dave lewis CEO of tesco. He says £250m is an estimate could be more and discrepancies could date back further than H1 2014"


    It's not been a great morning on the London market, with Tesco leading a fall in shares. The supermarket is down 7.25%, while the FTSE 100 overall is 51 points lower at 6,787. In Frankfurt the Dax has recovered from this morning's losses, and is now back where it started at 9,796, while the Cac 40 in Paris is still six points lower.

    NEW FLAT 12:03:

    Fancy living in a penthouse apartment overlooking Buckingham Palace and the Ritz? It will cost you - at least £25m, according to the Financial Times. The paper reports that developer British Land has sold a total of 18 flats in a new development in London's Mayfair for a total of £210, including one that sets a new record, selling at more than £5,000 per sq ft.

    LABOUR CONFERENCE 11:41: Via Blog Kamal Ahmed BBC Business editor

    blogs: "In the era of the Cold War, there was a joke that to make up for being late for the last two world wars, America was going to make sure it was bang on time for the next one. Labour appears to be adopting a similar attitude to the next big business debate: Europe and Britain's relationship with it."


    The second day of the Labour conference is underway. Ed Balls is speaking later. The shadow chancellor is expected to say that a Labour government would stop paying the controversial winter fuel allowance to the richest 5% of pensioners. You can have a look at the full conference agenda here.

    COOL BRANDS 11:20:
    People wait to buy the new Apple iPhone 6 and 6 Plus

    Apple has been voted "the coolest brand in Britain" for the third year in a row, the Guardian reports. The CoolBrands list saw Apple beat Aston Martin and Nike, which came second and third respectively. But Twitter has fallen out of the top 20, along with the BBC's very own iPlayer. Ho hum we'll get 'em next time.

    DEBT 11:14:

    Debt management firms "must raise their game" says the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). In a release this morning the regulator says many of the firms, which target people who have "often reached rock bottom", are failing to follow the new rules brought in in April to protect customers.

    UNDER EMPLOYED? 10:43: Via Twitter

    Has deputy leader of the House of Commons, Tom Brake been on holiday? His tweeting of last week's unemployment figures today seems oddly timed: "The latest unemployment figures from the ONS have been released showing a fall by 146,000, lowering total unemployment count to 2.02 million". Keep up.

    AIR FRANCE 10:30:
    Passengers wait at check-in counters during Air France one-week strike

    The head of Air France-KLM, Alexandre de Juniac, has given an interview to French newspaper Le Monde saying that he was prepared to suspend until December the rollout of the Transavia low-cost operation that sparked strike action by pilots. The strike has led to severe disruption in the past week. Air France flights have been reduced to 40% of normal service.

    AIR FRANCE 10:13: Breaking News

    French national airline, Air France-KLM, has announced it is putting a halt to its low-cost airline expansion plans in an attempt to end the strike by pilots that entered its second week today

    TESCO PROFITS 10:10:

    Barclays Capital analyst James Anstead says although there are few details at present as to why Tesco's profits need to be restated "there is a clear implication that Tesco's previous full year trading profit guidance of £2.4bn to £2.5bn needs to be reduced. He adds: "We cannot necessarily assume that the maximum change required is £250m."


    An 18-year-old "whizzkid" with a love for the board game Monopoly is preparing an audacious bid to lead one of UK's largest retailers, according to the Daily Mail. Harris Aslam already sits on the board of Nisa Retail. He has apparently has told the group's chairman he intends to stand for election as its next chief executive.

    TESCO PROFITS 09:46:

    Marks and Spencer's chief financial officer (CFO) Alan Stewart was announced as the new CFO of Tesco in July but he is still on gardening leave and is not due to join Tesco until December. Laurie McIlwee resigned as CFO in April but continued in post until just over a week ago. Over the last week there has been no CFO in the Tesco head office, the company has confirmed.

    TESCO PROFITS 09:39:

    Tesco says it has informed the financial regulator, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), about its investigation into the reporting of its profits.

    TESCO PROFITS Via Twitter Adam Parsons Business Correspondent

    tweets: "Tesco won't confirm my revelation that Chris Bush has stepped aside. But will confirm that Robin Terrell is now doing his job!"

    TESCO PROFITS 09:31:

    Tesco chairman Richard Broadbent says the retailer's investigation is focusing on the reporting of payments made to Tesco from its suppliers. It seems to be an issue of the timing of payments, rather than a "hole" in the accounts.

    TESCO PROFITS 09:18:

    Dave Lewis, Tesco chief executive, will not confirm that Chris Bush the managing director is one of the four executives suspended as part of its investigation into its profits reporting. He is speaking to journalists on a conference call.

    MARKET UPDATE 09:16:

    Aside from Tesco the FTSE 100 index is lower by 0.66% at 6,792 just over an hour into the trading day. Tesco is perhaps unsurprisingly the biggest faller. Meanwhile, engineering firm Petrofac is the biggest riser, up 1.72% to 1066p.

    TESCO SHARES 09:11:

    Tesco's share price is beginning to stabilise a little. Having fallen 11.3% on the open to 203.5p, Tesco shares are currently trading 7.99% lower at 211.25p

    TESCO PROFITS 09:01: BBC Radio 4

    James Bevan, chief investment officer at CCLA Investment Management, tells Today the profit warning from Tesco could amount to falsifying accounts. "They have decided to account for profits arising in future periods in the current period, and deferred costs that otherwise should have been recognised. That's really serious."

    TESCO PROFITS 08:57: Via Email

    Richard Hunter, head of equities at Hargreaves Lansdown, says Tesco's profit warning "does not come close to jeopardising overall profitability" at the supermarket, and the market will be happy that at least the bad news is out in the open and being dealt with.

    UK ECONOMY 08:44: BBC Breakfast
    Jeremy Cook

    Breakfast's Steph McGovern is down in London in the financial district talking to Jeremy Cook, chief economist at World First foreign exchange, who says we should be focusing on how strong the UK economy is following the Scottish referendum. Unemployment is down, GDP is growing - "all very very good news".

    TESCO PROFITS Via Twitter

    Sean Farrell on the Guardian's City Desk tweets: "Tesco CEO Lewis: 'This is not in the ordinary course of events. This has been audited by a big reputable firm.'

    TESCO PROFITS 08:35: Radio 5 live

    Four senior Tesco executives including the UK managing director Chris Bush have been suspended, while an investigation into profits reporting is carried out, Adam Parsons says on Radio 5 live. The share price has recovered a bit but is still down more than 9%.

    MINIMUM WAGE 08:21: Radio 5 live

    Shane Brennan from the Association of Convenience Stores says the minimum wage is becoming a "political football" between the main political parties, and warns a rise could hit employees negatively. "When the minimum wage goes up, small retailers cut back on the hours they offer staff," he tells Radio 5 live.

    CHILD BENEFIT 08:18: Radio 5 live

    Ed Balls is talking about the minimum wage on 5 live Breakfast, but he keeps falling off the air. He was half way through explaining how the Labour party wants to extend the child benefit cap - one of those "difficult decisions" necessary to "balance the books".

    TESCO SHARES 08:14:

    Tesco's shares opened down 11.3% at 203.5p - that's its lowest price since May 2003 - more than a decade ago.

    TESCO SHARES 08:09: Breaking News

    Tesco's share price falls by more than 10% in the first few minutes of trading in London.


    Menswear retailer Moss Bros has reported a pre-tax profit of £1.95m for the six months to July. That's slightly lower than their previous guidance and reflects the number of stores that were closed for refit in the first half of this year, the company said. Like for like sales were 6.4% higher.

    TESCO PROFITS Via Twitter Robert Peston Economics editor

    tweets: "Tesco! Oh my giddy aunt. Never thought it would come to this http://www.investegate.co.uk/tesco-plc--tsco-/rns/trading-update/201409220700142186S/ …

    ALIBABA 07:55:

    The Financial Times reports that Alibaba, the Chinese ecommerce group, has boosted the value of its IPO to $25bn (£15bn) by selling extra shares. That makes it the biggest IPO in history. Huge investor demand saw the company's share price surge 38% on its debut on the New York Stock Exchange on Friday.

    TESCO PROFITS Via Twitter

    Richard Hunter from stockbrokers Hargreaves Lansdown tweets: "Profit warning on a profit warning for #Tesco likely to put further pressure on a share price already down 39% over the last year"


    Other news from the stock market this morning: British bank Aldermore says it will float on the London Stock Exchange in October, aiming to raise £75m. Aldermore focuses on lending to small and medium-sized businesses and homeowners.

    TESCO PROFITS Via Twitter Adam Parsons Business Correspondent

    tweets: "Dave Lewis initiated inquiry over weekend. Am told Philip Clarke has officially left Tesco, but remains available to talk to investigation."

    PHONES 4U RESCUE 07:36:
    The Phones 4U shop sign.

    Phone network EE is to buy 58 Phones 4U stores - safeguarding 359 jobs - in a deal with administrator PricewaterhouseCoopers. The phone network was known to have entered negotiations over the weekend. On Friday Vodafone agreed to take over 140 Phones 4U shops.

    TESCO PROFITS Via Twitter Adam Parsons Business Correspondent

    tweets: "Tesco were due to report Interims next week. That has now been cancelled."

    LABOUR CONFERENCE 07:26: BBC Radio 4

    Labour shadow business secretary Chuka Umanna tells Today Labour is pro-business, but says: "What we have been clear about is we can't go back to business as usual and the kind of fast buck culture we saw in some parts of the economy that helped contribute to the 2008/09 crash."

    TESCO PROFITS Via Twitter

    City grandee David Buik tweets: "It never rains but it pours dear old Tesco. It appears profits have been over-stated by £250 mn - shares could be down 5% at the opening."

    TESCO PROFITS 07:15:
    A group of Tesco shopping trolleys

    "We have uncovered a serious issue and have responded accordingly," said Dave Lewis, who took over as the boss of Tesco last month. "The chairman and I have acted quickly to establish a comprehensive independent investigation. The board, my colleagues, our customers and I expect Tesco to operate with integrity and transparency and we will take decisive action as the results of the investigation become clear."

    TESCO PROFITS 07:11: Breaking News

    Tesco has released a statement saying it over-stated its expected profit for the six months to 23 August. In a trading statement on 29 August it said it expected half-year profits to be £1.1bn. It has now revised this down by £250m.

    LISTEN AGAIN Via Twitter Adam Parsons Business Correspondent

    tweets: The #WUTM podcast. All yours: bbc.co.uk/podcasts/serie…

    AIR FRANCE 07:03:
    Air France planes

    Pilots at Air France are looking ahead to a second week on strike this morning. France's transport minister Alain Vidalies says the fate of Air France is at stake in the dispute. Pilots are angry that the airline is expanding its budget carrier, which pays pilots less.

    LABOUR ANTI-BUSINESS? 06:55: BBC Radio 4

    Lord Jones tells Today that Labour has not given business the credit it deserves. "Without the wealth that business creates you have no public sector, you have no taxation, you don't have one job in the country. That's how important business is," he says.

    LABOUR ANTI-BUSINESS? 06:51: BBC Radio 4
    Digby Jones

    Lord Digby Jones, former head of the CBI and member of the last Labour government tells Today that Labour is casting doubt on its support for the UK business community. "Whatever the current shadow cabinet say - let's nationalise the banks, let's have a social market in energy, lets increase business taxes, whatever it may be - they are showing by their actions that they actually don't get it," he says.

    DEVOLUTION 06:42: Radio 5 live

    Wake Up to Money has been discussing the prospects for more devolution across the UK in the wake of the "No" vote in Scotland. Tony Travers from the London School of Economics says the UK is one of the most centralised democracies in the world - 95% of tax revenues go straight to the exchequer.

    MINIMUM WAGE 06:35: BBC Radio 4

    Is Labour leader Ed Miliband's pledge to raise the minimum wage to £8 per hour by 2020 anti-business?Simon Walker, head of the Institute of Directors, tells the Today programme he shares many of the Labour party's concerns - on energy prices, zero-hours contracts and wages. "But... we don't agree with Labour's instinct to legislate or regulate on these matters," he says.

    MARKETS 06:29: BBC Breakfast

    Breakfast's Steph McGovern is in the City in London before dawn this morning, talking to analysts and market traders about what's moving the markets after the "No" vote in Scotland last week. She'll be talking to a currency trader later to find out what's going to happen to the pound.

    MINIMUM WAGE 06:18:

    Labour's leader Ed Miliband says Labour will put the minimum wage up to £8 an hour if they win the election next year - up from the £6.50 is due to rise to this October. The unions say that's not enough, and want £10 an hour, while the CBI warns any rise will "put jobs at risk".

    Labour shadow  chancellor Ed Balls

    Ed Balls is expected to say that Labour will reinstate the 50 top rate of tax in his speech to the party conference later today. That's not necessarily news. But Labour haven't been completely clear on whether they would reinstate the 50p tax band until now. The inclusion of the proposal essentially amounts to an election promise eight months out from the general election.

    Phones 4U 06:02: Radio 5 live

    EE has confirmed it's looking into buy a few of those Phones 4 U shops now on the market. Judy Palmer from Begbies Traynor defends EE and Vodafone, the operators accused of helping to put the mobile retailer out of business, on Wake Up to Money calling their actions "commercial hardball".

    06:01: Edwin Lane Business reporter, BBC News

    Hello all. We're also getting the latest on the fate of Phones 4U, after it went into administration last week. Get in touch with us on bizlivepage@bbc.co.uk or tweet us @BBCBusiness.

    0600: Matthew West Business Reporter

    Morning folks. We start the day with news that luxury shoe brand Jimmy Choo is looking at a stock market float in London, there are also half year results from Moss Bros. The Labour party conference goes into its second full day with a speech from shadow chancellor Ed Balls. It's his last conference speech before the election so we'll bring you any nuggets from that too. Stay with us.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.