Banking bonuses: How much do they matter?

London's Canary Wharf London's Canary Wharf is part of the second biggest financial services industry in the world

The debate over bankers' pay has resurfaced with Labour's call for a block on Royal Bank of Scotland paying bonuses of double its bankers' annual salary.

Since the banking crisis in 2008 - there have been reforms, and calls for more.

Many of those in the industry say bonuses are vital for keeping talent - others say they are out of proportion.

We canvassed the views of experts on the topic.

The bonus sceptic

Luke Hildyard - head of research at the think tank the High Pay Centre

"We haven't seen convincing evidence that a bonus cap would drive people abroad. We are pro business so if we had seen such evidence we may revise our view.

"But there is also a lack of real evidence rather than anecdotal that the so-called top talent in the banking sector is irreplaceable.

"In all jobs in all sectors people leave for more money or other reasons and they are successfully replaced.

"Pay in banking is too high, and the bankers are not as irreplaceable as their banks seem to perceive them to be.

"Pay in the financial services sector has contributed to a risk-taking bonus culture which has proved damaging to society overall."

The headhunter

John Purcell at the city recruitment firm Purcell and Company

"If the likes of RBS were to be ultimately damaged by high-performing people leaving, that ultimately damages us on the whole as an economy.

"What went on in the past with bonuses was out of line. But there's a balance to be struck between commercial reality and politics.

"Almost nobody outside the financial sector understands banking - they think bankers go around with wheelbarrows of cash. But the truth is that a very small number of people can make an enormous difference to a company, and if they leave the company suffers.

"It's a bit like a football club. It rapidly goes downhill if a fantastic manager leaves. Extraordinary individuals can make a huge difference and that's why they get extraordinary pay.

"There is clear evidence I have seen of individuals, especially in smaller companies, moving to places like Singapore, Switzerland, Hong Kong and yes, New York."

Wall Street sign

The North American view

Ralph Silva - banking analyst at SRN

"We need to infuse some morals and ethics into these institutions. But as far as bonuses go, they (the banks) will find a way to pay perks.

"The problem with bonuses in all of Europe is the amount that is paid in America. The US banks have been doing very well and have been paying huge bonuses.

"They are getting lots of British bankers ready to get on a plane and go to New York City, and they are going to have to start paying bigger bonuses to keep people in the City of London.

"Bankers are fickle, and they will move - at a certain level. The small number of very top earners will make £5m to £6m and they will move for that.

"But for the average City investment banker, earning between £150,000 and £500,000, an extra 10% won't make enough of a difference. But double it? And it will."

London's Canary Wharf

Former banker

Chris Roebuck - visiting professor at Cass business school, and formerly at Citigroup

"Yet again what is an important issue for the British economy is being used for political point scoring.

"These people - the top level bankers - are not doing business in relation to UK High Street banking, they are doing business related to very large global business deals.

"Whilst it is understandable that people compare these pay levels with those of most people in the country, in comparison with their international counterparts their pay here in the UK is relatively low.

"The reality is that, should these people wish to, all they have to do is to walk across the road in London to an American bank, to JP Morgan, Goldman Sachs, or any other non-EU bank and they will be paid more.

"This is a global issue. In a global market. We do not have the power to deal with the issue of bankers' bonuses as one country, and if we use legislation to try to do so - in the end the market will win - and we will lose some of the tax revenues we so badly need for our schools, hospitals and other critical services."

"These people are not dealing with people's High Street accounts - they are investment bankers doing massive deals across the world.

"If JP Morgan's foreign exchange business is done through New York the person doing it could be sitting in London and could be paid through New York.

"We should also remember that the financial services sector brings in over 10% of UK GDP."

A £20 note with some piled up pound coins

The banker's spokesperson

Anthony Browne, British Bankers' Association

"There were a lot of problems with bankers' pay in the past, but it has been fundamentally reformed. People are being given longer-term rewards for longer-term behaviour and performance.

"The sums of money those in the financial services sector get don't really compute for the average wage earner - but it is a competitive market and it is a global market for bankers.

"A lot of people come to the City of London from elsewhere in the world, and that is positive for the UK economy. Bankers come here to win business, they pay taxes and they create jobs. It is very important for the UK economy.

"There have been reforms to the bonus culture around the world. Do people leave? No. But certain legislation could harm London's competitiveness. London used to be the leader in financial services, but it lost out to New York. That is not good for the economy."

More on This Story

Big Banking

Related Stories

More Business stories

RSS

BBC Business Live

  1.  
    09:58: CITY POWERS BBC Radio 4

    Jim O'Neill, the former Goldman Sachs man who invented the acronym BRICS, to describe the group of emerging markets has turned his attention to the devolution of government powers to the the UK's regions and cities. He tells Today cities should be able to spend much more of the local taxes they collect with a system of centrally available grants to help top up funds. His report also has the backing of the Chancellor. Mr O'Neill says he would be very surprised if at least some of his recommendations are not adopted in the Autumn Statement.

     
  2.  
    09:31: BANK OF ENGLAND MINUTES
    The Bank of England

    No changes in the vote in October. The Monetary Policy Committee stuck in the same position for the third month in a row voting 7 to 2 to hold interest rates at 0.5%.

     
  3.  
    09:18: TESLA SALE
    Tesla

    Mercedes-owner Daimler says it will make $780m (£485m) from selling a 4% stake it owns in electric car maker Tesla. A cooperation agreement to supply Mercedes-Benz cars with Tesla battery technology remains unaffected by the sale, Daimler chief executive Dieter Zetsche said.

     
  4.  
    09:01: MARKET UPDATE

    It's a bit of a mixed bag on the markets this morning. The FTSE 100 is down a touch (0.15%) at 6362.69. But Germany's Dax is up 0.50% at 8930.37 and France's Cac-40 is up 0.13% at 4086.47. The biggest faller on the FTSE 100 is BAT down nearly 4% to 3334.5p on those declining cigarette sales volumes.

     
  5.  
    08:44: HOME RETAIL PROFIT DROPS
    Home Retail share graph

    ...and consequently so has its share price. The group is down 4.3% to 168p on the news of those Homebase store closures. Share slumped 6% at the open so have recovered slightly, 40 minutes into the trading day.

     
  6.  
    TESCO WOES Via Blog Kamal Ahmed BBC Business editor

    "Tomorrow, Tesco will reveal its latest results. Sales and profits are likely to be down again," BBC Business Editor Kamal Ahmed writes in his latest blog. "Many believe that Tesco should move away from vouchers and one-off price promotions and win back customers with lower prices across all its ranges."

     
  7.  
    08:17: HOME RETAIL PROFIT DROPS
    A Homebase store in Stanford near Lincolnshire.

    Despite talking up the prospects for its full year profits, Home Retail is closing 25% of its 323 Homebase stores over the next four years. That's as it lets leases expire on some properties. Homebase managing director Paul Loft is also stepping down, although he will continue on in his role until a successor is found.

     
  8.  
    08:01: HOME RETAIL PROFIT DROPS

    Homebase and Argos owner Home Retail Group has reported a 5% fall in half-year pre-tax profit to £13.5m. But like-for-like sales were up 2.9% at Argos, and 4.1% at Homebase. Chief executive, John Walden said the group expects to meet City expectations for its full year profit. But he added: "as always, the full-year outcome will depend upon the important Argos Christmas trading period".

     
  9.  
    07:48: BRITISH AMERICAN TOBACCO
    Cigarettes in their package

    Cigarette-pedlar BAT has said revenue for the nine months to the end of September grew by 2.4%. "Industry volume has declined at a lower rate than last year, but is being impacted by large excise-driven price increases," it said.

     
  10.  
    SUPERGROUP Via Twitter James Quinn Executive Business Editor, Telegraph

    tweets: "Strong comeback from Sutherland who fell victim to all he tried to achieve at the Co-op Group, and can be credited with rescuing Co-op Bank."

     
  11.  
    07:29: SUPERGROUP
    SuperGroup chief executive, Euan Sutherland,

    Former Co-op Group chief executive Euan Sutherland is back having been announced as chief executive of SuperGroup this morning with immediate effect. He was previously CEO of Kingfisher UK, which operates B&Q, Screwfix and TradePoint.

     
  12.  
    07:21: GERMAN GROWTH BBC Radio 4

    Germany has very low unemployment, Dr Stephanie Hare, senior analyst for western Europe at Oxford Analytica tells Today. "Making more jobs for Germany isn't the issue here," she says. "We need stimulus and investment in countries that are going to help boost the future of Germany's trading partners in the eurozone. So we can either increase demand in Germany, or Germany could be part of a wider European solution to increase stimulus in its eurozone trading partners." She points out Germany has benefitted from other countries investing and stimulating its economy once or twice in the past century.

     
  13.  
    07:11: EUROTUNNEL

    Eurostar results yesterday, Eurotunnel results today. Revenues for the third quarter of 2014 increased 7% to €343.9m (£271.5m).

     
  14.  
    06:57: UK BORROWING Radio 5 live

    "The main reason tax receipts aren't as high as you'd like is the increase in personal tax allowance," says Alan Clarke, UK and eurozone economist at Scotiabank on Wake Up to Money. He's talking about yesterday's disappointing figures. There are more people in work, though, which means less spending on benefits, he says. Low-paid jobs mean that doesn't help as much as you may think, points out presenter Mickey Clark.

     
  15.  
    06:47: GERMAN GROWTH BBC Radio 4

    Christian Schultz, senior economist at Berenberg Bank, tells the Today programme Germany needs to work on its infrastructure, but even if it started to work on inward investment now the effects would not be felt for several years. This as more political pressure builds on Germany to act to avert another eurozone crisis. But German inward investment doesn't solve the problem, he says. "How does Germany fixing some bridges make French and Italian entrepreneurs invest more?"

     
  16.  
    06:34: STORM POWER
    storm

    The UK's wind farms generated more power than its nuclear power stations on Tuesday, the National Grid says. The energy network operator said it was caused by a combination of high winds and faults in nuclear plants. Wind made up 14.2% of all generation and nuclear offered 13.2%. As BBC environment analyst Roger Harrabin reports, for a 24-hour period yesterday, spinning blades produced more energy than splitting atoms.

     
  17.  
    06:24: CITY POWERS Radio 5 live

    On things like transport and education, local government can make better decisions, says Alexandra Jones, chief executive of the Centre for Cities, which does independent research and policy analysis on UK city economies on 5 live. "Whatever you're doing in a city, you have to balance the books, though, she says. Competitiveness on tax becomes a "race to the bottom" she adds.

     
  18.  
    06:13: CITY POWERS Radio 5 live

    "I think there's real momentum... this is the biggest opportunity in decades to transport the relationship with local government," says Mr Wakefield on 5 live. The debate for Scottish independence shows there are a lot of people interested in local powers, he adds.

     
  19.  
    06:04: CITY POWERS Radio 5 live

    Allowing UK cities to make their own decisions on tax and spending could boost economic growth by £79bn a year by 2030, a year-long study has concluded. "More people want local powers in Leeds," says Councillor Keith Wakefield, leader of Leeds City Council on Radio 5 live. He thinks councils can target some spending more efficiently.

     
  20.  
    06:01: Howard Mustoe Business reporter

    Good morning! Get in touch via email at bizlivepage@bbc.co.uk or on twitter @BBCBusiness

     
  21.  
    06:00: Matthew West Business reporter

    Morning all. We have the latest minutes from the Bank of England's September Monetary Policy Committee meeting at 09:30; Argos and Homebase owner Home Retail Group publishes interim results before that and there are trading updates from GlaxoSmithKline, British American Tobacco and Everything Everywhere. We'll bring you it all as it happens.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.